Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH doesn't want me to mention DS "dad"

136 replies

babyneversleeps · 22/05/2022 13:32

DS is 5 now and I have always told him he has another dad and sometimes I will mention it to see how he feels. Today he told me he would like to meet him when he's a bit older.

DH over heard it and became upset and said that I'm not his feelings into account and why do I keep mentioning it when his "sperm donor" doesn't even care about him. Which is probably true!

He has met him twice when he was a baby and that was it he stopped bothering once he realised he couldn't just sleep with me anymore and then I met DH when DS was 7 months old.

AIBU? should I never mention it again. I kind of think DH needs to put his feelings to a side as it's not about him and I want to be open with DS as much as possible.

OP posts:
Maggie178 · 22/05/2022 19:30

I'm an adoptive parent. We're encouraged to talk openly about biological parents. This makes the child feel comfortable asking questions. It's about putting the child first. You cant erase a child's past. You're child could at some point have feels regarding their biological father's rejection/abandonment. You want him to feel he can talk to his parents about that so you can support them.

whumpthereitis · 22/05/2022 19:03

Blood may not matter to some people and that’s fine, but the fact remains that for others it is incredibly important. It doesn’t always follow that children will share their parents opinions on it either.

Your DH is entitled to his feelings, but he chose to marry a woman who has child. He needs to deal with those feelings himself or in therapy, he can’t make you or your child responsible for them.

whumpthereitis · 22/05/2022 18:53

Your son should absolutely know about his biological dad. Long term, what if he gets in contact with his father and they develop a relationship? Is he going to be ‘allowed’ to ask about him? To speak to, or see see him? You don’t want your son feeling shamed or emotionally blackmailed over a natural curiosity as to his origins.

madasawethen · 22/05/2022 18:51

Stop talking about the sperm donor. You've told your son. He knows so leave it.

girlmom21 · 22/05/2022 18:46

Op presumably he calls your DH dad, was that his choice or yours?

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 18:45

@KettrickenSmiled

Fair play to you, absolutely right.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 18:44

It's actually wonderful that he cares enough for the child to feel that he doesn't want to lose his role as dad.

Nope. It's base level parenting.
Don't applaud a fish for swimming.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 18:43

CPL593H · 22/05/2022 18:37

@queenrollo "Your DH needs to accept that he gives far more power to the 'sperm donor' by secrecy than you ever will by just being open and factual with your son about the situation."

This is the absolute truth and Flowers for you. I'm sorry you went through that and hope your words inspire parents who may be in this sort of situation to be truthful.

This is such an important thread, and this comment goes to the heart of it.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 18:42

Of course he's in a sensitive position. It's ridiculous to suggest that he's not allowed to have feelings about the child's dad and the vulnerability of his own role as dad. As I said in my previous post, of course that doesn't give him the right to dictate, but a little bit of understanding of why he might be feeling insecure wouldn't hurt.

Your adoptive dad didn't make a fuss. Great. Good for him. He sounds lovely. Genuinely. But we're all different and have different feelings. As I said before, no, OP's DH isn't right to try and stop all mentions but maybe OP is inadvertently overdoing it. Maybe she isn't. We don't know. Either way, of course he needs to try and find a way to work through those feelings, but a little bit of empathy for how he might be feeling wouldn't go amiss. It's actually wonderful that he cares enough for the child to feel that he doesn't want to lose his role as dad.

He's just feeling a bit vulnerable which is potentially making him a bit unreasonable. I really dislike how you've attacked the OP's DH using quite unpleasant language like "juvenile bids for attention". Not nice.

Oh come off it with the dickpandering @SpidersAreShitheads

When - in the whole of mumsnet history - was there ever Special Pleading for all the stepmums who are butthurt that an absent mother is mentioned, who seek to ban all mention of the bio mother, & who get all angry about the "womb provider" & feel that her very existence might make them "lose her role as mum"?

None - because it doesn't happen.

Stepmums don't complain like this - their complaints are generaly more to do with getting the lion's share of parenting duties but no authority to back that up - & just for this, are told to suck it up, & that they shouldn;t have married a man they knew had exisiting children.
I've never seen a stepmum post here moaning that she's scared her stepkids might be aware she's not their 'real' mum, or issuing instructions to her stepkids' dad that he's not allowed to mention his kids' bio mother.

CPL593H · 22/05/2022 18:37

@queenrollo "Your DH needs to accept that he gives far more power to the 'sperm donor' by secrecy than you ever will by just being open and factual with your son about the situation."

This is the absolute truth and Flowers for you. I'm sorry you went through that and hope your words inspire parents who may be in this sort of situation to be truthful.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 18:33

I was 13 when I found out, in a busy Post Office while applying for a passport. My mother scooped up the paperwork, dragged me out by my wrist and refused to talk to me. When we got home my Dad told me that someone else was my father and that it was never to be mentioned again.

Oh @queenrollo ... Flowers
Way to go, your parents.
Making a kid feel like she was part of some dirty little secret.

OP - if you take anything from your thread, take this.
You are doing the right thing for your little boy by being honest.
Explain to DH what a shock DS forgetting, then finding out later, it would be, & how traumatising it can be for some kids to find out they have been lied to.

No need to over-egg it though.
As PP suggest - your FATHER is the bio man who helped me make you.
Your DADDY is your dad, who looks after you & loves you.
& NEVER mention meeting the bio father unless DS does, then explain that it's unlikely, but might be something that could happen when he is grown up.

SunshineCake · 22/05/2022 18:32

I feel sorry for your Dh tbh. He's putting all the hard graft in and suddenly the little chap he sees as his is asking for his biological dad. Your son needs to know he has a biological father obviously but there is so much more than biology in bringing up a child.

It isn't that your dh is jealous of a waste of space biological dad but probably more scared his little boy will prefer the other guy.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 18:24

@ImAvingOops I appreciate what your saying but nowhere did the OP say she was bringing it up too often, sounded more like occasionally.

My niece is in this exact situation.

Her 1st son was born to a total waster, currently in prison.

She is now married to a great guy and they have another child.

She would never deny her 1st sons father. He can see him whenever he wants, but is flakey as fuck. Pays no maintenance but she would never visit this on her innocent son.

Her son will make up his own mind, and it's becoming clear as time goes on how this will pan out.

Her DH treats her son as his own in every respect, as do his family.

Is he hurt or sensitive about mentions of the father?.. of course not.

Why would he be jealous of a total waster who's done nothing. It's ridiculous.

notanothertakeaway · 22/05/2022 18:21

queenrollo · 22/05/2022 18:00

My father left when I was 2 and I had no memory of him. His extended family all buggered off, so my Mum and Dad capitalised on this by not bothering to tell me the truth about my parentage.
I was 13 when I found out, in a busy Post Office while applying for a passport. My mother scooped up the paperwork, dragged me out by my wrist and refused to talk to me. When we got home my Dad told me that someone else was my father and that it was never to be mentioned again.
In that one afternoon my whole life turned out to be a lie and it was a lie that irreparably damaged my relationship with my parents - and my aunts and uncles because they were all complicit in this lie too.

This lie was for the most part instigated by my Dad whose favoured approach to anything difficult it to pretend it never happened.

I am 46 years old and it's only through therapy when I was 43 that I finally managed to let go of some the immense hurt this situation caused.

Your DH needs to accept that he gives far more power to the 'sperm donor' by secrecy than you ever will by just being open and factual with your son about the situation.

@queenrollo

I'm sorry to see your story. You have every right to feel angry that you were misled for so long

If it's any comfort, I work in this area and have seen several cases where eg Mum meets step dad when child is a baby, child grows up calling them Dad, and Mum / step Dad agree they will explain the truth to the child when they're older and old enough to understand..... but the right time never comes.... so they put it off even longer... and then it comes out in an unplanned way, which is just awful for the child

It's absolutely the wrong approach, but I honestly do not think it's always done with bad intent. Sometimes, they just make a terrible decision, with good intentions

Sirzy · 22/05/2022 18:19

Clymene · 22/05/2022 18:16

But her son is only 5 @Sirzy. If you don't mention it, kids just forget/pretend it didn't happen

They don’t. Even at 5 they are more than capable of understanding. They don’t need “sometimes” reminders unless it comes up in conversation.

Ds is nearly 13 now and as aware as he is of the situation I genuinely can’t remember the last time his birth father was mentioned. It doesn’t come up in natural conversation at all, if he mentions things I answer it but he just accepts it.

Clymene · 22/05/2022 18:16

But her son is only 5 @Sirzy. If you don't mention it, kids just forget/pretend it didn't happen

Sirzy · 22/05/2022 18:14

girlmom21 · 22/05/2022 18:10

@Sirzy op said sometimes, not regularly

Even so though why? Sadly the birth father is happy to miss out but who is gaining things by even sometimes reminders?

as I said earlier Ds is more than aware that my partner isn’t his father, and that his father made the choice to walk away without me needing to sometimes dig up old wounds all around.

BiscoffSundae · 22/05/2022 18:14

My daughter is 5 and her dad hasn’t been involved in her life (he has seen her 3 times) I never mention him to her and she never brings him up, why would I bring him up? Seems random to keep mentioning him so she “doesn’t forget” she’s fully aware she has a dad she doesn’t see not sure why I would need to keep reminding her or is that only if you have a new partner you should? (I don’t)

notanothertakeaway · 22/05/2022 18:13

Jjnbftgkhfrvjudv · 22/05/2022 17:34

Honestly, his real dad seems horrible and the way you described doesn’t sound like he’d want anything to do with him anyway. So why would u get DS hopes up to think he’d be able to meet him . Wouldn’t it be better to just leave him to think DH is his dad till he’s a teenager and you can explain what it means and the situation properly.

@Jjnbftgkhfrvjudv

I know you mean well, but this is the worst possible advice

I work in this field and waiting until the child is old enough to understand the truth is a recipe for disaster. The lie just gets bigger

All children are entitled to know their birth history. You can distinguish between (1) the father that helped to make you and (2) Dad who looks after you. That might be helpful. And no need to talk about "real" aka birth father

But the child has every right to know that he has a bio father out there

drpet49 · 22/05/2022 18:12

I totally see this from your DH pov. Why keep reminding a child his dad has abandoned him? Your DH is the childs dad now - doesn't take blood to make a family and you're literally promoting a sperm donor over a father.

^I agree with this.

girlmom21 · 22/05/2022 18:10

@Sirzy op said sometimes, not regularly

Sirzy · 22/05/2022 18:09

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 18:07

Oh god I despair! NO she is not doing that.

By bringing it up regularly yes she is.

there is a massive gulf between a child having no idea and being regularly reminded of the situation.

ImAvingOops · 22/05/2022 18:08

@AhNowTed , you put a lot of words into my mouth that weren't there! Yes, children need to know who their biological parents are - I actually think that's really important.
But they don't need to have regular reminders at 5 years old. And the man who has actually done all the fathering is allowed to have feelings too! He is the dad in the meaningful sense of the word and since OP has allowed this, she has a responsibility to think about him too.
I would leave it a bit now. Talk to your dh about how it's important that DS can recognise his roots and not feel guilty for it or as if it's wrong to mention the existence of bio dad. But don't keep bringing it up to a 5 year old. To him dad is the nan who is there everyday, who loves him.
I would look into dh adopting your DS and formalising the relationship - your dh might not feel so insecure. In his shoes, I'd be feeling insecure because you can live a child totally but if you and he split, he could lose that child forever. It's bound to make a person feel a bit sensitive

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 18:07

Itsbackagain · 22/05/2022 18:05

I totally see this from your DH pov. Why keep reminding a child his dad has abandoned him? Your DH is the childs dad now - doesn't take blood to make a family and you're literally promoting a sperm donor over a father.

Oh god I despair! NO she is not doing that.

OhmygodDont · 22/05/2022 18:06

my point is disregarding the dh totally I will admit.

but the op has fully told her child they have a biological father and brings them up regularly to check in. There is no way this child won’t alway know that dad did not actually make them. I just don’t see the need to bring it up every month or whatever let the child lead the conversation and ask the questions if they have them. I didn’t meet mine till much older than this child but still they where not mentioned to be regularly I just knew from earlier conversations. Sometimes we truly don’t give young children the recognition of what they will remember.

whilst on the other hand young childhood trauma is known to be majorly imprinted. Either young children remember and hold the information or they don’t.

Swipe left for the next trending thread