Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH doesn't want me to mention DS "dad"

136 replies

babyneversleeps · 22/05/2022 13:32

DS is 5 now and I have always told him he has another dad and sometimes I will mention it to see how he feels. Today he told me he would like to meet him when he's a bit older.

DH over heard it and became upset and said that I'm not his feelings into account and why do I keep mentioning it when his "sperm donor" doesn't even care about him. Which is probably true!

He has met him twice when he was a baby and that was it he stopped bothering once he realised he couldn't just sleep with me anymore and then I met DH when DS was 7 months old.

AIBU? should I never mention it again. I kind of think DH needs to put his feelings to a side as it's not about him and I want to be open with DS as much as possible.

OP posts:
Itsbackagain · 22/05/2022 18:05

I totally see this from your DH pov. Why keep reminding a child his dad has abandoned him? Your DH is the childs dad now - doesn't take blood to make a family and you're literally promoting a sperm donor over a father.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 18:05

queenrollo · 22/05/2022 18:00

My father left when I was 2 and I had no memory of him. His extended family all buggered off, so my Mum and Dad capitalised on this by not bothering to tell me the truth about my parentage.
I was 13 when I found out, in a busy Post Office while applying for a passport. My mother scooped up the paperwork, dragged me out by my wrist and refused to talk to me. When we got home my Dad told me that someone else was my father and that it was never to be mentioned again.
In that one afternoon my whole life turned out to be a lie and it was a lie that irreparably damaged my relationship with my parents - and my aunts and uncles because they were all complicit in this lie too.

This lie was for the most part instigated by my Dad whose favoured approach to anything difficult it to pretend it never happened.

I am 46 years old and it's only through therapy when I was 43 that I finally managed to let go of some the immense hurt this situation caused.

Your DH needs to accept that he gives far more power to the 'sperm donor' by secrecy than you ever will by just being open and factual with your son about the situation.

Terrible situation. And proof positive that the OP is doing the right thing by her son.

Flowers
AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 18:01

In the words of a certain TV judge, and I'm paraphrasing:

Never make a child feel bad about a parent.

They may be a useless good for nothing, but you never visit that on a child.

queenrollo · 22/05/2022 18:00

My father left when I was 2 and I had no memory of him. His extended family all buggered off, so my Mum and Dad capitalised on this by not bothering to tell me the truth about my parentage.
I was 13 when I found out, in a busy Post Office while applying for a passport. My mother scooped up the paperwork, dragged me out by my wrist and refused to talk to me. When we got home my Dad told me that someone else was my father and that it was never to be mentioned again.
In that one afternoon my whole life turned out to be a lie and it was a lie that irreparably damaged my relationship with my parents - and my aunts and uncles because they were all complicit in this lie too.

This lie was for the most part instigated by my Dad whose favoured approach to anything difficult it to pretend it never happened.

I am 46 years old and it's only through therapy when I was 43 that I finally managed to let go of some the immense hurt this situation caused.

Your DH needs to accept that he gives far more power to the 'sperm donor' by secrecy than you ever will by just being open and factual with your son about the situation.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 17:48

Dumblebum · 22/05/2022 17:45

How would a five year old know if he wants to meet him and see how he feels. That’s led by you. Why do you keep mentioning it? Yes it’s important to ensure your son knows about his parentage, but yoire going too far.

why are you doing it? Do you still have a thing for the father?

Seriously, what a ridiculous post. The OP is occasionally reminding her son he has a father. There is nothing wrong, and everything right about that.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 17:46

Your contribution was totally valid @Mossstitch & you had NO need to apologise for it!

It's a complicated business, this stepping lark.
Flowers

Dumblebum · 22/05/2022 17:45

How would a five year old know if he wants to meet him and see how he feels. That’s led by you. Why do you keep mentioning it? Yes it’s important to ensure your son knows about his parentage, but yoire going too far.

why are you doing it? Do you still have a thing for the father?

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 17:44

"Wouldn’t it be better to just leave him to think DH is his dad till he’s a teenager and you can explain what it means and the situation properly."

This is terrible and damaging. What the actual!!

Alcibiade · 22/05/2022 17:44

YANBU. Your DH is not.

It is unfair to your child not to be told about his biological father, and he might resent you for this when he grows up (I'm assuming that the 'sperm donor' remark was just your husband's idea of 'wit' and not literally true?)

Mossstitch · 22/05/2022 17:40

@KettrickenSmiled thank you💐 funnily enough my mother married my step-father when I was 4 yrs old too, so I would have always known he wasn't my biological father. Unfortunately I never felt that my step-father 'chose to love me' rather that I was forced on him because he wanted my mother. Was only when he was dying and thanked me for looking after him that I felt any emotion from him. But I'm bringing my dysfunctional family into the debate which is clouding my response so probably shouldn't have contributed🤷
I still stand by the fact that it shouldn't be brought up regularly unless by the child and they should be made to feel comfortable to ask anything knowing they will get an honest and unbiased answer just like any other 'awkward' subjects.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 17:40

OhmygodDont · 22/05/2022 17:33

There wasn’t anything not honest though. Just the conversation must of happened when I was so young I don’t remember it actually happening but I always knew my dad wasn’t my dad. I wasn’t forced to want to look for my biological by him always being mentioned anymore than I was put off meeting him should I ask. I did indeed meet him once. He was a waste of a space. But I wasn’t constantly asked if I missed him or wanted to see him.

Yes but that's entirely different. The choice was yours. In this case the DH doesn't want him mentioned. The OP isn't building up hope of a relationship, but is quite rightly occasionally letting her little boy know that he has a biological father.

CPL593H · 22/05/2022 17:38

Jjnbftgkhfrvjudv · 22/05/2022 17:34

Honestly, his real dad seems horrible and the way you described doesn’t sound like he’d want anything to do with him anyway. So why would u get DS hopes up to think he’d be able to meet him . Wouldn’t it be better to just leave him to think DH is his dad till he’s a teenager and you can explain what it means and the situation properly.

Just no. Honestly, no.

CPL593H · 22/05/2022 17:37

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 17:31

@OhmygodDont that's not very healthy though is it.

Honestly and transparency all the way.

Kids are pretty resilient when presented with the facts in a child-friendly way.

Taboo and don't upset the DH...
Never.

I believe this is right. It really doesn't have to be a daily or even monthly topic of conversation, but it needs to be open. I remember exactly where I was told (walking down a certain street, it was sunny, 50 odd years ago) I must have been 4/5. Remember feeling that this was something important but I just accepted it and I did retain it. My mother managed to screw an awful lot of things up, but I'm grateful to her for this.

Jjnbftgkhfrvjudv · 22/05/2022 17:34

Honestly, his real dad seems horrible and the way you described doesn’t sound like he’d want anything to do with him anyway. So why would u get DS hopes up to think he’d be able to meet him . Wouldn’t it be better to just leave him to think DH is his dad till he’s a teenager and you can explain what it means and the situation properly.

OhmygodDont · 22/05/2022 17:33

There wasn’t anything not honest though. Just the conversation must of happened when I was so young I don’t remember it actually happening but I always knew my dad wasn’t my dad. I wasn’t forced to want to look for my biological by him always being mentioned anymore than I was put off meeting him should I ask. I did indeed meet him once. He was a waste of a space. But I wasn’t constantly asked if I missed him or wanted to see him.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 17:31

@OhmygodDont that's not very healthy though is it.

Honestly and transparency all the way.

Kids are pretty resilient when presented with the facts in a child-friendly way.

Taboo and don't upset the DH...
Never.

OhmygodDont · 22/05/2022 17:24

I don’t ever remember being told my dad wasn’t my biological dad I don’t ever remember being asked how I felt about it.

honestly I wouldn’t keep asking him. He knows he has a dad and a biological dad. Let him ask you. He will remember those chats but you keep bringing them up are you pointing out how his not really
his dad and is different. If you two have children will you keep pointing out how his not really his?

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 17:21

OP original post "I kind of think DH needs to put his feelings to a side as it's not about him and I want to be open with DS as much as possible"

100% correct, and that's the top and bottom of it.

Far too much of this has gone on in the past. I come from Ireland and we all know the irreparable damage done by state and church in denying the rights of children to know who their biological parents are.

The OP is absolutely right to leave the door open for her son to make up his own mind when he's older.

knowinglesseveryday · 22/05/2022 17:17

sometimes I will mention it to see how he feels

I can't imagine why you would keep doing it. You're basically inviting him to take an active interest in a relationship which may not be open to him. Don't hide it but don't make a big thing about it. I'm not surprised your DH is upset.

Stravaig · 22/05/2022 17:10

Consistently use separate terms for each type of fatherhood - 'Dad' for DH vs. 'biological father'. Crystal clear for son, and might help your DH?

SpidersAreShitheads · 22/05/2022 17:05

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 16:42

I don't agree with PP who say that it's not the OP's partner's business. It is. He may not have contributed the sperm to make the baby but he's the dad in all meaningful senses of the word. And he probably feels a bit vulnerable. Imagine raising a child and treating it as your own, and then worrying that the original bio person could come and replace you at some point. I'm not saying he's right to say what he did (he isn't) but I think it's worth considering the quite sensitive position he's in.

He's not in a sensitive position FFS.
He's a grown man who went into marriage with his eyes open, who should understand - without having it patiently explained to him by his wife - that the little boy is the only one who is in a potentially 'sensitive position' & that the little boy's feelings are paramount in this.

My bio father attended the conception. Not a scrap else.
My (step)dad married my mother & formally adopted me when I was 4.
He never ONCE made a fuss about my bio father, never centred his feelings about my birth circumstances as being anything about him, & in short was a kind, loving, & totally unselfish dad.

He died before I looked up my bio father - but had he still been alive, he would not have raised so much as an eyebrow at me for wanting to know more about my genetic heritage. He would have encouraged me, not competed, & not made juvenile bids for attention by making that difficult contact All About Him.

My dad was a grown up.
Is your husband, OP?

Of course he's in a sensitive position. It's ridiculous to suggest that he's not allowed to have feelings about the child's dad and the vulnerability of his own role as dad. As I said in my previous post, of course that doesn't give him the right to dictate, but a little bit of understanding of why he might be feeling insecure wouldn't hurt.

Your adoptive dad didn't make a fuss. Great. Good for him. He sounds lovely. Genuinely. But we're all different and have different feelings. As I said before, no, OP's DH isn't right to try and stop all mentions but maybe OP is inadvertently overdoing it. Maybe she isn't. We don't know. Either way, of course he needs to try and find a way to work through those feelings, but a little bit of empathy for how he might be feeling wouldn't go amiss. It's actually wonderful that he cares enough for the child to feel that he doesn't want to lose his role as dad.

He's just feeling a bit vulnerable which is potentially making him a bit unreasonable. I really dislike how you've attacked the OP's DH using quite unpleasant language like "juvenile bids for attention". Not nice.

TabithaTittlemouse · 22/05/2022 16:59

I think @SpidersAreShitheads has written a very reasonable and insightful response.

gamerchick · 22/05/2022 16:59

This is your son's story, it's nothing to do with your bloke really. I'd answer questions if asked by my kid.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 16:59

@girlmom21 Thank you.

He died over half my life ago, & I still think of him every day.

Clymene · 22/05/2022 16:57

And everyone I know who has had a revelation that their dad (or mum) isn't who they thought it was is deeply,deeply traumatised by the experience.

While it might be preferable to think that you would have spent your life in blissful ignorance if you hadn't been told, it nearly always comes out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread