Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Angry at long nhs waits

164 replies

glitterwobbles · 22/05/2022 23:33

I get daily headaches and nerve pain in arms and legs.Was diagnosed with cervical myelopathy last summer.
Was referred to another hospital as mine does not have any neurosurgeons and need surgery to prevent it getting worse and possible paralysis.
Have been told that the wait for an appointment is 18 months.
I know that the NHS is struggling after covid. But I have a condition that will get worse and if i had the money could have the surgery privately within weeks.
Just feel let down by NHS and as if the list keeps getting longer as when I was referred it was 10 months. Feel as if I will never get to the top

OP posts:
andtheycalledthewindmoriah · 23/05/2022 14:41

Havanananana · 23/05/2022 14:25

A health care system that is free at the point of care will always be underfunded. That is to say the demand will always outstrip supply, as there isn't the financial barrier inherent in all supply/demand relationships.

If this were true then there would also be long waiting times and huge backlogs in the other countries that also have healthcare that is free at the point of delivery, such as most of the EU countries. Nowhere that has universal healthcare has let the situation deteriorate to the point where over 10% of the population is on the waiting list for a hospital appointment.

As for a financial barrier to healthcare and a supply/demand relationship - this is simply the flawed free market thinking being inappropriately applied to healthcare. No individual can know what their healthcare needs will be - today, tomorrow or at any time in the future - but using collective data and socialised healthcare provision should be able to provide for each individual as and when they need the care.

Add to that the layers and layers of wasteful management, plus superfluous workers and forms, and you get the mess which is the current NHS.

Here's my example of "wasteful management". I know a very capable person who is currently the deputy director of nursing in a large health trust. She has an MBA and several years of non-NHS experience in industry, as well as originally training and working as a nurse and having 20 years of NHS experience.

She should be spending her days looking at how to improve the service, planning for the future, managing the nursing staff, working with HR, trainers, facilities etc. to ensure that her Trust attracts, develops and retains the required staff. Instead, because there is a shortage of beds, a shortage of nurses and doctors, a shortage of nursing home places into which patients can be discharged, a lack of coordination between the Trust and social services (who have their own budgets and priorities) she spends all of her time fire-fighting. Dealing with "today's issues" - such as telling a patient that his operation has been cancelled for the third time (and then dealing with the nurse or receptionist who perhaps has had to face the anger and disappointment of the patient and his relatives), trying to find somewhere to send patients who cannot be discharged and so are blocking beds, trying to deal with staff falling ill or resigning from the unrelenting pressure. On top of which she has also had to cope with government directives to cut staffing levels - at a time when the hospital is already short-staffed and overwhelmed.

There is always room for improvement. There are new systems and technologies that can be used to simplify and speed things up. But none of this works if the system itself simply does not have the capacity to meet the demand. And none of this will improve if managers are spending all day fighting fires instead of planning ahead, making improvements - and nor will it improve as long as an ex-banker (Javid) ex-PR executive (Hunt) or ex-economist (Hancock) are in charge of policy, or as long as the heads of the NHS organisations in the UK are beholden to their political masters.

European countries have very different standards of living too. They have less stress and encourage natural parenting and do not have the obesity and alcohol problems we do. Many factors, cannot pinpoint one, but their lifestyles does not foster disease like ours, generally do.

There's too many nuances in this argument, but the fact is we will see a privatised health system and the thing to do is take steps to mitigate this fact, but sitting around angry or upset won't do anything except help you remain sick.

andtheycalledthewindmoriah · 23/05/2022 14:39

OP said angry at NHS wait times and let down by the NHS.

Never said she was angry at doctors or staff.

The NHS is a public agency and under administration from the government.

Being let down by the NHS IS being let down by government.
Being angry at the state of the NHS IS being angry at government.

So many comments trying to redirect OP's anger and it's still pointless because what's the point in anger, directed correctly or not?

What about a solution? Or is it just as long as there are enough people for your liking being angry at the Tories you're happy?

We started paying for private health insurance a few years ago to pre-empt this state of affairs with the NHS. It's being privatised slowly. Once it happens fully insurance will start getting unattainable.

Start seriously looking after yourself too, in every aspect you can. Diet, physical movement, attitude, stress levels, growing food, things that can prevent and ail disease and feed good health in an effort to make medical intervention a last resort.

Anger, ironically, will only aid disease.

Havanananana · 23/05/2022 14:25

A health care system that is free at the point of care will always be underfunded. That is to say the demand will always outstrip supply, as there isn't the financial barrier inherent in all supply/demand relationships.

If this were true then there would also be long waiting times and huge backlogs in the other countries that also have healthcare that is free at the point of delivery, such as most of the EU countries. Nowhere that has universal healthcare has let the situation deteriorate to the point where over 10% of the population is on the waiting list for a hospital appointment.

As for a financial barrier to healthcare and a supply/demand relationship - this is simply the flawed free market thinking being inappropriately applied to healthcare. No individual can know what their healthcare needs will be - today, tomorrow or at any time in the future - but using collective data and socialised healthcare provision should be able to provide for each individual as and when they need the care.

Add to that the layers and layers of wasteful management, plus superfluous workers and forms, and you get the mess which is the current NHS.

Here's my example of "wasteful management". I know a very capable person who is currently the deputy director of nursing in a large health trust. She has an MBA and several years of non-NHS experience in industry, as well as originally training and working as a nurse and having 20 years of NHS experience.

She should be spending her days looking at how to improve the service, planning for the future, managing the nursing staff, working with HR, trainers, facilities etc. to ensure that her Trust attracts, develops and retains the required staff. Instead, because there is a shortage of beds, a shortage of nurses and doctors, a shortage of nursing home places into which patients can be discharged, a lack of coordination between the Trust and social services (who have their own budgets and priorities) she spends all of her time fire-fighting. Dealing with "today's issues" - such as telling a patient that his operation has been cancelled for the third time (and then dealing with the nurse or receptionist who perhaps has had to face the anger and disappointment of the patient and his relatives), trying to find somewhere to send patients who cannot be discharged and so are blocking beds, trying to deal with staff falling ill or resigning from the unrelenting pressure. On top of which she has also had to cope with government directives to cut staffing levels - at a time when the hospital is already short-staffed and overwhelmed.

There is always room for improvement. There are new systems and technologies that can be used to simplify and speed things up. But none of this works if the system itself simply does not have the capacity to meet the demand. And none of this will improve if managers are spending all day fighting fires instead of planning ahead, making improvements - and nor will it improve as long as an ex-banker (Javid) ex-PR executive (Hunt) or ex-economist (Hancock) are in charge of policy, or as long as the heads of the NHS organisations in the UK are beholden to their political masters.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 23/05/2022 14:22

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/05/2022 14:09

@Ahurricaneofjacarandas There are selfish timewasters and flaky people in every country and I suspect it's a problem with any country that provides any repectable level of healthcare private or not. Blaming all of the NHS's problems on this is just plain daft and gaslighting. It's a tiny hole on the sinking ship IMO and I also work for the NHS.

So, you actually know nothing about this in other countries, you just 'suspect' it's a problem?
Have you ever worked in Primary Care? Or in A & E ?
No I thought not.

I'm a GP actually..... I don't know for sure but I fail to believe it isn't a problem to some degree in other countries and I also know categorically that it isn't what's causing the NHS to fail because... well... it's obvious

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 14:18

@RosesAndHellebores on no particular time line... NHS treated my fractured hip and femur brilliantly, cared for my dying mum, patched me up after a horrendous m/c accident as a teenager.... looked after my great aunty for years, provided fantastic support for our homebirth, treated my DD for a suspected liver issue as a baby, when she had a suspected skin cancer, operated pro actively... i won't go on.....

The sooner it is funded and staffed at the correct level the better.

RosesAndHellebores · 23/05/2022 14:11

I have used the NHS in the 60s (missed a chipped ankle bone) 70s (missed a broken ankle) as an adult in the 80s (missed graves disease), 90s (two dc: one nearly died at birth due to negligence and I.suffered a prolapsed bladder - no availability of grommets), 00s (not much needed by us except my father's GP treated him for three chest infections - he collapsed - with Acute Myeloid Leukaemia), 2010's (zero support available for dd's MH good job we had BUPA and an extra £6k). 2021 - total mismanagement of a back injury.

All the above have been sorted privately - except father; he died 11 months later. The NHS has always been crap regardelss of the political party in power and short on apology and treating people like sentient humans.

The sooner it goes the better.

Fulbe · 23/05/2022 14:10

@Thesefeetaremadeforwalking
"I left and went into the private sector and now patients that engage me are prepared to work with me to achieve a positive improvement."

A lot of the things you describe are more to do with social inequality. I'm glad you've found people who fit with what you think patients should be like. I'm also glad that someone like you is no longer working for the NHS.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/05/2022 14:09

@Ahurricaneofjacarandas There are selfish timewasters and flaky people in every country and I suspect it's a problem with any country that provides any repectable level of healthcare private or not. Blaming all of the NHS's problems on this is just plain daft and gaslighting. It's a tiny hole on the sinking ship IMO and I also work for the NHS.

So, you actually know nothing about this in other countries, you just 'suspect' it's a problem?
Have you ever worked in Primary Care? Or in A & E ?
No I thought not.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 23/05/2022 14:01

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/05/2022 13:55

@janj2301
"Until I worked at a GP I thought all the NHS funding issues were to mant managers believe me there is sooo much waste at primary care level, patients don't turn up for appoinmtnt, patients ask for referrals, never pick up the paperwork or never attend the hospital appoinment, patients don't collect paperwork to do their diabetic checks or routine blood tests. Don't attend smear/mamogram/diabetic eye tests/aortic aneursym checks, people seem to ignore ongoing conditions because obviously when they get worse the good old NHS will save them, sorry rant over"

I couldn't agree more.

I worked for 20 years in a Health Speciality in the NHS and it would have been a damn site easier if some patients just did as they were bloody told.

Because the NHS is free - at the point of delivery- they think that means free and they don't appreciate it.

Hence some rarely follow through on advice or any post-operative care, then they have problems and turn up at A & E blaming the clinician.
They don't want to engage with their own health especially with conditions such as diabetes. They continue to smoke, drink and eat rubbish food, then wonder why they get heart disease are obese or have a CVA (stroke).

Try casualty at a weekend when drunks of all ages are filling A & E, being abusive, violent, vomiting all over, messing themselves etc.
People who are ill through no fault of their own have to wait while Police are called to deal with these morons.
Staff are continually put at risk.

I left and went into the private sector and now patients that engage me are prepared to work with me to achieve a positive improvement.

There are selfish timewasters and flaky people in every country and I suspect it's a problem with any country that provides any repectable level of healthcare private or not. Blaming all of the NHS's problems on this is just plain daft and gaslighting. It's a tiny hole on the sinking ship IMO and I also work for the NHS

Fulbe · 23/05/2022 13:59

When Labour came into power in 1997 they doubled NHS funding. Since the Conservatives have been in power I've seen constant cuts and struggle. Within the first 6 months, we were having to find half a million pounds to cut across the city in my specialism. They make cuts of 30m, then generously a few months later "increase funding" by 3m. It's despicable and I can't believe anyone who uses the NHS keeps voting them in.

I've been in situations in which colleagues have broken down in tears because they can't even find a chair to sit on at work, so have to sit on the floor. It's dreadful, please vote for something different next time round.

I'm so sorry you're at the receiving end of this but you are really not the only one, and the staff are really not to blame.

Thesefeetaremadeforwalking · 23/05/2022 13:55

@janj2301
"Until I worked at a GP I thought all the NHS funding issues were to mant managers believe me there is sooo much waste at primary care level, patients don't turn up for appoinmtnt, patients ask for referrals, never pick up the paperwork or never attend the hospital appoinment, patients don't collect paperwork to do their diabetic checks or routine blood tests. Don't attend smear/mamogram/diabetic eye tests/aortic aneursym checks, people seem to ignore ongoing conditions because obviously when they get worse the good old NHS will save them, sorry rant over"

I couldn't agree more.

I worked for 20 years in a Health Speciality in the NHS and it would have been a damn site easier if some patients just did as they were bloody told.

Because the NHS is free - at the point of delivery- they think that means free and they don't appreciate it.

Hence some rarely follow through on advice or any post-operative care, then they have problems and turn up at A & E blaming the clinician.
They don't want to engage with their own health especially with conditions such as diabetes. They continue to smoke, drink and eat rubbish food, then wonder why they get heart disease are obese or have a CVA (stroke).

Try casualty at a weekend when drunks of all ages are filling A & E, being abusive, violent, vomiting all over, messing themselves etc.
People who are ill through no fault of their own have to wait while Police are called to deal with these morons.
Staff are continually put at risk.

I left and went into the private sector and now patients that engage me are prepared to work with me to achieve a positive improvement.

AntonHeck · 23/05/2022 13:46

Georgeskitchen · 23/05/2022 06:02

The NHS is not underfunded. It's badly managed. Too many overpaid managers and not enough front line staff.The waste is absolutely appalling

This. A health care system that is free at the point of care will always be underfunded. That is to say the demand will always outstrip supply, as there isn't the financial barrier inherent in all supply/demand relationships.

Add to that the layers and layers of wasteful management, plus superfluous workers and forms, and you get the mess which is the current NHS.

AchatAVendre · 23/05/2022 13:34

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 23/05/2022 13:24

It's also lazy just to abandon a sinking ship. Most people agree that a universal healthcare system is the fairest and most efficient way to provide healthcare. However society is so apathetic towards our once world class NHS and so quick to allow the corrupt cespool that is our national needers to just sell it to their mates. We should all be screaming from the rooftop from both the social and the professional sides but we don't and we won't until it's too late

Most people don't? No other country has adopted this model, and most European countries are based on some form of competition between healthcare providers, meaning that consumers can jump ship if one of them under-performs.

The NHS was great back in the day but times have changed and it appears to be a poor model of a healthcare system for modern times.

Havanananana · 23/05/2022 13:33

It would be good to take the NHS out of politics and have cross party long term planning

The Conservative government recently voted down the requirement for the NHS to provide long-term capacity plans.

NHS professionals are well qualified to state what they need. Who else is better placed? For example, if the projected demand for one type of age-related operation is X, then they know that they will need X doctors, X nurses, beds, operating theatres, technical equipment etc. Population figures are readily available - if 10 million people are today aged 40-50, then in 15 years time, these people will be 55-65 and X% are likely to need operation X.

But then the government comes along and says "Well, you can only have half the resources you need, and we want to delay the decision on building new facilities for X" the entirely predictable result is that 15 years down the line, there is only the capacity to treat a fraction of those who need to be treated. Which is where the UK is now, and has been for the last 10 or more years - a situation that will take a generation or more to resolve as more doctors, nurses, hospitals etc. cannot appear by magic overnight; the lead time is 10-20 years.

BigWoollyJumpers · 23/05/2022 13:32

Messenger report due any day, the word is that he wants to get rid of plenty of underperforming management, and stop the endless rotating doors for those who do shit jobs, get large redundancies, and then end up somewhere else doing the same job.

Ahurricaneofjacarandas · 23/05/2022 13:24

It's also lazy just to abandon a sinking ship. Most people agree that a universal healthcare system is the fairest and most efficient way to provide healthcare. However society is so apathetic towards our once world class NHS and so quick to allow the corrupt cespool that is our national needers to just sell it to their mates. We should all be screaming from the rooftop from both the social and the professional sides but we don't and we won't until it's too late

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 13:16

hippolyta · 23/05/2022 12:57

Absolutely this.
It doesn't appear that just pouring money into the NHS works.
Other countries have much better health systems than we do at similar cost so we must be getting it wrong. Someone needs to get a grip on the organisation.
Plan from scratch without preconditions including the sacred "free at point of use".

If you want to see how much NHS funding is not going to actual medical care look at NHS jobs. Hundreds of well paid newly created management posts.

Both main parties have totally different ideas on the NHS, so how would your solution work?

Without management, how does an organisation work?

Its just lazy to state NHS has too much well paid management, an example of how well managed the NHS actually is, would be the vaccine rollout, organised and delivered by the NHS, to national and international acclaim.... very cheap too.

Whereas the privately organised Track n Trace was and is a v expensive disaster.

hippolyta · 23/05/2022 12:57

Ladyelizabeth · 23/05/2022 06:34

It would be good to take the NHS out of politics and have cross party long term planning

Absolutely this.
It doesn't appear that just pouring money into the NHS works.
Other countries have much better health systems than we do at similar cost so we must be getting it wrong. Someone needs to get a grip on the organisation.
Plan from scratch without preconditions including the sacred "free at point of use".

If you want to see how much NHS funding is not going to actual medical care look at NHS jobs. Hundreds of well paid newly created management posts.

Havanananana · 23/05/2022 12:52

Considering that the Tories have apparently been selling off the NHS for decades, there does appear to be a hell of a lot of it left.

The Conservatives have been selling off the bits that can be turned into profitable businesses - why else would any company buy them? What's left are the bits that cannot ever be provided at a profit - cancer care, long-term conditions, mental health, A&E etc., and of course the training and development of nurses and doctors - all of which are vital to the health of the population in general.

Add in the lack of general capacity and you get the situation that the country is in now. There has been a huge increase of people using their savings to pay for life-changing surgery. For example people paying for knee and hip operations so that they can regain their mobility and independence, return to work and live a normal life again. People cannot wait 2-3 years for this kind of operation, in pain and with their conditions deteriorating, so they are increasingly opting to "go private". Great business for the private hospitals.

glitterwobbles · 23/05/2022 12:46

I agree that this is a political issue but we need to stop letting politicians run our healthcare.
I have been a passionate supporter of the NHS and have never thought we should have an insurance system. Right now I wish i had taken out private insurance years ago.
A system that blaims shortage of consultants is broken. How can surgeons be operating once a week for the NHS but work another 2 days privately?
I know I could borrow the cost of the surgery, but do not want to run up debts when my long term employment is unsure as my condition deteriorates.
The irony is I am a nurse working for the NHS.

OP posts:
FreddyVoorhees · 23/05/2022 12:18

BalloonsAndWhistles · 23/05/2022 06:17

Yes, it’s always the Tories. How would Labour have been any more amazing?

They wouldn't. They'd just spend more money, mostly via PFI, trumpet it as a glorious win whilst all the time the NHS just becomes more and more dysfunctional and the problem gets kicked into the long grass yet again.

Considering that the Tories have apparently been selling off the NHS for decades, there does appear to be a hell of a lot of it left.

Slappedarse · 23/05/2022 12:12

@Havanananana , it was the same as the EU countries in the African country I grew up in. I can never understand why people sing the praises of the NHS when a third world country was far superior in health care. My mother has waited four months with breathing problems. She’s been on deaths door a few times and only helped by steroids from a private gp which she then had to ask for again from the NHS gp twice. Had to resort to seeing the consultant privately as the appointment was finally made for august, after a two month wait for an X-ray result and then being sent for a ct scan. The gp didn’t bother to contact her and let her know what the X-ray results were, she just got a call from the hospital for the ct scan after the gp booked an urgent scan. Finally after seeing the private consultant, she feels a lot better in two weeks than she has since this started. I’m not sure she would have survived until August and it’s bloody disgusting that someone who was active and walked everywhere was in a state that she could hardly walk across a room without collapsing and gasping for breath and almost drowning in fluid build up, yet this was going to be left for 7 months before seeing a consultant. I have several other horror stories as I am sure lots of us do. Unfortunately private care isn’t always that great here either, especially as more and more people are forced to use it, and it’s extremely expensive compared to other countries. Something drastic needs to be done about the awful state of health care here.

AchatAVendre · 23/05/2022 12:11

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 12:01

I think this goodwill will fade when the inevitable privatisation happens and somebody will have to actually make the job roles appealing

Yep, amazing goodwill in the NHS to keep the thing functioning, far more than i ever experienced in the private sector.
There is a role for private/public partnership but the full privatisation is only inevitable if we vote Tory in 2 years time and much like we yearn for state ownership of utilities/transport, it'll be gone forever.

From what i hear, the current privatisations have gone too far, inefficient and costly, with far too many opposing organisations to deal with to do simple jobs like a discharge a patient back home.

The private sector isn't great in this country due to the existence of the NHS.

In the European country I lived in, healthcare providers cannot increase the premium charged should the patient have certain treatment or conditions. In the private sector here, its normal. And they also could not exclude pre-existing conditions. Again, normal in the UK.

Yet the reality is that for many people in the UK, they actually end up paying twice for healthcare. Once through general taxation and then once again often through their savings or a bank loan to cover that essential hip surgery or cataract surgery to maintain their quality of life because they can't face a never ending waiting list or constant cancellations in the NHS. Not to mention the people who just pay for private healthcare on top anyway because they don't trust the NHS.

Alexandra2001 · 23/05/2022 12:01

I think this goodwill will fade when the inevitable privatisation happens and somebody will have to actually make the job roles appealing

Yep, amazing goodwill in the NHS to keep the thing functioning, far more than i ever experienced in the private sector.
There is a role for private/public partnership but the full privatisation is only inevitable if we vote Tory in 2 years time and much like we yearn for state ownership of utilities/transport, it'll be gone forever.

From what i hear, the current privatisations have gone too far, inefficient and costly, with far too many opposing organisations to deal with to do simple jobs like a discharge a patient back home.

GrannyBloomers · 23/05/2022 11:58

Badbadbunny · 23/05/2022 10:27

It didn't help that the BMA wanted to restrict the number of doctors being trained and voted on a complete ban on new medical schools.

"avoid overproduction of doctors with limited career opportunities"

I.e. keep supply low to maintain high demand and wages etc!

www.bmj.com/content/337/bmj.a748

Agreed - why restrict the numbers so much. Clearly there will be a tipping point beyond which there would unlikely be jobs.

My understanding is though that there are many medical students who cannot get a placement as a doctor - some parents of medical students on here have complained of this.