Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 13:38

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:34

I clicked on streaming thought it started but they are just taping people standing in front. Like wtf even one woman with little boy under 5 standing in that gross weather, are people crazy. They are like hanging out giggling. God I feel so grossed out by the fandom. I was never a fan of anyone basically, can't remember in my life being like let's go there, I might see xyz 😩cringe

Well, well well.... we agree on something!

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:38

and they care if a woman is being hit but don't really care about a man

Maybe because people don't perceive a man being threatened by a slap from a woman, maybe because we all know it's men who murder women and other men in far bigger numbers than women do? Like I call bs on this one.

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 13:37

mummyrocks1 · 24/05/2022 13:24

Yes. I can see both sides. A very tricky decision for the jury. It's complicated with much of being she said/he said and contradictions.

If I was on the jury I would want more clarity on the photos AH produced. Were they doctored or not? I hope they revisit this. It's a huge deal.

There were many issues with the photos if you read that motion.
www.fairfaxcounty.gov/circuit/sites/circuit/files/assets/documents/pdf/high-profile/depp%20v%20heard/cl-2019-2911-plaintiff-mot-sanctions-3-22-2022.pdf

Amber's team have not been allowed to introduce any metadata because they didn't provide the evidence to Johnny's team as legally required for it to be verified.

The photo expert is on Johnny's rebuttal list.

I am not sure if this issue was yet fully resolved and if there are more motions related to it before it goes to the jury.

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:34

I clicked on streaming thought it started but they are just taping people standing in front. Like wtf even one woman with little boy under 5 standing in that gross weather, are people crazy. They are like hanging out giggling. God I feel so grossed out by the fandom. I was never a fan of anyone basically, can't remember in my life being like let's go there, I might see xyz 😩cringe

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 13:33

Some of these clips need to be remade with male / female voices switching roles. I really wonder if that was the case if people would be so quick to jump to supporting a male Amber as the imperfect victim if they heard a man saying what she is saying. Would they call the woman the abuser if they heard a woman saying what Johnny is saying. Would they hear these clips and think he was the one being abused if the voices were flipped? I think people are socially conditioned - they listen to this clip and can only imagine or hear Amber as the victim - no matter what she says or does. It would be an interesting study down the road. Play various clips to random people with the voices as they are and switched and see what the public's sociocultural perception is of males and females as abusers and victims. You would have to do it with people who had never heard of the case.

twitter.com/jacxpearl/status/1279723647192707073

There was an informal (?) study done where they had a couple walk through a park and sometimes the man hit the woman and sometimes the woman hit the man. Responses were completely different and those who saw it had a men can deserve to be hit but women can't, and its always wrong to hit a woman but not always wrong to hit a man, and they care if a woman is being hit but don't really care about a man / find it funny (weak), they stepped in when the woman was being hit but not the man...

mummyrocks1 · 24/05/2022 13:24

unctuousunicorns1 · 24/05/2022 12:58

"he can look much past today"

Oh, of course. I did wonder, before I saw the detail about the jelly babies, if he were munching sweeties to compensate, don't ex addicts do that sometimes? 🤔

I really am trying my very best to stay neutral whilst following all this, despite my extensive though not exhaustive collection of JD DVDs going back nearly thirty years. I don't envy the jury in this one bit.

Yes. I can see both sides. A very tricky decision for the jury. It's complicated with much of being she said/he said and contradictions.

If I was on the jury I would want more clarity on the photos AH produced. Were they doctored or not? I hope they revisit this. It's a huge deal.

Menora · 24/05/2022 13:14

Additionally yesterdays testimony about her career contradicts AH team saying he was stifling her career doesn’t it?

Menora · 24/05/2022 13:12

@mummyrocks1

it makes a lot of sense that these abandoning episodes triggered AH very badly, and to me it sounds like when she got triggered and hysterical, he became triggered to run away and withdraw. So they were never able to resolve any disputes at all in a healthy manner. I am not sure if the jury will pick up on this, that none of the audio or videos actually match with her testimony on this issue. I think she was too afraid to admit the abandonment triggers in court in case it was used against her, so she’s using drugs as the reasoning for her behaviour, which are well documented (and admitted by JD). I can accept she didn’t like JD on drugs, who would it sounds awful, but I don’t buy into that’s why she got upset when he was trying to leave

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 13:00

"Sources' say this is the list of possible rebuttal witnesses. Found on twitter.
twitter.com/GellertDepp/status/1528786046586068992

3 by deposition (Jennifer Howell, Candie Davidson-Goldbronn, Walter Hamada)

2 by live video link (Kate Moss, Lydia Filip)

11 live (Dr. Richard Shaw, Dr. Kimberley Collins, Ricahrd Marx, Mike Spindler, Doug Bania, Morgan Knight, Dr. David Kulber, Morgan Tremaine, Brian Neumeister, Dr. Shannon Curry, Johnny Depp)

I am surprised they aren't recalling Kevin Murphy to clarify a few details.

Amber's team has just over 4 hours left, Johnny's has just under 16.

unctuousunicorns1 · 24/05/2022 12:58

"he can look much past today"

Oh, of course. I did wonder, before I saw the detail about the jelly babies, if he were munching sweeties to compensate, don't ex addicts do that sometimes? 🤔

I really am trying my very best to stay neutral whilst following all this, despite my extensive though not exhaustive collection of JD DVDs going back nearly thirty years. I don't envy the jury in this one bit.

mummyrocks1 · 24/05/2022 12:56

Menora · 24/05/2022 12:52

I haven’t been active on here but I have followed the trial
what I struggled with was AH testimony that she was upset and anxious about JD using drugs and going on benders and that’s why she would get upset

yet every video or audio says nothing about drugs at all, barely a mention and nothing about benders. Just that he’s leaving her/the row and she’s upset he won’t stay with her to talk to her. Which fits with the diagnosis of BPD and abandonment.

I wonder if when they refer to splitting she is talking about him going on a bender after an argument. Although you're right it was not specifically said. She was pretty controlling too though. Getting upset when he spent too long with his friend Travis, upset when he wanted to go to a party and upset he wanted to spend time with his daughter. You could definitely say she wanted to isolate him or was worried about his time without her. She had bad dependency issues imo.

Menora · 24/05/2022 12:52

I haven’t been active on here but I have followed the trial
what I struggled with was AH testimony that she was upset and anxious about JD using drugs and going on benders and that’s why she would get upset

yet every video or audio says nothing about drugs at all, barely a mention and nothing about benders. Just that he’s leaving her/the row and she’s upset he won’t stay with her to talk to her. Which fits with the diagnosis of BPD and abandonment.

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 12:39

unctuousunicorns1 · 24/05/2022 12:35

One thing that made me roll my eyes was the notion of AH trying to get JD to see how bad his drug and drink problem had got. I mean, the woman was still in nappies when the world and his uncle knew that if he didn't sort himself out, he'd end up either, at best, a tragic, ageing, washed up, out of work, drunken junkie, or at worst, dead. But I guess you have to hit rock bottom before you can climb back up again. Has he kicked the demon d and d? I hadn't heard for definite? 🙁

I think he has said he is currently in recovery and sober. Not sure after almost 50 years of addiction, he can look much past today.

unctuousunicorns1 · 24/05/2022 12:35

One thing that made me roll my eyes was the notion of AH trying to get JD to see how bad his drug and drink problem had got. I mean, the woman was still in nappies when the world and his uncle knew that if he didn't sort himself out, he'd end up either, at best, a tragic, ageing, washed up, out of work, drunken junkie, or at worst, dead. But I guess you have to hit rock bottom before you can climb back up again. Has he kicked the demon d and d? I hadn't heard for definite? 🙁

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 12:25

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 12:21

What, if any, repercussions are there for sharing the plot of a not yet relased movie? Yesterday the 'expert' shared quite a few pieces of the plot as it relates to Amber's character in Aquaman 2. Would this be against the contract? The specific information shared was not central or important to the case itself.

AH didn't say it, so not her fault.

Doubt the studio could do anything. Don't think said expert witness is ever getting to see "top secret" scripts again though, but she's no longer an agent so I don't think it matters in the long term.

Studio will just be annoyed about the spoilers. But then Tom Holland is a catastrophe in a chair for marvel to the point other actors need to be with him for press conferences to step in 🤣 Tom is still Spiderman.

minou123 · 24/05/2022 12:24

adriftabroad · 24/05/2022 12:17

My Spanish DD (14) knows who KM is, as do her friends 😂

Fair enough 😁

I wasn't sure if she was still "on the scene" after 2000. There was a bit of a thing with Pete Docherty.

But after that the only thing I know of her is she retreated to the countryside and wore a lot of Burberry, so wasn't sure if she was still well known

Happy to be corrected.

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 12:21

What, if any, repercussions are there for sharing the plot of a not yet relased movie? Yesterday the 'expert' shared quite a few pieces of the plot as it relates to Amber's character in Aquaman 2. Would this be against the contract? The specific information shared was not central or important to the case itself.

adriftabroad · 24/05/2022 12:17

My Spanish DD (14) knows who KM is, as do her friends 😂

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 12:04

According to somenoe named Legal Bytes...

9 Jurors.

4 males mid20s-mid30s (3 asian and one caucasian who he says is Italian he lables these guys Jurors 1, 2, 3 and 7 based on their seats)

1 male in his mid 40s (asian) Juror 9

1 male in his 50-60s (caucasian) Juror 6

2 females in their mid 30s-40ish (one asian and one African-America/Indian) Jurors 4 and 5

1 female in her 50s (caucasian and catholic) Juror 8

I have no idea if this comes from observation or if he knows some of these details as facts.

Workwork21 · 24/05/2022 12:01

I'm 29 and know who moss is, mainly in relation to Pete Docherty.

minou123 · 24/05/2022 11:37

@ObjectionHearsay

😂ha ha ha
Yep me too, the thin look wasn't me in the 90s. I was once told I have "child bearing hips"

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 11:26

minou123 · 24/05/2022 11:23

Would that depend on the age of the person?

I'm an "oldie" at the grand old age of 40, so I know who Kate Moss is. 😁
But would someone 30 or under know who Kate Moss is? Would they know she was a a superstar supermodel?

I'm in my early 30's , closer to 30 than 35. I know who Kate Moss is, she was on every pre-teen and teen magazine of the 90's, as they pushed for the "supermodel look". 🤣 My arse was always too fat even at 10 to obtain such a look hahaha.

minou123 · 24/05/2022 11:23

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 10:54

KM will be damaging in my opinion not from a legal case wining perspective but a social one.

KM is a far more powerful woman than AH, with more "star presence". If she sits and basically says JD was never abusive to me, or AH's team have approached me trying to testify something I know not to be true. KM trump's AH, for the general lay person.

Personally I find it odd that the money you have in the bank and your celebrity power means what you say has more "weight" but the world is a celebrity obsessed funny place.

Would that depend on the age of the person?

I'm an "oldie" at the grand old age of 40, so I know who Kate Moss is. 😁
But would someone 30 or under know who Kate Moss is? Would they know she was a a superstar supermodel?

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 10:54

KM will be damaging in my opinion not from a legal case wining perspective but a social one.

KM is a far more powerful woman than AH, with more "star presence". If she sits and basically says JD was never abusive to me, or AH's team have approached me trying to testify something I know not to be true. KM trump's AH, for the general lay person.

Personally I find it odd that the money you have in the bank and your celebrity power means what you say has more "weight" but the world is a celebrity obsessed funny place.

FartSock5000 · 24/05/2022 10:48

Kate Moss lied to the police at the time. She initially said she was asleep in bed and didn't hear/see anything until they caught her out then she admitted to being in the centre of his tantrum.

This is detailed in news stories from back then so be interesting if Heards team bring it up.