Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angry at long nhs waits

164 replies

glitterwobbles · 22/05/2022 23:33

I get daily headaches and nerve pain in arms and legs.Was diagnosed with cervical myelopathy last summer.
Was referred to another hospital as mine does not have any neurosurgeons and need surgery to prevent it getting worse and possible paralysis.
Have been told that the wait for an appointment is 18 months.
I know that the NHS is struggling after covid. But I have a condition that will get worse and if i had the money could have the surgery privately within weeks.
Just feel let down by NHS and as if the list keeps getting longer as when I was referred it was 10 months. Feel as if I will never get to the top

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 09:18

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 09:10

I just can't get my head around our insistence for a fully state funded system, when pretty much no-one else does it that way

Especially as we also don't want to increase taxes further. Something's got to give somewhere.

Plenty of European countries have a tax payer funded model, the private ins element isn't like ours at all, its a top up, available to almost anyone, often paid for by employers.

Personally i think thats a good model to follow, as is introducing some extra charges, with exceptions for those on lower incomes.

How about the "something has to give" is to tax the wealthy? their marginal rates of income tax are lower than what most of us pay.

But in a country that can find 100s of billions for Trident and HS2, not sure that the argument that there is no money is valid, poor healthcare costs the country vast sums of money, productive people stuck on sick pay, at home.

BigWoollyJumpers · 23/05/2022 09:16

InChocolateWeTrust Your points 2, 3 and 4 - Absolutely agree.

Nurse training I think is a red herring. Nurse trainees DO get bursaries, of £5k per year. The student debt is irrelevant, as it is for anyone else. If you don't earn enough, you don't pay it back. There are thousands of potential trainees who can't get on courses at the moment, so no lack of students, just more places are needed. The biggest issue is though, the drop out rate, what can be done to ensure all these keen youngsters are motivated to keep going once they join the workforce.

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 09:10

I just can't get my head around our insistence for a fully state funded system, when pretty much no-one else does it that way

Especially as we also don't want to increase taxes further. Something's got to give somewhere.

InChocolateWeTrust · 23/05/2022 09:07

There are many, many issues.

  1. The failure to properly fund nurses training. Nursing isn't paid enough to have people graduating with huge amounts of debt, nursing bursaries were essential.
  1. The failure to properly fund & resource (separately from the NHS) social care to meet the needs of an ageing population. The NHS never had the capacity for managing the chronic conditions of the very elderly for decades, not to mention the problem of bed blocking where people are taking up space in hospital due to care needs not medical needs.
  1. The public health & society crisis. Diabetes is often preventable and it accounts for 10 percent of the NHS budget. Mental health is regularly one of biggest areas of spending at 10% plus. A chunk of this is down to lifestyle/economic/society based issues like obesity, poverty, and poor community support networks.
  1. Conversely, some societal factors mean that things which used to kill people prematurely now do so less - heart disease and lung cancer etc, caused by poor nutrition & smoking. The downside to this is instead of people dying quite fast mid 50s or 60s of heart attack, they live longer and have a longer period of geriatric ill health and cost the NHS more as a result.
BigWoollyJumpers · 23/05/2022 09:05

Switzerland. Switzerland comes top of the Euro Health Consumer Index 2018, and it's firmly above the eleven-country average in the Commonwealth Fund's list too. There are no free, state-run services here – instead, universal healthcare is achieved by mandatory private health insurance and some government involvement

Are the Tories wrong though? Every other system in Europe is part private part state. I just can't get my head around our insistence for a fully state funded system, when pretty much no-one else does it that way, and they all get better healthcare. And before anyone piles on, I am not talking of the US model, but the rest of the EU model.......

BigWoollyJumpers · 23/05/2022 08:57

we still spend less than EU averages on health, the figures only look comparable when we add in private healthcare spending

Except the majority of the EU countries have private funding included, because their systems include private funding. You are not comparing like with like.

wolfiemutt · 23/05/2022 08:55

The money simply isn't there and I'm not sure where it's going to come from in the very short term.

Any money will have to be raised by wealth taxes as we cannot burden income any more. Yes in an ideal world the 1% would pay more but that's not going to happen without global policies.

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 08:52

Well, the Govt has raised taxes for ordinary workers but not for the wealthy and how would you deal with the millions waiting (and dying) whilst a reorg takes place?

I think the only actual answer to that is to focus on essential services until we decide what the remit of the nhs should be in the present day. The money simply isn't there and I'm not sure where it's going to come from in the very short term.

Lalliella · 23/05/2022 08:50

Funny how there’s a magic money tree to pay over £100bn for a railway no-one op wants, but not enough money to fund the NHS properly. You’re angry at the wrong people OP.

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 08:47

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 08:31

So i would prefer far more spending on staff recruitment and esp retention first THEN once we get waiting lists down, look at how it is structured but in international comparisons

Well I'm sure you would, but you're looking at tax raises to achieve this and at the present time I'm not so sure how well that would go down. Especially as the money simply isn't being used to greatest efficiency right now.

Well, the Govt has raised taxes for ordinary workers but not for the wealthy and how would you deal with the millions waiting (and dying) whilst a reorg takes place?

Don't really understand why anyone would be against measures to increase staff retention.... unless its to run down the NHS.

I do agree social care needs urgent addressing, its a privatised model, doesn't work and needs integrating into the NHS, so the two work alongside each other BUT once again, the Tories aren't interested, just kind words, no more staff or wage rises, the number 1 reason for low staff numbers & even worse retention.

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 08:34

Also it's impossible to tackle the NHS without also considering the even bigger challenges with Social Care.

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 08:31

So i would prefer far more spending on staff recruitment and esp retention first THEN once we get waiting lists down, look at how it is structured but in international comparisons

Well I'm sure you would, but you're looking at tax raises to achieve this and at the present time I'm not so sure how well that would go down. Especially as the money simply isn't being used to greatest efficiency right now.

runnerswimmer · 23/05/2022 08:28

drinkingwineoutofamug · 23/05/2022 08:10

Our trust now does nursing apprenticeships , in 6 years they have trained up nearly 30 nurses/nursing associates.
We wouldn't of got them any other way.
Most of our new staff as over seas nurses now as no one in their right mind would come into medicine right now.

Side point. My daughters are epileptic. One has had fantastic experiences with the nhs. Now on the waiting list for surgery. 2nd daughter waited 2 years for an mri scan to find she has lesions on the brain. She's now having a panic as she needs a repeat scan and she's having symptoms of unsteadiness, nausea and headaches. Symptoms she's had for the past year that are getting worse. Symptoms she thought was the epilepsy. Changes in her behaviour. Worrying

Two years that is fucking ridiculous. If we are interested in a comparison in public health systems. I got diagnosed with epilepsy as a uni student in New Zealand, and got an MRI on the public health system (NZ citizen) in about three months. CT scan in about six weeks. That was under their last labour govt about 15 years ago.

Bojo and co are not totally for blame, we can hark back to Thatcher for fiscal austerity across the health, education and welfare systems.

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 08:27

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 08:16

The whole thing needs a radical rehaul. Soup to nuts. Its remit needs to be redefined, plus it's funding. We also need to look at staffing (I agree about the outrageous fees of locums, my friend is absolutely coining it). It probably requires more management, not less, but better quality and more skilled.

It needs to be a cross party issue, not a right/left debate.

Just pouring more money into the dysfunction would be a terrible decision. It may well need considerably more funding, but systemic issues need to be fixed first.

Disagree.
The two main parties have totally different views on the direction of the NHS, Labour want a publicly funded/owned healthcare system, the Tories want a privatised model. ... leading Tories wrote about this before coming into Govt.

Re organisations, of which the NHS has had several, are extremely disruptive & take years, people like the OP needing urgent care, cannot wait.

So i would prefer far more spending on staff recruitment and esp retention first THEN once we get waiting lists down, look at how it is structured but in international comparisons, the NHS does well on efficiency, badly on critical illness care, esp cancer and very badly on number of Dr's Nurses and beds.

monicagellerbing · 23/05/2022 08:23

There's far too many middle managers on ridiculous salaries. I've just left my job as a band 3 medical secretary, I had a band 4 line manager, then a band 5 manager above her then above her we had a band 7! All for one department. It's a fucking joke

Ponoka7 · 23/05/2022 08:21

I wonder why Chris Whitty and JVT both made the point of the NHS being run down to shocking levels right at the very start of the Covid broadcasts, if that wasn't the case. Chris Whitty was very vocal about why we were in crisis, the media decided not to run with it, though. I can remember seeing a Consultant in 2011 who was thinking of resigning because none of the equipment supplied by a government minister's friend was fully fit for purpose and it wasn't the cheapest bid. He could see the shape of things to come. We know from day one of the Torys coming to power that money was directed to their friends. The budget cuts and none funding of social care, the austerity cuts, including those across the benefit system has caused a crisis in sectors which work alongside the NHS. Things aren't going to get any better.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 23/05/2022 08:19

rwalker · 23/05/2022 07:48

The problem is that people have been bulldozed into think all the NHS problems are down to tory funding .

The reality is the problem is multi facited waste and fraud is massive in the NHS costing billions , people's shit life choices making a huge unnecessary demand ,processes that aren't fit for purpose wasting millions .
Staffing in our trust loads of consultants have resigned and come back as locums naming there price and holding the trust to ransom demanding eye watering fees for clinics because they know the trust has no choice procurement is a joke spending millions more than they need and this is just a few of the problems not funding related .

What I find more disappointing is Keir starmers wife work for the NHS and will know the above problem all too well but because the above don't score political point he's not interested .

PLEASE PLEASE don't be fooled into think all the problems are down to funding ask anyone who works in the NHS.

The problems are down to sustained underfunding which both major political parties are responsible. The problem is that the Tories are doing it on steroids. Big influencers in the Tory party have shamelessly and blatantly admited that they don't want an NHS any more. They have knowingly made changes which were designed only to piss off and demoralise the workforce (eg junior dr contracts, removing bursaries for nurses) and they allow the media to demonise this workforce and latch onto false or mossguided news stories rather than admit that the problem is about leadership and funding from above not the staff or the patients stuck in this awful system. Of course funding is an issue. The NHS is grossly underfunded. This is the main elephant in the room. There may be other things that can be marginally improved but everything else is just smokescreens. Find me the evidence that we adequately fund the NHS when it's one of the most poorly funded health services in the developed world

BalloonsAndWhistles · 23/05/2022 08:19

Sugarplumfairy65 · 23/05/2022 07:43

When labour were in power, there were no long waiting lists

There also wasn’t Covid. The NHS didn’t have this major problem until 2 years ago.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 23/05/2022 08:17

carefullycourageous · 23/05/2022 06:55

Apparently across the population one in six people are now on a waiting list. This is a deliberate political choice made by the Conservative party.

Nothing to do with Covid…

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 08:16

The whole thing needs a radical rehaul. Soup to nuts. Its remit needs to be redefined, plus it's funding. We also need to look at staffing (I agree about the outrageous fees of locums, my friend is absolutely coining it). It probably requires more management, not less, but better quality and more skilled.

It needs to be a cross party issue, not a right/left debate.

Just pouring more money into the dysfunction would be a terrible decision. It may well need considerably more funding, but systemic issues need to be fixed first.

drinkingwineoutofamug · 23/05/2022 08:10

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 07:38

How about taking away student fees for nurses and Dr's providing they render the equivalent of 10 years' full time to the NHS with the only exception illness. If they don't they pay it back

Yes i bet you'd have '000s queuing up to tie themselves into 10 years of rubbish pay, hi stress and poor working conditions if that was the deal..... not.

We managed not to charge tuition fee's 12 years ago, why can't we now?
its purely a political choice.

Our trust now does nursing apprenticeships , in 6 years they have trained up nearly 30 nurses/nursing associates.
We wouldn't of got them any other way.
Most of our new staff as over seas nurses now as no one in their right mind would come into medicine right now.

Side point. My daughters are epileptic. One has had fantastic experiences with the nhs. Now on the waiting list for surgery. 2nd daughter waited 2 years for an mri scan to find she has lesions on the brain. She's now having a panic as she needs a repeat scan and she's having symptoms of unsteadiness, nausea and headaches. Symptoms she's had for the past year that are getting worse. Symptoms she thought was the epilepsy. Changes in her behaviour. Worrying

BonnesVacances · 23/05/2022 08:10

How much is private treatment? I'd get a loan or try and borrow the money. It's wrong and you shouldn't have to but when it's your health, principles go out the window.

We waited 2 years for a specialist cardiology appointment for DD. Meanwhile we saw him privately and she was on medication within a month after the NHS referral. I can't imagine how poorly she'd be if we'd had to wait for the NHS appointment as she was deteriorating rapidly.

One of the most disappointing things about having a sick DD is finding out just how badly the NHS has been able to look after her. In her case it hasn't just been lack of funding and waiting times, but lack of care, interest and compassion. We all have PTSD from how she's been treated.

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 08:02

@rwalker How do you know what Starmer is interested in or not? How would you stop people resigning and coming back as Locums?

Consultants have always been able to do highly paid private work, maybe if NHS work wasn't so stressful, they'd do more of it?

Evidence please on "massive" fraud in the NHS.

On procurement, the NHS has to deal with the huge numbers of private companies the Tories have introduced - v time consuming and v expensive.

Yes i asked my DD who works in the NHS, if funding is a large factor? she looked at me as if i was mad, anyone who works in our local hospital knows its under funded and that leads directly to under staffing.

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 23/05/2022 08:01

NHS management is crap because a) nobody has any training or background in management and b) closed-loop recruitment: pay is too low to attract people from the commercial world, you often need a clinical qualification for management roles, and too many roles are short term secondments that nobody from outside will take as they will be out of a job in 6 months; and too many roles are for internal candidates only. Some of the managers are fantastic, but that doesn’t mean they can manage.

If I have to read another 100-page “strategy” with no objectives, no action plan and no reference to overlapping “strategies” I will scream. And cry, thinking of all the hours of work that went into it.

mandolinwind · 23/05/2022 07:54

May be of interest:

Information and guidance for patients waiting for a hospital consultation, treatment or surgery, region by region (England only). Data updated weekly:

www.myplannedcare.nhs.uk

Swipe left for the next trending thread