Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should grandparents help out with grandchildren?

187 replies

Magicfeet11 · 23/05/2022 16:27

I've always been of the school of thought that DH and I chose to have our children so looking after them was 100% our job and we shouldn't have any expectation of family to help. All of our parents are retired and we felt they were entitled to freedom to enjoy their retirement rather than stuck helping us out.

Added to that the fact we live a couple of hours drive from each side of the family so much support would have been impractical anyway.

We've always paid for full time childcare, arranged babysitters for the odd night out and generally muddled through illnesses etc between us. It's been ok but both working full time throughout has presented some challenges - we're tired most of the time, have been at breaking point on occasion and enjoy life much less than we used to pre kids.

Then I was reading an article today about having children and how it takes a village to raise them. Lots of the comments were about what it used to to be like before the nuclear family when extended families all lived in close proximity to each other and the kids would be in and out of grandparents and aunts houses and there'd always be someone to watch your kids for an hour if you needed to run an errand etc.
It really got me thinking. Before the baby boomer generation (our parents) presumably there just wasn't an expectation of a long and affluent retirement? Presumably when you retired you just expected to stay at home and help out with the family?
Therefore, have I been wrong all along and actually I shouldn't have felt so reticent to ask for free help from family? My mum made clear she didn't want to help but my MIL has always been willing yet I've always felt guilty about letting her even do bath time and bedtime because I've felt like it makes me look like I'm skiving/shirking my responsibilities...

YABU - grandparents should be off on world cruises rather than getting involved with babysitting grandchildren

YANBU - it does take a village and it's nice when grandparents ease the load by doing the odd bit of babysitting etc

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
user2908143823142536475859708 · 24/05/2022 16:05

My grandparents looked after us twice a week while my parents went out and we slept over every other Friday or Saturday. That was myself, my brother, my sister and our 7 cousins.

My parents do nothing for either of my kids. They wouldn't even make my eldest a sandwich one lunchtime. My eldest was starving and was crying for them to make him something because they'd told him he wasn't allowed to make his own sandwich. When I came off my work call and asked where was his lunch was and they were stuffing their faces, they told me they didn't know what to put in a sandwich.

Then they told my sister they couldn't visit her for a long weekend because my mental health wasn't great after having my dd and they had to help me with her. My mental health was fine and they've never helped out with her.

I did a lot for my parents, had them over for dinner regularly, looked after my mum after a knee operation and my dad stayed too, sorted physio, pain relief, district nurse to come to my house. I would get their shopping during covid, drop off leftovers they'd ask for. I don't do much for them now. Maybe an occasional request but only if it suits me.

They live nearby.

orangeisthenewpuce · 24/05/2022 16:01

@Magicfeet11 Thank you for this, it's good advice. She often offers and I've recently started taking her up on it a bit more. She seems to really enjoy spending time with the kids and even said she'd have them overnight for us if we wanted to go away etc. Don't think she'd offer if she didn't genuinely want to would she?

No, she definitely wouldn't offer. Take her up on it pronto!Smile

Sugarplumfairy65 · 24/05/2022 16:00

My MIL helped out loads when ours were little around her part time job. FIL was still working full time.
When FIL died, the kids had grown up and only one left at home, MIL came to live with us until she died 10 years later. It wasn't an easy 10 years, but it was the least we could do after she'd helped us out so much

Ragwort · 24/05/2022 15:49

In my immediate family none of my siblings (or I) live anywhere near our DPs, we'd all moved away in different directions by the time they retired and they then moved (in another direction Grin) so I've never had the experience or expectation of childcare 'on tap'. Likewise I would hope that my DS moves away from our rather dull, small town to start his career ... so we will be unlikely to be 'local'.
I agree with PPs, so many grandparents look tired and worn out when being expected to do full time childcare, school runs etc ... but frightened to say 'No'. Occasional babysitting is one thing, but expecting anything else is just entitled.

AryaStarkWolf · 24/05/2022 15:41

Of course it shouldn't be expected and every family is different, i count myself lucky though to have had my mother around to help out when mine were young, she was amazing and my now adult/teen children have a great relationship with her as well because of her involvement with them over the years which is lovely

hellcatspanglelalala · 24/05/2022 15:36

Each to their own. I was fortunate that both my DM and MIL were happy to help out, and did childcare for one day a week each, but I was fortunate to have a flexible job which meant they weren't tied to specific days.

I wouldn't want to be tied down to looking after grandchildren on a regular weekly basis (not entirely sure if I'll ever get any!) but I'll be happy to help out as and when.

DorotheaHomeAlone · 24/05/2022 15:33

I think this comes down to individual family cultures. My granny helped with us a lot when we were kids, regular childcare when we were small, school pickups, emergencies and we have a lovely bond as a result. My mum is now very involved in caring for her (although she lives independently and would never expect to move in). Similarly my mum helps loads with my kids and gets a lot out of that. They all adore her and have a beautiful bond independent of me.

In turn I’ll be as available as I can to help my own children with their kids if they need or want that. That is how family works for us. We love each other and if we can make life easier and nicer for one another then we do.

vivainsomnia · 24/05/2022 15:30

There was also the post where mum was angry because she came back from her night out and her girl was cuddling to grandma on the sofa because shed screamed in bed and grandma got told off for not trying harder.

If that was my DD or Dil, I'd tell her to get lost. With such attitude, I'm not surprised some don't want to do it.

youdothemaths · 24/05/2022 15:22

'It takes a village to raise a child' is one of my least favourite sayings. In my experience, most often used by smug busybody relatives who take great pleasure in telling you what you're doing wrong.

Also by people who can't be arsed to look after their own children.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 24/05/2022 15:18

LivingNextDoorToNorma · 23/05/2022 17:23

I don’t think ‘it takes a village’ means that grandparents, should ‘help out’ with grandchildren. I think it more means that everyone who comes into regular contact with a child, plays a role in shaping who they are.

My mil doesn’t provide regular childcare (although she would always help if we needed her). But she was here this morning rocking and singing to my 4 month old, while she and I had coffee. She is an important and wonderful part of our village. My mum works full time, she doesn’t have the time (or energy) to provide regular childcare. But spend a few hours every other Saturday all together.

‘It takes a village’ is more than that, though. It’s the TA who took her time to really get to know my eldest, and made all the difference to him starting school. It’s the lady who cuts his hair, who lets him talk her ear off every time he has a trim. It my husband’s friend, who always has a random superhero fact to reel off when we see him. It’s our neighbour who lets him stroke her dog when we meet her out walking.

The old school village (in and out of each other’s houses etc) doesn’t really exist anymore, simply because our lifestyles have changed. But the people positively influencing our children are still there, they just aren’t necessarily doing so by babysitting.

This is really lovely! Lucky child to have this village and the wise mum who acknowledges it and celebrates it. I can imagine you amass these fellow villagers quite easily, LivingNextDoorToNorma StarGrin

MrsAvocet · 24/05/2022 15:00

It depends so much on individual circumstances, but I don't think grandparent have any obligation to look after their grandchildren. If they are willing and able to do so, and it is also what the parents want then that must be very nice. But often not all those criteria are met, and in my observation childcare provided by family can be fraught with difficulties.If you employ someone, you can set out what you want, they tell you what they can provide and then you decide whether those things are compatible or not. It's not that simple with family. There seem to be plenty of theads on here from people complaining that their parents or ILs aren't following what they want for their children or they don't feel their family are respecting boundaries.
I never had the option of childcare from family and in some ways it made things difficult, but in other ways I think it made life simpler!

AhNowTed · 24/05/2022 14:46

@User57327259

Unfortunately what starts off as help, is soon expected and not even appreciated.

It's all to common sadly.

whumpthereitis · 24/05/2022 14:44

The thing is, a grandparent can provide childcare and still be without elder care. For all talk of swings and roundabouts, there are plenty of people left in nursing homes despite what they may or may not have done for their family. That said, people shouldn’t put childcare, or eldercare, expectations on anyone else. It’s your responsibility to provide care for the children you choose to have, and it’s your responsibility to organise the care you want when you’re elderly.

I don’t think anyone particularly needs to ‘understand’ why anyone else chooses to provide care, or doesn’t. We’re all different and we all want different things out of life. There’s nothing wrong in that.

User57327259 · 24/05/2022 14:29

@maddening
Swings and roundabouts really, no one is obliged to help, whether that is with childcare or elderly care. What goes around comes around imo.

If only this was true. I had help from my parents with my children and later I helped my parents in their old age. When my children had their own children I helped with babysitting while they worked. None of them worked 9-5, it was all anti social hours jobs. I did everything I could including helping with cleaning the house and various other stuff.
I had DGC 3 days one week and 4 days the alternative week and it was fine. I enjoyed their company and our outings.
Then I was involved in an accident. I was in hospital overnight but was good to go the next day, sent home by patient transfer. DGC were dropped off rather than I went to pick them up. About a week later I was due back at the hospital but I had to do that alone. I thought if I had ever needed help (I actually just wanted to be accompanied I did not need carried about or anything) the DC would have been fine with that. Clearly not. The doctor was outraged that I was still babysitting despite injuries. I then learned I was really just being taken advantage of for babysitting and no-one really cared about my welfare. I think I took the appropriate action. What I sent round certainly did not come back to me.

maddening · 24/05/2022 13:19

Swings and roundabouts really, no one is obliged to help, whether that is with childcare or elderly care. What goes around comes around imo.

pointythings · 24/05/2022 13:13

Grandparents are not obliged to help with grandchildren. Mine didn't, and I'm 54. My parents and ILs also did not help - partly because they both lived in a different country to us but also because we would not have expected it anyway. And neither expected me to take them in and care for them in their old age either.

I have two DC - if they have kids and are nearby, I'll help when I can (but may well still be working) but that's all. And I have zero expectation of them taking me in when I need care - I'll go to Switzerland if it comes to that.

Gizacluethen · 24/05/2022 12:57

Magicfeet11 · 23/05/2022 16:37

Is it as quid pro quo as that though? My DM has made clear I'm 100% responsible for her and her care in her elderly years and she absolutely will not go into a home. On your measure I should say I'm not helping her because she never lifted a finger with my kids... I just don't know if that's right

Tbh I think it is. She's not willing to help you when you need it but gully expects you to help her when she needs it. No. I wouldn't, caring for an elderly parent full time takes a huge burden. All so she can enjoy her life to the fullest. What about you enjoying your life?

Mary46 · 24/05/2022 12:26

I think make it clear from the start. My friend was say the son wants more now childcare.. My mum never helped us but expects everyone to run after her now. So its hard not to feel peeved. But mine dont need childcare now

Zemw · 24/05/2022 12:16

Grandparents shouldn't have to do anything, but I don't really understand not wanting too!

I still live where I grew up, so do my family and a wide circle of friends (London). It was like my children was raised by a village and it was fabulous. I even managed to work (shifts) as a single parent by swapping the children with another person also working shifts.

My parents were.very involved in all their grandkids lives - adhock babysitting and taking them on holidays.

jamapop · 24/05/2022 12:06

Both options are so binary. I don’t think it should be expected but I think it’s nice for them to be involved as much as they are happy to be. Every situation will be different.

We don’t really have any help. ILs love the GC but won’t put themselves out at all to help - so they love spending time with them if they are brought to them on a convenient day at a convenient time (we don’t live close and they would never visit). I actually find that adds to the burden more than anything as facilitating a relationship is on our shoulders but they offer nothing practical in return. My parents, for various reasons, offer very limited help.

I don’t know how much I’ll be around for any GC I have. A lot would depend on when they are born - being a 60 year old grandparent is presumably quite different to being an 85 year old one. In an ideal world I’ll give my children enough space to raise their own family but be very much part of their lives.

AhNowTed · 24/05/2022 12:00

There's been so many cases on here of sons and daughters taking the absolute piss out of their parents, expecting free full-time childcare.

I posted this earlier but it's worth posting again.

This poor woman's son/DIL demanding 4 days a week, and expected her to give up her job, calling her "selfish" - oh the irony.

When she replied she loves her job, the DIL helpfully suggested she doesn't need the money, and anyway she could work nights leaving her free for childcare all day!!

So worried and just want to keep the peace 😥 http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4321209-So-worried-and-just-want-to-keep-the-peace

HappyWinter · 24/05/2022 11:58

@ThatsNotMyMuffin I would want to help my children too, it might not be regular childcare as I will still be working, but I'd want to help in emergencies and so they are able to have a break and go out. I don't understand the mindset of not wanting to help at all, I understand why someone wouldn't want to do weekly childcare in the longer term, but I don't understand why they wouldn't want to offer occasionally even a few times a year. I hope I will have more empathy for my children when they are grown up and if they have children of their own. Parenting is hard and it's nice to have empathy and support.

ErinAoife · 24/05/2022 11:43

No they shouldn't be an expectation of grand parents to mind their grandchildren. If they want to do it, that is fine. In my situation my mil told me before I had any children that she will not be minding mine which was not very nice the way she did it. A few months later, she started minding kids so when I was expecting a year later my husband ask her to mind our kid despite I did not really want her to do it because of her comments but husband was adamant that he wanted her mum to do it. We paid her, she did not do it for free and if i had to put my kid to a proper register childminder I will have paid only £ 5 more a week so it is not like she was doing us a huge favour financially. She refused to bring our kid to playschool who was only a 5 mn walk from her house when my job was relocated to another school and therefore couldn't bring my kid anymore. I had to go to the owner to say that I could no longer have my kid in her school. She could not understand why my mil which is her neighbour could not do it, owner told me not to remove my son that she will do the collection and bring it back from my Mil as it is such a short walk from the school. But what was annoying me the most is Mil telling all her family how she was great minding her grand child. One of her brother commented to me that I should be grateful of my mil to be such a wonderful woman in order for us to be able to save money and we should really compensate her and not take advantage. I replied to him that we paid her more or less the going rate and if it was my decision my kid will have been mind by a registered childcare provider. MIL went bright red as of course she never mentioned she was getting paid. When our second was born, I put both of them in a creche setting as I did not want the hassle and to be honest it was piece of mind for me gave excuse that 2 under 5 will be too much for her to handle. In contrast my own mother do anything for her grandchildren but unfortunately for me she live in another country.

ThatsNotMyMuffin · 24/05/2022 10:53

I don't think there should be any expectations but I don't quite get how they don't want to? Surely they remember how hard it was and helping out a few hours a week isn't prohibitive to the grandparents having their own time?! To be honest seeing how little GP are willing to help us out makes me quite sure we won't be prioritising the grandkids visiting them in the care home at their time of need.

I hope I remember how hard this period was, and when my own kids have children, I will be on hand to help as much as possible. I'll have plenty of time for 'me time' when they're in their 20s. It's backbreaking work trying to juggle work and looking after kids and I won't let my own children be as tired and stressed as I have been, if I can make their life a little bit easier I will.

Justcallmebebes · 24/05/2022 10:05

when extended families all lived in close proximity to each other and the kids would be in and out of grandparents and aunts houses and there'd always be someone to watch your kids for an hour if you needed to run an errand etc.

This is exactly how my family is both my side and in laws and I wouldn't have it any other way. I love being a daily part of my grandkids' lives and having them in and out of my house. I grew up abroad and had no extended family close to hand. I know which I prefer