Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys in girls changing at swimming

239 replies

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 10:06

This is not a trans issue!

my daughter 11 attends swimming lessons at a hotel pool there are several parents who insist on helping there boys age 9/10/11 in the girls open plan changing room. The hotel’s suggestion is that my daughter and her friend change in the disabled changing room.
So the girls should be pushed out there own space. The boys have no additional needs but surely if they did they should use the disabled changing room.

OP posts:
Change123today · 23/05/2022 14:41

@SleepingStandingUp that what we ended up doing we managed to find a swim school with dedicated changing rooms - no parents whose children over the age of 7 allowed in the changing rooms. Lots of us just waiting - I swear mine took the longest!! As they got older it was harder as they swam (later in the day) in public pools but they would close the access to public swimming changing rooms - but much safer for all. Parents again banned from them. The classes where ability based but usually similar ages.

They did have disabled space which was available to use of appropriate if additional support needed.

Dinoteeth · 23/05/2022 14:35

But it also never ceases to amaze me how mums of girls aged 8/9/10 etc complain that their are boys with their mums in the female changing room and cause them of helicoptering - without seeing they are doing exactly the same!

This exactly!!!

While I'm happy with my DS doing into the boys alone part of that comfort comes from knowing that because it's a school pool rented out for swimming lessons the only people getting changed are other boys.
I really wouldn't be that comfortable sending him into the men's at a hotel, or private gym with other men changing.

It amazes me that the posh gyms, health clubs and hotels are the places with open changing rooms. Council places tend to have closed cubicles with doors 🚪

Clymene · 23/05/2022 14:33

In this instance, the disabled toilets are labelled disabled/family.

Simonjt · 23/05/2022 14:31

rookiemere · 23/05/2022 14:18

The 8+ boys should be getting changed in the disabled changing rooms if their DPs aren't comfortable with them in the male changing rooms.
I have to say if I was a guest at the hotel or a gym member as an adult female I wouldn't expect to have to share my space with age 8+ boys , I'm surprised they haven't had more complaints about this.

Being a child is not a disability.

Samcro · 23/05/2022 14:29

rookiemere · 23/05/2022 14:18

The 8+ boys should be getting changed in the disabled changing rooms if their DPs aren't comfortable with them in the male changing rooms.
I have to say if I was a guest at the hotel or a gym member as an adult female I wouldn't expect to have to share my space with age 8+ boys , I'm surprised they haven't had more complaints about this.

ffs
disabled changing rooms are for disabled people.

IrishMama2015 · 23/05/2022 14:29

The discussion seems to be happening in 2 parallels. Yes most kids 7+ can dress themselves. That is not the issue. The issue is parents do not want their kids alone and naked/dressing/undressing in a communal area without them. My area has one pool and so no we can't go anywhere else. I don't expect women or girls to give up their privacy for my DS so therefore the only conclusion is I go with him to the mens and use the cubicle there. I would also not let my DD in a changing room alone at this young age. It's not infantilising then it's PROTECTING them in spaces that abusers specifically target to prey on lone children.

itsgettingweird · 23/05/2022 14:27

This is why they need more changing villages.

I don't agree that boys should be allowed in the girls spaces or that the girls should move to accommodate them.

But it also never ceases to amaze me how mums of girls aged 8/9/10 etc complain that their are boys with their mums in the female changing room and cause them of helicoptering - without seeing they are doing exactly the same!

I agree with the mums above who have said seeing their 9yo walk into the mens alone makes them feel their children could be vulnerable - it needs to be recognised that parents of both sexes feel their young children are vulnerable unsupervised around grown men.

And the solution isn't just to shove the boys into the mens alone anymore than it is for the girls to loose their own space.

It's not black and white.

rookiemere · 23/05/2022 14:26

@SleepingStandingUp handily in this case there is a disabled changing room that can be used.
The debating point is should the girls have to use them rather than the Ladies changing room, or should the boys who are uncomfortable/DPs are uncomfortable with them going into the Mens changing room use them ?
Seems fairly obvious to me that girls should be able to use the Ladies changing room.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 14:25

I have to say we need to start taking DS, 7, swimming soon and I'd assumed there would be family hanging but I will def be checking before a pick a pool. Whilst I don't think it's OK to say "well it doesn't matter if they're at more risk of abuse, that pendulum will swing when he's older" or "boys don't deserve privacy like girls do" as it seems some believe on here, I do agree that boys over a certain age shouldn't be in there and as HIS mother that's on me, just like all the girl Mom's on here should be complaining every time theres an issue

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 14:20

WhoopItUp · 23/05/2022 14:15

I’m really surprised at people suggesting 9 is an appropriate cut off age. Surely 7 is the max (SN aside). My 5 year old can manage to get showered, undressed and changed after swimming with no fuss at all (other than being a bit slow as they gaff around). Surely the vast majority of 7 year olds can do this?

He could, although I'd have to shout through the door to hurry up. But did you miss the whole conversation about boys being more vulnerable around naked adult males either in terms of abuse or them just refusing to step in of anything happens in case they're accused of abuse? I had grown men tell me to come into the men's loos rather than them direct my 6 into a cubicle. They then all used cubicles so I could come and go without seeing their penis. I doubt women would do the same if I girl was standing in the loos asking where to go. (first time alone in the boys and was confused by urinals)

rookiemere · 23/05/2022 14:18

The 8+ boys should be getting changed in the disabled changing rooms if their DPs aren't comfortable with them in the male changing rooms.
I have to say if I was a guest at the hotel or a gym member as an adult female I wouldn't expect to have to share my space with age 8+ boys , I'm surprised they haven't had more complaints about this.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 14:17

Towel over the head is your answer but also why is it less embarrassing than flashing a dressing room full of girls/women? no the discussion was boys being expected to dress poolside whilst girls must have a changing room because "boys are easier, they don't need to get properly dressed or have a shower or privacy, they aren't GIRLS after all".
The answer is proper changing spaces for everyone which are safe, not telling boys they don't deserve privacy because they're only boys. No one would (rightly) countenance telling girls to change poolside because their privacy doesn't matter. My long haired son comment was in response to the "girls have long hair so need a changing room!" which is clearly nonsense as they can just put a towel on their head. And if a towel around them offered proper privacy, neither would need changing rooms.

WhoopItUp · 23/05/2022 14:15

I’m really surprised at people suggesting 9 is an appropriate cut off age. Surely 7 is the max (SN aside). My 5 year old can manage to get showered, undressed and changed after swimming with no fuss at all (other than being a bit slow as they gaff around). Surely the vast majority of 7 year olds can do this?

Clymene · 23/05/2022 14:14

This is a hotel swimming pool where children's swimming lessons are taking place. It is vanishingly unlikely the changing rooms are full of naked men.

I am a lone parent of a son and a daughter. By the time my son was old enough to get changed on his own, we switched to ones in a school so there were only other boys in there, no adult men.

suzyscat · 23/05/2022 14:13

It's not nice for anyone and it shouldn't be the girls who have to make space, but at the same time, young boys are also vulnerable to predatory adults so I fully understand parents not wanting to send primary age and young secondary age children into an adult male changing area unescorted.

Lavenderlast · 23/05/2022 14:11

Elsiebear90 · 23/05/2022 14:06

Why are people acting like seeing a male naked body will scar young boys and girls, but seeing naked girls and women is completely acceptable for both sexes? So male bodies are taboo, even for very young children, but it’s okay for 10/11 year old boys who are often very aware of what sex is and very very curious about women to be in a room full of naked women? It doesn’t make sense.

It doesn’t make sense. The people making such policy are so naive.

When my son was six I used to take him into the ladies changing room at the pool. He became very interested in breasts and kept pointing and giggling at some of the women! One time he even got an erection there 🙈 I don’t want to be talking about this on the internet, but I’m sick of everyone pretending that boys don’t react to the sight of a naked woman. It starts very young.

Lavenderlast · 23/05/2022 14:08

The hotel needs to sort it out, you should complain and keep saying the word “safeguarding”. Ask for their policy in writing, and make a formal complaint.

Our swim school is extremely clear that children under age 7 change in the changing room that is the sex of the parent and children age 7 or above get changed in the changing room that matches their sex. This may mean the 7 year old changes alone, which they should be able to do by then. If parents don’t like it they can’t yse the pool.

The last few hotels I stayed at all had a similar policy to our swim school. In one hotel where the pool access was via changing rooms I was stopped by staff and very specifically told my 7 yr old could not even walk through the girls changing room, he had to go through the mens on his own.

Your hotel sounds crap and misogynist. Girls wanting privacy is a disability is it? What about disabled people who might actually want to use their own room?

Elsiebear90 · 23/05/2022 14:06

Why are people acting like seeing a male naked body will scar young boys and girls, but seeing naked girls and women is completely acceptable for both sexes? So male bodies are taboo, even for very young children, but it’s okay for 10/11 year old boys who are often very aware of what sex is and very very curious about women to be in a room full of naked women? It doesn’t make sense.

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 14:06

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 13:55

And why should a boy be made to get dressed under a towel in a hall?

Because it's the least worse outcome. Girls are entitled to privacy in the women's changing-rooms. And that means boys above a certain age have to get dressed somewhere else. And yes, parents of boys are likely to choose pools with appropriate changing facilities if that is an option, so it's only really an issue where this isn't an option.

I don’t know if girls/women would be comfortable getting dressed in front of other women/girls anyway, the answer is cubicles for all. I hated having to shower with other girls at school, so the logical answer is a cubicle.

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 13:55

And why should a boy be made to get dressed under a towel in a hall?

Because it's the least worse outcome. Girls are entitled to privacy in the women's changing-rooms. And that means boys above a certain age have to get dressed somewhere else. And yes, parents of boys are likely to choose pools with appropriate changing facilities if that is an option, so it's only really an issue where this isn't an option.

Change123today · 23/05/2022 13:55

@Ntsure not at all I think there needs be spaces for mothers and sons. All children need to kept safe it’s the right thing to do.But instead of saying (not all) men stop being a risk to young children and fixing that we asking girls to submit to fix the issue - why should they have to?

At the moment girls have no choices …boys get mens changing rooms, female changing room and the family changing room …she gets none.

the argument constantly swings both ways - girls stopping swimming because they don’t have space to change.

At what point to we make it fair for all is what I’m asking - like I said even with family changing the mothers still being their sons into the female changing rooms :(

Moonface123 · 23/05/2022 13:54

My son wouldn' t use the male showers as alot of the men were showering naked at the gym.He came home and showered. He was 15 at the time, so how on earth can a lone parent be expected to send a young male in mens changing room on his own. ?

XelaM · 23/05/2022 13:53

more embarrassing*

XelaM · 23/05/2022 13:53

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 13:43

My son has long hair, so is he entitled to a changing room? Because that obv matters more than his towel falling down pool side and him flashing the whole pool his bits.

Towel over the head is your answer but also why is it less embarrassing than flashing a dressing room full of girls/women?

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 13:52

what exactly should mums of boys do in this situation? If the only changing rooms are male and female. Send them in unaccompanied to the mens putting them at risk of being sexually abused? Or are boys not allowed to go swimming?
Many other solutions have been suggested. Bring them ready-changed, change them in the car/carpark/hall under a changing-robe, get them to change poolside. Or change swimming-pools to one with unisex changing rooms.

Swipe left for the next trending thread