Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys in girls changing at swimming

239 replies

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 10:06

This is not a trans issue!

my daughter 11 attends swimming lessons at a hotel pool there are several parents who insist on helping there boys age 9/10/11 in the girls open plan changing room. The hotel’s suggestion is that my daughter and her friend change in the disabled changing room.
So the girls should be pushed out there own space. The boys have no additional needs but surely if they did they should use the disabled changing room.

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 23/05/2022 12:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

PeekAtYou · 23/05/2022 12:33

These are children you are talking about young children don't project your your feelings about men onto young young children 🙄

Boys manage to change with other boys at school swimming.

I have sons and I have noticed that some parents have higher expectations of their daughters than sons and it is likely that this extends into the teenage years and adulthood.

Treating 9/10 year old boys as "young young children" doesn't do them favours. It's a parent's job to give them confidence to take care of themselves and getting changed after swimming is within the realms of capability for the majority. I don't see girls getting into knots, banging their head in the womens, why would boys be doing the same when their swimming costumes as easier to get out of ?

gotthis · 23/05/2022 12:28

Sorry, the men were young boys at the time of assault

gotthis · 23/05/2022 12:26

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 12:16

Lots of smug girl mums on here. Off course your ‘precious’ girls will never sexually abuse boys right? Well it happens a lot in my sons secondary school, girls making obscene comments about boys genitalia, also my younger son was made to feel very uncomfortable when year 6 girls were re-naming boys and girls genitals and asking him if he likes them.
This thread will (as always) be turned into a boy bashing thread AND yes boys are at risk of sexual abuse too.

I know two grown men who were sexually assaulted in public toilets, messed them up for life. I support mixed changing facilities with secure cubicles for this reason.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 12:22

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 12:16

Lots of smug girl mums on here. Off course your ‘precious’ girls will never sexually abuse boys right? Well it happens a lot in my sons secondary school, girls making obscene comments about boys genitalia, also my younger son was made to feel very uncomfortable when year 6 girls were re-naming boys and girls genitals and asking him if he likes them.
This thread will (as always) be turned into a boy bashing thread AND yes boys are at risk of sexual abuse too.

Tbf no one has mentioned 11 yo girls in the Boys with Dad but of course the same point applies.

However, men DO pose a greater risk than women, which is why men are more comfortable sending their girls off (hence the issue not being raised here) than women are sending their sons off.

If men weren't a risk, and if men wouldn't rather ignore a kid in need that risk someone THINKING he's a risk, we wouldn't be having this chat.

x2boys · 23/05/2022 12:21

PeekAtYou · 23/05/2022 10:33

It's always boys in the girls changing rooms and never the other way round when girls have longr hair making swim hats more difficult.

It's easy to see how these babied boys end up as immature adults.

These are children you are talking about young children don't project your your feelings about men onto young young children 🙄

FeeLock · 23/05/2022 12:16

I'd definitely contact the management and discuss it privately with the manager. Girls start getting periods from age 8 sometimes (there was an article in today's Independent about this). I have G&B twins and our son came with me until he was 7.

The way for the management to deal with this is to make family changing rooms, not to require someone to move out because they don't want to have a difficult conversation with another guest.

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 12:16

Lots of smug girl mums on here. Off course your ‘precious’ girls will never sexually abuse boys right? Well it happens a lot in my sons secondary school, girls making obscene comments about boys genitalia, also my younger son was made to feel very uncomfortable when year 6 girls were re-naming boys and girls genitals and asking him if he likes them.
This thread will (as always) be turned into a boy bashing thread AND yes boys are at risk of sexual abuse too.

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 12:13

i definitely don’t think the solution is to tell parents of boys that they have to put their young boys in a situation where there is a very real possibility that they could be sexually assaulted though.

But I do think (reluctantly) as the mother of a boy that this is a problem for me to solve, rather than allowing boys over the age of around 8/9 to go into the girls' changing room at an age when the girls probably need more privacy and are becoming increasingly self-conscious.

I think most children that age can get changed by themselves. So the problem is generally men and the safety risk they are viewed as posing to young boys in a vulnerable situation. That leaves three solutions for their parents:


  • DC don't use the men's changing rooms. Instead, dress them ready to go swimming so they can just strip off a onesie or something like that and go straight in. Have a wearable towel or one of those changing towels for afterwards so they don't need to get changed back into their clothes or they can do it outside the changing-rooms.

  • The old classic of mum stands next to the men's changing room speaking incredibly loudly to her son while he gets changed so she knows he's not messing around and everyone in there knows mum is outside ready to rush in if they try anything. Unsubtle and irritating, but effective depending on the changing room layout.

  • Give boys a personal alarm in case they feel unsafe. Will probably be misused quite a bit and end up irritating a lot of people, but better safe than sorry and may work to frighten off a potential predator.


One thing I would say is be careful judging boys' ages - some are a lot younger than they look. My 5yo is very tall for his age and could probably pass for around 7. I remember a young girl telling him when he hadn't even turned 3 that this was the girl's changing room and he couldn't be in here, which I found quite funny 😁. The mother shushed her and I explained nicely that he was only 2 so very little and couldn't swim so I needed to keep an eye on him, but I hope that girl will still feel confident standing up for her right to privacy as she gets older!

Whatthechicken · 23/05/2022 12:11

I wonder when men are going to sort their shit out so women don’t have to worry about sending their boys into the men’s/boys to get changed alone.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 23/05/2022 12:10

Justkeeppedaling · 23/05/2022 12:06

The OP has said that the unisex changing room is badged disabled/ family so the boys and their mums are entitled to use it.

That is also unacceptable. Toilets for disabled people should be reserved for disabled people.

But that's not the fault of the people using the space labelled for them. I am disabled so need the extra space etc. But if the only facility I can use is labelled as family as well I cannot blame the family

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 12:08

Justkeeppedaling · 23/05/2022 12:06

The OP has said that the unisex changing room is badged disabled/ family so the boys and their mums are entitled to use it.

That is also unacceptable. Toilets for disabled people should be reserved for disabled people.

That's a debate to take up with the hotel, not the people who use a room labelled for them. It's like blaming parents using baby change facilities for using disabled toilets when they're put in as shared spaces.

Justkeeppedaling · 23/05/2022 12:06

The OP has said that the unisex changing room is badged disabled/ family so the boys and their mums are entitled to use it.

That is also unacceptable. Toilets for disabled people should be reserved for disabled people.

Sirzy · 23/05/2022 12:05

It’s labelled disabled/family.

and this in itself makes life harder for people with disabilities because the chances are when they need it then won’t be able to access the only space they can change in. For many people that uncertainty makes it so they can’t risk going swimming because they can’t wait around getting cold while a family finish off.

disabled facilities shouldn’t be shared facilities.

Change123today · 23/05/2022 12:03

for the one saying 9/10/11 boys are not a threat - yes BUT they are making my daughter uncomfortable and you are teaching your sons that their rights trump over right our daughters.

Please bring this up with the pool management whether it’s because your son struggles or to you men are a possible threat to your son THEY need to provide appropriate spaces. Don’t just take over womens spaces please teach your sons that. Or even teach them to protect themselves and independence. By over riding this your telling our girls their voice is silent and the boys need all the spaces.

Whatwouldscullydo · 23/05/2022 11:59

InChocolateWeTrust · 23/05/2022 11:55

I'm quite surprised at boys who want to go in the ladies at that age. My kid is not yet 6 and has started to object to coming in the ladies loos etc with me now, he's not weird about nudity/privacy yet but thinks because he's a boy he should be going in the gents.

I take my dd to swim.lessons every week. There are some dads who go too. They don't go in the male group change with their sons though. The dads seem happy to send their kids in by themselves.

This seems like a problem only the women face. Not saying they should not consider There to be a problem.. just wondered how aware they are that their husbands and partners don't put equal consideration into their sons safety.

Testina · 23/05/2022 11:58

Every time this comes up, it’s always boys in the female changing. And I always think - when is it going to be fathers who take their kids swimming?

No need to pile on with individual examples of those that do - if it were 50/50 then these threads wouldn’t always be about boys.

OP, I’d tell the swim school and the location that you don’t want boys over 8 in there and any parent who needs to be with an older child should be the one changing elsewhere.

(I pick 8 because that seems to be the usual age stated in changing rooms)

Clymene · 23/05/2022 11:57

I agree it's uncomfortable sending them into the men's on their own. But that's the right thing to do

InChocolateWeTrust · 23/05/2022 11:55

I'm quite surprised at boys who want to go in the ladies at that age. My kid is not yet 6 and has started to object to coming in the ladies loos etc with me now, he's not weird about nudity/privacy yet but thinks because he's a boy he should be going in the gents.

InChocolateWeTrust · 23/05/2022 11:53

And if you're half dressed 6 yo falls over / gets in a tangle who do you think is more likely to help? An adult woman who people will assume is just being kind, or an adult male who people will side eye and wonder about?

ive never seen a policy say 6 it’s usually 8/9.

Two years doesn't really change my point but I can repost the whole thing with 8 if that helps 🙄

The point is two years does change it . Why the fuck would an 8 or 9 year old fall over or get in a tangle getting changed for swimming? These are junior school kids who regularly have to dress etc for PE and the like, they should be able to cope without an adult for 10 mins and manage. These boys probably fall over playing football and don't need mummy on hand then.

FancyFelix · 23/05/2022 11:47

I totally support single sex changing facilities.
However the problem (as ever) is men.
When my boys were small but too old to change with me I did worry about them in the men's changing rooms.
It does feel quite risky sending your small boy into a changing facility with strange men.
However my kids didn't want to go in the ladies and had strict instructions to leave (even if they weren't finished) if a man approached them and to stay together.

Completely agree with this. It's uncomfortable sending a small boy into the mens alone but it's the only option for us.

bigbluebus · 23/05/2022 11:46

The cut off is 8 at all my local pools. When my DS had lessons and then moved on to the informal swim club he had to get changed unaided in the male changing rooms. He had a diagnosis of ASD. He was nearly always last out of the changing rooms but he managed to get dry, dressed and bring all his belongings out with him. No way would he have wanted to go in the ladies changing room or have me go in the men's. There was no disabled or communal changing room.
Unless these boys have SN that mean they can't get themselves dressed unaided then they need to be in their own changing room and their mothers need to leave them to it.

YesIKnowIABUbutIamreallytired · 23/05/2022 11:46

So much anger towards other parents on here.
Mothers of girls are upset because girls should not have to get changed in front of boys. Fair.
Mothers of boys are upset because they are worried about their children being naked alone in a room with strange naked men. Also fair.
Neither the mothers of boys or mothers of girls are to blame here. Open plan changing facilities are not suitable for families, and places that do not adapt to the needs of families are to blame. That's what needs to change. Choosing which sex gets put at risk/put in an uncomfortable situation is NOT the answer here.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 11:44

Two years usually makes a huge difference in the child’s ability to sort themselves out! it doesn't change their risk of being abused and it doesn't remove the risk of them falling over, losing something, ending up in a not.

Glitterspy · 23/05/2022 11:44

The cut off age for boys in women's spaces should be 8 IMHO. Any older than that and they're all too 'looky' for my liking...

We used to swim in a health club with similar arrangements (now we swim at the local pool which is all mixed so no issues). There were so many complaints that they enforced the 8+ rule.

Swipe left for the next trending thread