Although I believe AH to be the abuser in this relationship (based on the credibility of witness testimony and evidence presented in this case), I do agree with other posters in terms of feeling sorry for AH. I know it is a contested topic, but she has been diagnosed by one professional as having BPD and HPD (which actually has some similarities to NPD), and so I think it is important to remember that whilst many people with PDs won't manifest their symptoms to this extreme, some do, and actually these are medically recognised conditions and not something people choose to have. I think she also evidently has a history of childhood trauma which can impact different people in different ways as they grow up.
Personally, I believe JD when he says he has never hit a woman. That is not to say he hasn't responded badly to her abuse or hurt her accidently during physical altercations, but there have never been any reports of him physically assaulting previous partners, even when those relationships have been tumultuous and involved drug use. He was with the mother of his kids for years and she has spoken out in support of him. I really think if he was someone who had the potential to physically abuse women, his mask would have slipped by now. I also don't think it is fair to point to incidents where he has allegedly assaulted men; lots of men would do this to another man, but would never hit a woman. His substance abuse also does not mean he is a domestic abuser and can also make him more vulnerable to being a DA victim, whilst spiralling substance misuse issues can be a response to abuse, so I think this framing of him as a likely DA perpetrator because of his substance abuse is wrong
I think it is really sad that this case has been so public (even though it has been interesting to watch) and I never like to see someone getting as much hate as AH has been, regardless of what they have done. Although, I guess by publicly accusing JD of these things, she left him no choice. I hope, if AH has done these things, she gets some help and the media and JD's fans leave her in peace.