Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that if you regularly work out in gyms...

107 replies

daretodenim · 23/05/2022 04:45

..you haven't been approached by a random woman - not an employee - who off the bat offered unsolicited advice on what you should be lifting or your form?

This idea came up on another thread but I didn't want to derail.

I've not had it happen to me recently because I'm rarely in the gym, but definitely had random men do this when I was there more often. I've got a qualification in personal training and the advice they gave was usually nonsense for my body. I thought it was because I was younger, but a couple of friends have had it recently (since lockdown ended) and they're 49 & 50.

In all my years of working out though, I never had a random woman tell me I should be doing it differently. The most random women would say, if anything, was "Hi" as we passed and recognised each other. Or ask if I'd finished with some equipment. No unsolicited advice at all.

Anybody find women do it too?

OP posts:
godmum56 · 23/05/2022 14:03

Lunar27 · 23/05/2022 06:44

I think it depends. My gym has women who know what they're doing, so would have no problem with being approached. For anyone doing weights, form checking is essential, even for the experienced.

I totally get the annoyance and there are a lot of dicks in gyms. But I also see a lot of men and women with really poor form. The sort of form that'll result in injury. Personally I just leave them to it but I sometimes wonder if there's a duty of care with other gym goers.

Ultimately it's a sad state that we can't help others, especially when you can see they're doing it wrong.

no you have no duty of care to other gym goers....or to the people who are in tescos when you are......

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 23/05/2022 14:03

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/05/2022 13:58

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe it's not true. Because it's accepted and understood that everyone's mobility is different. The top fitness professionals and physios will advise you that it's fine if your body naturally moves that way. Knees over toes means don't let them collapse inwards or outwards.

Quite. So making pronouncements, either way, as to whether something should or shouldn't be done is moot altogether. Everybody is different.

I'll take advice from a professional who knows me.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/05/2022 14:01

Lunar27 · 23/05/2022 10:01

@Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious

That's true and I certainly don't (give unsolicited advice) but you can't escape looking round the gym when resting between sets and seeing other people doing their thing.

People adapting their lifts is fine, except when it's clearly putting their back at risk. In a case like this I'd question the ability of the PT. In all other cases, who cares as everyone has differences in mobility. I'm just talking about poor form that puts key body areas at risk.

It's impossible to know, hence why I never approach anyone. But as I said, there should be a duty of care. Otherwise we invariably end up wasting NHS resources on later life back, knee etc issues that are wholly preventable. This is what gym staff should be doing, so that randomers don't need to.

I do agree. I see a girl in the gym who rounds her lower back during deadlifts, I don't approach as I don't want to upset her, but I did mention it to a PT to have a quick and friendly word.
I think lift adaptations are fine but you're right, things like the lower back are so vulnerable, one wrong move and it could be really awful.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/05/2022 13:58

@LyingWitchInTheWardrobe it's not true. Because it's accepted and understood that everyone's mobility is different. The top fitness professionals and physios will advise you that it's fine if your body naturally moves that way. Knees over toes means don't let them collapse inwards or outwards.

Stellaris22 · 23/05/2022 13:46

The noises some men make makes me laugh. I’ll be working out with my PT and we’re there trying not to laugh sometimes.

Or the way some men slam weights down, barbells and on machines. If they can’t safely control the weights then it’s probably too heavy!

I definitely feel there needs to be less anger around having form corrected though if a qualified instructor is offering advice to help be prevent injury. After years of having a PT I can recognise things like Lat pull down or rows being done incorrectly but I’d be too shy to let the person know.

Chubarubrub · 23/05/2022 13:35

emmathedilemma · 23/05/2022 13:20

oh gawd, the rowing machines!! I have to look away sometimes and just imagine their boat sinking as their "oars" wave around! But i'd never think of saying anything to someone.
Never had unsolicited advice from anyone in my gym, male or female, but it's a fairly small and friendly place.

😂 I actually questioned my rowing technique after watching countless men writhe around on them like the kraken was pulling them under.

PT said I was doing just fine ☺️

emmathedilemma · 23/05/2022 13:20

dDdDdeeeee · 23/05/2022 10:39

I used to row recreationally for two clubs. Almost every time I set foot in a gym, I see people using the erg (concept 2 rowing machine) with terrible technique.

It's often men that have the worst approach: cranking the resistance up to the max and trying to do everything with their arms (when rowing is primarily driven by the power in your legs).

I inwardly wince, but would never dream of saying anything, because it would be a dickhead thing to do.

oh gawd, the rowing machines!! I have to look away sometimes and just imagine their boat sinking as their "oars" wave around! But i'd never think of saying anything to someone.
Never had unsolicited advice from anyone in my gym, male or female, but it's a fairly small and friendly place.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 23/05/2022 13:09

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 23/05/2022 12:41

I always hear people saying don't let your knees go past your toes in squats, which simply isn't true.

It is true. Do what you want to your own body, nobody cares.

Advice to anybody going to a gym is to ask a professional, not on a chatboard.

As a professional (retired) it isn't a global truth. It's advice for those with low levels of stability round the knee joint. Recent research (over a couple of decades) shows that their is nothing inherently dangerous about the toes creeping forward of the knee, in fact it is more functionally approrpriate if they do.

Basically yes, it is wise to go slowly to build up the knee joint musculature, tendons and ligaments but the movement of knees over toes is a perfectly normal movement of the knee and needn't be avoided.

TheOrigRights · 23/05/2022 12:48

Rosehugger · 23/05/2022 12:28

And some of us do or have done both.

Plenty of women or mixed groups hogs paths and a friendly 'coming through' helps to alert someone you're behind them so you don't make them jump, even if there's loads of room.

And I've had equal twattish behaviour from men and women in the pool.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 23/05/2022 12:41

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 23/05/2022 09:50

@Lunar27 but a random gym goer shouldn't be checking someone's form and going over to them. If worried, they should ask a staff member / PT to approach them. Some people lift poorly and it's painful to see, but also some people adapt their lifts due to issues with their body or mobility. I always hear people saying don't let your knees go past your toes in squats, which simply isn't true. That's why it's best left to qualified individuals rather than random people.

I always hear people saying don't let your knees go past your toes in squats, which simply isn't true.

It is true. Do what you want to your own body, nobody cares.

Advice to anybody going to a gym is to ask a professional, not on a chatboard.

thecurtainsofdestiny · 23/05/2022 12:39

I don't use the gym, but have had the Random Man advice at a yoga class. Never had this from a woman.

Rosehugger · 23/05/2022 12:34

EurovisionTragic · 23/05/2022 11:02

I’ve not had men offering me advice. I have had men coming up to me saying “are you going to be on there long?” When I’ve literally been on the equipment for 1 minute, not 20. I usually respond “I’m going to be on here as long as it takes” snd they walk off confused.

I work with a lot of men and what I’ve worked out is that when young (under 30) they are quite nice, 30-60 they are arrogant, over 60 mellowed out. Just my opinion. I don’t know why middle aged men are so miserable, but a lot of them are.

Yes, I've had that. And I must be like, two minutes on each machine.

I wish there was a women only gym near me. I used to go in the women's section at Holmes Place and it was bliss.

UseOfWeapons · 23/05/2022 12:32

Normally, just an acknowledgement of ‘Morning’, or ‘Bye’ when there are others in our workplace gym, as it doesn’t have an instructor in unless he has an appointment with someone. We have a duty of care to others using the gym because of this, and we are all aware.
I’ve been weight training for 38 years now, and had only positive interactions with men or women using the same gym, albeit rare in the first place. I have had others ask me about form, use of equipment, that sort of thing, as I’m a long-standing member. I have on two occasions asked someone if they needed help, as they were using the equipment incorrectly, and liable to damage themselves or the equipment. The woman I spoke to was grateful, as she didn’t know what she was doing. The bloke basically told me to F off, and carried on doing what he was doing. I left him to it. He then came up to me when he’d finished his workout, and said that, actually, he didn’t know how to use the stuff, had hurt himself, and could I advise?! I did, and apologised if I’d come across in the wrong way.
Otherwise, I just go in, workout, and sod off. I do agree with other posters stating that men are the only ones who hog equipment, make loud noise, groan, and posture.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 23/05/2022 12:32

I was form checked last week. By a man I had never met before. He appeared, silently, like Mr Ben's shopkeeper and proceeded to tell me why I was doing it wrong.

I was doing some 3/4 push ups and had positioned my hands quite specifically to target various smaller assistor muscles across the shoulder and down my trunk. Not the wide or narrow stance ones that are more usual but ones that would mean I was off balance, that certain muscle groups would have to work harder or would not be recruited at all.

He arrived and stood over me telling me I was doing it wrong, I needed to straighten my legs, not be on my knees, and that my hand positions were all wrong. I finished the reps I was doing then stood my short, round, tapping 60 body up and told him I was targeting my "infraspin and subscap" and needed him to leave me alone. He bloody well stayed staring at me until a PT came across and asked him to move away.

I felt like explaining the decades of experience I have, teaching exercise physiology to university students, being a specialist instructor, an injured older woman etc. But hissing 'Sod off' at him, under my breath, was as far as I went. Next time I will channel the OP of the other thread "Why thank you, Random Man!"

I will get more assertive, may even wear purple!

Rosehugger · 23/05/2022 12:30

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 23/05/2022 10:54

I've spent a lot of time in gyms in my life, and not once has a woman done this, nor has a woman...made weird noises

Oh GOD, the noise that some men make. "HUUUUURGGGGH!" every time they've lifted something, and you just know it's going to be either a Muscle Mary announcing their superior presence, or someone doing their first bench-press.

Christ, yes. Fuck off with the sex noises.

daretodenim · 23/05/2022 12:29

Maybe running clubs attract different people to those who go to gyms.

Plenty of knob heads in running clubs too. Not with advice but hogging paths or shouting 'coming through' when there's plenty of room to pass.

I think it's easier to control the atmosphere in running clubs with good leadership. Or maybe better to say that the leadership can determine the club's atmosphere. I've attended some that were pretty hostile and another one which is lovely. The nice one is run by a man who runs marathons - lots - but slowly. His goal is to get in before the sweeper! The club has been going for years and everybody is encouraged and supported for their own PBs whether it's 5km or an ultra. There was a case when one woman was getting competitive with others, comparing times etc, and he took her aside for a wee chat and she went back to normal, nice supportive runner!

See not all men are Random Man!

OP posts:
Rosehugger · 23/05/2022 12:28

Lunar27 · 23/05/2022 12:16

Maybe running clubs attract different people to those who go to gyms.

Plenty of knob heads in running clubs too. Not with advice but hogging paths or shouting 'coming through' when there's plenty of room to pass.

And some of us do or have done both.

daretodenim · 23/05/2022 12:22

Oh there were more replies than I expected but this thread has made me laugh while trying to eat my lunch!

And swimming..oh that's a whole other thread! 😂

Back to Random Man Advice. I think there's a difference between stepping in for someone doing something dangerous (bench press over face and no spotter) and furnishing your unsolicited opinion to someone (female) working out. I don't see these guys go to men and rest their arms on the machine, or interrupt their workout making them remove their headphones, and "offer advice", or tell them they're doing it wrong, or should be lifting more. I've only seen that sort of thing done to women. Maybe men who want to "give advice" to women and absolutely think they're just being helpful should first ask if they'd say it to a bloke who was bigger than them. If so, they should try it out on that bigger bloke first! 😅

OP posts:
Thatswhyimacat · 23/05/2022 12:22

I've not had this happen or heard of anyone it's happened to in real life, but I notice it CONSTANTLY on Instagram. Any celebrity, male or female, showing a lift in a reel, the men are there in the comments telling them they're doing it wrong. Celebrities with the best trainers in the world or my favourite, Olympic athletes.

Lunar27 · 23/05/2022 12:16

Maybe running clubs attract different people to those who go to gyms.

Plenty of knob heads in running clubs too. Not with advice but hogging paths or shouting 'coming through' when there's plenty of room to pass.

andtheycalledthewindmoriah · 23/05/2022 12:10

I think your point is that the men doing it are basically doing it as a way to come onto the woman.

And when that happens it changes the whole dynamic. Now you've rejected a man who is using your gym. But he doesn't feel the awkwardness of that because in his mind he was only offering help.

So he's made you uncomfortable at no risk to himself. A permanent shield for him 'what? I was only offering my help'

When we all know his real reason.

Great way of explaining it. Thanks.

TheOrigRights · 23/05/2022 12:07

Not in the gym as such, but plenty of women have helpfully advised me during classes e.g. body pump when I've got the bar in the wrong place, or suggested using different weights.

That said, I'm pleased I'm in my running club, where men and women all get along well together, giving advice, ribbing each other, saying "ooooh nice shorts", congratulating good race results, or efforts at training, supporting each other when we're struggling. Maybe running clubs attract different people to those who go to gyms.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 23/05/2022 12:04

Mookie81 · 23/05/2022 11:14

Has anyone noticed in the gym pool, it's mostly men who hog the slower lanes thinking they're Michael Phelps but actually swimming like a fucking beached whale, splashing everywhere?
I honestly want to drown them.

Oh no, I've always found that they hog the faster lanes because obviously no-one, not least of all a mere woman, can swim faster than them. Even if they are going so slowly in doggy-paddle that you'd need a theodolite and GPS to ascertain that they're actually moving.

My last gym didn't have speed lanes in the pool, you were expected to pick a line and stick to it, but that didn't stop the men swimming right up to you to try and make you get out of their way. I used to stop and tell them that what they were doing was dangerous, and that they needed to give other swimmers reasonable space, which made all but the arsiest ones back off (and I was more than happy to get into a shouting match with ones who wanted to argue back).

Some of them were fucking awful though, I got hit and kicked on several occasions and a friend actually had a man swim right over the top of her.

Pickabearanybear · 23/05/2022 11:55

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

beeeeeeeeeeeeeeee · 23/05/2022 11:29

I've had unsolicited advice from both men and women in a range of scenarios. Ranging from people telling me to drink peppermint tea for chronic acid reflux (medical advice tells you not to do this), drinking a glass of water for a migraine. To men helping me park. All the people in each scenario thought they were being helpful, so I politely thanked them and quietly ignored them in each case.
Life if full of people that are going to annoy us to some degree, if its just a minor irritation, I just brush it off. To me it's only a problem if someone won't fuck off and in that instance a more blunt or aggressive approach is needed.