Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that if you regularly work out in gyms...

107 replies

daretodenim · 23/05/2022 04:45

..you haven't been approached by a random woman - not an employee - who off the bat offered unsolicited advice on what you should be lifting or your form?

This idea came up on another thread but I didn't want to derail.

I've not had it happen to me recently because I'm rarely in the gym, but definitely had random men do this when I was there more often. I've got a qualification in personal training and the advice they gave was usually nonsense for my body. I thought it was because I was younger, but a couple of friends have had it recently (since lockdown ended) and they're 49 & 50.

In all my years of working out though, I never had a random woman tell me I should be doing it differently. The most random women would say, if anything, was "Hi" as we passed and recognised each other. Or ask if I'd finished with some equipment. No unsolicited advice at all.

Anybody find women do it too?

OP posts:
LampLighter414 · 23/05/2022 10:09

It's a minority of men who do this but yes never seen a woman do it

GaspingGekko · 23/05/2022 10:05

I've had unsolicited, unnecessary (and clearly bollocks) cycling "advice" from a random bloke when commuting. And blokes in the gym feel the need to compliment me on my progress - obliging me to remove headphones while running on the treadmill.
Never women, occasionally a smile or nod between women, but never unsolicited advice or comments.

Ted27 · 23/05/2022 10:05

I’ve never had random advice from a man or a woman in my gym.

I have myself offered some help on a couple of occasions to women who were clearly new to the gym and were struggling with the equipment and then pointed a PT in their direction

SillyLittleBiscuit · 23/05/2022 10:03

Not the gym but the local butcher tried to tell me how to run round the park. Was suggesting fartlek I think, but I didn’t stop to listen for too long.

Duty of care should be left to people who work in the gym. I’ve no idea of a random man’s qualifications (nor he mine) so I wouldn’t want or accept advice.

notacooldad · 23/05/2022 10:01

I have been going to gyms lifting weights since around 1985, so over 35 years and no one has approached me about my form.

Lunar27 · 23/05/2022 10:01

@Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious

That's true and I certainly don't (give unsolicited advice) but you can't escape looking round the gym when resting between sets and seeing other people doing their thing.

People adapting their lifts is fine, except when it's clearly putting their back at risk. In a case like this I'd question the ability of the PT. In all other cases, who cares as everyone has differences in mobility. I'm just talking about poor form that puts key body areas at risk.

It's impossible to know, hence why I never approach anyone. But as I said, there should be a duty of care. Otherwise we invariably end up wasting NHS resources on later life back, knee etc issues that are wholly preventable. This is what gym staff should be doing, so that randomers don't need to.

Svalberg · 23/05/2022 09:59

In the gyms that I've used, there has always been at least 1 staff member around whose job it is to give advice and who you're supposed to tell if you think someone is doing things wrongly, and who you can ask for advice if you need it. More difficult if it's a 24 hr gym, the one round the corner from work (pre-pandemic) was & a female colleague wore ear buds to ignore getting unwanted male advice after once being followed around by a man seemingly wanting to act as her PT

Ohilovetorave · 23/05/2022 09:54

Can anyone link to previous thread?

I had a young male PT once encouraging me to slow down with my single leg squats, I was ok with that tbh.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/05/2022 09:50

@Lunar27 but a random gym goer shouldn't be checking someone's form and going over to them. If worried, they should ask a staff member / PT to approach them. Some people lift poorly and it's painful to see, but also some people adapt their lifts due to issues with their body or mobility. I always hear people saying don't let your knees go past your toes in squats, which simply isn't true. That's why it's best left to qualified individuals rather than random people.

Madamecastafiore · 23/05/2022 09:47

Oh if it's a man I'm giving advice to 9/10 times they tell me they know what they're doing. If it's a woman they'll 9/10 take the advice on board.

Madamecastafiore · 23/05/2022 09:46

I do it if someone is doing something that could potentially hurt themselves but that's because I'm qualified, I have had unqualified men correct me but tell them to go away as they are clearly talking crap.

jammyrose · 23/05/2022 09:45

Nope, never happened to me.

Ponoka7 · 23/05/2022 09:44

My DD (25) has, she is also a qualified PT and looks seriously ripped, so she obviously trains correctly. She uses two gyms and now two older men have been told that she doesn't need advice or has time to talk, they've started making comments about how she is too small to be lifting the weights she is. Now the comments have moved on to what she is wearing, which is standard gym gear, just not baggy. She's had to make a complaint. There's people in there who do need help and they've approached my DD for advice. It's only random young women who the two older (70's) men try to give advice to. In the other gym it's just hogging the equipment (by men from women), not wiping it down and the noises from the men who go.

Thestoppedfan · 23/05/2022 09:35

No I haven’t but I have given advice before when someone was using the machine backwards and clearly struggling. I told her I had done the exact same thing before and showed her how to use it. I haven’t had anyone correct my form male or female but I don’t think I would be offended either way.

Lunar27 · 23/05/2022 09:29

MoonGoon · 23/05/2022 07:23

What is form checking?

Believe it or not, there is a right and wrong way to carry out certain lifts. Deadlift, squat, bench etc. Getting it wrong will result in injury. Perhaps not immediately but over time.

Form checking, or checking one's form is something everyone needs to do, irrespective of experience as form can deviate. Every PT or class instructor should be prioritising this but many don't. Hence why you might not have heard about it.

MoonGoon · 23/05/2022 07:23

What is form checking?

Roghtab · 23/05/2022 07:17

but I also see a lot of men and women with really poor form. The sort of form that'll result in injury

This judgement is partly why I won't go to a gym - I have a disability with my foot, it's not noticable at all and I look 'normal' but I have to adapt some exercises to do them safely, after advice from a PT.

To you, it may look like I'm lifting 'wrong' but I'm absolutely fine.

KatherineJaneway · 23/05/2022 07:16

Never been approached by a woman with unsolicited advice at the gym but have by men. Very annoying. Luckily the bloke that use to do it at our gym (not just yo me) appears to have moved on thankfully.

Can't believe the amount of people on the other thread who want to excuse this type of behaviour. These guys aren't being helpful, they are doing it to feel superior.

FrancescaContini · 23/05/2022 07:12

By women - no, never.
Men - over the years: yes, definitely.

Ditto: how to park a car/use a computer etc. Which I can do perfectly well.

Unsolicited advice from a man really really gets on my tits.

Knittingchamp · 23/05/2022 07:11

Yes!! Always younger women with a phone. 3 times. I always say I have a PT thank you, are you soliciting for business? When they say no, I say, well don't give people advice as.you are unqualified and might injure someone. That gets rid of them. I'm slightly older so probably get away with the cheeky older woman thing but honestly!

Itloggedmeoutagain · 23/05/2022 07:08

I go regularly and I lift weights and do resistance training and it's never happened to me from either men or women. Can't say it would bother me if it did though

dammit88 · 23/05/2022 07:04

What was the other thread?

This has never happened to me either, from a man or a woman!

roundtable · 23/05/2022 06:58

We have a woman at our gym that tries to coach everyone. People have left because of her. I would say she is more of an exception - she is very lacking in self awareness.

In my experience:
Regular gym -men offering advice
Weightlifting classes - both.

I think it depends on the type of gym and the type of person that goes there and whether or not certain types of people are allowed to dominate.

bjjgirl · 23/05/2022 06:52

I get approached by women regularly complimenting my gym outfit or asking if I do pt, never men in my gym (pure gym)

MsTSwift · 23/05/2022 06:49

You do get older women doing a similar with baby care though “where’s his hat” etc