Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:57

Well feminism is not haiku, it's not"describe what feminism means to you"and then bam that's legit feminism. It doesn't work that way. It's not a"pick which feminism suits you"and it's not"humanism". Women may call it different names but it always comes down to basic principles of having ALL women liberated from patriarchy, from bottom to top, otherwise it is not feminism. If feminists argued for"mutual abuse"theory we would never have women's shelters

Menora · 24/05/2022 14:49

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:44

You still don't get to say who should have kids or not.

Feminism centers women, not men. Feminism is not a movement that caters to mens feelings, me calling a man old is irrelevant.

That’s not what it means to me though

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 14:47

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:44

You still don't get to say who should have kids or not.

Feminism centers women, not men. Feminism is not a movement that caters to mens feelings, me calling a man old is irrelevant.

I don't control whether or not anyone has kids but I certainly can have an opinion as to various groups of people that I think shouldn't have kids. I do get to say my opinion - my opinion is not linked to the sexual activity of people in those groups and whether or not they reproduce.

LetitiaLeghorn · 24/05/2022 14:45

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:48

My point was, the man can defend himself. The woman in different situation might not be able to and just from experience everyone already expects a violent attack from men so that's why they would be concerned it might escalate. They see women as weaker, as in majority cases they are

I think this is such a short-sighted view. There are many men that suffer domestic abuse and violence in their home that never report it because they fear people will laugh at them or scorn them because they are being abused by a woman. They don't fight back because that's not their nature or they've learned not to fight back. You're basically backing up that view with the words that men can defend themselves,so we don't need to worry about that form of violence.

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:44

You still don't get to say who should have kids or not.

Feminism centers women, not men. Feminism is not a movement that caters to mens feelings, me calling a man old is irrelevant.

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 14:37

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:30

I think you are being pathetic with"I hope you don't have kids". What you read rang true so you ran to your privileged"I don't like you and am entitled to say whether you should reproduce or not". I hope you don't get much chance to repeat that to anyone. That is all I will say.

No. You misunderstood. It would be sad for both your sons and daughters to grow up with your view of men and women. Women are far more capable than you give them credit for and men are not immune to harm. Same as someone raising their sons to be incels or any other highly sexist and discriminatory view - I wish their parents didn't have kids either. Whenever parents hold sexist and discriminatory views that harm their daughters and sons - I would prefer there weren't children being raised with these harmful views.

Menora · 24/05/2022 14:35

It makes no sense that it’s ok to call men names due to their age but not women and that it causes no harm. Isn’t this toxic feminism I don’t think it’s what feminism is about. It’s not about putting men down to protect women it’s about ensuring women are not being discriminated against or treated differently or badly because they are a woman. This is why this whole argument about male DV victims is whack, if it’s based on the fact it happens more to women doesn’t mean it never happens to men

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:30

I think you are being pathetic with"I hope you don't have kids". What you read rang true so you ran to your privileged"I don't like you and am entitled to say whether you should reproduce or not". I hope you don't get much chance to repeat that to anyone. That is all I will say.

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 14:27

You are right. There is a wide global where women have few rights. However we have been talking about the context of the UK and the US.

I hope you don't have sons,...or daughters. That is all I will say.

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:22

Well imagine that, there is plenty of world out there other than English speaking western one where women have shelters. That is hugely disproportionate and not representative at all of women across world. Majority of women are still dependent on men this or that way and have little options. You don't need to go far either, plenty of it in"Western"places too(womens shelters are overcrowded so not sure why you mention it as problem solved. Once we don't need them anymore then I'll take it as a sign that things are good for women).

I would tell him to get away so I can see what is going on. At the end of the day that is what you do, you don't try to hit back-YOU LEAVE or stop the attack if you can in self defence. Women aren't able to overpower men in this way and often have to defend themself with counter attack. It is not the same so don't try to equate everything. If women became extraordinarily and on par with men in strenght then we'll talk about it in"equal terms", until then it's pointless.

Re Johnny old creepy man-he certainly is to me. He doesn't look like a vital middle aged man, he looks mid 60s. I don't call women old, I may call them older or mature because I know what negative connotations old brings to women. It does not hurt men who still have most power to call them old. Get over it.

Anyway I'm getting off topic rant over

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 14:21

Amber's team has rested their case and JD's team is now arguing their motion to dismiss.

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 14:12

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:01

RE hypothetical son situation. I would tell him to get away from her just as I would tell my daughter. But guess what women don't have that mercy from others, when they tell others they are being attacked or abused by their spouse they have to stay because most of the family doesn't want you back home once you are"married off"or people tell you to deal with it. We see a lot more adult men living with parents than we do women

That might be true in your community / culture but I have never ever heard that sentiment in my almost 50 years of life. There are tons of services, crisis lines, programs for women and there are many many families who support their loved ones and don't have a "you were married off" attitude - as I said, this is the first time I have ever even heard of that attitude towards women.

Why would you tell your son to get away from her if men can't be victims because they always have the power / priviledge?

adriftabroad · 24/05/2022 14:10

58 "a creepy old man"

You know your audience, I hope? We are mostly in our early 40s and early 50s, I imagine.

I think you mean " middle aged"

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 14:10

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 13:59

This is a fair point, and I am aware of the social experiment you are referring to.

Whilst a power imbalance is prevelant between men and women, and statistically more women are killed by men, than men killed by women. The fact remains it still does happen.

I do think that more discussion need to be had around female on male domestic abuse outside this circus. I also think social norms around women slapping or hitting men in arguments needs to re-framed.

If a woman stands up in a restaurant and slaps her male partner and storms out, there is little to no objection. However role reverse if a man stood up and slapped a woman, I can confidently say a ruckus would occur.

I'm the mother of a son, and if anyone behaved abusively towards him male or female I'd support him. Just because he is a male does not mean he can not be abused, belittled, assaulted and so forth.

I completely agree that this case is not the right forum. It has opened up online channels for men to share stories of their experiences of abuse - and get support rather than mocking and being dismissed. There is also a lot of support for Johnny from female victims / survivors and so I don't think it is as harmful to women as some people think. I think the younger generation is more open to an egalitarian view and most do accept that men can be victims. A couple times over the past year I have seen threads on a reddit site where people ask questions and men have shared their stories and it has been well received overall.

Once you start looking you also see all kinds of places in movies and TV where violence against men is trivialized, minimalized or made into a joke and this gets reinforced and normalized in people's minds as acceptable.

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 14:01

RE hypothetical son situation. I would tell him to get away from her just as I would tell my daughter. But guess what women don't have that mercy from others, when they tell others they are being attacked or abused by their spouse they have to stay because most of the family doesn't want you back home once you are"married off"or people tell you to deal with it. We see a lot more adult men living with parents than we do women

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 13:59

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 13:54

I am curious as to why you think men can always defend themselves. What if the woman comes up behind them? Knives? guns? psychological abuse? less strong and disabled men? very strong women? Social pressure to never fight back? fear of repercussions and legal action if they push or hold a woman off of them?

Would you call her abuser? Would you call your son a victim? Would you care and support him or her?

This is a fair point, and I am aware of the social experiment you are referring to.

Whilst a power imbalance is prevelant between men and women, and statistically more women are killed by men, than men killed by women. The fact remains it still does happen.

I do think that more discussion need to be had around female on male domestic abuse outside this circus. I also think social norms around women slapping or hitting men in arguments needs to re-framed.

If a woman stands up in a restaurant and slaps her male partner and storms out, there is little to no objection. However role reverse if a man stood up and slapped a woman, I can confidently say a ruckus would occur.

I'm the mother of a son, and if anyone behaved abusively towards him male or female I'd support him. Just because he is a male does not mean he can not be abused, belittled, assaulted and so forth.

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 13:58

Cantbelieveiusedtowatchthiscrap · 24/05/2022 13:55

@Miscfeminista Creepy old man 😬

Objection! Ageism! Sexism!

Cantbelieveiusedtowatchthiscrap · 24/05/2022 13:55

@Miscfeminista Creepy old man 😬

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 13:54

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:48

My point was, the man can defend himself. The woman in different situation might not be able to and just from experience everyone already expects a violent attack from men so that's why they would be concerned it might escalate. They see women as weaker, as in majority cases they are

I am curious as to why you think men can always defend themselves. What if the woman comes up behind them? Knives? guns? psychological abuse? less strong and disabled men? very strong women? Social pressure to never fight back? fear of repercussions and legal action if they push or hold a woman off of them?

Would you call her abuser? Would you call your son a victim? Would you care and support him or her?

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:51

Also it's a court proceeding on domestic violence allegations. Why would you come there

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:50

adriftabroad · 24/05/2022 13:48

err... they have a different attitude to life than you? If a 5 yr old wants to see JD (Jack Sparrow?) so what?

"grossed out", odd thing to say. You do you, let others do what makes them happy.

I really doubt a 5 year old would want to see him, he isn't wearing a bloody costume or looks like him. He looks like creepy old man that he is. And the kid didn't look like he was having fun he was moaning, as kids those age do

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:48

My point was, the man can defend himself. The woman in different situation might not be able to and just from experience everyone already expects a violent attack from men so that's why they would be concerned it might escalate. They see women as weaker, as in majority cases they are

adriftabroad · 24/05/2022 13:48

err... they have a different attitude to life than you? If a 5 yr old wants to see JD (Jack Sparrow?) so what?

"grossed out", odd thing to say. You do you, let others do what makes them happy.

Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 13:44

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:38

and they care if a woman is being hit but don't really care about a man

Maybe because people don't perceive a man being threatened by a slap from a woman, maybe because we all know it's men who murder women and other men in far bigger numbers than women do? Like I call bs on this one.

Is threat of death the only concern anyone should have?

Yes men kill each other and women far more often than women do. That isn't the totality of abuse nor abusive behaviour nor harm caused to others. There are many, many significant impacts of abuse and assault other than death.

If your son has a girlfriend who beat him with a frying pan, who kicked his balls repeatedly, who punched him in the face and called him names. Who spread rumours and lies to try to ruin him professionally, who demeaned him, taunted him, mocked him. Would you care or would you tell him well men kill more women than women kill men so I don't care. Would you think he probably has done something to deserve it. Would you continue to support his girlfriend as she must have a good reason to assault your son and he has more power so she is still the victim?

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 13:44

There's a woman dressed like poop standing there waiting for crying out loud

https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxL7MW05PpB4fjxOp2Thjd-vWMx3uPN_b1