Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys in girls changing at swimming

239 replies

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 10:06

This is not a trans issue!

my daughter 11 attends swimming lessons at a hotel pool there are several parents who insist on helping there boys age 9/10/11 in the girls open plan changing room. The hotel’s suggestion is that my daughter and her friend change in the disabled changing room.
So the girls should be pushed out there own space. The boys have no additional needs but surely if they did they should use the disabled changing room.

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 13:17

Are you generalising that all men are a risk? yes, I clearly meant every man is a rapist and a paedophile! 🙄🙄🙄🙄

my comment was that as a group, men pose a higher risk of carrying out sexual abuse. would you like to prove me wrong? and I say this as a wife of a wonderful husband, mother to three boys, Aunty to two great nephews etc. THEY might never do anything wrong but that doesn't mean someone else's husband, sons or nephews won't. and that's more likely than someone's mother, daughter or niece.

Trivester · 23/05/2022 13:15

It’s best to drill down in these situations and ask lots of questions.

what if a disabled person needs to use the disabled facility? who will take priority - should the girls wait or the disabled person?

Depending on their answer you might want to enquire if
it is the policy that the hierarchy of needs is boys, then disabled, then girls? (and whether they are offering a discount to female members)
or
if they are aware of their legal obligations to provide facilities for the disabled (maybe they need to check with someone more senior to be sure)

Try and channel your inner preschooler and ask all the obvious questions.

Dinoteeth · 23/05/2022 13:13

Georgeskitchen · 23/05/2022 10:50

Non SEN children of 9/10/11should not need their mother to dress them

SEN or not SEN I actually don't believe any 10 or 11 year old boy would want to be seen dead in the girls changing room. 8/9 year olds maybe but by 10 no chance.

Bootothegoose · 23/05/2022 13:13

Not unreasonable at all.

I always remember my sister coming home from swimming extremely upset at about fourteen. She had been to the pool with her friends and when she had gone to get changed in a cubicle, there was a spout of giggling and she looked down to see two boys peering under the bottom at her.
My mum rang the leisure centre and they were very unconcerned and advised she lay a towel under the door (it was about a foot gap). Would never get away with that now but we changed pools.

DD goes swimming at our local leisure centre and it’s family, male and female. We go in the family area and get changed in a cubicle. That being said I put them both in onesies with their costumes on before hand and they put them back on after and they get straight in the bath when they get home.

Having boys in a girl’s changing rooms at the expense of their feelings of comfort is outrageous and as the mother of a son and a daughter he would be going straight to the boy’s changing room.

Whatwouldscullydo · 23/05/2022 13:08

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 13:01

I agree. Part of the reason we're having this discussion is because it's overwhelmingly mums who do the running around for children's activities such as swimming. Hence it's a much bigger problem for mums of boys (or both genders).

Though fathers can behave inappropriately as well. The number of men who think it is appropriate to accompany their daughters into the women's toilets/changing-rooms...😡. Much worse than having boys in there and they ought to know better.

Yeah its always NAMALT when you tell them bounderies apply to them

Yet when they can take advantage suddenly men are dangerous and their dd shouldn't be exposed even witg a father to protect her and of an age its appropriate that they attend whatever facility applicable to the sex of the parent

Which is it? Cos from.where I'm.standing it looks like you are using your dd to be a dickhead.

XelaM · 23/05/2022 13:03

on*

Freemoney22 · 23/05/2022 13:02

This reply has been deleted

XelaM · 23/05/2022 13:02

UnderripeBanana · 23/05/2022 11:16

The cut off is 8 in all the pools around here but it's never enforced. Boys as old as 11 are often in the womens changing rooms, which forces my daughter into a cubicle Angry

Last time one came in I happened to be changing too and went around bra-less for ages and another woman (a kind feminist stranger!) joined me. The boy stayed in the main changing 🙄 but started hiding behind his oblivious mum. Hoping next time he will be less keen to come in.

Tried asking staff to enforce but they're minimum wage teenagers.

So you were deliberately walking bra-less "for ages" in front of an unknown to you 11-year-old boy? Wtf is wrong with you 🤨

I have a daughter, but some people of this thread are mental

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 13:01

Whatwouldscullydo · 23/05/2022 12:54

This is the reason men won't sort it out. And actively participate in keeping up the image of men being predatory. Because it absolves them of responsibilities. Leaves it all to the mum.

They don't want it to change they benefit too much from things the way they are

I agree. Part of the reason we're having this discussion is because it's overwhelmingly mums who do the running around for children's activities such as swimming. Hence it's a much bigger problem for mums of boys (or both genders).

Though fathers can behave inappropriately as well. The number of men who think it is appropriate to accompany their daughters into the women's toilets/changing-rooms...😡. Much worse than having boys in there and they ought to know better.

gotthis · 23/05/2022 12:59

tigerlilymochalatte · 23/05/2022 12:50

I completely agree with this, I have a DD and a DS and I can see how women and girls dont want to change infront of boys but I can also see that boys aged around 10 can still be vulnerable on their own changing with grown men they dont know.

Mums of girls often comment on how the girls feel (which also matters) but as a mum of a boy, the thought of sending a 9 year old boy in to change without knowing whos also in there and whats going on can be quite worrying. It is most likely to be fine but you wouldn't know otherwise. Mums of girls can supervise DD changing until they are 100% happy they are ready to be on their own and can always pop in to check if they're unsure.

The only answer is unisex and family cubicles, solves a lot of issues.

This

Waxonwaxoff0 · 23/05/2022 12:55

All children age 8 and above at DS's swim school have to change alone in their own sex changing room. DS goes into the boy's changing room. It's at a private pool though so there are no general members of the public there, just the other kids in the class.

Whatwouldscullydo · 23/05/2022 12:54

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 12:52

I noticed it was usually mum with about 3 kids to wrangle despite dad being there too and he was happily in the male changing not having to supervise any children. In that situation send the boys in with Dad ffs!

This would make me angry too. When DH and I are out with DC together, DH takes him to the men's toilet/changing-room with him. Every single time. Because they're "boys". It's been that way since DC was no longer a baby in the pushchair.

This is the reason men won't sort it out. And actively participate in keeping up the image of men being predatory. Because it absolves them of responsibilities. Leaves it all to the mum.

They don't want it to change they benefit too much from things the way they are

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 12:54

Sirzy · 23/05/2022 12:05

It’s labelled disabled/family.

and this in itself makes life harder for people with disabilities because the chances are when they need it then won’t be able to access the only space they can change in. For many people that uncertainty makes it so they can’t risk going swimming because they can’t wait around getting cold while a family finish off.

disabled facilities shouldn’t be shared facilities.

This is a very good point, I’ve actually never seen it used by a family.

OP posts:
ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 12:52

I noticed it was usually mum with about 3 kids to wrangle despite dad being there too and he was happily in the male changing not having to supervise any children. In that situation send the boys in with Dad ffs!

This would make me angry too. When DH and I are out with DC together, DH takes him to the men's toilet/changing-room with him. Every single time. Because they're "boys". It's been that way since DC was no longer a baby in the pushchair.

tigerlilymochalatte · 23/05/2022 12:50

Swayingpalmtrees · 23/05/2022 10:52

Unisex family changing rooms should be available in every leisure centre along with the single sex facilities for men/women - boys and girls. Why is it so hard to implement such a basic function such as providing safe changing areas for everyone.

I completely agree with this, I have a DD and a DS and I can see how women and girls dont want to change infront of boys but I can also see that boys aged around 10 can still be vulnerable on their own changing with grown men they dont know.

Mums of girls often comment on how the girls feel (which also matters) but as a mum of a boy, the thought of sending a 9 year old boy in to change without knowing whos also in there and whats going on can be quite worrying. It is most likely to be fine but you wouldn't know otherwise. Mums of girls can supervise DD changing until they are 100% happy they are ready to be on their own and can always pop in to check if they're unsure.

The only answer is unisex and family cubicles, solves a lot of issues.

BashfulClam · 23/05/2022 12:49

The answer is definitely not boys being in the girls changing rooms. I used to hate this when it was family swimming at my gym. Boys of 10/11 in the female changing rooms. One pointing out to another ‘you can see that woman’s Boobies!’. I complained and they simply put up a sign. I noticed it was usually mum with about 3 kids to wrangle despite dad being there too and he was happily in the male changing not having to supervise any children. In that situation send the boys in with Dad ffs!

Whatwouldscullydo · 23/05/2022 12:47

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 12:42

And this is what I agree with.
Obviously the parents on this site think only girls are at risk of abuse and not boys.

Surely parebts need to take sone responsibility here ?

Phone. Email. Look online. Find pools that have facilities that suit you.

Don't just show up to a pool and expect to be able to override everyone else's safety amd privacy because you won't go elsewhere or pick a day your dh /dp can take the kid instead.

What do you think the rest of us did?

Hankunamatata · 23/05/2022 12:47

This is why I moved lessons to a pool with mixed changing village with big family showers and changing rooms. Mine do have sen though you wouldn't know it to look at and are incredibly vulnerable. I wouldn't want them in any changing space without direct supervision.

gotthis · 23/05/2022 12:46

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 23/05/2022 12:40

The 18yo boys are intimidating to your 12yo son the same way that your 12yo son would be intimidating to my 8yo daughter.

IMO it is clear cut, from 8 (9 at a stretch) everybody goes in the changing room that matches their sex. Anybody that needs assistance from someone the opposite sex should ask for a separate cubicle.

Are you saying you don't care if 8 year old boys get assaulted? Do you think mixed changing with cubicles is unacceptable? I know a pool that has this poolside, seems to work.

Clymene · 23/05/2022 12:46

Over 90% of sexual assaults in changing rooms happen in mixed sex changing facilities.

They do not keep women and children safe.

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 12:46

Are you generalising that all men are a risk?

Clearly not all men are a risk, but some are and the percentage who are is a lot higher than it is for women. Also, not every male in a public changing-room will be some other child's father.

The National Crime Agency estimates that between 1-3% of men have paedophile tendencies. So that's as high as 1 in every 33/4 men. Not taking into account that paedophiles may deliberately target public toilets and changing rooms where they can access vulnerable children so the percentages there may be higher.

So while the risks shouldn't be overstated, neither should they be ignored, and any parent sending young children into a situation where they are vulnerable and unsupervised needs to make sure that they are aware of the risks and know what to do should anything happen. And that's an awkward conversation to have with a 9 year old boy, which is why getting changed in the car park or hall might be preferable.

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 12:42

gotthis · 23/05/2022 12:26

I know two grown men who were sexually assaulted in public toilets, messed them up for life. I support mixed changing facilities with secure cubicles for this reason.

And this is what I agree with.
Obviously the parents on this site think only girls are at risk of abuse and not boys.

LovelyLovelyWarmCoffee · 23/05/2022 12:40

stayathomer · 23/05/2022 10:39

i wish there was a solution to all of this, my 12 yo uses the mens changing room and he hates it to the point he now basically just grabs towel barely dries and runs out. There is a training session after his lesson and he says some of the 17 and 18 yos are intimidating. My 14 yo is very lanky and I used to hate seeing him walk in behind grown men and used to get him to regularly shout through the door. My 9 yo is tiny and doesn’t mind but would be in trouble if anyone picked on him but his lesson is different so dh can go with him, 7yo will be lucky in that way too. I know women and girls deserve their own spaces but please just try and see that it’s not so clear cut and I understand why parents bring their boys into the womens

The 18yo boys are intimidating to your 12yo son the same way that your 12yo son would be intimidating to my 8yo daughter.

IMO it is clear cut, from 8 (9 at a stretch) everybody goes in the changing room that matches their sex. Anybody that needs assistance from someone the opposite sex should ask for a separate cubicle.

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 12:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 12:36

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 12:22

Tbf no one has mentioned 11 yo girls in the Boys with Dad but of course the same point applies.

However, men DO pose a greater risk than women, which is why men are more comfortable sending their girls off (hence the issue not being raised here) than women are sending their sons off.

If men weren't a risk, and if men wouldn't rather ignore a kid in need that risk someone THINKING he's a risk, we wouldn't be having this chat.

Are you generalising that all men are a risk?
If so, does this mean that fathers should not be changing their child’s nappies, wiping their bottoms, helping them to get dressed, bathing them etc. As in your eyes ‘men’ are a risk but these men are another child’s father.

Swipe left for the next trending thread