Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Part 4 AIBU to keep this discussion on Amber and Jonny going?

988 replies

ENoeuf · 22/05/2022 18:39

Just in case we run out on part 3

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Menora · 25/05/2022 14:33

IrisVersicolor · 25/05/2022 14:24

NPD is thrown around on MN like smarties. Primarily because posters don’t understand that PDs are serious mental health diagnoses, and that being selfish, self-centred narcissistic traits does not equal NPD.

‘Gut feelings’ about people you have never met are nothing more than a attempt to validate opinion/prejudice.

Or it’s just a laypersons opinion, thoughts and feelings which are influenced by many different factors
no one on here is professing to be an expert

unctuousunicorns1 · 25/05/2022 14:32

By God, assuming this is genuine, then it's pretty damning. If they are the words of a woman who is covered in painful glass cuts and slashes, and has been repeatedly raped with a bottle only a few hours ago, then I'm Joan of Arc. You can throw all the "you don't know how a victim would react/behave" at me, I just don't buy it. We also have to assume that she is surrounded pyschopaths whose only concern is for JD and so are ignoring her piteous state. That doesn't seem likely either.

I feel very sorry for her as I really think she is very ill. In fact I feel for both AH and JD, like pp have said there will be no winners in all this sorry affair, only losers. They both seem to be messed up, dysfunctional individuals from fucked up backgrounds. And I really hope I'm wrong, but I fear that whatever the outcome of the trial, there's a real risk that one (or both) may end up dead as a result. I hope I'm not being dramatic saying that.

TempName01 · 25/05/2022 14:30

Wow Kate Moss was awesome 😄

IrisVersicolor · 25/05/2022 14:24

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 10:39

I also spotted AH a mile off, I said so in first thread. Agree 100% she has NPD. NPD is brutal and not just narcissm, it is a whole other level. I am in the process of divorcing myself and DD from it.

I'm so sorry you're going through that. I think a lot of people following this case are bringing their own experiences in; I guess we all do that to an extent. But to suggest that AH has narcissistic personality disorder when even Dr Curry didn't come up with that diagnosis says to me that you might be projecting. As I posted above, potentially she didn't actually meet the threshold for BPD either. But she certainly didn't have an NPD profile.

I actually think 'gut feelings' and this kind of anecdotal personal experience is something we need to be more careful about. Not in terms of keeping yourself safe but making big sweeping judgements about people.

NPD is thrown around on MN like smarties. Primarily because posters don’t understand that PDs are serious mental health diagnoses, and that being selfish, self-centred narcissistic traits does not equal NPD.

‘Gut feelings’ about people you have never met are nothing more than a attempt to validate opinion/prejudice.

Menora · 25/05/2022 14:22

Miscfeminista · 25/05/2022 14:18

And AH's team is not that bad at all, they have good comebacks and generally, there's little they could do that I would consider worse than Camille style of cross. They come with good arguments(obviously that's biased since I find AH story making sense)and JDs team had to work a lot harder and go in circles only to try make her witnesses say"well yes it may be so or it may be so in this hypothetical situation". They also had to go for repetition a lot to be convincing to jury I suppose. Overall I found JDs testimonies a bit dull

The only thing I don’t like about her team is that Elaine doesn’t really seem to understand twitter or social media and she can really panic and shout out in court a lot

Miscfeminista · 25/05/2022 14:22

Ok I'm a bit shocked with Kate Moss voice, I don't think I ever heard her before. Had no idea she's from UK either

ObjectionHearsay · 25/05/2022 14:22

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 13:58

Where does she say "I didn't do it on purpose"? Do you have a timestamp?
And the bit about xanax, adderall and hallucinogens? Thanks.

10:31. amber: I never meant to hurt him
10:32 amber: I didn't do it on purpose

ENoeuf · 25/05/2022 14:21

The Australia tapes sound like JD team trying to get her out the way as they are bad for each other. It's clear where their loyalty lies, and clear they think they are both trouble. They are trying to get shot of her so they can fix his finger. I don't think it's an admission of guilt re the finger but it also doesn't support the rape story. However twice there is reference to her getting support/medication fixed. (Not sedatives).
I think they aren't clear and are mainly people who weren't there piecing it's together and trying to get them apart.

OP posts:
Menora · 25/05/2022 14:20

the entertainment expert who testified for AH said his career started a downward spiral in 2010. this was the timeframe of the split with Vanessa and getting with Amber.

I could not understand the reasoning that AH career was going up the same time JD was tanking yet her team say he was holding back her career opportunities because he was jealous. His was tanking because of his addictions and yet hers was better than ever I can see why he would have probably hated it. Chicken and egg did his addictions cause both the career and relationship issues or did the relationship issues contribute to his addictions and career free fall.

Miscfeminista · 25/05/2022 14:18

And AH's team is not that bad at all, they have good comebacks and generally, there's little they could do that I would consider worse than Camille style of cross. They come with good arguments(obviously that's biased since I find AH story making sense)and JDs team had to work a lot harder and go in circles only to try make her witnesses say"well yes it may be so or it may be so in this hypothetical situation". They also had to go for repetition a lot to be convincing to jury I suppose. Overall I found JDs testimonies a bit dull

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 14:11

Jerry Judge sounds both exhausted and really worried. He says to who ever he is talking to on the phone that he has never seen Johnny this hurt. He is also adamant that he thinks that Amber caused most of the damaged.

I think it is also pretty clear that the end that she set up this recording so she could listen to what they were saying about her.

Menora · 25/05/2022 14:09

Kipper sounds really angry and pissed off

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 14:09

Then 10.30 for her returning to the conversation to say that she loves him and didn’t mean to hurt him. That’s the point where she says that she didn’t do it on purpose.

She also sounds totally trashed- slurring, sobbing and stomping about. It is worth listening to the whole thing because it is fairly obvious that Dr.Kipper knows that she did it- as though she admitted it to him before the recording started.

Menora · 25/05/2022 14:08

After the drug thing she starts going back into panicking about how she will get him back now he ‘hates her’
this is the push pull they were in
all she’s seemingly worrying about really is losing him, not actually worried about him

Menora · 25/05/2022 14:06

@Aspiringmatriarch
when I heard this it was so faint, you have to turn up the volume

she says I didn’t mean to at about 4 mins in
then at 8 mins she’s crying a lot
10 mins she says it’s all her fault and she didn’t do it on purpose
11 mins saying sorry I love him
16 mins Jerry Judge says she threw the first punch and bottle

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 14:03

It’s 30 mins 40 seconds for the drugs.

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 13:58

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 13:11

Here’s the Australia audio. She says ‘I didn’t do it on purpose’ and ‘I’m so sorry’ a few times while Dr.Kipper and Debbie are looking for the finger tip. They also discuss getting him out of there and away from her. The implication is that she is having a psychotic episode.

It completely blows apart her story of what happened in Australia.

Where does she say "I didn't do it on purpose"? Do you have a timestamp?
And the bit about xanax, adderall and hallucinogens? Thanks.

Menora · 25/05/2022 13:53

Miscfeminista · 25/05/2022 12:01

I think what comes out as pattern is Amber’s personality being criticised whenever there is a comparison of their acts or possible wrongdoings while Depp’s barely-most people took the stance similar in court where she is the accused one and has to defend herself; I think this greatly influenced people in assuming who’s guilty first. At this point a lot of opinions sound like Hicksville trailer guy.

Relentless comments about her being”unlikable”and”strange”-I thought I was being harsh in judging people(well prob still am)but I don’t remember thinking like this about some of the people similar to Amber back when I was at school or younger. She may be”Hollywood”but there’s a lot Ambers out there and I bet some like Hicksville guy or even dr Curry would be her friend in real life while she’s fun then when a Depp person would appear they’d suddenly see her”bad character”and ditch her when she’s not convenient and likeable anymore.

Even I got swayed and have to remind myself a lot that this all isn’t about what’s likeable or not about her character, at all

I didn’t like those types of people in school either.

I think it’s definitely a mental struggle to believe what someone is saying when you do not like them and why I am not a psychologist or a police officer etc. Humans find it so hard to be objective and even professionals let their own opinions and bias creep in. Trust me when I say I wish I did like her (for my own sake not hers) and I’ve tried hard to look outside of my own bias as to why. I didn’t follow the U.K. trial at the time (have read it since) and I was more neutral yet curious about her at the start of this trial. I didn’t really understand why so many people didn’t like her until I saw her depositions, interview and testimony.

Aside of what she is saying, it’s her mannerisms expressions and the elaborate story telling I don’t like about her. I don’t actually blame her for over inflating her loss of earnings to $100mil, I mean if you were being sued for 50 you would probably clap back too. you would also want your friends to defend you, even though few of them ever saw anything

I do not have a CLUE why she did that op Ed after signing an agreement with JD in the divorce, that happened to coincide with Aquaman and I don’t know why she’s lied about her charitable donation pledges either. The little elaborations have now become huge and have come back to bite her. I just don’t know what to think about the Australian incident at all

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 13:37

Jerry Judge seems to think that she is up to something on that audio. He says (and obviously this is not under oath which is why it wasn’t allowed) that she admits to thrown bottles at Depp and punching him first.

She then openly admits toward the end to taking Xanax, adderall, hallucinogens and other stuff on tops of her anti- psychotic meds. Jerry Judge seems to think that she’s on coke as well. There goes her pretence of not doing drugs.

If the tape is true then she is a fucking psycho liar. Who makes up a horrific rape?

Legrandsophie · 25/05/2022 13:11

Here’s the Australia audio. She says ‘I didn’t do it on purpose’ and ‘I’m so sorry’ a few times while Dr.Kipper and Debbie are looking for the finger tip. They also discuss getting him out of there and away from her. The implication is that she is having a psychotic episode.

It completely blows apart her story of what happened in Australia.

mummyrocks1 · 25/05/2022 12:34

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 12:21

Yes I have. It does seem that way. But the evidence his finger wasn't cut off by a glass bottle being thrown contradicts this evidence. It's a shame that audio tape can't be heard by the jury. Why would JD make up how he hurt his finger if it was AH? Maybe he was so out of it he doesn't remember properly. Could she have purposely trapped it in a door or something similar instead?

Does anyone have a link to that audio? I keep hearing that she apologises for hurting him and unless there's something wrong with my hearing (possible), I don't get that from listening. Is there a different audio being referred to, or a clearer one? Because I hear her saying sorry but nothing about hurting him. It's quite indistinct at that point though.
If it's the video I'm thinking of, I question some of the subtitles are in the bits which are hard to make out. They seem a bit 'creative licence' to me. Also if we're talking about the same audio, nobody seems to be suggesting in it that she has taken responsibility for the finger - unless I'm missing something?

Yes you are correct. She says I am sorry repeatedly but no reference is made to the finger. So I guess it is an assumption she is saying sorry for the finger but it could have been something else. I think Dr Kipper implied she did it but obviously that's not fact.

I was also interested in the fact that no one refers to her injuries and she is not treated. This is the main point for me. Given the assault she is describing she 100% would have at least some visible injuries but instead they medicate her and send her to bed.

Aspiringmatriarch · 25/05/2022 12:21

Yes I have. It does seem that way. But the evidence his finger wasn't cut off by a glass bottle being thrown contradicts this evidence. It's a shame that audio tape can't be heard by the jury. Why would JD make up how he hurt his finger if it was AH? Maybe he was so out of it he doesn't remember properly. Could she have purposely trapped it in a door or something similar instead?

Does anyone have a link to that audio? I keep hearing that she apologises for hurting him and unless there's something wrong with my hearing (possible), I don't get that from listening. Is there a different audio being referred to, or a clearer one? Because I hear her saying sorry but nothing about hurting him. It's quite indistinct at that point though.
If it's the video I'm thinking of, I question some of the subtitles are in the bits which are hard to make out. They seem a bit 'creative licence' to me. Also if we're talking about the same audio, nobody seems to be suggesting in it that she has taken responsibility for the finger - unless I'm missing something?

Boulshired · 25/05/2022 12:17

i listened to the Hicksville incident which is the other sexual assault, it was here that the spoke about not taking coke and being against it. If Rocky Pennington is to be believed then this is not true. It’s these details that actually weren’t needed in the details of the event, she wasn’t asked. But as a juror if a believe the coke is a lie then why should I believe the rest. Why did neither side get the records and statements from those at Hicksville who were third party.

TiddyTidTwo · 25/05/2022 12:13

Very interesting that TMZ are trying to block their journalist who obtained the video being called as a JD witness. I hope the judge allows this testimony as copyright for the video can only be signed over by the owner (AH) and under oath, she denied supplying it.

Sozzler · 25/05/2022 12:12

Although I believe AH to be the abuser in this relationship (based on the credibility of witness testimony and evidence presented in this case), I do agree with other posters in terms of feeling sorry for AH. I know it is a contested topic, but she has been diagnosed by one professional as having BPD and HPD (which actually has some similarities to NPD), and so I think it is important to remember that whilst many people with PDs won't manifest their symptoms to this extreme, some do, and actually these are medically recognised conditions and not something people choose to have. I think she also evidently has a history of childhood trauma which can impact different people in different ways as they grow up.

Personally, I believe JD when he says he has never hit a woman. That is not to say he hasn't responded badly to her abuse or hurt her accidently during physical altercations, but there have never been any reports of him physically assaulting previous partners, even when those relationships have been tumultuous and involved drug use. He was with the mother of his kids for years and she has spoken out in support of him. I really think if he was someone who had the potential to physically abuse women, his mask would have slipped by now. I also don't think it is fair to point to incidents where he has allegedly assaulted men; lots of men would do this to another man, but would never hit a woman. His substance abuse also does not mean he is a domestic abuser and can also make him more vulnerable to being a DA victim, whilst spiralling substance misuse issues can be a response to abuse, so I think this framing of him as a likely DA perpetrator because of his substance abuse is wrong

I think it is really sad that this case has been so public (even though it has been interesting to watch) and I never like to see someone getting as much hate as AH has been, regardless of what they have done. Although, I guess by publicly accusing JD of these things, she left him no choice. I hope, if AH has done these things, she gets some help and the media and JD's fans leave her in peace.