Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH doesn't want me to mention DS "dad"

136 replies

babyneversleeps · 22/05/2022 13:32

DS is 5 now and I have always told him he has another dad and sometimes I will mention it to see how he feels. Today he told me he would like to meet him when he's a bit older.

DH over heard it and became upset and said that I'm not his feelings into account and why do I keep mentioning it when his "sperm donor" doesn't even care about him. Which is probably true!

He has met him twice when he was a baby and that was it he stopped bothering once he realised he couldn't just sleep with me anymore and then I met DH when DS was 7 months old.

AIBU? should I never mention it again. I kind of think DH needs to put his feelings to a side as it's not about him and I want to be open with DS as much as possible.

OP posts:
Lavenderlast · 22/05/2022 16:08

If you tell a 5 yr old about something, the 5yr old is going to get very interested and want to know more. My worry for you all is that you are accidentally creating a longing in your child for his bio father, who has already rejected him and would probably do so again, or even worse, want to be involved (and start demanding parental responsibility rights over school choice etc)!

You’ve done well and been honest about the fact that he has another father, you’ve told him a few times to make sure he understands, I think your DH is right and you should stop mentioning it (unless your child has questions). You do not want your child to feel that there is something missing and that he has been deprived of his father.

SpidersAreShitheads · 22/05/2022 16:01

I have 12 yr old DD and DS (twins) and my DP is not their bio dad. We got together when the DC were about 6 months old (he was the brother of my then best friend and I knew him very well already).

Bio dad is not interested. We split up when I was 8 wks pregnant (my decision) and he's never been in touch. Not once. I contacted him to confirm the birth but he never acknowledged it. I presume he thought I was going to chase him for money but I've never taken a penny from him. He doesn't want to be a dad, clearly, so I don't want him involved in any way.

My DC call my partner "daddy" and they consider him to be their dad. DP considers them to be his children. My DC are aware that DP is not their bio dad. I mentioned it casually very occasionally but then when they were a bit older and asked questions, I gave them the (child-friendly) full facts.

They are very pissed off with bio dad and swear they never want anything to do with him. It's their choice. I've never badmouthed him, even though he's behaved appallingly. Weirdly he didn't want me to have a termination (we discussed it) so fuck knows what he actually did want. Anyway.

I don't agree with PP who say that it's not the OP's partner's business. It is. He may not have contributed the sperm to make the baby but he's the dad in all meaningful senses of the word. And he probably feels a bit vulnerable. Imagine raising a child and treating it as your own, and then worrying that the original bio person could come and replace you at some point. I'm not saying he's right to say what he did (he isn't) but I think it's worth considering the quite sensitive position he's in.

I agree with a PP, adoption would be a very good move for you OP. It's something we've planned to do, but have never quite gotten round to it. But we will. My DC are both autistic and my DS has high needs so it's actually really important, just in case something happens to me. If you DH adopts your DS, that will make him feel more secure and could help with how vulnerable he's feeling.

With reference to your DC, when you say you mention it "regularly" - how often do you mean and in what context? I think after five years with pretty much no contact you're on safe ground to say to DS that bio dad helped to make him, and that's great, but he's chosen to have a different life elsewhere. And that there are different types of dads - and that his dad that's bringing him up may not have helped to make him, but he's chosen to be his dad and that's very special. That kind of thing.

They are tricky conversations to navigate but I think just being factual and unemotional about bio dad, giving basic facts while also emphasising the role of your DH as his "adopted" dad is all that's needed.

RedPlumbob · 22/05/2022 15:48

DenholmElliot1 · 22/05/2022 13:37

I'd be doing the opposite. If my son was asking about his father i'd be trying to facilitate contact.

Your DH doesn't really get a say in the matter. Presumably he knows who his father is and has a relationship with him.

My child is 7 and asks about her “father” sometimes, but I sure as shit will never facilitate contact. He was extremely abusive, arrested and spent time in prison, and he “abandoned” my child because, in his twisted mind, it was the worst thing he could possibly do.

In reality, it’s given me a huge amount of freedom, I’m no longer looking over my shoulder, I’m no longer constantly panicked and anxious.

You cannot facilitate contact with a man who simply isn’t fucking interested in being a parent - the sort that flits in once or twice a year is hugely damaging, I’ve seen it and a totally absent parent does far less damage.

I have remained single so I don’t have the complication that OP does, but the DH needs to get a fucking grip.

RonaCoaster · 22/05/2022 15:43

I think you just need to have a proper conversation about it all with your partner. His feelings are real and can’t just be dismissed. If he hasn’t properly thought things through it’s probably quite a natural reaction to feel threatened by the reminder that he is not the legal parent of the little boy he thinks of as his son.

I’m sure though that if it comes from a place of love for your son that he would understand that he has a right to know the truth of his biological father and that this is actually more beneficial to their relationship in the long term. if after you discuss things properly he is still insisting that you hide your sons father from him that’s a different matter as that is not his decision to make.

Have you ever discussed the option of adoption? Does he have legal parental responsibility?

GetTheStartyParted · 22/05/2022 15:17

My DH adopted DS when he was 7. One of the first parts of the process was ensuring DS understood he had another parent and who DH was to him. They stressed this was very important and my lovely DS said "I met Daddy when I was 3". When the adoption was finalised we had a big party to celebrate their relationship becoming official.

He is now 19 and has little interest in his bio dad, but knows he can ask anything. It is not taboo. He and DH are really close, no different to the relationship he has with the child we had together.

You are right to keep your child aware of their background and your DH needs to understand that.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 15:14

A child has every right to know who both his parents are.

I would bring it up casually every now and then and take your lead from that.

You certainly don't want your son avoiding the subject for fear of upsetting your DH!

If you deny your son knowledge or access he will not thank you for it later. He can find out for himself your ex is a waste of space.

Your DH needs to butt out. This is NOT about him, far from it.

ponkydonkey · 22/05/2022 15:10

I agree woth@KettrickenSmiled

Yes of course you should talk about him... and try to set up some sort of contact.

Don't let it be a surprise later on in life!

LocalHobo · 22/05/2022 15:10

I would use different terms. Father vs dad. So X is your father so he helped me make you but Y is your dad because he loves and cares for you and that's what dads do.
This.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 15:07

He's had the sleepless nights and financially provided, you're a family.

This is a fairly major assumption @LostSocksBrigade, given how few bio fathers step up to their full share of parenting. OP doesn't say he's done anything of the sort. And for all we know, she out-earns DH by a significant amount.

Floralnomad · 22/05/2022 15:06

Has your husband legally adopted your son as that’s what I’d be sorting out .

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 15:02

DH over heard it and became upset and said that I'm not his feelings into account

DH need to remember that he is not a lion on the savannah, who needs to eat his rival's offspring in order to stay Top Cat.

While he's doing that, he can grow the fuck up & realise that his feelings are simply NOT IMPORTANT in this context. He knew you had a son, he knew this son had a living father - sure, it's great for him to feel he wants to be the daddy DS didn't get ... but not at the bizarre expense of you (or DS!) not being ALLOWED to mention DS's father.

Is this a one-off, or is he controlling in other ways?

I would tell him ONCE how out of order he is to prioritise himself & his selfish immaturity over YOUR CHILD's FEELINGS, & if he ever pulled such a ridiculously self-important stunt again, I would leave him without a second thought.

Your precious child does not need to be on the arse end of your new husband's attempt to control you.

CPL593H · 22/05/2022 14:54

Eeksteek · 22/05/2022 14:01

Yes. The last thing you want is it being a horrible shock at 13.

Totally this. I grew up knowing that I had a birth father (who couldn't have been less interested) It isn't about contact, it is about preventing the information being a shock at the worst possible time (teens) He will find out anyway, eg from birth certificate and it is best he can absorb it in a natural and non drama filled way.

I can understand your DH feelings, but he needs to deal with them. I had a birth father and a Dad and the 2 are not comparable. I hope he can see that.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/05/2022 14:53

Goingforarun · 22/05/2022 14:01

What are the benefits to 5 year old child for regularly reminding him?

That when you finally ask, you aren't dismissed with a 'you did know once, but you forgot' and not actually answered at all.

LostSocksBrigade · 22/05/2022 14:50

On the one hand you definitely don't want it to shock him later, and it does need to be mentioned. But at the same time I can understand why your dp feels upset, he feels like dad and this other man has never been involved. He's had the sleepless nights and financially provided, you're a family.
You're both right in a way, and how you both feel is important. Now with that said he can't ask you not to mention it, but he's probably worried about losing his child. Just sit down and have a frank conversation about it, explain about not wanting it to be a shock etc. Maybe there's a solution like a photo album for your little one, it can have a photo of bio dad and baby, if there are any, and lots of photos of other family members etc. You can explain that it's his biological dad, and that your partner is also dad. It'll just become normal but takes the pressure off the idea of meeting up etc. Your child doesn't understand the situation right now, doesn't and can't understand why bio dad wasn't interested. I'd keep the idea in place, but not worry about facilitating contact unless child or bio dad bring it up themselves.

lunar1 · 22/05/2022 14:48

He's 5, he will need a regular reminder until he's older so he doesn't forget. It's important to make sure he knows he can ask about him when he's older.

Your husband's attitude is understandable but unhealthy for your DS and he needs to stop asking this of you.

Clymene · 22/05/2022 14:45

I would use different terms. Father vs dad. So X is your father so he helped me make you but Y is your dad because he loves and cares for you and that's what dads do.

And yes, this needs to be something he grows up having always known. Your husband needs to grow up a bit.

WallaceinAnderland · 22/05/2022 14:40

babyneversleeps · 22/05/2022 13:50

The thing is if I never spoke to him about it he would never ask I never know if I'm doing the right thing.

If you don't speak about it he will forget and of course he won't ask, he will have no memory to remind to him ask. Then it will come as a huge shock to him when he's older and needs to know.

You are right to remind him and to also talk about the many different kinds of family. Your DH is just going to have be a grown up and do what's right for the child.

Travis1 · 22/05/2022 14:36

This situation is a lot of why I’m NC with my mother. I found out accidentally when o was 10/11 that my ‘dad’ wasn’t my dad. It was always a big bad thing to talk about and she has been positively fucking obstructive to my attempts to get information. Please don’t let your husbands ego stop you being open with your son.

Beamur · 22/05/2022 14:36

I think it's in your son's best interest longer term to know the truth. Your DH needs to see that he is the person who will love and bring DS up but not feel undermined by not being his biological father.

Mellowyellow222 · 22/05/2022 14:32

your husband is being selfish. This isn’t about his feelings it’s about your son’s.

does he want to pretend he is your sons biological father? That will only lead to a huge upset in years to come when the truth comes out.

your husband is the one who is there - hopefully he is a good parent and your son will love him like a father. But he can’t wish away your sons biological dad. Yes the man sounds useless and your son will realise that. But he deserves the truth about who he is. Your husband does not have the right to take that away from him just to spare his own feelings.

TheWildRumpyPumpus · 22/05/2022 14:10

All children have a right to know their biological history - I say that as an adoptee. Your DH knew the situation when he married you obviously, he needs to get on with it now and support your DS. If his bio Dad is flakey, DS is going to need support from both of you as he navigates this relationship. With social media your son will be able to find his Dad when he’s older if he wants to, better that you are involved in the process and don’t make him some kind of mystery your son wants to solve later.

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 22/05/2022 14:07

Goingforarun · 22/05/2022 14:01

What are the benefits to 5 year old child for regularly reminding him?

Going by the experience of DSis and DNephew the benefit is that the child knows, even if without much understanding, so that later, in teens, it doesn't come as a shock and they can make a decision about contact without the rawness of a new discovery.

TeenPlusCat · 22/05/2022 14:05

Goingforarun · 22/05/2022 14:01

What are the benefits to 5 year old child for regularly reminding him?

So he doesn't forget.
So when it comes out as a teenager it doesn't shake his foundation to the core that Dad isn't his bio dad.

titchy · 22/05/2022 14:05

Goingforarun · 22/05/2022 14:01

What are the benefits to 5 year old child for regularly reminding him?

Because if she didn't mention it regularly he'd forget and grow up thinking her dh is his biological dad, then get a massive shock when someone tells him otherwise. At the moment the kid is aware and well adjusted to the idea. It needs to be kept that way, and that means mentioning it regularly even if it pisses the dh off - the kid is priority here.

KangarooKenny · 22/05/2022 14:02

I think you should mention his DF as that allows him to speak about him, as your DS may feel he can’t with your DH’s attitude.

Swipe left for the next trending thread