Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SarahSissions · 23/05/2022 17:08

Hells bells. If Amber Heards team thinks this guy is doing her any favours then they are barking. He’s been caught out by this ethics question, he needs to shut it down- not keep arguing the point, he’s just undermining his credibility

TiddyTidTwo · 23/05/2022 17:07

Cross exam has him by the balls in the first few minutes and he's not liking it

StormzyinaTCup · 23/05/2022 17:07

Oh dear!

Boulshired · 23/05/2022 17:06

Midlifemusings · 23/05/2022 17:01

A lot of what he is saying could apply to just about anyone. He included non verbal looks that would be perceived as threatning in his description of psychological abuse....so giving your spouse the evil eye makes one abusive.

Yeah, I think we are all narcissist.

Miscfeminista · 23/05/2022 17:02

She could be abusive to children, animals, other men who are impaired or weaker in some way and so on, there are different scenarios where a woman could be the abuser. It is never to be equated to patriarchal male violence, regardless of comparison whether it is worse or better etc.

In this case even if they were both jealous and controlling, only one was more powerful to do so and overrule the other. That is what patriarchy survives on-men keeping women on large under control whether institutionally, socially by imposing what is acceptable behaviour for women or on one by one basis where the partner keeps the woman in domestic abuse situation, where she has to do as he say lest she wants him to lash out and punish her by humiliation, assault etc. As the dr mentioned, it's about control and asserting dominance. I would hardly be scared of Amber(tho she is a bit taller and probably stronger than me)shouting at me. Their power imbalance has been chewed on plenty already so no need to repeat that

Midlifemusings · 23/05/2022 17:01

Boulshired · 23/05/2022 16:58

This is longer than Dr hughes or feels like it, those who complained about dr curry (including myself) dishing out diagnosis this guy is on the same level. I wouldn’t seek this guy out if I was an addict. He has made really good points and then goes on on blanket statements which for me spoils it. The biggest problem is those who support Amber see what he is saying in Depp, those who support Depp see Amber in his description. I see both of them and neither them in his description.

A lot of what he is saying could apply to just about anyone. He included non verbal looks that would be perceived as threatning in his description of psychological abuse....so giving your spouse the evil eye makes one abusive.

Boulshired · 23/05/2022 16:58

This is longer than Dr hughes or feels like it, those who complained about dr curry (including myself) dishing out diagnosis this guy is on the same level. I wouldn’t seek this guy out if I was an addict. He has made really good points and then goes on on blanket statements which for me spoils it. The biggest problem is those who support Amber see what he is saying in Depp, those who support Depp see Amber in his description. I see both of them and neither them in his description.

adriftabroad · 23/05/2022 16:56

willithappen · 23/05/2022 16:23

All this guy is doing is eating Ambers very limited time she already has, promoting his own book and coming across very unlikeable to the jury.
Lovely reviews about him online also 🙃

I agree, hes really settled in and is enjoying himself.

Everything he says about NPD and JD I apply to AH.

Midlifemusings · 23/05/2022 16:56

This is slightly off topic but there is something about this pyschiatrists mannerism's and eye movements and voice that make him sound like he is in an animated movie. He makes me think of Rafiki from Lion King.

If he gets tired of psychiatry, I feel like he could get work as a voice actor in animated films!

RosieRooster83 · 23/05/2022 16:54

I'm watching the trial live. Victims apologise too. They are made to feel like it is all their fault and they then end up apologising.

BonnesVacances · 23/05/2022 16:52

I dare say that's probably what AH believes herself.

Midlifemusings · 23/05/2022 16:49

If they do a good job on cross, they can easily point out how this guy just described Amber.

The debate will go on. There are many on here who do not believe a woman can ever have power over a man due to the privilege and physical strength that men have and therefore women can never be abusers and men can never be victims. That seems to be the main argument from those supporting Amber. That regardless of what she did or does to anyone, she can only ever be a victim because she will never be more powerful than a man, and certainly never more powerful than Depp.

TiddyTidTwo · 23/05/2022 16:42

Oh he's blown it!

BonnesVacances · 23/05/2022 16:40

Lol! He's literally describing AH when detailing what a narcissist is Grin Massive own goal! Are AH's team actually on her side?

TiddyTidTwo · 23/05/2022 16:39

A lot applies to AH too, here.

Not sure this is helping her. Plus he's never even met JD.

Odd

StormzyinaTCup · 23/05/2022 16:39

There is an own goal coming up here!!

Midlifemusings · 23/05/2022 16:29

Well that was not what AH's team would have wanted to hear. He said abusers don't seek out counsellong or help, they don't want anyone to know what is going on in the house...and Johnny basically had a live in team to counsel and help him.

Midlifemusings · 23/05/2022 16:28

StormzyinaTCup · 23/05/2022 16:23

But didn't the surgeon in Australia say it was a 'velocity' injury and didn't believe is was shut in a concertina door as was told to him by JD.

He said it was a crush injury due to the damage to the bone and there was one more part but I don't remember what it was.

Aspiringmatriarch · 23/05/2022 16:24

BonnesVacances · 23/05/2022 16:18

So is his testimony that due to drug and alcohol abuse JD suffers memory lapses and doesn't remember punching and/or raping AH?

I think so, essentially. People in a blackout don't form memories so that would be true whatever he was doing. Cognitive issues can obviously affect both behaviour and memory.

willithappen · 23/05/2022 16:23

All this guy is doing is eating Ambers very limited time she already has, promoting his own book and coming across very unlikeable to the jury.
Lovely reviews about him online also 🙃

StormzyinaTCup · 23/05/2022 16:23

Aspiringmatriarch · 23/05/2022 16:20

With regard to the Orthopaedic specialist, how does that fit in with AH saying JD's finger tip was taken off by the phone? I missed some of it.

She theorised that but I don't think she's ever claimed to have seen it happen. The Orthopaedic guy was a bit inconclusive really, he seemed to indicate it was more likely to have happened by the finger getting trapped in something and said the injury wasn't consistent with what Johnny had described happening. He didn't really get into Amber's theory and wasn't asked about it in cross-examination either. Maybe because she says she didn't witness it so it would be speculation anyway.

But didn't the surgeon in Australia say it was a 'velocity' injury and didn't believe is was shut in a concertina door as was told to him by JD.

Midlifemusings · 23/05/2022 16:22

BonnesVacances · 23/05/2022 10:11

What does a face that's been battered look like? Especially when the batterer is wearing rings?

Look at boxer's faces after being repeatedly punched in the face. There are also many pictures online of victims of domestic violence who have been violently attacked.

Maybe someday Amber will share her skin routine that allows her to be violently attacked and punched in the face with heavy rings, thrown and dragged across glass, kicked and thrown across rooms, and frequent violent attacks that leave pretty much no mark. There are so many people who would benefit from her knowledge and ability to be like a boxer in a ring taking round after round after round of punches and hits with heavy rings and to walk away without a mark. Maybe she will sell her secrets and make millions from it. She says she is a woman's advocate so why not let all the other women in on it so they don't have to deal with cuts and bruises and injuries when they are attacked.

StormzyinaTCup · 23/05/2022 16:21

I think they need to bring in JDs ADHD on cross.

To summarise 'Don't do drugs kids'!!

Aspiringmatriarch · 23/05/2022 16:20

With regard to the Orthopaedic specialist, how does that fit in with AH saying JD's finger tip was taken off by the phone? I missed some of it.

She theorised that but I don't think she's ever claimed to have seen it happen. The Orthopaedic guy was a bit inconclusive really, he seemed to indicate it was more likely to have happened by the finger getting trapped in something and said the injury wasn't consistent with what Johnny had described happening. He didn't really get into Amber's theory and wasn't asked about it in cross-examination either. Maybe because she says she didn't witness it so it would be speculation anyway.

BonnesVacances · 23/05/2022 16:18

So is his testimony that due to drug and alcohol abuse JD suffers memory lapses and doesn't remember punching and/or raping AH?

Swipe left for the next trending thread