Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the hell do you do in this situation?

90 replies

bibbidibbobbidybo · 22/05/2022 13:23

Posting so I can try give advice to a lovely friend of mine who is suffering and at a loss as to what she can do.

Il keep it as short as I can.

DF (friend) bought house cash with inheritance a couple of years ago and put partners name on the deeds also (not married) they have 2 DC.

Relationship needs to end, he is controlling, a bully, manipulator and I believe mentally abusive. Poor DF is in bits things are not good at home at all.

Her partner is the breadwinner she is a SAHM and has no income at all other than money partner will send her for things (again very controlling)

She wants to end the relationship but he will not leave the house unless she agrees to sell and give him 50%. He already has quite a high paid job and savings where as DF has nothing but the house as she put all her money into that and also gave up working to please him. She is primary career to the children and when I say that she does 99.9% of everything with the children.

She has nowhere she can go, and cannot claim any benefits until he's left the house which he will not do. She doesn't want to give him 50% as that will leave her struggling to buy another House and would most definitely mean the children will have to move schools and areas.

Please could anyone offer any advice as to what would be her best options in this situation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TunaSalad · 25/05/2022 14:06

Ah sorry I under estimated the situation there. I know when my ex was in the @Mr Wonderful Oh So Sorry' phase, I could have gotten away with a little more than usual.
I see that's not the case here.

Such a horrible state of affairs to be trapped in this situation, your poor friend.

JanglyBeads · 25/05/2022 07:29

Financial abuse included in Coercive Control law which came into force last year; this article links to how various banks etc are tackling it

news.trust.org/item/20210429151515-6tobl/

Bogeyes · 25/05/2022 03:25

Was she bullied or coerced into putting his name on the deeds? Legal advice needed here

billy1966 · 24/05/2022 23:54

It is a crime.

I wonder would it be worth the OP going to the police and asking advice from them.

OhamIreally · 24/05/2022 15:11

Your poor friend. This level of coercive control is a crime now. It's not legal to treat another person like this.
Can she ask Women's aid what the likelihood is of a conviction if she goes to the police?

Do you know if he's working PAYE or self employed?

Johnnysgirl · 24/05/2022 14:02

Fair enough, op.

Realistically, though, all she's going to walk away with is her 50% of the house value. The rest is his.

bibbidibbobbidybo · 24/05/2022 13:52

@Johnnysgirl

While I understand what you are saying sometimes it's not as cut and dry and it would seem.

My friend has now been out of work for over 6 years, she has lost a lot of confidence, she has 0 money. He sends her money for fuel and buys her clothes (part of the control I've spoke about) she is still living in the house with him until they are able to sell it. He will not help with childcare at all and is often out of the house from 8am to 11pm (straight to pub after work) he has said he will take all the clothes he's bought her which will leave her with nothing. She has no family to help support her. She doesn't have enough money to even get the children into nursery at the moment and the reality of it is that at the moment it is just not a viable option. She has lived with years of abuse and control and it's very scary having to leave your home, take your children, start from scratch with no money and very little support.

So while I appreciate that technically she could get a job at the moment your comment is not helpful as the most important thing right now is getting her and the children away from him and making sure she walks away with something. He has already told her that she is finished if she goes through this and he will take everything she has. I'm not sure she's in the mental space to go to work right now.

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 23/05/2022 20:48

Testina · 23/05/2022 20:45

@SlightlyGeordieJohn “She doesn’t need his permission to work” - in what way is that a useful contribution to the thread? Especially posted after quoting the ways in which the husband stops her?

Op says she's leaving him, why would a threat to end the relationship if she gets a job hold any weight now?

TheHumanExperience · 23/05/2022 20:46

It would be good if she could gather all the evidence she needs. This way she can take it with her. Women's Aid is a good place to start. I'm sure if he has control of all the purse string, she hasn't got money for a soliciter. Evidence is always key. Text messages, Emails, voice messages, bank statements, proof of inheritance and where the money was withdrawn for the house purchase etc etc

Testina · 23/05/2022 20:45

@SlightlyGeordieJohn “She doesn’t need his permission to work” - in what way is that a useful contribution to the thread? Especially posted after quoting the ways in which the husband stops her?

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 23/05/2022 19:53

bibbidibbobbidybo · 23/05/2022 19:04

Unfortunately this isn't an option as he won't allow her to work. He worries about her being around other men in the work place (she's never gave him any reason to) and this is a big point of tension in the relationship. If she even mentions it then it turns into explosive rows. He has told her she is never to work while they are together. Children are 2 and 4 and without help towards childcare she would be working for nothing until they are older so right now it wouldn't help the situationSad

I think at this point and after making some calls she's going to put the house up and walk away with 50%, rent and hopefully get back on her feet.

She doesn’t need his permission to work.

Octomore · 23/05/2022 19:28

Hopefully with good legal advice she may be able to prove coercion, it sadly things are stacked against her.

She effectively gave him half the house when she put him on the deeds, whereas he has never signed over any rights to his assets

Bonheurdupasse · 23/05/2022 19:21

Johnnysgirl · 23/05/2022 18:36

So if she can prove that he only has 50% legal ownership due to Undue Influence
How would someone with full mental capacity prove such a thing?

@Johnnysgirl
There is case law on this, it can be done by people who were compos mentis if they were in a vulnerable position relative to the other party.
Legal advice received at the time would however work against that. However the coercive control if provable would work against that (legal advice) again.
It would be very case specific.

bibbidibbobbidybo · 23/05/2022 19:08

Johnnysgirl · 23/05/2022 18:38

I also don't understand why the "he wouldn't let me work, he told me the relationship would be over if I did" holds water when she's leaving anyway?

While she is still living in the home he will offer no support with the children, no money towards childcare (deposits, months up front for nursery etc) he won't give her fuel money, he will make life unbareable.

I know it's hard to understand but this is a lady who gave up her career and has lost a lot of confidence and all independence. If I could offer more financial support to her I would but unfortunately I'm unable to.

We also have school holidays coming up and as he will not help towards childcare cost I'm not sure how she would even afford the nursery even while earning.

As I mentioned before no contact with any family anymore.

OP posts:
bibbidibbobbidybo · 23/05/2022 19:04

TunaSalad · 23/05/2022 16:56

Whilst he is in best behaviour mode can your friend take advantage of that and start applying for jobs?

If there is no violence or danger she might be best playing the long game and getting herself an income in the view to mortgaging half the house and buying him out as soon as she possibly can. It seems unlikely that she can avoid giving him the 50%

The problem with deferring the sale, is that houses often increase in value and she will have to give him half of the value at the point of sale. Depending on her earning potential she might not be able to afford to remortgage at that point.

How old are the children?

Unfortunately this isn't an option as he won't allow her to work. He worries about her being around other men in the work place (she's never gave him any reason to) and this is a big point of tension in the relationship. If she even mentions it then it turns into explosive rows. He has told her she is never to work while they are together. Children are 2 and 4 and without help towards childcare she would be working for nothing until they are older so right now it wouldn't help the situationSad

I think at this point and after making some calls she's going to put the house up and walk away with 50%, rent and hopefully get back on her feet.

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 23/05/2022 18:38

I also don't understand why the "he wouldn't let me work, he told me the relationship would be over if I did" holds water when she's leaving anyway?

Johnnysgirl · 23/05/2022 18:36

So if she can prove that he only has 50% legal ownership due to Undue Influence
How would someone with full mental capacity prove such a thing?

RedHelenB · 23/05/2022 18:29

Threetulips · 22/05/2022 16:47

He wouldn’t get 50% as he has two children who need a roof over their heads.
She needs a lot of paperwork and a decent solicitor.

He would as they're not married and both names are on the deeds. He may have to wait though, given there are children involved.

Bonheurdupasse · 23/05/2022 17:17

She needs a solicitor.
I would think perhaps not trusts but similar - a similar part of law, equity.

So if she can prove that he only has 50% legal ownership due to Undue Influence. And that indeed resulted in him getting the 50% being an Unconscionable transaction.
And hence she should have full equitable ownership of the house. (Ie in equity rather than common law) And the court should translate that into 100% legal ownership as well.

TunaSalad · 23/05/2022 16:56

Whilst he is in best behaviour mode can your friend take advantage of that and start applying for jobs?

If there is no violence or danger she might be best playing the long game and getting herself an income in the view to mortgaging half the house and buying him out as soon as she possibly can. It seems unlikely that she can avoid giving him the 50%

The problem with deferring the sale, is that houses often increase in value and she will have to give him half of the value at the point of sale. Depending on her earning potential she might not be able to afford to remortgage at that point.

How old are the children?

AchatAVendre · 23/05/2022 16:48

LemonTT I would say that although she should explore whether he coerced her into signing over the house, it will be an upward struggle. He will argue that he invested in the home and supported the household when they were together which is presumably longer than the the two years since she bought the house. Where did they live before this and who paid for it?

I think it will be almost impossible for the OP to claim that signing away half her house (and therefore inheritance) was invalid. It was only 2 years ago, she must have had legal advice telling her of all the risks and making it clear that it was her choice to do so, that she wasn't married and so on, presumably have been advised to make a will because they're not married and own property together and so on.

Even in cases of marriage fraud (where one partner marries another to try and gain financial advantage), its hardly ever successfully challenged. Different if there was a big difference in cognitive abilities, or one of them was much older and more infirm that the other (and even then its an uphill struggle), but its hard to see any successful challenge here.

Unless she has proof of threats of abuse, violence, etc?

LemonTT · 23/05/2022 16:30

They are not married so unless they actively created joint ownership of an asset, none exists. They did this for the house but not the pension. The house is now a joint asset. Giving him an apparent entitlement to half the value.

She has the following entitlements and rights.

She can report his abuse to the police. This is the act from which everything springs. Because then she take steps to get an occupation order to remove him from the house.

She can try to access legal aid.

A mesher order won’t apply because they are not married. But she can apply under the childrens act to defer sale of the house even if they are not married.

She can claim CMS, which he will be obliged to pay whether he likes it or not. If he is PAYE, he can’t avoid paying. If he is self employed he can manipulate his income and avoid it.

She can claim benefits.

I would say that although she should explore whether he coerced her into signing over the house, it will be an upward struggle. He will argue that he invested in the home and supported the household when they were together which is presumably longer than the the two years since she bought the house. Where did they live before this and who paid for it?

Vikinga · 23/05/2022 16:13

My friend was able to claim benefits when she split with her ex (they weren't married) even though still lived together for another year.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 23/05/2022 16:04

HogInAManger · 23/05/2022 15:32

Yes where domestic violence occurs the family court can (and does!) grant an occupation order forbidding a legal owner from living in a home they own.

This is however usually a time limited order pending completion of the sale of the property (to give parties time to re-arrange their affairs and go their separate ways).

What relevance does domestic violence have in this case though?