Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My adult brother bullies me . I need help to deal with him.

138 replies

Littepinkyogapants · 23/05/2022 16:14

My brother (40) is successful in the work place and a high earner . He has always been domineering and bossy but over the last 10 years has become cruel . We had a hard childhood . I had many issues with drinking and mental health.

I got help and sorted myself out in late and got married . Since then ( 4 years ago ) my brother has had periods of not wanting to talk to me or when he does being extremely rude .After I see him I feel like a failure .

A few things he has said in the last year

1)What do you know about work ? Your a teacher ! It’s not a job. You are a childminder !!

2)You gave your child the shittest name. Why use such a crap generic name ? ( We used Oliver)

3)You are a typical woman - got married ,pregnant and that’s it - you have no originality .

4)About 3 weeks after the birth of my daughter , in a room full of people , he told me -Your talking like a fucking retard. Why are you talking with your hands !?

  1. what the fuck do you know about life ?

6 .It’s disgusting you work part time but I suppose women have no real drive .

He is extremely rude and critical To most people but me now more than anyone I feel. I never say a word as i hate confrontation.

He moans about everyone. He always wants me to agree with him And I feel I have to agree with him. I hate I don’t just walk away and end up agreeing with him.

I will be spending 4 days at a family get together this week. My brother called last night to moan about our family and was extremely rude to me on the phone. All of the usual put downs. After the call I sat and cried .

I have spent many years working to be the person I am . I have a loving husband and 2 wonderful young children and I am happy . Yet my brother can make me crumble .

My brother is unhappy . Has been for years . Is finally splitting from his partner ( not wife as he doesn’t believe in marriage !)

How can I cope with spending 4 days with him? I’m terrified? My parents are aware of his behaviour but don’t want to confront him. He always gets away with it. I hate that I don’t stand up to him. I hate the way he makes me feel .

OP posts:
Anonnnnnnm · 23/05/2022 20:23

He is toxic. Cut him off until he's willing to change.

Thereisnolight · 23/05/2022 20:21

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 23/05/2022 19:53

How has it come to pass that you've just allowed your brother to walk all over you like this? You say he used to be nice, why couldn't you ever challenge him and just tell him to stop being such a shit?

I think it's really sad you're getting so upset about this that you're seriously considering missing your mother's party than just tell him to shut the fuck up talking to you like a piece of shit.

I appreciate you don't like confrontation, but most people have to step outside of their comfort zone sometimes, and confronting your brother - over the phone if you like - would be a good start to getting a backbone and maybe repairing your relationship.

Gosh, why did she never think of just standing up for herself all these years? That would have solved it straight away!

I don’t think you’ve been in this family dynamic. Standing up to him would lead to a huge shouting match - in front of the DC - and would not stop it from happening again.

if she’s going to stand up to him it will have to be slowly, patiently and calmly, over a prolonged period during which she only sees him for short times in a neutral setting and preferably with the parents nowhere near.

Testina · 23/05/2022 19:58

I’d make the next family event that I attended at the same time as him, his funeral.
And even that, I probably wouldn’t!
Not just mouthing off online… I have seen my brother for 30 years. Arsehole is as arsehole does.

1AngelicFruitCake · 23/05/2022 19:56

threecupsofteaminimum · 23/05/2022 17:58

That's helpful, do you always make terrible jokes at other peoples expense, read the room yeh. She's being abused by her brother and you think it's funny.

I cringed at this. What on Earth were you thinking?!

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 23/05/2022 19:53

How has it come to pass that you've just allowed your brother to walk all over you like this? You say he used to be nice, why couldn't you ever challenge him and just tell him to stop being such a shit?

I think it's really sad you're getting so upset about this that you're seriously considering missing your mother's party than just tell him to shut the fuck up talking to you like a piece of shit.

I appreciate you don't like confrontation, but most people have to step outside of their comfort zone sometimes, and confronting your brother - over the phone if you like - would be a good start to getting a backbone and maybe repairing your relationship.

RinklyRomaine · 23/05/2022 19:45

I just wouldn't go. I've been NC with my brother for 5y and it's been so liberating. He's like this but snide, with a terrible temper. My DPs enable him, although they often drop contact for a bit. Both hate that I refuse to have anything to do with him but I've stood my ground with DHs full support and they've given up pushing now. The thing is, he isn't going to change. He's horrible, but you are an adult and you don't have to take this from anyone. I'd just ring your mum and tell her. Say no, no thank you, I don't want to hear it any more.

catandcoffee · 23/05/2022 19:44

Great minds think alike.. was going to say the same. tell him to fuck off and as for your parents they are allowing his behaviour. Let your husband deal with him. He is a nasty bully.

coconuthead · 23/05/2022 19:44

I would not go and I would tell my parents exactly why. Then I would go NC with your disgusting bully of a brother. Life is too short to be treated like this

user1471556818 · 23/05/2022 19:37

Congratulations for having a good life with a worthwhile career and your own family to focus on
Honestly just stop seeing him ,speaking to him and giving him power over you
Miss this meet up
I know easier said than done but think of what you are showing your child is acceptable
Good luck

Notanotherwindow · 23/05/2022 19:23

Or alternatively to why are you talking like a retard just say you're adapting to your audience.

Notanotherwindow · 23/05/2022 19:18
  1. You wouldn't know much about teaching. You'd have to impart something worth listening to.

  2. I was delirious with relief that he didn't come out looking like you.

  3. You're a typical neanderthal. More hair than brains, make more noise than sense and thankfully almost extinct. (The implication being that he is the last of the species, I know they are actually extinct lol)

  4. Why are you talking like a cunt? Stop talking with your arse!

  5. What the fuck do you know about me? You never shut the fuck up long enough.

  6. And yet I'm still happier than you...

Fixyourself · 23/05/2022 19:16

I have a brother just like this but worse!
All the people commenting to stand up for your self and answer back have no clue what having a sibling like this is like. Answering back would make this much worse and the insults more harsh.
You need to go no contact. I have been for 6 years now and it’s such a weight off my shoulders.

ThreeLocusts · 23/05/2022 19:04
  • sorry, posted too early - it would be great if you could find it in you to push back yourself at your mum's birthday. It would be a shame if you went only out of sense of obligation, full of dread. You have a right to be there and enjoy your mum's company.

It's hard to break the patterns of decades but you know you are right and he is just horrid. How about you tell him up front not to speak to you unless he has something nice to say? And if he is still nasty to you, as is likely, say 'you're rude' and walk away.

Other than that, do what is good for you and if that means going NC, so be it.

Chica10 · 23/05/2022 19:00

You have over come so many challenges in your life, why would accept such appalling treatment from someone that just happens to be your brother? You wouldn’t accept this from a friend, surely, then why are you taking it from him? Just don’t go. You don’t have to please anyone any longer other than your self. Put your self first

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 23/05/2022 18:59

You do realise that you don't have to go to this family event, you don't have to put up with him speaking to you like that and that you don't have to even tolerate him in your life at all?

I hope you are getting some kind of counselling.

StationaryMagpie · 23/05/2022 18:58

I do love my big brother, but he can be an obnoxious bellend at times, and he knows EXACTLY the buttons to press to piss me off/upset me if he wants to. (and i can do the same to him.. we annoy the crap out of each other)
The difference between you and I, is i have always stood up for myself because he's my brother, and i've been giving as good as i got since we were little.

Honestly, the best thing you can do is either ask your DH to step in, or just look your brother straight in the eye and tell him to "Shut the fuck up, no-one asked for, or cares about your opinion"

or something like someone said upthread "Who asked you?" "Do you ever shut up?" "Some people would think you're just rude.. you're not just rude, you're a dickhead as well!" and the mumsnet classic "Did you mean to be so fucking rude?"

I once really upset my brother when he was being REALLY obnoxious.. i told him the reason no-one likes him is because he's a self centered, selfish arsehole.

After the four days, (if you have to really go, which i wouldn't if you don't!) just go low/no contact. You don't have to put up with his shit.

Craftycorvid · 23/05/2022 18:58

Well, I’m channeling my DM in saying this, here, but I suspect he’s jealous of you. He is also a misogynist dimwit. Calmly correcting his stereotyping each time; asking deadpan what is wrong with having children; asking him when he became a qualified teacher as he appears to be an expert....you get the idea. Good luck!

ThreeLocusts · 23/05/2022 18:57

Your brother sounds like a bully but also like a committed misogynist. 'Typical woman' etc.

IrisVersicolor · 23/05/2022 18:57

There is absolutely no point staying in contact with this man.

butimjayigetaway · 23/05/2022 18:57

Littepinkyogapants · 23/05/2022 16:14

My brother (40) is successful in the work place and a high earner . He has always been domineering and bossy but over the last 10 years has become cruel . We had a hard childhood . I had many issues with drinking and mental health.

I got help and sorted myself out in late and got married . Since then ( 4 years ago ) my brother has had periods of not wanting to talk to me or when he does being extremely rude .After I see him I feel like a failure .

A few things he has said in the last year

1)What do you know about work ? Your a teacher ! It’s not a job. You are a childminder !!

2)You gave your child the shittest name. Why use such a crap generic name ? ( We used Oliver)

3)You are a typical woman - got married ,pregnant and that’s it - you have no originality .

4)About 3 weeks after the birth of my daughter , in a room full of people , he told me -Your talking like a fucking retard. Why are you talking with your hands !?

  1. what the fuck do you know about life ?

6 .It’s disgusting you work part time but I suppose women have no real drive .

He is extremely rude and critical To most people but me now more than anyone I feel. I never say a word as i hate confrontation.

He moans about everyone. He always wants me to agree with him And I feel I have to agree with him. I hate I don’t just walk away and end up agreeing with him.

I will be spending 4 days at a family get together this week. My brother called last night to moan about our family and was extremely rude to me on the phone. All of the usual put downs. After the call I sat and cried .

I have spent many years working to be the person I am . I have a loving husband and 2 wonderful young children and I am happy . Yet my brother can make me crumble .

My brother is unhappy . Has been for years . Is finally splitting from his partner ( not wife as he doesn’t believe in marriage !)

How can I cope with spending 4 days with him? I’m terrified? My parents are aware of his behaviour but don’t want to confront him. He always gets away with it. I hate that I don’t stand up to him. I hate the way he makes me feel .

You have to decide.

Ignore it. Let it slide.

Make a joke/game of it.

Rule that you go no contact with him.

The key to happiness in life is ceasing this whole 'ughh what should I doooo?' thing and moving to the 'right, what do I do?' thing...

Realise that you eradicate so much mess when you

make a decision
implement it

Pick an approach with your brother. Stick to it.

Ignore it. Let it slide.
anytime he makes any comment you either ignore or change the subject.

"hey sarah, your dress is shit"

*thanks mark, how's the dog?"

irrelevant is fine. he may go 'what dog?!' you just say 'so you're well?'

you're cutting off his source of instant gratification.

Make a joke/game of it.

"hey sarah, your dress is shit"

"i know right! lol i like looking stupid. how you been?"

You're cutting off his source.

Rule that you go no contact with him.

just don't go anywhere he will be.

It's a shame he's so sad but it's not his right to take that out on you.

Nimo12 · 23/05/2022 18:56

I voted that you are unreasonable only because you don't stick up for yourself. Just tell him to fuck off and give the family event a miss. explain why to other family if you have to but you don't have to have a relationship with him and he sounds awful. He's not worth your tears lovely.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 23/05/2022 18:54

Wow, he sounds like a very, very unhappy person. My guess is he has nothing in his life except work but he actually hates that.

I wouldn’t go. Also, you say you have a daughter. I wouldn’t allow someone who is such an unabashed misogynist anywhere near my daughter (or my sons for that matter).

CockSpadget · 23/05/2022 18:49

What a vile person, and if your parents are witnessing the way he speaks to you and are letting him get away with it, then they are just as bad. I certainly wouldn't be feeling any obligation to attend the party of someone who is enabling your abuser, mother or not.
Why would you want to risk your children witnessing their mum being abused like this? Remove him from your life OP, before he does any more damage.

Cherrysoup · 23/05/2022 18:42

Your parents enable him, so they’re complicit. I wouldn’t go. If you really think you must, tell your Dh to defend you and use some of the more adult advice eg tell him he’s boring you and what an unhappy little man he must be to constantly want to be so negative about others. No wonder his partner is leaving him.

mumsys · 23/05/2022 18:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.