Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the hell do you do in this situation?

90 replies

bibbidibbobbidybo · 22/05/2022 13:23

Posting so I can try give advice to a lovely friend of mine who is suffering and at a loss as to what she can do.

Il keep it as short as I can.

DF (friend) bought house cash with inheritance a couple of years ago and put partners name on the deeds also (not married) they have 2 DC.

Relationship needs to end, he is controlling, a bully, manipulator and I believe mentally abusive. Poor DF is in bits things are not good at home at all.

Her partner is the breadwinner she is a SAHM and has no income at all other than money partner will send her for things (again very controlling)

She wants to end the relationship but he will not leave the house unless she agrees to sell and give him 50%. He already has quite a high paid job and savings where as DF has nothing but the house as she put all her money into that and also gave up working to please him. She is primary career to the children and when I say that she does 99.9% of everything with the children.

She has nowhere she can go, and cannot claim any benefits until he's left the house which he will not do. She doesn't want to give him 50% as that will leave her struggling to buy another House and would most definitely mean the children will have to move schools and areas.

Please could anyone offer any advice as to what would be her best options in this situation?

OP posts:
AchatAVendre · 23/05/2022 15:37

Crazycatlady83 · 22/05/2022 17:53

The OP would be trying to argue that there is a resulting trust as she contributed all the purchase price so should get 100%. Partner didn't contribute anything so should be entitled to nothing. The deeds were only put in his name cos he is a controlling twat etc etc.,

The partner would be trying to argue either (1) the deeds are correct and they agreed to share it 50/50 regardless of whether she contributed to the entire purchase price or not, or (2) he contributed towards improvements to the property so should be entitled to a percentage share (normally representative of how much he contributed - so if he contributed £20k and the property was worth £100k, he should get 20%)

I agree, but why on earth didn't the legal advice she must have had when purchasing the property and putting him on the deeds point out the pitfalls to her? It was only 2 years ago..

HogInAManger · 23/05/2022 15:32

Yes where domestic violence occurs the family court can (and does!) grant an occupation order forbidding a legal owner from living in a home they own.

This is however usually a time limited order pending completion of the sale of the property (to give parties time to re-arrange their affairs and go their separate ways).

Johnnysgirl · 23/05/2022 14:31

SlatsandFlaps · 23/05/2022 14:26

If she calls the NCDV, they will find a solicitor and it will be covered by Legal Aid due to the abuse. They will get an occupational order within a matter of days, to get him out of the house for 30 days. After which if she wishes, she could always go to a women's refuge. They are fantastic!

Seriously?

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 23/05/2022 14:30

Babyroobs · 22/05/2022 20:53

Even if he was entitled to something from the house, she may be able to get a court order to stay there with the kids until they leave education. A least that would give her time to come up with a plan to buy him out of his share. How old are the kids?

But he has the right to stay there too. You can’t just kick someone out of a house that they own with you.

SlatsandFlaps · 23/05/2022 14:26

If she calls the NCDV, they will find a solicitor and it will be covered by Legal Aid due to the abuse. They will get an occupational order within a matter of days, to get him out of the house for 30 days. After which if she wishes, she could always go to a women's refuge. They are fantastic!

Johnnysgirl · 23/05/2022 14:20

DogsAndGin · 23/05/2022 14:17

He is legally entitled to the money from his half of the house, surely she knew that was the case when she put him on the deeds 🤷🏼‍♀️

She isn’t married to him, so she isn’t entitled to anything of his. We all know how it works, I don’t understand why women are still putting themselves in this situation.

She chose to have children with a man she wasn’t married to. Very silly indeed!

Yes, this.
And you still get posts like "Go after his pension, op! See if he'll still take half the house then, eh!"
It's a sad, pretty hopeless situation to find yourself in, but also quite a stupid one.

DogsAndGin · 23/05/2022 14:17

He is legally entitled to the money from his half of the house, surely she knew that was the case when she put him on the deeds 🤷🏼‍♀️

She isn’t married to him, so she isn’t entitled to anything of his. We all know how it works, I don’t understand why women are still putting themselves in this situation.

She chose to have children with a man she wasn’t married to. Very silly indeed!

2022again · 23/05/2022 14:12

The answer to this may be no (sadly!) but have they previously made any other legal arrangements or even any informal written arrangements eg. wills, declaration of trust, co-habitation agreement, life insurance/income protection etc. I've only ever bought a property via mortgage so don't know how it works with cash but you can own a property either as joint tenants OR tenants in common so perhaps there is paperwork from when she bought the property that states this, these confer different benefits . I doubt the house would be able to be sold until the youngest has reached 18 anyway... "The Court must consider the intentions of the parties when they entered into the purchase of the property, the reasons behind that purchase and the welfare of any child under the age of 18 ".

There will be a document trail that shows she put the entirety of the house purchase cash in so I'm sure the courts would be acknowledging this and not award 50:50 seeing as he has far higher earning potential (unless he is intending to provide 50:50 of the childcare to allow her to work.)

PurassicJark · 23/05/2022 13:52

Oh good she does have proof, I cross posted. She may stand a chance then hopefully.

Oldieandgoldie · 23/05/2022 13:51

Urgent! Make sure all his messages are backed up somewhere, in case he gets to her phone.

PurassicJark · 23/05/2022 13:46

As someone else said, her only option is free advice from legal aid. She has no money from the sounds of it, it's all gone on the house and other things. So a shit hot lawyer is out of the question, she can't afford one. How would she pay the fees?

Reality is, she's probably screwed unfortunately. Even if she can get someone to help her, how is she going to prove he forced her? Does she have any messages to show he did?

bibbidibbobbidybo · 23/05/2022 13:37

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 21:31

How did she become isolated from her family?

Let me guess.. he didn't like them, they disapproved of him, so she cut them off.

God it's so depressingly familiar.

Bingo! Sad

OP posts:
bibbidibbobbidybo · 23/05/2022 13:35

Thanks yet again everyone for the comments.

After weeks of abuse and making her life hell now she's said she's leaving he's changing his tune and turning back into the 'perfect partner' and love bombing her with gifts etc but she is 100% sure this time that enough if enough.

Woman's aid is a good start and getting some good legal advice, I've been passing on the messages and my DF is very grateful.

It's so sad to see a man so hell bent on making a woman's life (and his childrens) hell because she wants to leave him.

She does have messages that prove he's said she can't work so I'm guessing this will be a good bit of evidence along with a lot more controlling behaviours (cameras around the house etc) and a tirade of abusive texts.

In all honestly all I want to do is call the police and get her out of there but she has asked I don't and I don't want to over step or make her life any harder!

Again, I really appreciate the comments.

OP posts:
Testina · 23/05/2022 13:23

Given that your friend has no money for a solicitor, I think the place to start is Women’s Aid as they’ll understand the situation only too well, sadly, and also can signpost to all the services she needs.

Please don’t let her near MN AIBU for any legal advice though!

Relationship advice is much better here though.

Testina · 23/05/2022 13:12

Onlyhuman123 · 23/05/2022 12:03

I haven't read all the responses so I may be repeating some but surely, if she was 'forced' to give up her career, she can demonstrate that she is therefore dependant on her partners income...she can therefore claim his pension. I'm sure he'll soon change his mind about having half the property value when he has to give up, possibly more than 50% of his pension.

@Onlyhuman123 honestly, why post shit like this? You say you haven’t read the thread - it’s only on page 2 and multiple people who are better informed that you would have given you pause for thought.

I’d love to know why you have the confidence to be “sure” on this, when you’re posting nonsense.

It’s so important not to go around posting utter crap like this, because it’s just going to end up with more people make awful choices.

I get that you don’t know. I don’t get your confidence in posting that you’re sure of things that you don’t know. And I sure as hell don’t get why you wouldn’t just RTFT first - or just scan it, it’s short!!

Please, stop posting crap like this.

HogInAManger · 23/05/2022 12:48

As others have said, your friend needs urgent legal advice. She might be able to get legal aid in view of the income and DA issues with a view to getting an occupation order to remove DP from the home.

Re the home, assuming it is in England and it is registered in the parties’ names at the land registry, the legal ownership is joint, (either 50/50 equity or a stated percentage of equity if tenants in common).

The starting point for the courts is that the beneficial ownership (ownership of the equity in the home) mirrors the legal ownership.

To get 100% ownership of the home back your friend will have to ask the court to disregard the legal ownership. There are some precedents in your friend’s situation but it is a very difficult and costly process to argue in court. This requires expert legal advice costing tens of thousands of pounds

Frankly, your friend’s best course of action is to seek free advice (via legal aid or from Shelter as a starting point). . Then sit tight, get an occupation order and make the other party take action to pursue their claim on the house (if they are so minded).

user1471462115 · 23/05/2022 12:19

And get the child benefit in her name, to give her the pension contributions towards state pension.

Ottersmith · 23/05/2022 12:16

She needs to call the police so that he goes to jail for coercive control and emotional abuse. That would be the first step.

Johnnysgirl · 23/05/2022 12:05

Onlyhuman123 · 23/05/2022 12:03

I haven't read all the responses so I may be repeating some but surely, if she was 'forced' to give up her career, she can demonstrate that she is therefore dependant on her partners income...she can therefore claim his pension. I'm sure he'll soon change his mind about having half the property value when he has to give up, possibly more than 50% of his pension.

She can't possibly prove she was forced to stop work, many women become sahm's through choice.
And they're not married, nothing entitles her to his pension.

Onlyhuman123 · 23/05/2022 12:03

I haven't read all the responses so I may be repeating some but surely, if she was 'forced' to give up her career, she can demonstrate that she is therefore dependant on her partners income...she can therefore claim his pension. I'm sure he'll soon change his mind about having half the property value when he has to give up, possibly more than 50% of his pension.

Andromachehadabadday · 23/05/2022 12:00

Crazycatlady83 · 22/05/2022 21:19

I think you are getting confused between a "Mesher Order" (deferred house sale on separation to allow one person to live in property until children are 18 and then sale) and a Occupation Order where a abusive partner is removed from the family home. These are normally time limited for 1 year (to allow proceedings to commence for divorce or sale of the house etc) Not rare at all and can't think of one person who ever regretted having a abusive partner removed from the family home

You are right. It’s the wrong terminology, I actually quoted someone above who mentioned an occupation order until the kids are older. But due to crappy mums et it didn’t pull through. That’s why I used the term occupation order. But also, you are incorrect I didn’t use mesher order, because they don’t apply if you aren’t married.

You know full well, since you knew what I was talking about I wasn’t referencing having an abusive partner removed when I talked about regret. Since I listed why people regret it. They often find that when it comes time to sell, their earning potential hasn’t increased by enough and they are priced out of the market.

cestlavielife · 23/05/2022 11:11

She needs to report him fir coercive control
Maybe go to a refuge
And fight for her share of house from there
But she has to tell it as it is
If he kicks off call police
That might even help with evidence if he does kick off

Sunshinegirl82 · 22/05/2022 21:34

This sounds like a really difficult situation. It would probably be worth calling this organisation:

rightsofwomen.org.uk/get-advice/

She might be able to get some help from them and if court action is necessary it might be possible to consider instructing a barrister on a Direct Access basis which can be cheaper.

www.directaccessportal.co.uk

billy1966 · 22/05/2022 21:34

I think she has to make it very clear when getting legal advice and calling Women's aid that she was forced by him to put him on the deeds.
Clearly against her best interests.
He does not share his assets.
He is financially abusive.
She is not allowed to work.

She needs to be very firm and immovable that she was forced to put him on the deeds.

That is coercive control and her best chance of helping herself is to be very clear on this point.

AhNowTed · 22/05/2022 21:31

How did she become isolated from her family?

Let me guess.. he didn't like them, they disapproved of him, so she cut them off.

God it's so depressingly familiar.