Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys in girls changing at swimming

239 replies

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 10:06

This is not a trans issue!

my daughter 11 attends swimming lessons at a hotel pool there are several parents who insist on helping there boys age 9/10/11 in the girls open plan changing room. The hotel’s suggestion is that my daughter and her friend change in the disabled changing room.
So the girls should be pushed out there own space. The boys have no additional needs but surely if they did they should use the disabled changing room.

OP posts:
TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 22:17

@ChocolateHippo 1in 35 where does that figure come from?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 21:40

And as for I'm not unsympathetic, but fight the flipping battle and leave the girls to their space you do realise that I'm actually a woman too, the lack of daughters doesn't change that. So the "female spaces for females" also affects m+boy-Mom's and most of us don't want random 11, year olds pointing and giggling at our bits either. It isn't as "us lovely girl-mommies and you stupid boy-Mom's" as you'd like

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 21:36

you're talking nonsense.

No, I'm not
Yes you are.

But in reference to your comments that I'd implied yeah, fuck girls and their dignity and that I assume [my] son is welcome where we and our girls are changing not in your assertion that girls deserve privacy which I'd already agreed with numerous times.

Abd as for "precious" boys, surely all parents should treat their kids that way. And I may not have daughters but I have nieces and proxy-nieces. Being surrounded by penis'at home doesn't mean that boy-moms suddenly hate girls ffs.

Brefugee · 23/05/2022 21:08

Except I've repeatedly said I'm my posts that I agree lads over 8 or so shouldn't be in the girls either, I just don't think it's as simple as "send them in the men's, whats the worst thaw t can happen" so yeah, you're talking nonsense.

No, I'm not. I am saying that the girls - lucky ones - and women - have their own space and boys are not required there, thanks. And if you are worried about your son going into the mens's changing - you are the one who is going to have to push to get somewhere for the boys to change. The girls already have one and it has been a long struggle, and still is, to allow women to do sport and have their own spaces. I'm not unsympathetic, but fight the flipping battle and leave the girls to their space.

Frankly I think that individual cubicles, and some family rooms, are the answer and that is what we have where i live. But if i were in a girls/womens room and boys were in - mums or not - and giggling and pointing? I would ask their mum to remove then and request of the management that girls don't have boys encroaching in their space. It is not a difficult concept to grasp that maybe the parents of boys could get active on the boys behalfs instead of just barging into where the girls are, is it?

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 21:07

you mothers of precious boys

How unpleasant. It's not precious to not want your child (male or female) to be at risk.

And most people on here (including me) have said that it's not a problem for girls and women to solve. And have suggested alternatives to having boys in girls' spaces. Thereby 'fighting their corner' without inconveniencing girls.

But 'just send them into the men's and who cares if they're assaulted' is not a pleasant narrative in relation to 8 year old children.

And it's interesting that it's often women (in this case, mothers of boys) who are having to fight their corner. Men mostly get off with a free pass once again while women get the blame.

OnTheGoAlways · 23/05/2022 21:03

YANBU...but childrens swimming lessons seem to be a free for all. My DS 7 goes once per week, it is extremely busy when we're there, Full of swimming lessons and closed to the public, and every week men come into the womans changing rooms with their children, doesn't seem to matter the gender of the child and quite often a couple will bring their child into the womans changing room and sit and chat while naked children are getting changed.

SleepingStandingUp · 23/05/2022 20:57

Brefugee · 23/05/2022 20:54

It might say a lot about men, both in terms of the threat they pose and their awareness of that that would make them step back, not help etc, but as I didn't raise them, that's not on me. My concern is my 10 yo. Saying we'll it's ok for male 10 yos to be at risk cos the risk is from men so it's on men isn't really helpful.

yeah, fuck girls and their dignity, right?
You are the mother of a boy: fight their bloody corner then, don't just assume your son is welcome where we and our girls are changing, FFS. We have to fight enough bloody battles about this without you mothers of precious boys taking away our rights. I'd walk round naked too just to piss them off.

Except I've repeatedly said I'm my posts that I agree lads over 8 or so shouldn't be in the girls either, I just don't think it's as simple as "send them in the men's, whats the worst thaw t can happen" so yeah, you're talking nonsense.

Brefugee · 23/05/2022 20:54

It might say a lot about men, both in terms of the threat they pose and their awareness of that that would make them step back, not help etc, but as I didn't raise them, that's not on me. My concern is my 10 yo. Saying we'll it's ok for male 10 yos to be at risk cos the risk is from men so it's on men isn't really helpful.

yeah, fuck girls and their dignity, right?
You are the mother of a boy: fight their bloody corner then, don't just assume your son is welcome where we and our girls are changing, FFS. We have to fight enough bloody battles about this without you mothers of precious boys taking away our rights. I'd walk round naked too just to piss them off.

LisaSimpson1984 · 23/05/2022 20:47

My husband takes my five year old to her swimming lesson on a Saturday morning. Obviously he takes her into the mens changing room to get changed. No cubicles, open plan room. It’s at 8am though so it’s usually very very quiet.

Recently he took her in and as he was drying her off, an older man came in. Husband said he stripped off and wandered around, bollock naked, for a good 5 minutes before my husband became uncomfortable and left. For no discernible reason. Just looking in the mirror, slowly putting his stuff in the locker before putting his trunks on etc. Penis adangle. Pretty much level with my four year olds face. How lovely.

Now obviously there are going to be naked men in there. Obviously. Husband usually just chats away to 4 to keep her distracted. But my husband felt that this was deliberate.

Whether the man was simply oblivious, making a point (like the poster above with her breasts out to scare the 11 year old), or whether his intentions were more sinister, we shall never know, but my husband became very uncomfortable and he pretty much chucked 4’s dress over her head and finished drying off her hair in the corridor (she was furious about not getting to dry her costume in the spinner, so then that was a whole thing…).

I think I might need to take her from now on because that makes me feel quite sick. I can understand the concerns of the boy-mums on here (although again it’s not the problem of the girls to solve).

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 20:27

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 20:08

Thanks for all the answers and replies I didn’t expect so many, I’m really sorry so many people feel their sons are in such danger in mens changing rooms.

It's not a question of 'feeling'. In a world where up to 1 in 35 men have paedophilic tendencies, young boys who are unsupervised in a vulnerable situation where they are undressed just are in a certain degree of danger unless they're clued up and capable of dealing with predatory males, because sooner or later the probability is that they're going to come across one. A 14 year old might be capable, a 7 year old probably not (regardless of whether they can get themselves sorted without help). That doesn't mean that older boys should change with girls and women, but it is a very real danger which parents need to take into account and which shouldn't be minimised.

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 20:08

Thanks for all the answers and replies I didn’t expect so many, I’m really sorry so many people feel their sons are in such danger in mens changing rooms.

OP posts:
TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 20:03

itsgettingweird · 23/05/2022 14:27

This is why they need more changing villages.

I don't agree that boys should be allowed in the girls spaces or that the girls should move to accommodate them.

But it also never ceases to amaze me how mums of girls aged 8/9/10 etc complain that their are boys with their mums in the female changing room and cause them of helicoptering - without seeing they are doing exactly the same!

I agree with the mums above who have said seeing their 9yo walk into the mens alone makes them feel their children could be vulnerable - it needs to be recognised that parents of both sexes feel their young children are vulnerable unsupervised around grown men.

And the solution isn't just to shove the boys into the mens alone anymore than it is for the girls to loose their own space.

It's not black and white.

My daughter goes in on her own but complains about it when she comes out!

OP posts:
Marlboroandmalbec34 · 23/05/2022 18:22

Thank you for this thread op. I have a 4 yr old girl and a 6 yr old boy. I take them to a swim class weekly at a hotel/ gym. It’s really busy and I have been changing both in the ladies but there are lots of teenage girls and I wondered if I was in the wrong. I knew I would need to start sending my boy into the mens soon and dreaded it. My boy is tall and is often mistaken for 8/9. So I’m going to stop. I have just bought two lovely long hooded towels and will change both pool side from now on.

rookiemere · 23/05/2022 18:08

@ILoveMyLifeToday I have no issue if an older boy needs help and uses a cubicle in the female changing room. I think few people would have any objections in those circumstances.
I can't remember what we did once DS hit 8. I'm pretty sure he just used the mens changing room, but he was generally with a pal and I can't remember ever being concerned about it. Maybe I should have been, but he would have been mortified to have to change in the Ladies.

SpeedofaSloth · 23/05/2022 17:43

Our local pool uses 8 years as the cut off age, that's OK I think. Older isn't, IMO.

ILoveMyLifeToday · 23/05/2022 17:41

I used to have to help my son when he went swimming at about 8 years old. I don't think they had a disabled changing room. He has autism and ADHD but the other mums wouldn't have known that and he wasn't I diagnosed back then anyway so I would have felt like a fraud using it. We used the girls changing room but went in a cubicle, I hope no one was offended. Never crossed my mind back then tbh. My bad.

BeautifulDragon · 23/05/2022 17:25

We swim at our local health club and the changing rooms are open plan. There is also a family changing room, but that is often occupied by men with young daughters, so if I'm changing too it's not suitable.

I have a 9yo girl & 7yo boy, so see it from both sides. The cut off point for boys in the female changing room is 8+ and I am worried for when DS will have to go it alone on the men's.

The posters saying 'why can't these boys manage to get changed alone' etc are missing the point by a mile. They are vulnerable children, alone and dressing themselves in-front of unknown men. It's hardly surprising why some mums would find this is an issue.

If I had two boys I probably wouldn't mind as much, but I don't. I would have no idea if DS was in trouble or needed help and he wouldn't be able to contact me.

WhoopItUp · 23/05/2022 17:20

Nothappyatwork · 23/05/2022 14:47

This was my answer to my local gym when they insisted that my eight-year-old was able to get changed on his own or that actually he wasn’t able to access the female changing rooms. I went and waited in the men’s. I’m actually most of the men commented who understood why I did it.

If the only people getting changed were boys (I.e. a kids only swimming lesson) , I can understand this. However, if there are men getting changed in there, this is appalling. They have a right to privacy too.

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 15:48

LittleOwl153 · 23/05/2022 15:25

Surely the alternative to all this boys can invade girls spaces when it suits their mothers - tough luck on the girls is to look for swimming lessons when the pool is being exclusively used by swimming lessons and therefore the ONLY people getting changed are children. That way there is no excuse for boys to use girls spaces. Most of the pools we use have blocks of time for swim lessons where noone else uses the pool - probably for this very reason.

To refuse to put boys in a changing room with other boys and instead invade a girls only space is very wrong. If you don't want your boys in the men's changing - then take them somewhere suitable - which by the way is not the ladies. I hope more girls start to challenge this rubbish but they don't as it is being forced upon them by adult women!

I don’t think anyone has said they don’t want their sons in a changing room with other boys, they’ve said they don’t want their children in a pool with adult men who may or may not have their genitals on display and rightly so, it is enough to make a young boy uncomfortable. Just the same as your daughter might not want to see other adult women’s genitals. I’m also surprised that any young girl, or young teen would even want to get dressed in a changing room without using a cubicle. I understand if there wasn’t any available but I’ve yet to go to a public swimming pool and not see cubicles for people to use.

Youdoyoutoday · 23/05/2022 15:45

Our local centre has a mixed changing room but with individual cubicles, larger family one at the back and single sex showers with individual shower cubicles.

Why does everything have to be mixed and on show? Most people prefer privacy.

LittleOwl153 · 23/05/2022 15:25

Surely the alternative to all this boys can invade girls spaces when it suits their mothers - tough luck on the girls is to look for swimming lessons when the pool is being exclusively used by swimming lessons and therefore the ONLY people getting changed are children. That way there is no excuse for boys to use girls spaces. Most of the pools we use have blocks of time for swim lessons where noone else uses the pool - probably for this very reason.

To refuse to put boys in a changing room with other boys and instead invade a girls only space is very wrong. If you don't want your boys in the men's changing - then take them somewhere suitable - which by the way is not the ladies. I hope more girls start to challenge this rubbish but they don't as it is being forced upon them by adult women!

Change123today · 23/05/2022 15:06

But it also never ceases to amaze me how mums of girls aged 8/9/10 etc complain that their are boys with their mums in the female changing room and cause them of helicoptering - without seeing they are doing exactly the same!

@Dinoteeth

i was more than happy for my daughter to go in alone - she wanted to & I supported the independence. But due to an upsetting incident with a boy from her school (he was with his Mum) making comments at school she got upset and asked me to go with her - I had to stand with a towel so she could get changed. I’d preferred not to be standing in a hot changing room!!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/05/2022 14:52

I think most places state 8 as the cut off age?

My 8 yo does struggle a bit as he has ADHD - fortunately (for us) everywhere we tend to go has village changing.

However if it was a boy girl divide for children lessons he’d have to go in the men’s and I’d hope he didn’t end up losing 3/4 of his stuff/ try to get in the pool in his socks/ gloves/ whatever.

Minimalme · 23/05/2022 14:51

I couldn't make any of my three ds change in the female changing room beyond the age of 8!

Even my 12 yr old child who is disabled with the capacity of a 2/3 year old knows men and women don't change together and that his bits are not for public display.

I have stood waiting outside the mens changing room for 30mins up to now waiting for him to change into his swimmers!

If he can do it, then honestly, most 8+ year old boys can too.

Nothappyatwork · 23/05/2022 14:47

This was my answer to my local gym when they insisted that my eight-year-old was able to get changed on his own or that actually he wasn’t able to access the female changing rooms. I went and waited in the men’s. I’m actually most of the men commented who understood why I did it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread