Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Sozzler · 24/05/2022 10:13

Or maybe AH thought she could use JDs and KMs tumultuous relationship to her advantage and approached KM to try to get her to testify against JD. Perhaps there are communications that won't look good on AH. Just a theory, who knows, but I have a feeling there are a few more revelations yet to come in this trial.

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 09:56

That's a good point @StormzyinaTCup

OP posts:
StormzyinaTCup · 24/05/2022 09:27

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 09:11

Yes I saw all the excitement etc - I just can't see KM being the smoking gun in all this.
This thread is full of people questioning the relevance of witnesses - how AH sister isn't helpful etc it's not that weird I'm saying I can't see how JD team calling someone from 20 years ago is going to be shattering.

Maybe they have remained good friends? If so he may have spoken to her about 'things'.

Aspiringmatriarch · 24/05/2022 09:21

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 09:09

Elaine is AH counsel? So she needs to point out the time

Yes, especially if they are trying to argue that JD's behaviour may have worsened over time because of his chronic substance abuse.

Aspiringmatriarch · 24/05/2022 09:18

But what could Kate Moss say that's so massively damaging to Amber? We already know they had a somewhat volatile relationship with Johnny smashing up at least one hotel room. That doesn't mean he hit her (Kate) of course or was controlling, jealous, verbally abusive etc.

One could still argue that destroying property like that is abusive and intimidating in and of itself, so unless she's coming on the stand to say it was both of them having the time of their lives then that reflects badly on Johnny. And she will certainly be questioned about the incident.

She can absolutely debunk the rumour that Johnny pushed her down some stairs, but that doesn't alter the fact that Amber was aware of the rumour and that factored into the situation with Whitney, as she has testified.

She can say how lovely he was and that's obviously a positive for Johnny, but it doesn't cancel out Ellen Barkin's testimony or the fact that his jealousy has been mentioned by other witnesses. All she can really do is say what her experiences were, which as we know don't necessarily reflect how he may have behaved in other relationships.

You could argue that neither does Ellen Barkin's testimony say anything about other relationships or use Kate to discredit her as a 'woman scorned', but that will ultimately be up to the jury to determine. If it's a case of determining whether he had the capacity to be abusive, I would say that evidence from one partner (or two including Amber) is enough to suggest that he could be.

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 09:11

Yes I saw all the excitement etc - I just can't see KM being the smoking gun in all this.
This thread is full of people questioning the relevance of witnesses - how AH sister isn't helpful etc it's not that weird I'm saying I can't see how JD team calling someone from 20 years ago is going to be shattering.

OP posts:
KittyWithoutAName · 24/05/2022 09:11

I was shocked by the memory test he failed where they gave him three words to remember and five mins later he couldn’t remember any of them. The expert was saying that’s unusual for a man in his 50s. I guess drug use/drinking/addiction rots your brain?

Yeah, I suppose that's what it is meant to show. My DP is 30 and he wouldn't be able to pass that test, although that's because he has a brain injury from being smacked in the head one too many times. I don't think Johnny has that.

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 09:09

Elaine is AH counsel? So she needs to point out the time

OP posts:
TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 09:05

"It's 24 years ago, I just don't think it holds much weight for me. Elaine needs to make clear the passage of time"

Ellen Barkin??

Rinoachicken · 24/05/2022 09:00

I don’t see how you can object and say ‘not relevant - too long ago’ when it was relevant enough for your own client to talk about it on her testimony.

Rinoachicken · 24/05/2022 08:59

But if they call KM AFTER her team is out of time, Elaine won’t be able to do or ask anything!

And I’m not sure if they could object on the basis it was so long ago when it was
AH herself who dragged KM name into the trial in her testimony.

From what I understand, Depps team had wanted to call KM right from the beginning but we’re prevented from doing so for some reason (perhaps objections from the other side about relevance). So they couldn’t use her.

But as soon as AH named her in her testimony that meant Depps team COULD now call her, and they are. If you watched the trial you can see the excitement from JDs team as soon as KMs name left AH’s mouth. They were VERY excited. Which says to me that KM testimony is going to be VERY strongly in JDs favour and could be very damaging for AH.

I think she really fucked up when she mentioned KM and it may really come back to haunt her.

Boulshired · 24/05/2022 08:55

even knowing that the clock was ticking to ask an expert witness the significance of eating sweets and doddles as being traits of a narcissist. Why just why? It then gave Depp team right in front of the jury the chance to mock by eating a sweet, whilst the question was successfully objected to. Depps team have done a better job of splitting cross between the lawyers. I just can’t get my head around the time planning.

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 08:52

Not for you, but for the jury it might
Of course, just saying as a person watching it, and a layperson like the jury, stuff that's from over 20 years ago doesn't feel relevant either way.

OP posts:
Curlykimbo · 24/05/2022 08:37

Johnny and his lawyers looked extremely pleased when Amber slipped up mentioning Kate Moss. I think she could be very damaging indeed but let’s see.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 24/05/2022 08:36

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 08:27

It's 24 years ago, I just don't think it holds much weight for me. Elaine needs to make clear the passage of time.

Not for you, but for the jury it might

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 08:28

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 08:27

It's 24 years ago, I just don't think it holds much weight for me. Elaine needs to make clear the passage of time.

I also don't think the ex bottle lobbing story holds much weight for AH either.

OP posts:
ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 08:27

It's 24 years ago, I just don't think it holds much weight for me. Elaine needs to make clear the passage of time.

OP posts:
Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 24/05/2022 08:19

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 05:55

I dont think Kate Miss is going to do much damage tbh - she isn't at the height of fame and they have JD in front of them already for any star struck jury members. All she will do is say he never hit her and the stairs is a rumour I guess. And we know people can become abusive especially with the amount of damage he's done to himself with drugs etc since 1998. Elaine just has to ask if he was arrested for criminal damage while with her.

Well if her testimony is he never assaulted her whilst high, it will really damage AH claim that he's violent due to drink and drugs. KM can testify that he trashed a hotel room but if she says he never once touched her, the seeds of doubt will be planted in the jury's mind. With only 4 hours left, AH team are running out of time.

minou123 · 24/05/2022 07:43

JenniferAlisonPhilipaSue · 24/05/2022 07:34

there's only a few days left, can they get through all the witnesses in that time?

For AH team with 4 hours left, no.

But they don't have to use all thier witnesses on thier list.

JD team also have a huge list of witnesses, they have 15 hours left, so can strategically call more witnesses. But again we don't know how many or who.

Boulshired · 24/05/2022 07:38

I also think Depp team is playing mind games in rebuttal and may even be playing chicken with Heards team regarding the cross. If they could get McMillan or Kevin Murphy on the stand with no cross it could be awful for Heard but neither are mentioned in the source leak.

JenniferAlisonPhilipaSue · 24/05/2022 07:34

there's only a few days left, can they get through all the witnesses in that time?

minou123 · 24/05/2022 07:23

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 01:11

And how many witnesses does Amber have left?

There is a pre trial list of all witnesses for both AH and JD. As I understand it, you have to list everyone you could potentially call, but that doesn't mean you will use everyone on your list.

I won't list everyone on AH list that is on her witness list, but hasn't been called yet because this post would be huge 😁
But the key people (IMO) who she hasn't used yet from her list are:

Adir Abergel - Hairdresser
Julian Ackert - Data forensic expert (was the expert in the UK trial)
Benjamin Wizner - Civil Liberties expert
James Franco - Actor friend (ex boyfriend?)
Elon Musk -Business magnate. Friend (ex boyfriend?)
Tasya Van Ree - Photographer ex wife
Johnny Depp

These people are on her list, but as they only have 4 hours left, the definitely won't call everyone.
There is a lot of speculation if she will call JD as her witness tomorrow.

They may rest thier case tomorrow and not call anymore of thier witnesses. But they may call anyone from their list 🤷‍♀️

QuebecBagnet · 24/05/2022 07:07

I was shocked by the memory test he failed where they gave him three words to remember and five mins later he couldn’t remember any of them. The expert was saying that’s unusual for a man in his 50s. I guess drug use/drinking/addiction rots your brain?

Boulshired · 24/05/2022 07:00

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 01:11

And how many witnesses does Amber have left?

There are witnesses still left on her submitted list but other than I haven’t seen much her rumour or press releases are drowned out.

whilst looking, I didn’t know morgan tremaine was TMZ

Boulshired · 24/05/2022 06:46

I think they have both lost their cases for substantial damages, Depp can’t win money that Amber hasn’t got anyway. All of the rebuttal is going to do is feed the public with Depps versions of event. Ambers team is going to have to be extremely efficient with effective with 1 to 2 questions cross. It just doesn’t make sense to put yourself in this position

Swipe left for the next trending thread