Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the hell do you do in this situation?

90 replies

bibbidibbobbidybo · 22/05/2022 13:23

Posting so I can try give advice to a lovely friend of mine who is suffering and at a loss as to what she can do.

Il keep it as short as I can.

DF (friend) bought house cash with inheritance a couple of years ago and put partners name on the deeds also (not married) they have 2 DC.

Relationship needs to end, he is controlling, a bully, manipulator and I believe mentally abusive. Poor DF is in bits things are not good at home at all.

Her partner is the breadwinner she is a SAHM and has no income at all other than money partner will send her for things (again very controlling)

She wants to end the relationship but he will not leave the house unless she agrees to sell and give him 50%. He already has quite a high paid job and savings where as DF has nothing but the house as she put all her money into that and also gave up working to please him. She is primary career to the children and when I say that she does 99.9% of everything with the children.

She has nowhere she can go, and cannot claim any benefits until he's left the house which he will not do. She doesn't want to give him 50% as that will leave her struggling to buy another House and would most definitely mean the children will have to move schools and areas.

Please could anyone offer any advice as to what would be her best options in this situation?

OP posts:
Rainbowqueeen · 22/05/2022 21:26

I’d start with womens aid.

She can definitely claim benefits even with him in the house - this is a very common scenario.

Does she have her own bank account?? I’d also look into switching child benefit to be paid into that. If he kicks off, call the police.

Johnnysgirl · 22/05/2022 21:26

bibbidibbobbidybo · 22/05/2022 21:20

they are not married but both children are his. He is truly awful I just wish I could click my fingers for her to take her out of this situation. My door is open but she is reluctant to leave the home as if she does he will stay and she and the kids are going to struggle to find anything as she is isolated from all family and social housing waiting lists are upwards of 3!years. Such a crap situation that money in the house is the only thing she has and he won't help towards childcare cost for her to get back into work and without a penny it's just so difficult for her to get on her feet

It sounds very difficult, but she must have known that in putting him on the deeds he now owns half the house?
There's no point in not facing this, there's no way round it now.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 22/05/2022 21:22

Favouritefruits · 22/05/2022 15:48

She needs to tell him she wants half his pension, he’ll soon change his tune.

What possible right would she have to his pension?

bibbidibbobbidybo · 22/05/2022 21:20

they are not married but both children are his. He is truly awful I just wish I could click my fingers for her to take her out of this situation. My door is open but she is reluctant to leave the home as if she does he will stay and she and the kids are going to struggle to find anything as she is isolated from all family and social housing waiting lists are upwards of 3!years. Such a crap situation that money in the house is the only thing she has and he won't help towards childcare cost for her to get back into work and without a penny it's just so difficult for her to get on her feet

OP posts:
Crazycatlady83 · 22/05/2022 21:19

Andromachehadabadday · 22/05/2022 21:09

An occupation order is rare. Very rare when they aren’t married and lots of women regret them when it comes to sell.

Theres quite a few threads on here where women wished they hadn’t. They had to cover the mortgage, upkeep etc to give their ex a big chunk of cash at the end of it.

I think you are getting confused between a "Mesher Order" (deferred house sale on separation to allow one person to live in property until children are 18 and then sale) and a Occupation Order where a abusive partner is removed from the family home. These are normally time limited for 1 year (to allow proceedings to commence for divorce or sale of the house etc) Not rare at all and can't think of one person who ever regretted having a abusive partner removed from the family home

Andromachehadabadday · 22/05/2022 21:09

An occupation order is rare. Very rare when they aren’t married and lots of women regret them when it comes to sell.

Theres quite a few threads on here where women wished they hadn’t. They had to cover the mortgage, upkeep etc to give their ex a big chunk of cash at the end of it.

burnoutbabe · 22/05/2022 21:04

They are not his kids though?

But generally they would order a sale unless there are very specific reasons why those kids need to go to a particular local school (disabilities etc)

knittingaddict · 22/05/2022 21:03

Favouritefruits · 22/05/2022 15:48

She needs to tell him she wants half his pension, he’ll soon change his tune.

She's not entitled to half his pension if they aren't married.

He may be entitled to half of the equity of the house if he's on the deeds.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 21:01

Obviously what the hell was she thinking (god this is depressingly common) but I'm glad she has a friend like you to help her out of this awful situation.

Newmumatlast · 22/05/2022 21:00

Threetulips · 22/05/2022 16:47

He wouldn’t get 50% as he has two children who need a roof over their heads.
She needs a lot of paperwork and a decent solicitor.

Thats not necessarily correct. He may get 50% but deferred i.e. not order for sale right now

Newmumatlast · 22/05/2022 20:57

bibbidibbobbidybo · 22/05/2022 13:23

Posting so I can try give advice to a lovely friend of mine who is suffering and at a loss as to what she can do.

Il keep it as short as I can.

DF (friend) bought house cash with inheritance a couple of years ago and put partners name on the deeds also (not married) they have 2 DC.

Relationship needs to end, he is controlling, a bully, manipulator and I believe mentally abusive. Poor DF is in bits things are not good at home at all.

Her partner is the breadwinner she is a SAHM and has no income at all other than money partner will send her for things (again very controlling)

She wants to end the relationship but he will not leave the house unless she agrees to sell and give him 50%. He already has quite a high paid job and savings where as DF has nothing but the house as she put all her money into that and also gave up working to please him. She is primary career to the children and when I say that she does 99.9% of everything with the children.

She has nowhere she can go, and cannot claim any benefits until he's left the house which he will not do. She doesn't want to give him 50% as that will leave her struggling to buy another House and would most definitely mean the children will have to move schools and areas.

Please could anyone offer any advice as to what would be her best options in this situation?

She should go and see a solicitor. Unfortunately she should never have put him on the deeds. It would be difficult without any evidence as to % intention agreed between the parties to get away from a 50/50 split

Babyroobs · 22/05/2022 20:53

Even if he was entitled to something from the house, she may be able to get a court order to stay there with the kids until they leave education. A least that would give her time to come up with a plan to buy him out of his share. How old are the kids?

burnoutbabe · 22/05/2022 19:41

It's very hard to displace a 50/50 split in a joint tenancy unless you have clear evidence you intended to have it differently.

Being off the deeds and having paid sone if the deposit is easier to prove you should own some. )ie the opposite situation)

Stack v dowden is the leading case where it went 65/35 to the last but they had very separate finances.

bibbidibbobbidybo · 22/05/2022 19:24

Thank you so much for all of the comments.

Some really good advice,

Unfortunately due to his control she gave up her career and relays solely on him, no joint account etc she has to ask for every Penny. The child benefit goes into his account also.

I'm going to see her tomorrow and try to make a plan and il help as much as I can. She's a fabulous mum and lovely lady it's breaking my heart to see her suffer.

OP posts:
bibbidibbobbidybo · 22/05/2022 19:24

Thank you so much for all of the comments.

Some really good advice,

Unfortunately due to his control she gave up her career and relays solely on him, no joint account etc she has to ask for every Penny. The child benefit goes into his account also.

I'm going to see her tomorrow and try to make a plan and il help as much as I can. She's a fabulous mum and lovely lady it's breaking my heart to see her suffer.

OP posts:
Andromachehadabadday · 22/05/2022 18:16

Has she reported the abuse? I believe that helps in getting legal aid.

Trying to prove he cohersed her into putting his name on is likely to be an expensive endeavour.

JanglyBeads · 22/05/2022 18:14

She can speak to women's aid before she sees a solicitor too!

Unsure33 · 22/05/2022 18:12

Your DF needs to go to a reputable family law solicitor. The first hour might be free . They will confirm exactly what her options are . Then woman’s aid .

yesthatisdrizzle · 22/05/2022 18:10

If the relationship is abusive, was she bullied or coerced under duress into putting his name on the house? If so, she has a very strong case for it to be invalidated.

Aprilx · 22/05/2022 17:59

Threetulips · 22/05/2022 16:47

He wouldn’t get 50% as he has two children who need a roof over their heads.
She needs a lot of paperwork and a decent solicitor.

If they were married, maybe. But they are not so frankly the two children don’t come into it, other than obviously for child support.

As it is, they jointly own an asset, she essentially gifted half (or whatever portion the deeds say) to him. She can’t just take it back unfortunately.

Crazycatlady83 · 22/05/2022 17:53

The OP would be trying to argue that there is a resulting trust as she contributed all the purchase price so should get 100%. Partner didn't contribute anything so should be entitled to nothing. The deeds were only put in his name cos he is a controlling twat etc etc.,

The partner would be trying to argue either (1) the deeds are correct and they agreed to share it 50/50 regardless of whether she contributed to the entire purchase price or not, or (2) he contributed towards improvements to the property so should be entitled to a percentage share (normally representative of how much he contributed - so if he contributed £20k and the property was worth £100k, he should get 20%)

Beancounter1 · 22/05/2022 17:49

Crazycatlady's post above gives a solution that would be great if it could happen, but even if it can't she can probably get a court order to say the house can't be sold until youngest child is 18.

Then after this court order, police can be involved if he still won't move out.

Livelovebehappy · 22/05/2022 17:45

But OP has said he has contributed money to home improvements too. Would this also help his claim to half the house?

Crazycatlady83 · 22/05/2022 17:16

She needs a solicitor. The Trusts of Land and Appointment of Trustees Act has a mechanism in it whereby someone can claim the deeds do not reflect the true ownership of the property and therefore should be disregarded (it's called a Resulting Trust) It's a tricky application to make and will be expensive if she decides to engage a solicitor. Presumably she has a paper trail to show she contributed everything to the property so this will help.

His contributions to the improvements of the property may result in a court stating he should have a share but this probably wouldn't be 50/50. But there are very strict rules on what he would need to achieve to do this, and a solicitor will be able to advise.

His controlling behaviour would be beneficial showing why the courts shouldn't follow the deeds and may help in getting a occupation order but won't assist in anything else.

A solicitor may be able to advise on the occupation order and Trust work under legal aid (if she doesn't have an income) and once he is out of the house, she can then apply for benefits.

Babyvenusplant · 22/05/2022 17:06

Favouritefruits · 22/05/2022 15:48

She needs to tell him she wants half his pension, he’ll soon change his tune.

They're not married so his pension won't come into it