Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..to think brother (and sil) acted like a knob

84 replies

SuperTiredAgain · 22/05/2022 20:55

Mum died September. We need to clear out her house. "I might come up this weekend" said brother. "I don't know which day, I'll let you know" he said. I said, "ok, I'm free all day Sunday and can get there at 9am and spend full day with you sorting stuff". I said I was busy Saturday.

Next thing I hear is "I've got all weekend free so we (him, sil and nephew) are coming Saturday (🤷 yes he knew I was free Sunday so...) "We've hired a van" he says. "We want to put everything in storage".

Fine said I. But one request, please please leave all mums clothes which are in her bedroom, because I really want to look through them myself. Om another occasion I had specifically also asked him to leave her coats which were in downstairs cupboard.

Ok says brother. I reiterated this request several times and he definitely knew my wishes

There is loads of shit at my mum's house with no sentimental value that would have been really usefully sorted out while the van was there - old treadmill and arm chair needed driving to a skip or charity shop, entire contents of shed could have been taken somewhere (tip, charity, storage).

What happened? Sil decided to sort through all my mum's personal possessions - all the clothes - her pants draw, socks, bra drawyer, sorted all her tops and trousers and boxes everything up for storage. The whole.of the upstairs (mums bedroom and spare room) she boxed up and they took everything to storage. They also took all her coats and left everything else in the cupboard. I have no idea where this storage place is. I didn't want it, they did.

I am so so sad and was really really angry with my brother. He said "we worked our arses of Saturday" - yes I know, but I'd rather you hadn't. I'd rather you waited for me. I'd rather if you had done anything at all on Saturday that you had cleared the shit that I don't care about.

I hate the thought that sil has been through all my mum's stuff. All her private stuff. Brother thinks it's all fine, it's not like they've thrown the clothes away or anything.

I'm super sad. I wanted to potter round in mums bedroom, fold her things, sniff her smell on her jumpers one last time. Now I won't get to do that

Why the f couldn't they have waited for me. It's the only thing I asked them to leave alone

OP posts:
Mellowyellow222 · 22/05/2022 22:08

I would have been cross too.

especially your sister in law going through your mums stuff like that. It was insensitive of her when she knew the clothes had special meaning to you.

i would have to explain to her why I was upset. I am sure if it was her mum she wouldn’t want an in law taking on what you considered to be such an intimate task.

I am so very sorry for your loss. Your feelings here are valid.

FinallyHere · 22/05/2022 21:56

I'm very sorry for your loss.

What is the point of putting it into storage?

And who is going to pay the storage costs?

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 22/05/2022 21:52

Hankunamatata · 22/05/2022 21:11

In gentlest way. They boxed it up. They haven't gotten rid of anything. Your grieving and it hurts but everything will be in boxes.

You miss the point. OP wanted to see it all in situ - to touch, see and ‘sniff’ the clothes and say goodbye.

@SuperTiredAgain - I totally get it. It was hugely comforting for me to be able to do exactly what you described after my mother’s passing and before my sister despatched everything to the charity shop or skip.

Flowers
RosieLeaLovesTea · 22/05/2022 21:49

I completely understand why you are angry and sad about this. They should have respected your request. I hope her smell is still there and you get to hold and treasure her personal items for your goodbye. Lots of hugs.

Kite22 · 22/05/2022 21:46

Discovereads · 22/05/2022 21:29

I’m sorry for your loss and understand completely about sorting through a late mothers clothes and possessions. I did that for my mother and it took a whole day because I kept breaking down and crying. I do wonder though if your brother was tired of waiting for you to do this and that is why he just went ahead and cleared her house? Your mother passed away in September, it is now the end of May, so I don’t think he’s been too quick or overly rushing you in a time of grieving. Perhaps he feared another weekend/month/season might go by with you still not pottering around her bedroom with all her things as she had left them 8 months ago. I think it’s worth having a conversation with him about his intentions and why he could not continue to wait for you. I know with my mother, we had to sell her home quite quickly as it was mortgaged so I was clearing her possessions out only a few weeks after her funeral. Perhaps there is something like that? A need to sell the house soon that forced his hand?

I think this is a good point.

I am also confused as to why you are just moving it into storage and not dealing with it (and yes, I have had to clear out my parents house and I know what an emotional and difficult thing it is to do).

NumberTheory · 22/05/2022 21:46

I realise you’re working through your grief so I don’t mean this in the sense of you being in the wrong, only in the sense of pointing out how it might look to your brother and so why he might have acted as he did.

You live nearby and have had 8 months to do sorting that was important to you, but you haven’t. You seem to have had a clear idea of what you wanted him to do and what you wanted to do without reference to what he wanted out of it. It’s possible he finds this pretty controlling and gets in the way of him grieving. The coming up on the day you weren’t available may have been to do with when the van was available or their convenience or not wanting to do all that physical work the day before going back to work. But it may have been because he wanted to be in the house without you there so he could take it in at his own pace.

it doesn’t sound like anything’s been got rid of. Just stored. So you can still go through it yourself if that will really help. Just ask him for details on the storage place. But maybe you just need to spend a little time at the house and say goodbye to her. Then if there’s something specific you remember that you’d like that was packed away, ask your SiL if she can help you locate it.

I understand the disappointment, but the real issue is losing your mum, you and your brother both have to deal with that and you should try and cut each other plenty of slack in doing it. Not just for his sake, but for yours too. Anger/disappointment/etc. at him isn’t going to help you.

CorsicaDreaming · 22/05/2022 21:46

I am so sorry OP, that is such unfeeling behaviour on their part and I totally understand why you feel so sad and angry about it. I would feel the same in your place.

Fidodidit · 22/05/2022 21:43

I think he’s an arse. It’s taken my DB and I eighteen months to go through my DM’s things. We have families but the two of us have mostly just gone through it together. My SIL won’t have done this in a million years.

WrongWayApricot · 22/05/2022 21:42

That's out of order. They purposely did the only thing you asked them not to do? I cannot imagine a reasonable explanation for that. I'm so sorry they did that OP SadFlowers

Axahooxa · 22/05/2022 21:42

Horrible behaviour and YANBU!

Ruralbliss · 22/05/2022 21:41

That's horrendous behaviour.

You have every reason to be furious and sad.

I'm so sorry they robbed you of your saying goodbye to your mum via her personal space, things and smell.

They definitely were knobs.

winterchills · 22/05/2022 21:41

Awww this is really sad and I completely understand why you would have wanted to do that 😢

5zeds · 22/05/2022 21:39

It will be ok. Do the rest of the house. Take any small bits to the storage place when it’s done and have a look in the boxes. It really will be ok.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 22/05/2022 21:32

Why have you hung on so long to sort her clothes? It seems it was really important to you to spend time looking through her clothes....yet its been 8 months since she passed.

catandcoffee · 22/05/2022 21:29

So sorry about your Mum OP.
I totally get it... her smell on her clothes would have possibly brought you closure.

Your sister in law had no right to go through your mums things. How dare she that's so disrespectful to you and your Mum.

The good thing about the clothes being boxed... her smell will be there for you. 💐

Discovereads · 22/05/2022 21:29

I’m sorry for your loss and understand completely about sorting through a late mothers clothes and possessions. I did that for my mother and it took a whole day because I kept breaking down and crying. I do wonder though if your brother was tired of waiting for you to do this and that is why he just went ahead and cleared her house? Your mother passed away in September, it is now the end of May, so I don’t think he’s been too quick or overly rushing you in a time of grieving. Perhaps he feared another weekend/month/season might go by with you still not pottering around her bedroom with all her things as she had left them 8 months ago. I think it’s worth having a conversation with him about his intentions and why he could not continue to wait for you. I know with my mother, we had to sell her home quite quickly as it was mortgaged so I was clearing her possessions out only a few weeks after her funeral. Perhaps there is something like that? A need to sell the house soon that forced his hand?

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 22/05/2022 21:27

I agree it sounds like lack of communication. You need to have a phone conversation about what needs doing and divide up the jobs. Why is stuff going into storage rather than to charity or the tip?

Brainstorm22 · 22/05/2022 21:23

I say this kindly. It's just stuff. You will always have the memories of your mum.

My brother and mum waited 4 hours after my dad died to tell me. By that time he was in the morgue and I didn't get to say goodbye to him.

While this is shitty behaviour I'd let it go.

MoveOnTheCards · 22/05/2022 21:18

I’m sorry for your loss. I can understand why those elements were important to you and why you are frustrated and upset. Can you get the details of the storage space from your brother to go through your mum’s more personal items?

If you have a good relationship with you SIL can you perhaps talk to her about the best way forward with your mum’s possessions / the house? I wonder if that might be a way to get your brother to be a little less ‘practical’ about it?

ShaneTwane · 22/05/2022 21:18

40andlols · 22/05/2022 21:15

I'm really surprised that the replies on here haven't been more understanding. What they did was thoughtless and actually not only thoughtless but they completely disregarded what you'd asked.

I'm so sorry it turned out like this and that you've been robbed of the one potentially enjoyable element of the thing and left with all the shit.

To be fair I think most people are very understanding and agree op had every right to be upset. Grief can do strange things to people and we don't know if ops brother and sil thought they were being proactive and helpful. It's not going to help op to try and imply her bro and sil are awful and have deliberately tried to hurt her when for all we know they may have been trying to make it easy for her.

BessieBeach · 22/05/2022 21:15

No, they should have respected your desire to take your time over your mums possessions. I don’t think your brother really understood that this wasn’t just about packing up. It was going to be something you needed to do for your mum and yourself. I understand it. It is unfortunately the kind of thing that sticks with us after someone has died. However, I think the best approach (and probably the one your mum would want) would be not to fall out with them over it but tell them that you’re hurt that they did not understand your need to spend time with your mums clothes. I’m so sorry for your loss. It’s a tough time. I lost my mum too quite a few years ago now. Take care. x

40andlols · 22/05/2022 21:15

I'm really surprised that the replies on here haven't been more understanding. What they did was thoughtless and actually not only thoughtless but they completely disregarded what you'd asked.

I'm so sorry it turned out like this and that you've been robbed of the one potentially enjoyable element of the thing and left with all the shit.

ShaneTwane · 22/05/2022 21:14

I'm so sorry for your loss op. Unfortunately it sounds like miscommunication or they just thought they were doing the right thing as her stuffs been left for so many months. They should absolutely let you know how to access her things in the storage unit so you can collect anything you wish to keep. 💐

vipersnest1 · 22/05/2022 21:14

Sorry, but I can't help but agree with @Finalcountdowntoourtripaway. To my mind, they were looking for something.

Finalcountdowntoourtripaway · 22/05/2022 21:11

So they deliberately rummaged through her stuff knowing you wouldn't /couldn't be there.? Dodgy imo.
Sorry for your loss but they don't sound sincere.

Swipe left for the next trending thread