Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angry at long nhs waits

164 replies

glitterwobbles · 22/05/2022 23:33

I get daily headaches and nerve pain in arms and legs.Was diagnosed with cervical myelopathy last summer.
Was referred to another hospital as mine does not have any neurosurgeons and need surgery to prevent it getting worse and possible paralysis.
Have been told that the wait for an appointment is 18 months.
I know that the NHS is struggling after covid. But I have a condition that will get worse and if i had the money could have the surgery privately within weeks.
Just feel let down by NHS and as if the list keeps getting longer as when I was referred it was 10 months. Feel as if I will never get to the top

OP posts:
Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 23/05/2022 11:54

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 11:27

Any other well-run organisation looks at why it is unable to attract sufficient trainees, unable to train them (there is also a lack of experienced staff to actually train the new staff), unable to retain them (working conditions, pay levels, flexible working for people with children etc) and does something about it. The NHS cannot do this - everything is decided from above by ministers with no experience of healthcare (the current Minister is a former banker) and a PM who ideology does not embrace socialised healthcare, preferring instead to promote a free-market approach

Yes, my DD recently qualified, within two weeks was given a full case load, little support or additional training specific to her role, shit load of unpaid over time, even to the extent she has to use her car (at her expense)
On top of that, she took 2 hours off for a GP appointment and they took 1/2 days leave off her!

She loves her work but its easy to see she wont be able to keep up these workloads and stress levels, already has been offered jobs abroad and in private sector.
Indeed her Uni actively encouraged students to seek work in non NHS sectors, they'd have overseas and private sector organisations come in and run talks on private sector work (pre CV)

I think something that the public don't fully appreciate as well is how much of this crap most healthcare professionals accept already because they so passionately want to keep the NHS. I think this goodwill will fade when the inevitable privatisation happens and somebody will have to actually make the job roles appealing. Someone will have to fund this. Do we think it'll be the soulless businesses or the general public?? The NHS isn't perfect but people have NO idea what they're in for if when it goes tits up ...

AchatAVendre · 23/05/2022 11:52

Havananana live in an EU country, and have lived in two other EU countries.
The "EU model" does NOT usually involve any private insurance element - and there is not one universal "EU model" as each country approaches healthcare provision slightly differently.

I still have my GP in another European country where I used to live, as you don't get automatically kicked off their lists if you move about 5 miles away (another problem with the NHS system) and its sometimes quicker to make an appointment with them if I'm visiting the country.

Last year I needed a steroid injection for a problem in my foot caused as a side effect by the untreated problem in my knee. What a fuss from the NHS. Eventually the GP agreed that I could have one and it was then referred to some other place that took weeks to get in touch, who then put me on a waiting list. I emailed my European GP, made an appointment later that week, flew over and paid 65 euros for the injection. Its around £400 or more to get it done privately here.

AchatAVendre · 23/05/2022 11:43

Its a dreadful system and often sexist. I have a knee injury which is relatively easily resolved by day case surgery. 99% chance of success in fixing the problem. Yet my NHS trust refused to give me the surgery and basically told me to go away and sit down and stop being active instead. I had to fight very hard for an MRI scan to diagnose the problem.

Yet my DH went along with almost an identical issue in his left wrist (he is right handed) and even before the MRI and nerve conduction tests, he was booked in for surgery.

The NHS as a healthcare system honestly terrifies me. I don't trust the system to make good decisions for my health and yet the private sector in this country is tiny and under-developed as a result of the NHS, giving people few real choices unless they want to lose all their savings.

Plantstrees · 23/05/2022 11:36

@Badbadbunny You are totally correct. The BMA has a lot to answer for but the general public seem to be unaware of the history here.

@Havanananana I have private medical cover in UK but have seriously considered retiring abroad as even our private system is worse than the public system in many EU countries. I have first-hand experience of the system in a couple of places and have been very impressed with the standards of care and speed at which treatment is provided.

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 11:27

Any other well-run organisation looks at why it is unable to attract sufficient trainees, unable to train them (there is also a lack of experienced staff to actually train the new staff), unable to retain them (working conditions, pay levels, flexible working for people with children etc) and does something about it. The NHS cannot do this - everything is decided from above by ministers with no experience of healthcare (the current Minister is a former banker) and a PM who ideology does not embrace socialised healthcare, preferring instead to promote a free-market approach

Yes, my DD recently qualified, within two weeks was given a full case load, little support or additional training specific to her role, shit load of unpaid over time, even to the extent she has to use her car (at her expense)
On top of that, she took 2 hours off for a GP appointment and they took 1/2 days leave off her!

She loves her work but its easy to see she wont be able to keep up these workloads and stress levels, already has been offered jobs abroad and in private sector.
Indeed her Uni actively encouraged students to seek work in non NHS sectors, they'd have overseas and private sector organisations come in and run talks on private sector work (pre CV)

Badbadbunny · 23/05/2022 10:27

Plantstrees · 23/05/2022 09:55

I think the biggest issue is the lack of nurses and doctors. No amount of money can fix that easily as there are not enough qualified staff around to fill the vacancies.

In my view all medical training should be free, but it would still take time for the extra qualified professionals to filter through the system.

It didn't help that the BMA wanted to restrict the number of doctors being trained and voted on a complete ban on new medical schools.

"avoid overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities"

I.e. keep supply low to maintain high demand and wages etc!

www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

Badbadbunny · 23/05/2022 10:23

janj2301 · 23/05/2022 09:51

Until I worked at a GP I thought all the NHS funding issues were to mant managers believe me there is sooo much waste at primary care level, patients don't turn up for appoinmtnt, patients ask for referrals, never pick up the paperwork or never attend the hospital appoinment, patients don't collect paperwork to do their diabetic checks or routine blood tests. Don't attend smear/mamogram/diabetic eye tests/aortic aneursym checks, people seem to ignore ongoing conditions because obviously when they get worse the good old NHS will save them, sorry rant over

Nice bit of victim blaming there!

Havanananana · 23/05/2022 10:17

How about taking away student fees for nurses and Dr's providing they render the equivalent of 10 years' full time to the NHS with the only exception illness. If they don't they pay it back.

No! That is the equivalent of indentured labour. The government could (and Jeremy Hunt did) impose pay freezes, increase working hours, remove health and safety protections and generally make any demands that they wanted to - with the threat hanging over the nurses and doctors that if they don't like it, they can leave; and pay back the £100,000 training costs. No sensible person would sign up for this.

Any other well-run organisation looks at why it is unable to attract sufficient trainees, unable to train them (there is also a lack of experienced staff to actually train the new staff), unable to retain them (working conditions, pay levels, flexible working for people with children etc) and does something about it. The NHS cannot do this - everything is decided from above by ministers with no experience of healthcare (the current Minister is a former banker) and a PM who ideology does not embrace socialised healthcare, preferring instead to promote a free-market approach.

Havanananana · 23/05/2022 10:04

I live in an EU country, and have lived in two other EU countries.

The "EU model" does NOT usually involve any private insurance element - and there is not one universal "EU model" as each country approaches healthcare provision slightly differently.

My healthcare here is paid for by the State through deductions made from my wages - just like the UK National Insurance deductions. My employer likewise has to pay something similar to NI. Overall I pay no more here than in the UK. The unemployed, those unable to work through sickness or disability, those not working (students, pensioners etc.) have their contributions covered by the State.

The difference between here and the UK is stark when it comes to the delivery of healthcare. Back in the 1960s, the government here (and in many other EU countries) made the conscious decision that since the country was wealthier than it had ever been, the standard of universal healthcare should be as good as that previously only available to those able to pay for it. What this means is:

  • Here there are twice as many doctors per 1,000 population as in the UK;
  • I can walk in to my GP surgery and be seen by my GP at any time - I might have to wait 20 minutes at most;
  • I get an annual check-up "MOT" and a 20-minute follow-up appointment to discuss the 3-page report, review medicines, address any issues etc.;
  • On the one occasion I urgently needed an ambulance it arrived within 10 minutes;
  • For the same incident, I had x-rays, an ultrasound scan and pain relief immediately on arrival at A&E - nobody was waiting;
  • Next morning (a Sunday) the consultant said an operation would be a good option. When I asked when it could happen, he looked puzzled and said "In about an hour - I'll finish the ward round, then I'll operate";
  • The hospital is a training hospital. The student nurses are paid a bursary, are paid for the shifts they work under training, receive all meals on and off duty for €30 a month and have student accommodation provided for a very small fee;
  • At my last "MOT" I mentioned a minor niggle - an irritation rather than anything life-threatening. The GP referred me to a specialist who saw me the following week and then phoned me to say that he could do the required minor operation "on Friday" - i.e. three days later.
  • There are no waiting lists to speak of. At the height of the pandemic there were of course delays, but the hospitals caught up within 3 months. My daughter, a healthcare professional in another EU country, confirms that there too they caught up with the backlogs within a few months.
The UK could have this level of service - it is after all the 5th/6th/7th wealthiest country on the planet. That it doesn't have this is entirely down to political decisions and mismanagement (and some very poor decisions like PFI) from all of the major parties over the last 40 years.
LakieLady · 23/05/2022 09:55

How about taking away student fees for nurses and Dr's providing they render the equivalent of 10 years' full time to the NHS with the only exception illness. If they don't they pay it back.

Absolutely this, but I'd add mat leave as well.

And this is what people voted for. If people choose to elect a party that doesn't believe in adequate funding for public services, this is what happens.

Plantstrees · 23/05/2022 09:55

I think the biggest issue is the lack of nurses and doctors. No amount of money can fix that easily as there are not enough qualified staff around to fill the vacancies.

In my view all medical training should be free, but it would still take time for the extra qualified professionals to filter through the system.

janj2301 · 23/05/2022 09:51

Until I worked at a GP I thought all the NHS funding issues were to mant managers believe me there is sooo much waste at primary care level, patients don't turn up for appoinmtnt, patients ask for referrals, never pick up the paperwork or never attend the hospital appoinment, patients don't collect paperwork to do their diabetic checks or routine blood tests. Don't attend smear/mamogram/diabetic eye tests/aortic aneursym checks, people seem to ignore ongoing conditions because obviously when they get worse the good old NHS will save them, sorry rant over

80sMum · 23/05/2022 09:49

tttigress · 23/05/2022 05:46

Personally I blame the decision to lockdown the country for nearly 2 years.

But would it have been any better for the health services if we hadn't locked down?

I guess we'll never know. But I do agree that the lockdowns were disastrous for the nation in almost every respect.

Wizzbangfizz · 23/05/2022 09:43

Ffs the NHS is not “free” - I pay a higher rate of tax and a good proportion of that goes on healthcare which I can’t even access - doctors and dentists around here are impossible to see - I fear getting ill because i don’t think me or my family will get the care we would need. The system is utterly broken and slinging more money at it won’t help - it needs root and branch reform.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 23/05/2022 09:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Supply and demand. None of us have a duty to work for less than we're worth. If consultants and GPs and any other hcps don't like the pay and work conditions in the UK they're more than entitled to quit, do private work or move to a country that actually pays them what they're worth. It's not their responsibility to keep the NHS afloat and they do more than enough of this out of goodwill already. How come when bankers and CEOs crashed our economy and are just plain fraudulant with our economy we weren't allowed to adequately penalise them because 'they're too valuable to our society and will just leave'. Even lorry drivers got the same reaction. And yet we think healthcare staff should just take it up the arse? This deluded attitude is another reason why the NHS is shot. News flash, they're working people with lives and familes not saints

EngTech · 23/05/2022 09:40

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/05/2022 09:22

@nocoolnamesleft Be angry at the fucking Tories who have been destroying the NHS for the next decade. I hope your wait is less than you fear.

How about being angry at Tony Blair and New Labour who wanted to sell it off ?

www.opendemocracy.net/en/ournhs/moment-of-honesty-is-required-new-labour-began-dismantling-of-our-nhs/

You can’t say that about Labour 😳

They have promised to save the NHS until they get into power and will then realise the multiple problems, waste being one of them

TheKeatingFive · 23/05/2022 09:36

How about the "something has to give" is to tax the wealthy? their marginal rates of income tax are lower than what most of us pay.

While I see why this would be the go to solution for public sector workers, the unfortunate truth is there's a tipping point where this ceases to raise more income as there are many loopholes and international opt outs.

But in a country that can find 100s of billions for Trident and HS2

While those were disgraceful wastes of public money, it's not carte blanche either. The economic situation is much more challenging right now than it was when that money was spent. We have high levels of covid borrowing to service, plus interest rates on the rise, so I don't think anyone should be thinking because lots of money has been spent on things in the past, that's justification for lots of borrowing now.

EngTech · 23/05/2022 09:36

Georgeskitchen · 23/05/2022 06:02

The NHS is not underfunded. It's badly managed. Too many overpaid managers and not enough front line staff.The waste is absolutely appalling

Have to agree with that, far too much waste which needs sorting out 👍

Badger1970 · 23/05/2022 09:33

My Dad is 82 and has several ongoing medical conditions. He gets appointment after appointment at the local hospital, which is a 40 mile round trip for me to have to take him, have time off work and Dad is so frail that it knocks the stuffing out of him for days. And the honest answer is that he's never going to "get better", his GP could manage these conditions just as well as some student Doctor in a hospital clinic.

You add that up across the UK and that would save billions.

Odessafile · 23/05/2022 09:32

@InChocolateWeTrust good post. And far more complex than the simplistic 'all mangers are bad' mantra.

Odessafile · 23/05/2022 09:29

Private sector management ? Like capita or group 7 lol. Because management of privatised utilities has gone so well 🙄

Odessafile · 23/05/2022 09:27

@Thesefeetaremadeforwalking he didn't though did he ? Actually poured money in to the NHS and improved things. Why not blame jeremy hunt who actually wrote a book advocating it ?

Overthewine · 23/05/2022 09:26

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Odessafile · 23/05/2022 09:24

The old chestnut about too many managers.
What about having enough managers and clinical staff ? Funnily enough many managers are clinical staff (we have 4 band 7 ward managers all who do the odd clinical shift).
Equally get rid of the managers and clinical staff will have to take on their duties anyway just as nurses have taken on some junior doctor tasks.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/05/2022 09:22

@nocoolnamesleft Be angry at the fucking Tories who have been destroying the NHS for the next decade. I hope your wait is less than you fear.

How about being angry at Tony Blair and New Labour who wanted to sell it off ?

www.opendemocracy.net/en/ournhs/moment-of-honesty-is-required-new-labour-began-dismantling-of-our-nhs/