Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Midlifemusings · 24/05/2022 21:49

What happened there. That made no sense at all.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 24/05/2022 21:49

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 21:40

He reviewed a lot-depositions, tapes, videos, texts, other drs notes. We have only seen a fraction of all of that, he actually sat down and looked at pile of stuff related to JD, took notes and made observations. It wasn't"just like that"and I think he hasn't done anything more unethical than the jury will imo

But he didn't speak to him. You cannot diagnose someone without actually speaking to them. He was completely unethical. I think it's great the doctor today has pointed that out and the exact reason why.

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:43

Eeeeee!!! Tea might burn

minou123 · 24/05/2022 21:42

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:40

I was finishing cooking tea. Who is this woman?

This is the long awaited, much anticipated Jennifer Howell.

She was Whitney (AH sister) old boss.

vegang · 24/05/2022 21:41

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:40

I was finishing cooking tea. Who is this woman?

Jennifer Howell, ex colleague and best friend of Whitney

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:40

I was finishing cooking tea. Who is this woman?

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 21:40

He reviewed a lot-depositions, tapes, videos, texts, other drs notes. We have only seen a fraction of all of that, he actually sat down and looked at pile of stuff related to JD, took notes and made observations. It wasn't"just like that"and I think he hasn't done anything more unethical than the jury will imo

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:36

I have C-PTSD. I believe she may have ptsd from her childhood but I'll bet my house she doesn't have it from JD.

minou123 · 24/05/2022 21:35

There, I understood right! Woo Hoo 😁

I'm getting the hang of this USA Civil Court malarkey

Although, I didn't know AH team filed the motion twice, to force JD to get a psychiatrist assessment

minou123 · 24/05/2022 21:26

KTheGrey · 24/05/2022 21:22

@minou123
I believe that AH has claimed PTSD as a consequence of suffering abuse at JD's hands. This opened the door for her psychiatric assessment. JD isn't claiming for PTSD - although I would bet he has had quite an amount of therapy since 2016.

Ahhh, that makes perfect sense.

I couldn't work it out; why the judge allowed the motion for AH to be assessed but not for JD.

Got it now, thank you

adriftabroad · 24/05/2022 21:24

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:20

Also Sméagol completely missed his own clients behaviour 😂

Ha! So true.

KTheGrey · 24/05/2022 21:22

@minou123
I believe that AH has claimed PTSD as a consequence of suffering abuse at JD's hands. This opened the door for her psychiatric assessment. JD isn't claiming for PTSD - although I would bet he has had quite an amount of therapy since 2016.

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:20

Also Sméagol completely missed his own clients behaviour 😂

Boulshired · 24/05/2022 21:20

According to those watching the jurors Dr speigel didn’t go down well anyway. Dr shaw probably only needs to say ignore Dr Speigel and everyone would nod and agree.

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 21:17

Oh sorry @KTheGrey I was trying to remember - it was a camp fire I was thinking of. Tricky as I'm also trying to show interest in Meeting Content 😂

OP posts:
ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 21:16

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 21:10

Why did they make the UK dr clarify that rule again when the other pysch yesterday said clearly he was making observations and giving his opinion, not diagnosis? What is the point? It can only mislead the jury, which seems to be main tactic of JDs team-misleading

He was not just "giving his opinion" he was clearly stating JD had NP traits, and that he had enough of them to warrant a diagnosis.

Dr Spiegel really did come across as the most unethical psychiatrist I have ever met. You can't sit and start spouting what traits people have in your professional opinion because of text messages, media appearances and playing the role of a pirate.

He also went on to basically say he diagnosis people all the time off notes!! I think that was more shocking to me! Genuinely the guy was a quack Dr.

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:15

From my experience my gut is telling me who the narc is. I can smell it through the screen.

KTheGrey · 24/05/2022 21:15

@ENoeuf
I think AH has testified to two very similar occurrences when JD threatened to break the wrists of young women who were getting touchy feely with her under the influence of MDMA. She said it happened with a friend at the Hicksville Trailer Park (friend not produced as witness afaik) and then with an air hostess on a flight to Russia. I believe the air hostess is listed as a rebuttal witness for later in the week.

vegang · 24/05/2022 21:13

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 21:10

Why did they make the UK dr clarify that rule again when the other pysch yesterday said clearly he was making observations and giving his opinion, not diagnosis? What is the point? It can only mislead the jury, which seems to be main tactic of JDs team-misleading

I guess because Dr Spiegel was there as an expert witness and giving his "professional opinion" which isn't allowed if they haven't examined them/got their permission

ObjectionHearsay · 24/05/2022 21:12

So this psychiatrist is spot on though on a serious note.

You can not diagnose someone without even meeting them or speaking to them. And these big personality disorders take many hours of assesments and time.

Narcissistic personality disorder is not just being a narcissist. It's completely different. Everyone is naturally a bit of a narcissist as much as we'd like to deny it, but we can all be selfish, dissmisive of others, jealous and so on. But NPD is seriously a different kettle of fish.

I have professionally supported one person who had NPD and believe me when I say they genuinely struggle to function in society. It's debilitating for the person.

The other disorder I have also had experience with is Grandiose delusions and that was an eye opener!!

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:12

Because misc AH doctor somewhat took the piss out of the ethical rules, cherry picking to suit AH. This doctor abides by all the rules. That's the difference

minou123 · 24/05/2022 21:12

ENoeuf · 24/05/2022 21:02

@minou123 oohhhhh that makes sense ok. Does that apply to JD doctor diagnosing AH or AH doctor diagnosing AH. Frustrating as I'm on camera and already look dodgy texting to one side 😂

Ha ha ha 😁

No, the other 2 forensics psychiatrist actually met and assessed AH.
The ethics rule is you cannot diagnose someone unless you have met them.

So as these other 2 doctors met AH, they are not violating ethics.
Whereas Dr Speigal never met JD, so should not be diagnosising or even giving a professional opinion about him.

I think, and I don't know for certain because they have only alluded to it in court, but....

Before the trial AH team presented a motion to demand JD meet and be assessed by psychiatrist doctor.
The judge said No.

However, JD team presented a motion demanding AH meet and be assessed by psychiatrist doctor.
The judge said Yes and AH had to attend the assessments with Dr Curry and Dr Hughes.

There may seem to be an imbalance and "unfairness" of why AH has been formally assessed, but JD hasn't. But that's what the judge ruled.

Miscfeminista · 24/05/2022 21:10

Why did they make the UK dr clarify that rule again when the other pysch yesterday said clearly he was making observations and giving his opinion, not diagnosis? What is the point? It can only mislead the jury, which seems to be main tactic of JDs team-misleading

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 24/05/2022 21:09

He's a fantastic witness! Speaks calmly, especially when compared to yesterdays dude. Also rips into yesterdays testimony.. that Dr may have screwed his own career!

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 21:09

Yeah well Bouls they are her witnesses. Tbf they sound ok until cross examination

Swipe left for the next trending thread