Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..to think brother (and sil) acted like a knob

84 replies

SuperTiredAgain · 22/05/2022 20:55

Mum died September. We need to clear out her house. "I might come up this weekend" said brother. "I don't know which day, I'll let you know" he said. I said, "ok, I'm free all day Sunday and can get there at 9am and spend full day with you sorting stuff". I said I was busy Saturday.

Next thing I hear is "I've got all weekend free so we (him, sil and nephew) are coming Saturday (🤷 yes he knew I was free Sunday so...) "We've hired a van" he says. "We want to put everything in storage".

Fine said I. But one request, please please leave all mums clothes which are in her bedroom, because I really want to look through them myself. Om another occasion I had specifically also asked him to leave her coats which were in downstairs cupboard.

Ok says brother. I reiterated this request several times and he definitely knew my wishes

There is loads of shit at my mum's house with no sentimental value that would have been really usefully sorted out while the van was there - old treadmill and arm chair needed driving to a skip or charity shop, entire contents of shed could have been taken somewhere (tip, charity, storage).

What happened? Sil decided to sort through all my mum's personal possessions - all the clothes - her pants draw, socks, bra drawyer, sorted all her tops and trousers and boxes everything up for storage. The whole.of the upstairs (mums bedroom and spare room) she boxed up and they took everything to storage. They also took all her coats and left everything else in the cupboard. I have no idea where this storage place is. I didn't want it, they did.

I am so so sad and was really really angry with my brother. He said "we worked our arses of Saturday" - yes I know, but I'd rather you hadn't. I'd rather you waited for me. I'd rather if you had done anything at all on Saturday that you had cleared the shit that I don't care about.

I hate the thought that sil has been through all my mum's stuff. All her private stuff. Brother thinks it's all fine, it's not like they've thrown the clothes away or anything.

I'm super sad. I wanted to potter round in mums bedroom, fold her things, sniff her smell on her jumpers one last time. Now I won't get to do that

Why the f couldn't they have waited for me. It's the only thing I asked them to leave alone

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Discovereads · 23/05/2022 08:25

sweeneytoddsrazor · 23/05/2022 00:06

All this trying to paint the brother and his wife as devious and searching for something is really tedious and unnecessary. They have had Sept to do that if they so wished. Why would they leave it until now?

I agree. In my personal experience relatives intent on ransacking for valuables get there before the funeral and trash the place while claiming they are looking for a will. They don’t wait 8 months, or forewarn you they are coming up on x day to pack out the house. And the belongings had to be dealt with on this case as the house has been sold and is under time pressure to be cleared.

Pottedpalm · 23/05/2022 06:51

im wondering what the next step is. Are you going to leave all the stuff in boxes and pay for storage long term? If not you will have to sort and clear out unwanted stuff, send to charity/the tip/for sale..
All of which would have been done more easily from the house with s van.
There is little point paying to store stuff you don’t want.

MichelleScarn · 23/05/2022 06:51

I read the section about you trying to work with your brother & his need to ‘handle’ everything before parting with it, & thought ‘Oh dear’.

Is this not exactly what op wants to do though and the reason for so many posters being horrible to the dB and sil?
Also the accusations they're only doing it to see what they can steal... are those being winged at the op too?

@SuperTiredAgain you are being very honest in your recognition that emotions are driving things and that they actually are good people.
Don't let posters on here whip things up and cause a fall out.

RedHelenB · 23/05/2022 06:23

SuperTiredAgain · 22/05/2022 23:22

I should probably mention that I do actually love my brother a lot and do think he's a nice person. This has just really upset me! My SIL is also a nice SIL and a kind person. I know she didn't do this out of malice and was likely trying to help. Just wish the two of them had not done this.

Then don't fall out over it. The clothes are there for you to sort through. Let it go.

TigerLilyTail · 23/05/2022 04:16

A friend of mine had awful problems with her brothers clearing out their mums house after she died. She had been round and boxed some things up and asked that they be left for her (not valuable things but sentimental things) and they put them in the skip. They were other things too, but their relationship is beyond repair now.

I think in this case, I totally understand why the OP is upset and I think she should communicate clearly that she is disappointed that they ignored her wishes on this. But, you can't unring a bell, so it's better to draw a line under it and move on.

I agree with the others that it's madness to put her things in storage but as long as the OP isn't paying, then I'd leave them to it. Hopefully, the rest of the clear-out will go smoothly.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 23/05/2022 01:34

So sorry for your loss, and for this too, which must have felt like another small loss on top of the bigger one.
I understand - you wanted to be near to your mum one more time, by going through her most personal items, and now that's not an option for you. But I think your grief is overtaking your more rational senses (again, understandable) and since your B and SIL are generally nice people, then I think this wasn't a deliberate act.

I suspect what happened was that your brother heard "clothes" and did not hear/process "Don't touch those".
Brains work in funny ways - we tend to process the action first before the negation of it, so if we say to someone "don't fall off the chair" if they're standing precariously on one, their brain will go "fall off the chair" first, before processing the "don't" aspect, and they may well fall off the chair. Better to say something like "Take care on that chair, it's a bit dangerous".
In your case, I can't know exactly what you said to your brother, but if it was "don't touch mum's clothes" then he may not have remembered exactly what you said, just that you mentioned your mum's clothes. But I'm making excuses for him - you said you told him numerous times, so he should have "got it" by the time he got to the house.

Do get the information from them on how to get to the storage facility though - at least your mum's stuff is there, so you can go through her clothes there, and they might still have some of her scent on them still. Thanks

expat101 · 23/05/2022 00:45

This was never going to be a nice nor easy thing to do for any of you, however it has been 8 months and you mentioned previously you have popped in for a coffee from time to time, so you have had the oppportunity to do what you wanted to do with your Mother's clothing.

You must accept that you have had your time to do as you wish and that Your Brother has every right to go into the home when he could too..

Your Brother and SIL have arranged and paid for storage for your/his Mum's things. You also say the house is virtually sold, there is no more further time for this work to have been undertaken.

I understand it has been very confrontational for you but this was never going to be a happy task and I would suggest your SIL probably didn'ty know where to start and thought being a bit more emotionally detached from personal items, it would be an easier task if she packed your Mum's clothing. I doubt very much that there was any ill feeling towards you at all by her doing so, it was simply a practical solution.

However you need to move forward and along with your brother work out how to dispose of the unwanted items, whether it be by garage sale or skip bin.

Hopefully you can all sit down at the end of the task and share a drink together and give Mum a toast.

MushyPeasPrincess · 23/05/2022 00:23

Of course they/he acted like knobs ignoring the ONE thing you asked them to respect for you.
There is no debate they were wrong to do so.
But there's several posters who hang around AIBU just to argue with any OP and try to put them "in the wrong", no matter what the topic.

Lolllllllllllll · 23/05/2022 00:08

Why would the brother and sil be looking for "SOMETHING" 8 months after the OPs mum died. 🤷🏻‍♀️ That doesn't sound likely at all.

Also not sure why the OP is mad at the SIL, it sounds unlikely that the brother will have told her that the OP didn't want her looking through his Mum's stuff. She probably assumed the OP and her husband found it difficult and just thought she was helping. I'm not sure going through the OPs Mum old clothing was being nosy.

I also don't understand why the OP is so mad about them coming on Saterdsy. The OP has said that they didn't work well together when they tried to clear things before. It makes sense that the brother would try and come on a different day tbh.

OP, I'm sorry about your loss.

SuperTiredAgain · 23/05/2022 00:06

There isn't any historic bad feeling between me and sil. She's a nice person. I suppose there have been previous occasions where I feel she's crossed the line from daughter-in-law duties, to daughter duties, or where I feel she has got involved when she shouldn't, but it's not bothered me this much before. SIL is a nice person and so is DB. (They just can sometimes be a wee bit selfish / act in their own best interests). I love DB and we r normally really close.

OP posts:
sweeneytoddsrazor · 23/05/2022 00:06

All this trying to paint the brother and his wife as devious and searching for something is really tedious and unnecessary. They have had Sept to do that if they so wished. Why would they leave it until now?

AnAfternoonWalk · 22/05/2022 23:57

vipersnest1 · 22/05/2022 21:14

Sorry, but I can't help but agree with @Finalcountdowntoourtripaway. To my mind, they were looking for something.

Yes this. Brother and sil were hoping to find something valuable in your mother’s personal possessions. That’s why they focused on that under the guise of folding her clothes and coats and putting them in storage boxes while leaving everything else that had no value to them and needed cleaning out.

While the brother is entitled to look through everything, so are you. He found out from you which day you could go and he and his wife picked the day before to get to the “good stuff” before you.

You and your brother should have gone through it together with the sil working downstairs perhaps, giving you space and time and privacy the first day of dealing w mother’s possessions.

It also sounds like there is some resentment and bad feeling to begin with between you and sil. Obviously none of us here can make a judgement one way or another on that relationship, not knowing the history etc.

timeisnotaline · 22/05/2022 23:56

Given he didn’t want to get rid of anything or decide when together you need to say I will be there all day Saturday, and I will decide whatever I think suitable to do with stuff since we are now clearing mums stuff while deliberately ignoring any requests of the other. You still need to hire a van and actually be useful with it and move large furniture instead of the clothes I’ve asked you not to and which I can fit in my car. If I have to hire a van because you couldn’t use your brain and shift actual furniture with the van you hired then I will have it dumped on your front lawn.
and if he objects - oh why should I be paying any attention to your requests? You did the one thing I asked you not to, and I’m furious you robbed me of that time I was going to use saying goodbye to mum. But you think I should respect your wishes? Don’t call me until you’ve hired a van and are going to help this time.

SuperTiredAgain · 22/05/2022 23:53

Universalaunt - yes I expect he has some attachment issues. I don't mind that he wants this storage. And yes, I expect he will be storing for quite sometime. And yes, I expect SIL is only too familiar with his difficulty in parting with stuff and suspect the storage was her idea to ease his anxiety about the time pressure (which is nice of her). After the clothes incident, I ensured I rescued today, anything at all that means something to me and now feel I have all I need (a few photos, old letters from me to mum, and a couple.of odds and ends) They can do what they like with everything else now. It's up to them.

OP posts:
MindPalace · 22/05/2022 23:49

They sound horrible, ignorant and selfish. Sorry, OP. 💐

TheOrigRights · 22/05/2022 23:46

YANBU OP. I would have felt exactly the same as you do.

Going through a deceased person's personal items (underwear and the like) is not something an IL should do if there is a willing daughter to do so. It's a matter of respect. I would have hated someone other than one of my siblings to do this for either of my parents.

That you had made your wishes clear makes it even worse.

UniversalAunt · 22/05/2022 23:44

Hi @SuperTiredAgain it’s good to hear back from you.

I read the section about you trying to work with your brother & his need to ‘handle’ everything before parting with it, & thought ‘Oh dear’.

I assume that your brother is rather like this at home with his own stuff & that your SiL is used to him being like this, hence the practised side-stepping of disposing of anything (because it takes forever & is a torture) but getting it moved out so that the house sale can go through. Would it be fair to say that your brother has an attachment disorder or just for this task?

Either so or not, you need to make progress for yourself. You have told how you have initiated & tried to get stuff moving but met with passive resistance from your brother. You have been reasonable.

Would SiL be your ally in getting access to the storage unit so that you can retrieve what matters to you? After she owes you a bit of consideration…

You may need a few brief focus visits to complete your mission, but it can be done.

Somehow I think that your brother may be storing stuff for some time, at his cost & out of your SIL’s way for some time. The sooner you are settled with your treasures, the better.

Kite22 · 22/05/2022 23:43

OnaBegonia · 22/05/2022 22:46

I agree with PPs, you've had 8 months to potter and sniff, the house was on the market yet no clearing has been done, what a back to front way of doing things.
Why storage? now that needs sorted.

I have to agree with this.
I know some posters think it harsh, but it is actually spot on.
I do get that OP wanted to take time to go through her Mum's clothes, but the point is, she has had 8 months to do that, if she felt it was something that was important to her. She lives locally, and has now said she has been into the house several times.
She has now also said that they sold the house in March - in doing that, they have now given themselves a deadline.
OP could have spent a day or several evenings at her Mum's house throughout the Autumn, Winter and Spring. She has chosen not to, and now (having sold) the choice is to just get rid without much sorting, or to remove it to somewhere where they can sort later. OP has done neither, so her brother has done the latter. Seems an odd thing to me, but it is the 'less final' option, so OP can still do what she wants with her Mum's clothes.
OP has already spent time wandering through the house, and touched things, and sat with a coffee, and spent time there.
The brother hasn't cleared the house a week after his Mum died.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/05/2022 23:40

Again gently OP do you think you would have been able to do it in one day, did they think maybe it would be too much for you? If this was the one thing you wanted to do yourself then surely you should have been doing a bit at a time when you have popped in for coffee. I well know the overwhelming grief losing a parent can cause, having recently lost my Dad, and I am sorry for your loss, but please try not to let this thing come between you and DB/SIL it will only cause more heartache

Horsemad · 22/05/2022 23:24

This was NOT miscommunication - how could it be when OP states she reiterated what the agreement was re her Mum's clothes? 🤨

Your brother & SIL rode roughshod over your wishes and you have every right to be pissed off. I'd be mad as hell if that happened to me.

SuperTiredAgain · 22/05/2022 23:22

I should probably mention that I do actually love my brother a lot and do think he's a nice person. This has just really upset me! My SIL is also a nice SIL and a kind person. I know she didn't do this out of malice and was likely trying to help. Just wish the two of them had not done this.

OP posts:
Vikinga · 22/05/2022 23:14

I'm really angry on your behalf op. I dont understand why they would have done that when you explicitly asked them not to and there are so many other things that would have made more sense for them to sort.

Luckily, they haven't thrown anything away so ask them for the storage details and when you're ready, go and get the clothes and sort through them.

SuperTiredAgain · 22/05/2022 23:09

SILs time would have been much better spent transporting the rubbish?! 🤨 ooh really, do you see yourself above that and in charge??

I meant because she had hired a van, it surely would've been more useful to have actually used it to transport big stuff. I don't have a van. I can't transport big stuff, but now they've taken the clothes I wanted to sort, and left all the big stuff and we will have to now get another van if they want it in storage, or find another way of getting it to the tip if they want it chucked

OP posts:
Krabapple · 22/05/2022 23:07

I can’t believe some of the replies on here! Show some compassion please. I can fully understand why you are so upset. It does seem odd behaviour from your brother. It doesn’t sound like he meant any malice though so try not to fall out with him over it. It sounds like you need each other’s support.

SuperTiredAgain · 22/05/2022 23:05

Sorry to those who think I'm being to harsh on sil and it's DB who should be the target of my anger. Just to reassure - I am more angry at dB. He was there with her. She was likely trying to help. She has actually apologised on text now too. It is dB I'm more annoyed at because he was the one who knew I wanted the clothes left. He could've ask sil to help with clearing ANYTHING ELSE.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread