Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 05:55

I dont think Kate Miss is going to do much damage tbh - she isn't at the height of fame and they have JD in front of them already for any star struck jury members. All she will do is say he never hit her and the stairs is a rumour I guess. And we know people can become abusive especially with the amount of damage he's done to himself with drugs etc since 1998. Elaine just has to ask if he was arrested for criminal damage while with her.

OP posts:
Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 01:11

And how many witnesses does Amber have left?

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 00:48

Kate Moss is going to be one of the most damaging for AH.

Then they have the rebuttal to Whitney, also the flight attendant who's going to say the kick never happened.

Dr Curry is going to hone in on how unstable AH is. The finger Dr is going to go to town on the finger issue.

Then you are about to have someone tear apart all the meta data on her pictures and prove photoshopping, followed by Warner Bros who are going to quash AH counter claim by eventually admitting to "lack of chemistry" the media mogul lawyer is going to say how damaged JD has been financially by all this and how slanderous the accusations are.

Then JD will end it all with a truly believable Oscar performance , and I mean people are going to be "moved" by it. Tears will flow and ebb naturally because the man is an incredible actor, and he will have his final swan dance.

And AH team is just going to sit there silently and watch the house burn down like 3 lemons.

I'd be angry of I were AH right now, really really angry.

Boulshired · 24/05/2022 00:25

copied from law crime daily below is the list for Depps rebuttal and amber hears team have left four hours they probably won’t get through them all but still

  • Dr. Richard Shaw
  • Dr. Kimberly Collins (forensic psychologist)
-Candie Davidson-Goldbronn (Children's Hospital of Los Angeles rep)

-Walter Hamada (Warner Bros. Pictures)
-Richard Marks (entertainment lawyer)

-Mike Spindler (damages expert)

-Doug Bania (social media expert)

-Morgan Night (Hicksville witness)

-Dr. David Kulber (Depp's hand doctor)

-Jennifer Howell (former friend of Whitney Henriquez)
-Kate Moss (Depp's ex-girlfriend)

-Bryan Neumeister (metadata expert)

-Morgan Tremaine

-Lydia Fillip (flight attendant)

-Dr. Shannon Curry (forensic psychologist)

-Johnny Depp (plaintiff)

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 00:10

That’s also a good point. Whenever women deal with abusive men, they became damaged goods and liable property, no one considers you as worthy or interesting much anymore. Similarly for single women with kids, men just assume you have to settle for less and don’t approach because most want to do what they want on their terms, not have consideration towards women’s time and their extra responsibilities(as a woman on the other hand I wouldn’t date a man with kids because he would most likely try to make me do the childcare for him and use it as an excuse to avoid other responsibilities between you)

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 00:03

@ObjectionHearsay It is concerning because even if she wants to retreat from Hollywood, it will take time and she probably has other expenses unsettled(other than donations, that’s probably last thing to worry about at the moment). She would also need security for some time more. They did mention couple of times that social connections are everything in Hollywood so maybe she will be able to do something behind the scenes or collaborate here and there with her friends in some ways, I doubt she’ll go from Hollywood to broke in an instant. Either way it will be stressfull, I’m honestly not sure if the whole surrogacy thing was a good idea, especially at this point. Obviously I wish her luck, baby is a baby at the end of the day but the timing(and paying someone to carry a baby for you generally, while claiming to be feminist)seems very strange

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 00:01

mummyrocks1 · 23/05/2022 23:38

AH however, to put bluntly she's fucked. She isn't getting any acting roles by any major studios again. I doubt she can turn her hand to journalism or being an ambassador of anything thanks to this witch hunt. She can't even flog shampoo because of all this. I do worry for her, I seriously do. If this goes as south as I think it's going to go for her, she's got no income, a young baby, a 7milliom donation hanging over her that will haunt her. What is she going to do? I really do hope she has some form of decent support around her.

Marry a rich man? She does seem to be able to attract the rich and famous.

I've no dog in this fight, either way.

But Jesus Christ, I don't think there's a millionaire planning on marrying her any time soon after this. Can't see many swiping right on her tinder profile.

Worst case scenario a abusive partner who cuts fingers off and shots in your bed at best a very traumatized woman who will suffer long term for the abuse she has endured and will need a lot of support to overcome this.

It's a bit like asking do you want to put your hand in to a bag of broken glass or in to a hornet's nest for the majority of men.

ObjectionHearsay · 23/05/2022 23:57

From what I've read all they can do when time is up is object, to allow due process. But no cross examination, nothing else. Just sit there watching.

Now as US civil law in such cases dictates that In a civil case, the plaintiff must convince the jury by a “preponderance of the evidence” (i.e., that it is more likely than not) that the defendant is responsible for the harm the plaintiff has suffered.

Who the hell gives the other team 10+ hours to hammer away at the above point 😳

Boulshired · 23/05/2022 23:52

If amber team call anymore witnesses then maybe they on running there clock out on purpose. Throughout the case I’ve felt a sense of unease with Heards lawyers even when they have had good moments. We already know that there has been huge problems with her evidence and getting information she needed from Depp. There must be concern for what neumeister has to say. Depps team (apart from Depp) can be very good at getting witnesses on the stand ask the right question and move on. You don’t give one side the last days before closing all to themselves.

mummyrocks1 · 23/05/2022 23:41

Why does JD need so many lawyers? Some of them seem to sit there doing absolutely nothing. Do you think he meant it to be intimidating? Force by numbers?

Can we read too much into how well he seems ti get on with his lawyers? They seem to genuinely get on. Or is this a brought relationship? Whereas AH seems ti have no relationship with her at all.

mummyrocks1 · 23/05/2022 23:38

AH however, to put bluntly she's fucked. She isn't getting any acting roles by any major studios again. I doubt she can turn her hand to journalism or being an ambassador of anything thanks to this witch hunt. She can't even flog shampoo because of all this. I do worry for her, I seriously do. If this goes as south as I think it's going to go for her, she's got no income, a young baby, a 7milliom donation hanging over her that will haunt her. What is she going to do? I really do hope she has some form of decent support around her.

Marry a rich man? She does seem to be able to attract the rich and famous.

minou123 · 23/05/2022 23:27

Boulshired · 23/05/2022 23:06

Something is not right, it does seem that they don’t mind the clock disappearing. I didn’t understand that time spent on the re direct of Dr spiegle. Some witnesses were quicker than that redirect.

Thinking about this more maybe they think their time doesn't include cross examining JD rebuttal witnesses?

Maybe they think the judge will allow them time to cross examine, even when they run out of time?

I'm starting to doubt I understand this time thing. The way I understood it was they each have the same amount of time, but once you use all of your time, that's it. Boom. You're done. You can't call anymore witnesses, you can't cross examine witnesses and nor can you object.
But maybe I'm wrong and they know something we all don't. (Which is likely 😂)

ObjectionHearsay · 23/05/2022 23:23

Miscfeminista · 23/05/2022 23:13

Well, I don't know how much will he recover. It's sad to say about anyone but I doubt he will manage to stay clean for a long time. He's getting older, some drug abuse effects are irreversible and he will be recovering addict for rest of his life(if he ever actually tries to get sober again). Also all of these things that came out in public will never go away, he lost trust of a good chunk of people through years due to drug addiction. It looks like he wanted to drag AH with him to the bottom. Her dreams have been crushed but honestly, Hollywood is still not a very pretty place for women. She might go on with her life in different direction-at least more healthy and with more time to change her life than JD. This was his attempt to blame her for his life falling apart, despite it being on very shaky legs even before they got together. He appears actually quite lonely and not all there. Not feeling particularly sorry for him tho

I don't disagree with you here fully.

At 58 and over 40 years of heavy substance misuse, nobody is walking away from that unscathed, physically or psychologically.

However, I think he will continue with his music, his art, he has a fanbase of millions. He's due to appear in a foreign language film. So whilst he won't be Hollywood A list, he will go on.

AH however, to put bluntly she's fucked. She isn't getting any acting roles by any major studios again. I doubt she can turn her hand to journalism or being an ambassador of anything thanks to this witch hunt. She can't even flog shampoo because of all this. I do worry for her, I seriously do. If this goes as south as I think it's going to go for her, she's got no income, a young baby, a 7milliom donation hanging over her that will haunt her. What is she going to do? I really do hope she has some form of decent support around her.

Miscfeminista · 23/05/2022 23:13

Well, I don't know how much will he recover. It's sad to say about anyone but I doubt he will manage to stay clean for a long time. He's getting older, some drug abuse effects are irreversible and he will be recovering addict for rest of his life(if he ever actually tries to get sober again). Also all of these things that came out in public will never go away, he lost trust of a good chunk of people through years due to drug addiction. It looks like he wanted to drag AH with him to the bottom. Her dreams have been crushed but honestly, Hollywood is still not a very pretty place for women. She might go on with her life in different direction-at least more healthy and with more time to change her life than JD. This was his attempt to blame her for his life falling apart, despite it being on very shaky legs even before they got together. He appears actually quite lonely and not all there. Not feeling particularly sorry for him tho

Boulshired · 23/05/2022 23:06

Something is not right, it does seem that they don’t mind the clock disappearing. I didn’t understand that time spent on the re direct of Dr spiegle. Some witnesses were quicker than that redirect.

ObjectionHearsay · 23/05/2022 22:54

I think they thought giving AH the stand for so long would win. I don't think they calculated how poorly she would be received. It ate in to time they don't have.

I've yet to see a slam dunk moment for them for the Jury.

And now they have basically handed over the ball and court to JD's team who are poised by the looks of their rebuttals to slam dunk one after another, over and over again.

Fresh in the Juries mind, ready for deliberation.

I think both will come out as losers in that no claim is going to be awarded to either party. But JD's team know they have a slim chance of winning this and this whole court case is all about tearing AH apart and her claims and her character. He will recover, she won't.

I've given up trying to figure out who's done what now, I think I'm now just here to watch the grand finale and the aftermath of this. 😳

ENoeuf · 23/05/2022 22:51

www.cbr.com/amber-heard-aquaman-2-claims-denied-wb-exec-dceu/amp/

OP posts:
minou123 · 23/05/2022 22:48

Miscfeminista · 23/05/2022 22:45

I have a feeling they are trying to waste their time(if cross still counts as AH team's time). A lot of useless nitpicking that is boring the jury

Today's cross counts as JD teams time.

Essentially, whoever is asking the question, direct or cross, it counts down on thier teams time. Including any objections.

Miscfeminista · 23/05/2022 22:45

I have a feeling they are trying to waste their time(if cross still counts as AH team's time). A lot of useless nitpicking that is boring the jury

minou123 · 23/05/2022 22:42

ENoeuf · 23/05/2022 22:37

@ObjectionHearsay I know I can't understand why they've left themselves in this position. Their witnesses were so dry and didn't add much recently. JD psychiatrist said nothing helpful.

I don't understand the strategy either.

The only thing I can think of is they think they have done enough, with all thier own witnesses, to prove JD claim should lose and thier counterclaim should win.
And they think they don't need any time to cross examine rebuttal witnesses as the rebuttal witnesses are going to be useless.

Maybe?

Boulshired · 23/05/2022 22:40

Forget all the op Ed’s, law suits they have both burned Disney and Warner Brothers. Made me laugh scripts are top secret but I share it with you and the thousands watching and the millions on social media.

ENoeuf · 23/05/2022 22:37

@ObjectionHearsay I know I can't understand why they've left themselves in this position. Their witnesses were so dry and didn't add much recently. JD psychiatrist said nothing helpful.

OP posts:
minou123 · 23/05/2022 22:37

mummyrocks1 · 23/05/2022 22:30

They should get the man to do more, he is much better.

Yep!

I mean it's comes to something when even the judge has to tell you what question to ask to avoid an objection.

ObjectionHearsay · 23/05/2022 22:36

ENoeuf · 23/05/2022 22:34

15 h 51m - Depps team
4h 09 m - Heard team

AH teams are in a dangerous position here, they may have to sit silently whilst JD's team spend 10+.comfortable hours at the end tearing everything apart.

ENoeuf · 23/05/2022 22:34

15 h 51m - Depps team
4h 09 m - Heard team

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread