Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Boulshired · 25/05/2022 08:19

@Legrandsophie ignore the above I read it completely wrong. I mean blurred about what happened where and when

Boulshired · 25/05/2022 08:16

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 08:07

I’m not sure it is blurred. Everyone, other than AH’s friends and sister, have testified either that the abuse didn’t happen or that she hit him. And Whitney’s testimony has just been blown up.

So what evidence does she actually have apart from hearsay? The inference on the text messages is tricky because you can make it mean whatever you believe it to mean- just like all written text.

It’s the testimony of what happened in the trailer, and the damage it caused.

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 08:07

Boulshired · 25/05/2022 08:00

There has been so many testimonies that is has become so blurred. Seeing the Hicksville testimonies side by side, they are chalk and cheese of the trailer.

I’m not sure it is blurred. Everyone, other than AH’s friends and sister, have testified either that the abuse didn’t happen or that she hit him. And Whitney’s testimony has just been blown up.

So what evidence does she actually have apart from hearsay? The inference on the text messages is tricky because you can make it mean whatever you believe it to mean- just like all written text.

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 08:04

That will leave AH with only the Australia story as unverifiable. But in the light of all the other being shown to be direct lies and manipulations of the truth then I’m not sure the jury can believe her. How can we believe anything she’s said when she has been caught lying so many times now. The children’s hospital testimony was really damning because it turns out she donated much less than we though. I suspect the ACLU only got more because she needed them to bolster her story.

Boulshired · 25/05/2022 08:00

There has been so many testimonies that is has become so blurred. Seeing the Hicksville testimonies side by side, they are chalk and cheese of the trailer.

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 07:58

What I think we’ll here today:

  • meta data has been tampered with/ taken by devices not available at the time they were supposedly taken.
  • Kate Moss will clear up the staircase incident between her and JD (possibly share something she knows about his relationship with AH).
  • Flight Attendant testimony to totally discredit story about flight to Russia.
BonnesVacances · 25/05/2022 07:55

unctuousunicorns1 · 25/05/2022 07:23

" heavy substance abuse that's come out"

But there's nothing new about that; it's been well known for decades. You'd have to have been living on Mars not to be aware of it. 😐

I also thought it was well known that JD drank a lot, did drugs and messed up hotel rooms. I remember it from when he was with KM too and whilst I expected he'd calmed down a fair bit as he got older, I knew he still had issues.

I also knew that Tim Burton often had a job persuading some studios to work with him because of his reputation for turning up late and being unreliable on set. But I also knew that everyone who worked with him spoke very highly of him and that he turned out stellar work, so it was excused.

I'm not even a JD fan. I don't dislike him but he's not the reason I watch a film. I remember watching him in 21 Jump St and then him going out with KM and have always been aware of him as a Hollywood actor and all his issues.

TiddyTidTwo · 25/05/2022 07:47

Today is going to be very interesting, especially the metadata expert

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 07:28

The AH having no chemistry sounds possible, although I remember them saying they don't bow to pressure but the petition probably didn't help any decisions. I saw it with my kids and her character didn't really fit.

OP posts:
ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 07:27

I didn't previously think 'very heavy substance abuse' with black outs, taking it around his kids, constant use - I knew he liked to 'party' obviously but I didn't have him (if I ever actually thought about him) in the same category as other heavy, addicted, unpleasant types in my mind.

OP posts:
unctuousunicorns1 · 25/05/2022 07:23

" heavy substance abuse that's come out"

But there's nothing new about that; it's been well known for decades. You'd have to have been living on Mars not to be aware of it. 😐

JenniferAlisonPhilipaSue · 25/05/2022 07:13

but I don't think anything can be done about the UK trial verdict as JD was denied the right to appeal. who do you complain to, to get that right reinstated?

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 07:00

I'm going to listen with interest to closing arguments. I'm still having a hard time following the lies A is alleged to have made, although the photo 'in different light' is clearly the same one just with contrast adjusted. I think some of her evidence has been hard to believe in places - the bottle incident for example.
I'm not convinced J reputation is fully restored - that's balanced by the misogyny and very heavy substance abuse that's come out. Whether the social media fan base translates to new roles/continues will be interesting.

OP posts:
Boulshired · 25/05/2022 06:28

I’m holding off on my final opinion of the uk case until neumeister, if it turns out that none of the abuse images can be verified then I do think the uk trial is on dodgier grounds than before. Different expert witness for amber but the same company who dealt with the data for the sun. The UK trials evidence hasn’t held up and she has been caught in, to put it politely misleading and incorrect statements. It can’t be denied that her testimony in this trial would have effected the UKs judge opinion of her, who at the time found Amber and her friends credible.

LetitiaLeghorn · 25/05/2022 03:09

I actually found yesterday doc spot JD more accurately than dr Curry managed with AH

Of course you did. Because Dr Spiegel was telling you what you wanted to hear and Dr Curry was telling you things you didn't want to hear. You're now a committed Amber Heard supporter so you're never going to want to take anything on board that challenges that. It's very normal. A Depp supporter would be the same the other way round.
I wonder what the jury is thinking, though.

Miscfeminista · 25/05/2022 02:37

I just finished today’s trial. I saw the dr testifying for JD and since I read comments here first, I was left a bit underwhelmed. He did not prove that anything dr yesterday said could not apply. You can argue about that G-something rule on ethics but AH lawyer has said at the end short and simple that court permitted him to give his professional opinion and that one of the associations actually did find exception for the rule such as court setting/forensic psychology. I just found this very hair splitting and close to irrelevant-basically two docs that disagree on approach. Big deal. I would still take yesterdays doctor opinion into account despite not agreeing with all of it(neither am I bothered with diagnosis and specific names)it’s the characterisation he gave that didn’t seem off the mark and made sense after hearing whole trial so far. I’m just very bothered that some of his unintentional demeanour was taken as unprofessional because he didn’t say XYZ but X y.—-Z. I understand those fields are all about words and how you use them but he honestly pretty much didn’t commit any horror other than as said, today doc disagreeing with how he put things and generally disagreeing that he should have even testify without interviewing JD. I actually found yesterday doc spot JD more accurately than dr Curry managed with AH in all those hours(and yes, these are my worthless opinions but there you go)

Curlykimbo · 25/05/2022 02:01

twitter.com/Beatrix32021692/status/1529193418659966978?s=20&t=7E41mX-wUdHRYe1jS45uLQ

This is interested. I wonder who TMZ are trying to protect and why now?

TiddyTidTwo · 25/05/2022 01:49

"Thing I'm more interested is how do we move on from this as a society, what impact will all this have on discussions of domestic abuse and violence. Will it be positive or negative, will more male victims come forward, will women be believed less! I'm very worried about the latter"

Positive I think. More men will come forward. AH has, mostly imo, pissed women survivors off. Me one of them. I think in general, we can all see the bad egg.

TiddyTidTwo · 25/05/2022 01:42

'"No evidence' - she literally has enough evidence that a UK court ruled Depp was physically violent on 12 separate occasions. Whatever you might think about that, don't out and out lie and say she has no evidence. NO court is going to make that finding on 'no evidence'.

Her ex spoke out about the arrest in the clearest possible terms;"

My take is bizzare? The uk ruling seriously needs looking into. You cannot look at the live trail and say the closed UK trial with AH as a witness is now fair.

Also the arresting officer when AH attacked her partner was accused of homophobia even though that arresting officer was a lesbian and gay rights activist.

Also see my previous link to her ex Co star witnessing her behaviour, drug taking and trashed apartment years before meeting JD

I

ObjectionHearsay · 25/05/2022 01:00

AH isn't winning her counterclaim
JD isn't winning his defamation case

But what has happened is JD has regained credibility, support and reputation. Which is what he wanted. So he wins a personal victory.

Weather you agree he should or not, that's up to you that's anyone's choice to make and opinion to have, and I accept that.

AH however, now has reduced popularity, support and reputation.

Again weather you agree she should, or shouldn't I'll leave that, and respect everyone's personal opinion on it.

Thing I'm more interested is how do we move on from this as a society, what impact will all this have on discussions of domestic abuse and violence. Will it be positive or negative, will more male victims come forward, will women be believed less! I'm very worried about the latter.

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 00:39

@TiddyTidTwo Your whole approach to this is bizarre beyond belief. Who the fuck gets this excited about such a sordid and sad situation?

'No evidence' - she literally has enough evidence that a UK court ruled Depp was physically violent on 12 separate occasions. Whatever you might think about that, don't out and out lie and say she has no evidence. NO court is going to make that finding on 'no evidence'.

Her ex spoke out about the arrest in the clearest possible terms; meanwhile one of Depp’s exes actually testified against him in this trial, he's been arrested on multiple occasions for violent behaviour and is currently being sued for assaulting a crew member on the set of one of his films.

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 23:56

Let's be honest now. AH testimony, her witnesses and her lawyers are a bloody joke. It's embarrassing.

How did it get this far?

That's a rhetorical question btw

TiddyTidTwo · 24/05/2022 23:28

She's lying
She's a narcissist
She has previous history of abuse
He's a mess, drugs alcohol
So is she though
His previous partners all say the same. All supportive of him
She got arrested
She's disliked in Hollywood, ex Co stars (see my previous links) I can add more
WB - unbiased
No evidence she was abused
JD - hospital pictures of severed finger

A severed fucking finger? Plus a cigarette burn on his face?

A severed fucking finger? I'll say it again. That's HUGE. Plus audio of her admitting it to kipper as she'd took multiple illegal drugs that night too.

Boulshired · 24/05/2022 23:20

There have been reports of death threats on both sides. For Jennifer it was more than the break in. The collateral damage from the trial will last for some time. Expert witnesses have been dragged especially Ambers. Domestic violence has been made into a joke. I’ve always been abuse on both side but Ambers credibility means it’s hard to know what’s truth and what’s not. but there are many on both sides that they are so entrenched that a new video could come out and capture it all or a written confession and they still wouldn’t have it.

Sozzler · 24/05/2022 23:15

I actually think it is more likely that AHs team objected to most of the deposition but that JDs team thought it was still worth getting her to confirm the sratement is genuine as so many of the public have read it and know what is in it anyway.