Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My adult brother bullies me . I need help to deal with him.

138 replies

Littepinkyogapants · 23/05/2022 16:14

My brother (40) is successful in the work place and a high earner . He has always been domineering and bossy but over the last 10 years has become cruel . We had a hard childhood . I had many issues with drinking and mental health.

I got help and sorted myself out in late and got married . Since then ( 4 years ago ) my brother has had periods of not wanting to talk to me or when he does being extremely rude .After I see him I feel like a failure .

A few things he has said in the last year

1)What do you know about work ? Your a teacher ! It’s not a job. You are a childminder !!

2)You gave your child the shittest name. Why use such a crap generic name ? ( We used Oliver)

3)You are a typical woman - got married ,pregnant and that’s it - you have no originality .

4)About 3 weeks after the birth of my daughter , in a room full of people , he told me -Your talking like a fucking retard. Why are you talking with your hands !?

  1. what the fuck do you know about life ?

6 .It’s disgusting you work part time but I suppose women have no real drive .

He is extremely rude and critical To most people but me now more than anyone I feel. I never say a word as i hate confrontation.

He moans about everyone. He always wants me to agree with him And I feel I have to agree with him. I hate I don’t just walk away and end up agreeing with him.

I will be spending 4 days at a family get together this week. My brother called last night to moan about our family and was extremely rude to me on the phone. All of the usual put downs. After the call I sat and cried .

I have spent many years working to be the person I am . I have a loving husband and 2 wonderful young children and I am happy . Yet my brother can make me crumble .

My brother is unhappy . Has been for years . Is finally splitting from his partner ( not wife as he doesn’t believe in marriage !)

How can I cope with spending 4 days with him? I’m terrified? My parents are aware of his behaviour but don’t want to confront him. He always gets away with it. I hate that I don’t stand up to him. I hate the way he makes me feel .

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
timeisnotaline · 26/05/2022 08:48

Tell your husband you love him and he can say whatever he wants to your brother.
I no longer spend Christmas with my parents as my Brother is there . I avoid going to see my parents when brother is there . I probably see him
4 times a year but can easily make it less and none if necessary .

that is such good progress!! If you can do all that you can do one more step right now- block him on your phone. Go on, it takes seconds. And phone calls like last night will never happen again. Onto the rest of your amazing life op!

Ferngreen · 26/05/2022 06:05

Jings- you DM must have contributed to producing this nasty lump of a man.

And now DPs stand by whilst he is cruel.

I don't think you need to attend DMs birthday if that horror is going to be there and it's a bit rich her expecting you to go along to be cruelly abused.

Tell them you won't be going because of him.

autienotnaughty · 26/05/2022 05:48

You are not benefiting from this relationship and he is unlikely to change. I would not attend events where he is there and I would see parents separately.

Murdoch1949 · 26/05/2022 05:35

Absolutely staggered that you spend a minute with him, let alone 4 days. He's abusive to you and you're allowing him to be. Terminate your relationship with him, your children will become to be affected by the way he treats you

Astrak · 24/05/2022 20:25

I think that you should totally delete your brother from your life, by all means available to you. See your parents away from their home, or via Skype or something similar.
Remove yourself and your family from contact with him.
He has a negative effect on you. He won't change. You can.

suchasadcliche · 24/05/2022 09:47

Your brother sounds like a coke addict. Even if he's not he's an aggressive twat. Speak to his partner and find out the truth. If you can't help him I would cut him out.

Mandodari · 24/05/2022 09:42

@Aubriella
Thanks Aubriella. Have not heard a dickie bird in years. Early on he made an attempt to give me a second chance (his words) via our cousin but I declined. The cousin no longer keeps in touch with him either after realising what a dick he is!

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 24/05/2022 09:18

I was so sad to read your post OP. He has no right to speak to you like that.

Your parents need to face exactly what has been going on maybe they don't see the full extent of it or understand how it affects you. I think if you tell them verbally they may interrupt or start saying it's an exaggeration because they don't really want to face up to this. Maybe writing it all down in a clear, calm, non-exaggerated way, just as you did in your post, a list of the comments and behaviour without commentary,. I think seeing it in black and white like that might shock them and at least they will have to read it without minimising the whole thing. It might help them understand, particularly that you do not want to bring your children into this dynamic, and nor should they want to see their grandchildren witnessing the stress, fear, and upset that this man generates. Send a copy to him that you will not put up with it anymore and you don't want your children to experience it. He needs to realise the impact of his behaviour.

Because seriously, someone needs to tell him. You say that he is known for being difficult and rude. Maybe it's time he faces that and does something about it .

Attending the party is a dilemma, I wouldn't want to do the four days either and maybe that is the price your parents pay for enabling him, although like you they may not haven't really known how to deal with him.
However, it feels wrong that his behaviour is literally stopping you from meeting up with your family and you are the one being banished.
It is a four-day event - do you have to be at all four? or could your parents organise it so that you and your brother come on different days? Could you meet your parents for lunch somewhere, without him. Or celebrate with them on a different weekend. Its not an easy situation but maybe it is good that things have come to a head and either way you wont be putting up with this from now on.

Aubriella · 24/05/2022 05:53

Mandodari · 23/05/2022 22:01

I have an older brother, very similar though not as openly aggressive. I am a computer engineer in the tech science industry and he continuously referred to be as a data entry clerk. He mocked my decision not to have children and said it was just an excuse to hide the fact that I was, in his words, barren. He said I only chose my partner because I left it too late and had to settle.
The day after my mother's funeral, I told him that he was obviously a deeply unhappy person who could only make himself feel good by making other people miserable. I told him to say what ever he had to there and then because that was going to be his last opportunity to talk me ever again. He said I needed help because I was mentally ill and stormed off. I blocked his number, his email and thankfully was in the process of moving so he didnt have my new address. That was nearly 10 years ago and was the best thing I ever did. You can't reason with abusive men. If you cite any example of their behaviour, they brand you unreasonable and crazy. The only power you have is to cut them out of your life root and stem. Knowing that I will never again have to put up with him mocking and belittling me and my DH brings me such peace.

Well done!

Do you have any news of him?

DFOD · 23/05/2022 23:24

Mandodari · 23/05/2022 22:01

I have an older brother, very similar though not as openly aggressive. I am a computer engineer in the tech science industry and he continuously referred to be as a data entry clerk. He mocked my decision not to have children and said it was just an excuse to hide the fact that I was, in his words, barren. He said I only chose my partner because I left it too late and had to settle.
The day after my mother's funeral, I told him that he was obviously a deeply unhappy person who could only make himself feel good by making other people miserable. I told him to say what ever he had to there and then because that was going to be his last opportunity to talk me ever again. He said I needed help because I was mentally ill and stormed off. I blocked his number, his email and thankfully was in the process of moving so he didnt have my new address. That was nearly 10 years ago and was the best thing I ever did. You can't reason with abusive men. If you cite any example of their behaviour, they brand you unreasonable and crazy. The only power you have is to cut them out of your life root and stem. Knowing that I will never again have to put up with him mocking and belittling me and my DH brings me such peace.

/\ /\ THIS

Mandodari · 23/05/2022 22:01

I have an older brother, very similar though not as openly aggressive. I am a computer engineer in the tech science industry and he continuously referred to be as a data entry clerk. He mocked my decision not to have children and said it was just an excuse to hide the fact that I was, in his words, barren. He said I only chose my partner because I left it too late and had to settle.
The day after my mother's funeral, I told him that he was obviously a deeply unhappy person who could only make himself feel good by making other people miserable. I told him to say what ever he had to there and then because that was going to be his last opportunity to talk me ever again. He said I needed help because I was mentally ill and stormed off. I blocked his number, his email and thankfully was in the process of moving so he didnt have my new address. That was nearly 10 years ago and was the best thing I ever did. You can't reason with abusive men. If you cite any example of their behaviour, they brand you unreasonable and crazy. The only power you have is to cut them out of your life root and stem. Knowing that I will never again have to put up with him mocking and belittling me and my DH brings me such peace.

Blaze1886 · 23/05/2022 21:58

You need to completely cut him out of your life, see family when he isn't going to be there

Your life will be no worse off without him in it. Not sure how you've put up with it for so long

TheHatinaCat · 23/05/2022 21:50

You don't deal with him, you just cut him out of your life.

If you've agreed to go to your Mum's Birthday already then go and give him a very wide berth.

mytrueaccount · 23/05/2022 21:39

I find standing up to bullies can make them back off. I don't mean you should risk being outright nasty back, which could set him off further. But have you tried telling him, "Why is it you always seem to find me so useless?" "It really hurts my feelings how you talk to me." "Do you mean to sound so unkind?" "You are so critical of me I wonder if it means you're unhappy with your own life."

If he doesn't stop, well, give up and avoid contact. I just worry that that might make you feel even sadder...

Namechangeplease · 23/05/2022 21:26

I’m so sorry OP 🌺🌺 do you want to go to the get-together? You don’t have to if you don’t want to. And if you do, can you stay somewhere else away from your family and brother? Also, I wonder if you’ve ever had therapy/thought about having therapy, to help you recover from what your brother has put you through. Wishing you all the best 🌺

HappyNannie · 23/05/2022 21:22

You are not responsible for your brothers behaviour he’s just a miserable bully and he gets away with it because you don’t stand up for yourself, You have children what would you advise them under these circumstances?

Astrak · 23/05/2022 21:18

I think that you should speak to your parents and explain why you won't be joining them at the family celebration. Don't get into an argument over it. Just repeat a brief, explanatory sentence about your brother's consistently vile behaviour and your refusal to be harassed by him ever again. Arrange another date to visit. Inform them that if they tell brother that you are visiting on that date, and he turns up, you will leave immediately and not return.
You have made a good life for yourself and your family. Don't jeopardise it now.
Best wishes. ❤

LemonDrizzles · 23/05/2022 21:06

Learn a few comebacks that you would realistically say and practise practise practise in the mirror, close your eyes, confidently, calmly and flatly, unemotionally imagine yourself saying it.

A few options

"No"

"I see things differently from you"

"Hm, I see"

"You mean, in your opinion..."

All the very best

Stapleton143 · 23/05/2022 20:56

I actually did call the police on my abusive bullying/violent brother 9 years older who started hitting me from a young age about 9, my parents turned a blind eye. Effected my confidence all my life and married to escape him. Even after being married for 20 years kept phoning making threats. I believe he has undiagnosed autism and mental health problems who knows? He is a nasty bully even in his 60s I have very little contact with him now.

Maytodecember · 23/05/2022 20:45

Practice this: hand up as in “stop” Your brother speaks to you you hold up your hand and say your choice of phrase “not now” “ not listening” Always use the same phrase. No more, no less. Walk away.
Then after the family party go nc.

DFOD · 23/05/2022 20:39

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 23/05/2022 20:28

You're right. I haven't been in this situation, because if my brother was a cunt to me I'd tell him to stop being a cunt to me.

You can't categorically say what would or wouldn't happen if she stood up to him - regardless, she has a phone and could call him. I disagree that he needs a 'prolonged period in a neutral setting' to deal with it - he's not a child that needs a softly softly approach. Obviously she's not going to incite an argument on the phone but just getting across that she won't tolerate the abuse anymore would a step in the right direction.

OP has clearly been the boiled frog in this situation.

But what does not tolerating it actually involve? She only has one consequence with a grown adult to walk away - might as well cut to the chase - and avoid exposing herself to his wrath yet again. Clearly his long term partner/wife couldn’t tolerate his behaviour and has concluded that walking away is the only option / consequence.

However I would be firmer with your DPs - they have thrown you and your DCs under the bus to selfishly to save their own discomfort. They have really let you down repeatedly.

RampantIvy · 23/05/2022 20:32

He always gets away with it.

Because no-one has ever challenged him, and he has been allowed to get away with it.

I would avoid seeing him and block him everywhere.

OnceMoreWithoutFeeling · 23/05/2022 20:28

Well he sounds like the most colossal cunt OP. Just never ever see or speak to him again. And if there are any more "family gatherings" mooted, just ask if your bro is invited and if he is say "then I'm afraid I and my family won't be coming, because (brother) is invariably incredibly nasty to me, as you very well know and I'm done with it Happy to see you at another time seperately to celebrate your birthday/marriage/hamster's christening with you."

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 23/05/2022 20:28

Thereisnolight · 23/05/2022 20:21

Gosh, why did she never think of just standing up for herself all these years? That would have solved it straight away!

I don’t think you’ve been in this family dynamic. Standing up to him would lead to a huge shouting match - in front of the DC - and would not stop it from happening again.

if she’s going to stand up to him it will have to be slowly, patiently and calmly, over a prolonged period during which she only sees him for short times in a neutral setting and preferably with the parents nowhere near.

You're right. I haven't been in this situation, because if my brother was a cunt to me I'd tell him to stop being a cunt to me.

You can't categorically say what would or wouldn't happen if she stood up to him - regardless, she has a phone and could call him. I disagree that he needs a 'prolonged period in a neutral setting' to deal with it - he's not a child that needs a softly softly approach. Obviously she's not going to incite an argument on the phone but just getting across that she won't tolerate the abuse anymore would a step in the right direction.

OP has clearly been the boiled frog in this situation.

WiddlinDiddlin · 23/05/2022 20:27

Ideally, don't go, don't be around him, but I realise that is easy to say and not easy to do.

If you must be around him - ensure that YOU get to choose when you leave, whether thats you being the driver, or ensuring your partner is on side so that when you say 'we're leaving' they immediately facilitate that, up to you.

My dad used to do some of what your brother does to you - he would make vile comments to me in front of other people because he thought it made him look funny and clever and got him attention - I mean it DID get him attention, he just never noticed that it was looks of horror from other people.

I picked a response, a simple one as I was never going to get away with a lengthy statement like 'why are you so mean you must be a very sad little person'... that would be 'oh you are being over sensitive'.

So I went with 'Rude!' and getting up and leaving. Every. Single. Time.

The behaviour did in fact reduce, occasionally it pops up again but we're talking once in six months rather than several times each time we saw him.

My sister also had some unpleasant habits - particularly, ringing me to witter at me without asking if I was in the middle of something or busy and then working round to being rude to me. She's especially fond of asking me something then interrupting me!

At the first hint of her not listening or being rude, I would just hang up.

Again, the behaviour has reduced significantly.

You won't FIX people like this, you won't change who they are - but you can, by controlling YOUR reaction to their behaviour, change their behaviour towards YOU.

Swipe left for the next trending thread