Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
mummyrocks1 · 25/05/2022 12:05

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 11:51

Has no one listened to the Australia tape? It wasn’t allowed in court because there are more people on it (apparently they are only allowed the tapes that are just the two of them recorded for therapeutic reasons). In it she can be heard hysterically apologising for hurting him and saying that she didn’t mean it while his team try to find the part of his finger. It completely disproves her narrative of Australia.

Yes I have. It does seem that way. But the evidence his finger wasn't cut off by a glass bottle being thrown contradicts this evidence. It's a shame that audio tape can't be heard by the jury. Why would JD make up how he hurt his finger if it was AH? Maybe he was so out of it he doesn't remember properly. Could she have purposely trapped it in a door or something similar instead?

Miscfeminista · 25/05/2022 12:01

I think what comes out as pattern is Amber’s personality being criticised whenever there is a comparison of their acts or possible wrongdoings while Depp’s barely-most people took the stance similar in court where she is the accused one and has to defend herself; I think this greatly influenced people in assuming who’s guilty first. At this point a lot of opinions sound like Hicksville trailer guy.

Relentless comments about her being”unlikable”and”strange”-I thought I was being harsh in judging people(well prob still am)but I don’t remember thinking like this about some of the people similar to Amber back when I was at school or younger. She may be”Hollywood”but there’s a lot Ambers out there and I bet some like Hicksville guy or even dr Curry would be her friend in real life while she’s fun then when a Depp person would appear they’d suddenly see her”bad character”and ditch her when she’s not convenient and likeable anymore.

Even I got swayed and have to remind myself a lot that this all isn’t about what’s likeable or not about her character, at all

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 11:51

Has no one listened to the Australia tape? It wasn’t allowed in court because there are more people on it (apparently they are only allowed the tapes that are just the two of them recorded for therapeutic reasons). In it she can be heard hysterically apologising for hurting him and saying that she didn’t mean it while his team try to find the part of his finger. It completely disproves her narrative of Australia.

Menora · 25/05/2022 11:14

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 10:57

@Menora I think you've summarised a lot of what I think. She definitely in my min took on a relationship with someone very difficult to live with

I can see my younger self a little. No I didn’t deserve any abuse, no one does but I also made some terrible decisions for myself. No one forced me to do some of the things I did. I can blame trauma, my parents or my ex for things but I did do some of those things myself. And taking my own accountability for my own actions has helped me heal, and learn. You don’t go to therapy and sit and blame someone else the whole time and someone nods and says poor you. You have to face your own choices and actions and understand them. AH can’t do this in court because she’s clinging onto her career and finances. Rightly or wrongly JD is angry with her for not taking accountability, as he thinks he has taken some accountability in terms of his drug use. And here I am talking about going to the hotel to record him, the Op Ed and the divorce donation situation. Not the choice to stay with JD

Boulshired · 25/05/2022 11:12

The danger for me has always been the recalled memories of Australia, as it’s been mentioned before is past the realms of mutual abuse. This is not two people in a toxic relationship feeding off each other’s anger. This is a sadistic rapist (I count this as rape) or a sadistic liar. This will not be resolved in the trial and when the circus surrounding these claims calms down this will be remembered and both sides SM will abuse each other. Completely making a mockery of sexual assault victims.

TiddyTidTwo · 25/05/2022 11:09

"I could be 100% wrong. Obviously. I could be projecting massively, obviously. But I can almost smell it!"

I too could be wrong adrift but I completely agree.

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 10:57

@Menora I think you've summarised a lot of what I think. She definitely in my min took on a relationship with someone very difficult to live with

OP posts:
Menora · 25/05/2022 10:55

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 10:39

I also spotted AH a mile off, I said so in first thread. Agree 100% she has NPD. NPD is brutal and not just narcissm, it is a whole other level. I am in the process of divorcing myself and DD from it.

I'm so sorry you're going through that. I think a lot of people following this case are bringing their own experiences in; I guess we all do that to an extent. But to suggest that AH has narcissistic personality disorder when even Dr Curry didn't come up with that diagnosis says to me that you might be projecting. As I posted above, potentially she didn't actually meet the threshold for BPD either. But she certainly didn't have an NPD profile.

I actually think 'gut feelings' and this kind of anecdotal personal experience is something we need to be more careful about. Not in terms of keeping yourself safe but making big sweeping judgements about people.

I will start this by saying I do actually believe JD was at times violent to or around AH. I believe there was some mutual violence. I believe there were episodes of jealousy and drug use. I even believe he hurt her. I do not believe some sections of the story but overall I think she has a basis of truth and she has overlaid this with embellishments - either through fear or anxiety of ‘losing’ or she thought she wouldn’t be believed for what might have been to her, lower level violence. (All violence is wrong IMO).

But there is something about AH’s mannerisms that make me feel uneasy and uncomfortable. I have no formal qualifications on this matter. I find it hard to reconcile how different she is from still photos where she looks poised and calm, or acting, to when I have seen her in promo interviews for her work before the divorce and her divorce deposition videos where comes across as rude, impatient, manic, angry and agitated.

Once on the stand in this trial she is again completely different, flipping through what appears to be fake crying, laughing at the Hicksville guy, remembering things she says she forgot in intense detail and just a wild range of emotions she is either struggling to control or is acting. I am not sure. I would not be friends with this woman. I don’t think she’s reliable or likeable. I do believe she treated her sister badly who was vulnerable.

I have felt sorry for her because I think she has classic signs and behaviours of intense abandonment issues and got with a guy she fell in love with who was an absolute mess. She did not know how to deal with what was happening and dealt with many things badly. I don’t think she can admit to these things herself because it will make her look bad, so JD (and fans) are picking her apart. Her career will never recover I don’t think, even if she wins this trial.

this trial has divided the world, literally. We can’t discount that males suffer violence based on this trial though. Sometimes in life it isn’t black and white with a winner and loser. They are both losers in their own way which is sad

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 10:49

Making a cuury for DD tonight and settling down for the afternoon!

That sounds great. Wishing you and DD all the best with it all. 😊

adriftabroad · 25/05/2022 10:46

Thank you aspiring, as I said, I could be projecting massively, but the more I watch, the more I think I am not. NPD is so rare. But I would be as bad as the ridiculous phychiatrist if I gave a prognosis over the internet, obviously!

I personally cannot wait for KM. I think it will be good.

Making a cuury for DD tonight and settling down for the afternoon!

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 10:39

I also spotted AH a mile off, I said so in first thread. Agree 100% she has NPD. NPD is brutal and not just narcissm, it is a whole other level. I am in the process of divorcing myself and DD from it.

I'm so sorry you're going through that. I think a lot of people following this case are bringing their own experiences in; I guess we all do that to an extent. But to suggest that AH has narcissistic personality disorder when even Dr Curry didn't come up with that diagnosis says to me that you might be projecting. As I posted above, potentially she didn't actually meet the threshold for BPD either. But she certainly didn't have an NPD profile.

I actually think 'gut feelings' and this kind of anecdotal personal experience is something we need to be more careful about. Not in terms of keeping yourself safe but making big sweeping judgements about people.

Menora · 25/05/2022 10:39

AH appears to have a hard time letting this relationship go emotionally than JD in some ways. She has referred to him multiple times as her soulmate and used the present tense of loving him over and over. I am unsure whether she genuinely still has feelings for him of some kind or whether she’s playing mind games with him, or to appeal to what they once had.

He comes across as wanting to escape her clutches and intense dislike for her, yet has spent the past few years all consumed by everything Amber and sitting in a courtroom with her for weeks on end.

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 10:33

Grin I scheduled so I'm busy in the morning than clear enough to 'listen to the radio' from 3 Grin

OP posts:
minou123 · 25/05/2022 10:32

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 10:12

So basically the jury have to decide if A was making up the op-ed content (we know it's been agreed it refers to JD) and if she did , then did it impact his earning. If she didn't, the impact doesn't matter because truth is a defense.
I don't think A has a chance of winning her claim, which was £££ plus immunity from his accusations. I guess in case she says anything else in the future?

The jury instructions, I think, will be really interesting.

They have been submitting, to the judge, what they want to be included in the jury instructions, so it'll be interesting to hear what the judge tells them.

Between this and the Sue Grey report due to be released, I'm not sure how I'm going to get any work done today.

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 10:27

Boulshired · 25/05/2022 10:11

Other than Dr Shaw the psychologist in my opinion have all in some ways let their profession down, from Dr Speigel no explanation needed, Dr hughes with her gender bias and dr curry where I do think it’s was over the top to actually diagnose on such a short time.

With you on that I think

OP posts:
adriftabroad · 25/05/2022 10:25

*I mean I have always parented alone, he moved out when DD was 2, but sort of played happy families when it suited him. He did not want a divorce. He wanted control.

I do not think AH wanted a divorce.

adriftabroad · 25/05/2022 10:21

@Boulshired I completely agree with your opinion.

Especially your concerns of how it affects DV in the future, for women. Although @TiddyTidTwo is correct, it has certainly raised the fact that male DV by women is a real thing. More than we realise.

I also spotted AH a mile off, I said so in first thread. Agree 100% she has NPD. NPD is brutal and not just narcissm, it is a whole other level. I am in the process of divorcing myself and DD from it. It has made me physically ill. I am giving up $$$s to simply be rid. I will have nothing to fall back on. It has taken me 18 years to do this and realise this and parent alone. I am not in my own country and this has made it very easy to be exploited.

A key part of NPD is defaming your partners reputation to absolutely everybody. It is isolation. But totally believing your lies. I think Elaine has clocked this.

I just hope the truth of the matter comes out. I just think AH has NPD. I really do. JD was abused. I do not care for either of them particularly. JD seems to have empathy. AH is prepared to exploit everybody, including her DSis. (I also agree with a PP that he is protecting Whitney)

I could be 100% wrong. Obviously. I could be projecting massively, obviously. But I can almost smell it!

@Legrandsophie I think you have it right on the outcome today.

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 10:12

So basically the jury have to decide if A was making up the op-ed content (we know it's been agreed it refers to JD) and if she did , then did it impact his earning. If she didn't, the impact doesn't matter because truth is a defense.
I don't think A has a chance of winning her claim, which was £££ plus immunity from his accusations. I guess in case she says anything else in the future?

OP posts:
Boulshired · 25/05/2022 10:11

Other than Dr Shaw the psychologist in my opinion have all in some ways let their profession down, from Dr Speigel no explanation needed, Dr hughes with her gender bias and dr curry where I do think it’s was over the top to actually diagnose on such a short time.

ObjectionHearsay · 25/05/2022 10:03

Miscfeminista · 25/05/2022 02:37

I just finished today’s trial. I saw the dr testifying for JD and since I read comments here first, I was left a bit underwhelmed. He did not prove that anything dr yesterday said could not apply. You can argue about that G-something rule on ethics but AH lawyer has said at the end short and simple that court permitted him to give his professional opinion and that one of the associations actually did find exception for the rule such as court setting/forensic psychology. I just found this very hair splitting and close to irrelevant-basically two docs that disagree on approach. Big deal. I would still take yesterdays doctor opinion into account despite not agreeing with all of it(neither am I bothered with diagnosis and specific names)it’s the characterisation he gave that didn’t seem off the mark and made sense after hearing whole trial so far. I’m just very bothered that some of his unintentional demeanour was taken as unprofessional because he didn’t say XYZ but X y.—-Z. I understand those fields are all about words and how you use them but he honestly pretty much didn’t commit any horror other than as said, today doc disagreeing with how he put things and generally disagreeing that he should have even testify without interviewing JD. I actually found yesterday doc spot JD more accurately than dr Curry managed with AH in all those hours(and yes, these are my worthless opinions but there you go)

I have to completely disagree with you. Other points you have raised I have agreed with, but if we were on the jury I'd wholeheartedly disagree with you here on Dr Spiegel.

Dr Spiegel is not a forensic psychologist, he is a psychiatrist. He was not court ordered to make an assesment. He acted unethically and outside the remit of his medical capabilities.

His testimony is completely irrelevant to the case. His opinions unfounded and his observations completely irrelevant.

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 09:57

Menora · 25/05/2022 09:38

You cannot compare Dr Curry to Dr Speigal! Dr Curry actually used psychiatric evaluation tools to assess amber to come to a diagnostic conclusion. Dr Clown watched him on Graham Norton 🤦🏻‍♀️

This is an interesting video which suggests that the scores Amber was given did not meet the threshold for the diagnosis that Dr Curry made. I think Dr Curry played well with the public (and possibly the jury); she's attractive and articulate, but Dr Hughes was actually more qualified as well as being an actual DV expert.

Dr Spiegel was really interesting but obviously there's a question mark over whether he should have been discussing Depp’s mental health in the first place. I don't have an opinion either way on that but his cross-examination definitely didn't go well.

Boulshired · 25/05/2022 09:45

I think this case will be determined by whether the jury judge each case separately on its merits or if they pick a winner. In so much as who they believe the most will be rewarded. As I’ve said before for Depp this has been about the court of public opinion. I think Depp has done enough to quash or limit damages to the counterclaim.

Menora · 25/05/2022 09:38

You cannot compare Dr Curry to Dr Speigal! Dr Curry actually used psychiatric evaluation tools to assess amber to come to a diagnostic conclusion. Dr Clown watched him on Graham Norton 🤦🏻‍♀️

mummyrocks1 · 25/05/2022 09:27

*I’m not sure it is blurred. Everyone, other than AH’s friends and sister, have testified either that the abuse didn’t happen or that she hit him. And Whitney’s testimony has just been blown up.

So what evidence does she actually have apart from hearsay? The inference on the text messages is tricky because you can make it mean whatever you believe it to mean- just like all written text.*

She has photos- although I will be very interested to see what the experts opinions are on them. Imo the jury is out on that.

She has a make up artist and JDs friend who saw bruises. She has a hairdresser who saw chunks out her scalp. She has text messages and emails she has sent claiming abuse over a prolonged period of time. one where JDs assistant says JD kicked her and an audio where JD says he head butted her- accident or not is to be decided! I can't remember ever accidentally head butting someone even in an argument though.

She has medical notes from a couple therapist reporting abuse and from her doctor saying she has a bloody lip and a bruise under the eye. She has Clear evidence that suggests JD does have blackouts and periods of time when under the influence that he doesn't remember and becomes a monster.

She has an expert saying that JDs finger was not cut off by her throwing a bottle. Which if they believe this put him as a liar too and the jury could discount lots of his testimony too.

She has audiotapes where he is at least verbally abusive and intimidating behaviour. As does he though.

I think the experts opinion on the photos will be make or break for her.

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 09:18

Yes, absolutely agree @Boulshired

I suspect the whole pint of AH’s testimony was to muddy the waters and put in doubts about the evidence he had presented about her. It all felt really reactionary, especially Whitney dropping in that bit about him controlling her devices as the reason she didn’t take pictures. Also very convenient that she couldn’t produce her phone or messages from the time period either.