Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys in girls changing at swimming

239 replies

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 10:06

This is not a trans issue!

my daughter 11 attends swimming lessons at a hotel pool there are several parents who insist on helping there boys age 9/10/11 in the girls open plan changing room. The hotel’s suggestion is that my daughter and her friend change in the disabled changing room.
So the girls should be pushed out there own space. The boys have no additional needs but surely if they did they should use the disabled changing room.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 24/05/2022 03:25

Ntsure · 23/05/2022 11:02

The disabled changing room is for disabled people.
woukd you be happy for your children to get dressed alone in a room with men? Probably not, so why on earth do you think the parents of boys would be happy with that.
a 9/10/1/ year old boy in a changing room with their mum isn’t a threat to your kids

No that's fine because small boys are only going to grow into disgusting men who want nothing more than to rape women and girls.

And disabled people can clearly just go fuck themselves, why would they need the facilities they fought for the provision of?

Parents - if you are not comfortable with the changing arrangements provided - you can refuse to allow your child to use them, and you can make a big noise with the facility and the club/school/whatever.

What you can't do, is trample over everyone elses provision or rights to make lives easier for yourselves.

LateAF · 24/05/2022 02:10

A child’s age is not always obvious- my 5 year old son gets mistaken for an 8 year old as he’s off the centile growth charts for his age. I’ve had looks before from other mums when I take him to the ladies with me. I also have a very real fear of abuse if he was alone in the mens (this is because a close relative experiencing childhood abuse while in a mens toilet). So the solution isn’t obvious. At the moment we are trying out changing poolside under big robe towels- my boys don’t love it but I do feel judged using the ladies changing facilities as a mum of young boys.

Gentleness · 24/05/2022 01:45

I agree with PP - dads taking girls into the boys changing rooms is also a problem, causing real embarrassment to my sons. There isn't a solution for pools that are stuck with 2 changing rooms, at least not one that doesn't involve parents sacrificing a bit of peace of mind, speed or convenience.

We have my pre-teen sons having 8 year old girls watching them try to cover up in the open boys' changing rooms and also my daughter having young boys watch her in open girls' changing rooms. We do our best to help them navigate this, but the lack of awareness of some parents of the privacy many children prefer is just stunning.

TravelDreamLife · 24/05/2022 01:34

They have one male & one female open plan change room each. They're very small, max 4 people. There's an individual, lockable bathroom (also disabled but not badged so ok to use). Also two large unisex change rooms. They have no doors & are mostly used by parents to change babies & very young children. It's a very old complex. Desperately needs updating but that costs money & owner is a tightwad.

Dinoteeth · 24/05/2022 00:56

I understand if there wasn’t any available but I’ve yet to go to a public swimming pool and not see cubicles for people to use.

It's very common in private gyms and hotels. I've tried load of places for swim lessons some times only a couple of lanes are reserved for lessons. The rest open for the gym members, hotel guests. Or the changing room may also be used by people using the gym rather then the swimming pool. Hence adults changing at the same time as kids.

The best answer is the communal changing villages with mix sex cubicles. Which tend to be found in council pools. But council swimming lessons tend to have far too many kids and my experience was far too little progress.

Children in with opposite sex parents has been an issue for years my DMum now in her 70s stopped swimming with her Dad because he wasn't comfortable letting her go into the ladies alone and she didn't want to go into the men's. In MN world the issue is always boys in the ladies but girls in the boys with dad is an issue too and mums going into the boys.

XelaM · 24/05/2022 00:38

It honestly would never cross my mind to go into a men's changing room as a solution to any problem. 🙈

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2022 00:36

I am a woman and will not violate womens/girls spaces with my growing DS. I also won't leave my child naked and alone and vulnerable with strangers ESPECIALLY makes so I choose the best of a bad situation. A cubicle in the mens dressing room. so your answer is to violate mens spaces because they're less important. Good lesson for your son eh, one way to work towards equality. Make it clear that men should not be entitled to privacy from women if it's suits women because men did it first so fairs fair.

XelaM · 24/05/2022 00:32

your son*

XelaM · 24/05/2022 00:31

I'm quite shocked at a grown woman who would WANT to go into a men's changing room on a regular basis. That's literally the worst solution. Why not change your som pool-side with a long towel? Surely it's better than going into a men's changing room 😖

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2022 00:30

madasawethen · 23/05/2022 23:16

The solution is to take your sons into the men's changing room

Except it isn't because men are also entitled to privacy toom. I appreciate they're only men and its MN BUT how is ok for me to sit in there whilst teenage lads, young men etc are getting dressed?

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2022 00:26

I DON'T WANT MY SONS IN YOUR DAUGHTERS SPACES!!

I DON'T THINK IT'S OK FOR GIRLS TO NOT HAVE A SAFE SPACE

I THINK THE ISSUE THAT MY SON DOESN'T HAVE A SAFE SPACE DOESN'T MEAN I CAN TAKE SOMEONE ELSES

I've said all this and you persist in going on about how I'm taking your kids space and how I want my precious boys there.

Quote me once where I've suggested anything along the lines of

yeah, fuck girls and their dignity, right?

just assume your son is welcome where we and our girls are changing, FFS

you mothers of precious boys taking away our rights

Where have I once suggested that it's the jobs of girl-Mom's to fight for safe spaces for boys?

You have a bug up your arse but I didn't put it there so stop having a go at me about things you've imagined I've said.

And my kids are 6 and 2, so perfectly entitled to use the women's changing room / toilets and actually the disabled changing facilities too

And the fact your response to a kid being made to come into the changing room with Mom would be to expose your naked body to him says all I need to know about you, frankly.

I'd walk round naked too just to piss them off.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2022 00:26

Oh fuck no idea what that just did.

SleepingStandingUp · 24/05/2022 00:25

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Confusion101 · 24/05/2022 00:24

Clymene · 23/05/2022 14:14

This is a hotel swimming pool where children's swimming lessons are taking place. It is vanishingly unlikely the changing rooms are full of naked men.

I am a lone parent of a son and a daughter. By the time my son was old enough to get changed on his own, we switched to ones in a school so there were only other boys in there, no adult men.

This!!!!!

A lot of people have spoken about their experience during swimming lessons. In our local pool / hotels, there is nobody else in the pool only those getting lessons. Sessions are scheduled with a short break between each to allow for dressing room use, so why on earth are there naked men lounging around in your dressing rooms? 🙈

I agree with all those saying it is not fair to make females feel uncomfortable in their own dressing facilities. Ideally all swimming pools should have family changing areas, or cubicles for everyone, no open plan changing area. Thankfully the only ones with the open plan gender specific ones around here are older swimming pools, although now that I think about it the hotels actually have this set up.

UnderripeBanana · 24/05/2022 00:20

Re going around braless, it's normal for these changing rooms! When the boy came in, most of the women and all the tween girls covered up. Why the fuck should we?

I'm not doing a sex dance for the kid 🙄 I'm in and out the showers trying to get the younger ones' hair washed. Ideal world there would not be an almost teenage boy there Angry

IrishMama2015 · 23/05/2022 23:52

@HiJenny35 there is no normal toilet. There is a womens and a mens and you have to go through one or the other to get to the pool and out again. There is no other pool unfortunately for us in a small rural town. Also the pool is open to all during kids swimming lessons. It is the leisure centre who had told me to do this as the best course of action.

I agree it's not ideal. It's embarrassing for all. But I won't put my son at risk. And I would never use a male childminder under any circumstances. Certainly I can't afford to pay for swim lessons and a childminder during swim lessons. My DH works during the swimming lesson hours available.

HiJenny35 · 23/05/2022 23:46

IrishMama2015 · 23/05/2022 23:25

I do this and below thread was accused of violating mens privacy.

There is a problem in some public places of no suitable space for parents with opposite gender children who still need parental supervision/ protection.

I am a woman and will not violate womens/girls spaces with my growing DS. I also won't leave my child naked and alone and vulnerable with strangers ESPECIALLY makes so I choose the best of a bad situation. A cubicle in the mens dressing room.

It's not OK for you to take your child into a men's changing room any more than it is a man to be in a cubicle in the womans. The same way as I'd report to the police a man who repeatedly did this I'd report to the police a woman who repeatedly did it, it's disgusting behaviour and you have no right. Use a normal toilet, take your child home just in a towelling gown, change pools to one with unisex cubicles, pay a male childminder to attend with you, whatever it is you have absolutely no right to be in a men's changing room.

Sweetmotherofallthatisholyabov · 23/05/2022 23:45

I wonder if you asked the gym/swimming pool/hotel whatever what their provision was for safe guarding unaccompanied children in changing rooms would their response be to just ban unaccompanied children? My ds in almost 6 and his swimming place is opening a family changing room - thank god. And I think the men's has a little separate area in it for kids already- but you've to walk through the main one to get to it. I'll also seen another local pool which has a small changing room which is more mixed before you have the main changing room. So you can have boys in there in the women's or women in the men's, but basically means you can be with your child to change before/after they walk through the main room with showers and pool access.

So if you're girls you go to the main changing room to change, your mom can come with you. If you want your dad you need to stay in the outer changing room with him and he says goodbye before you walk through the main one with showers to the pool. If you're a boy you either go into the men's solo or with dad, up to 8 you go into the women's outer changing room with mom or after 8 the men's outer changing room with mom. It's also mainly used for lessons which means the likelihood of adults changing is slim.

HiJenny35 · 23/05/2022 23:41

I don't think children should have to endure getting changed in front of other girls or boys, it's so much more common for schools and child venues than it is for adult facilities. Many girls developing don't like getting changed infront of other girls. We moved out children to a pool with individual cubicles that anyone can use and we've never had any issues since.

IrishMama2015 · 23/05/2022 23:25

madasawethen · 23/05/2022 23:16

The solution is to take your sons into the men's changing room

I do this and below thread was accused of violating mens privacy.

There is a problem in some public places of no suitable space for parents with opposite gender children who still need parental supervision/ protection.

I am a woman and will not violate womens/girls spaces with my growing DS. I also won't leave my child naked and alone and vulnerable with strangers ESPECIALLY makes so I choose the best of a bad situation. A cubicle in the mens dressing room.

rainbowmilk · 23/05/2022 23:18

My experience of this is as follows. I was a keen swimmer from a young age, and good at it. My dad didn’t want to take me and my sister into the mens and my mum wouldn’t go to the pool, so I was in charge of myself and my younger sister at 7. No adult supervision, I was expected to sort myself and sister out and I did.

I started puberty at 9. Mums were bringing in boys of 11/12 at my local pool and they would be staring, giggling, or both. I couldn’t use the cubicles because the teenage girls would try to hog them to escape the boys.

It came to a head when a boy made a sexual comment about my chest and his mum pretended not to hear it. I refused to go swimming from that session onwards. I missed out on years and years of a hobby I enjoyed because the space meant for me was being used by mums of boys, on the basis that the risk to them was worth me not being able to swim at all.

It makes me sad that we’re in 2022 and young girls are still being faced with this dilemma. Parents of boys need to lobby for facilities suitable for them, not just take the ones that are for a different group and shrug the consequences off. This is absolutely part and parcel of why men are so entitled, and have little interest in respecting womens spaces.

madasawethen · 23/05/2022 23:16

The solution is to take your sons into the men's changing room

Lady089 · 23/05/2022 23:10

Brefugee · 23/05/2022 20:54

It might say a lot about men, both in terms of the threat they pose and their awareness of that that would make them step back, not help etc, but as I didn't raise them, that's not on me. My concern is my 10 yo. Saying we'll it's ok for male 10 yos to be at risk cos the risk is from men so it's on men isn't really helpful.

yeah, fuck girls and their dignity, right?
You are the mother of a boy: fight their bloody corner then, don't just assume your son is welcome where we and our girls are changing, FFS. We have to fight enough bloody battles about this without you mothers of precious boys taking away our rights. I'd walk round naked too just to piss them off.

So you’ve ranted and raved about girls spaces but at the very end of your post, you’ve said you’d expose your body to a young boy child to piss them off. So you’ve just admitted you’re willing to expose yourself infront of a child which goes against every thing you apparently stand for 🤔

Brefugee · 23/05/2022 22:22

you do realise that I'm actually a woman too, the lack of daughters doesn't change that.

Look. You want something for your son. I want my daughters to keep their single sex changing room. I have that and so i will a) keep complaining if boys are in there and b) support you in your fight to get space for your boys, or unisex or whatever it is you want to keep them safe but not have them in the girls space

It isn't about your sex, it is about you getting the outcome you want for your boys. I don't have sons, so i don't go out of my way to think what boys might need, I'm very busy fighting for what my daughters need. But i am fully supportive of boys not being put in danger.

But boys do not belong in women and girls' spaces. I haven't mentioned boy-mommies or girl-mommies so pack it in. You want something that i actually don't need. So no, i am not going to start your campaign for you. You can start it and I'll support you. Just leave the girls their space.

ChocolateHippo · 23/05/2022 22:20

TonksInPurple · 23/05/2022 22:17

@ChocolateHippo 1in 35 where does that figure come from?

NCA figures. They found that the number of men with a sexual interest in children is much higher than had previously been thought.

Swipe left for the next trending thread