Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not forgive friend's DH for DV

61 replies

Oysterbabe · 22/05/2022 13:23

A couple of years ago a friend's DH beat her up and threw her down the stairs. She required hospital treatment but made a full recovery. He was arrested and they split up. Several months later they quietly got back together.

Today we met coffee and she brought him with her. It's the first time I've seen him since it happened. I was coldly civil. AIBU for not forgiving him when she has?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HikingforScenery · 22/05/2022 17:34

Of course yanbu. I would not want anything to do with her. Why did he come with her? Is he controlling her?

DinoWoman · 22/05/2022 17:30

Oh, hell no. I would be politely asking to only meet up one on one with your friend going forward. If she queries it then you can always say that it just changes the dynamic when he is there. I wouldn't forgive him and I'd want nothing to do with him.

Redruby2020 · 22/05/2022 17:29

Georgeskitchen · 22/05/2022 13:50

YANBU. The fact he came with her is a red flag in my book.
I know of no man, including my OH, who would willingly come along to a girls catch up

Exactly lol nor my abusive ex, he wouldn't of come along either and didn't. People thought cos I went out freely on nights out that there was no way he was abusive or controlling, but there are so many different ways in which someone can be abusive.

Evilista · 22/05/2022 17:29

I would struggle not to tell him what i thought of him or leave.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 22/05/2022 17:27

The level of violence he inflicted was brutal.
I couldn't forgive him, she must have very low self esteem.
The control is already happening him coming out for lunch is telling.

Redruby2020 · 22/05/2022 17:25

Lavenderlast · 22/05/2022 13:33

Yanbu for not forgiving the unforgivable, but you were perhaps unwise to show him how you feel. DV abusers usually cut their victims off from those who might support/encourage them to leave. I suspect she didn’t bring him to coffee, he insisted on coming. Red flag. He’ll control all of her friendships and if he senses hostility he’ll try to end the friendship. Be careful what text messages you send to her, he is probably reading them.

Abusers don’t suddenly turn into nice guys. He will hurt her again. All you can do is be someone she can run to for help when she needs it and not let him cut you off.

Thankyou! I've had someone I know, say to me, if it's not true that they can change, then why can they switch it on and off 🤔 I was like 🤔 well for that exact reason, because they choose who to do it to, and who they CAN do it to, most importantly.

Redruby2020 · 22/05/2022 17:22

orwellwasright · 22/05/2022 13:28

Such a difficult one. If you come away from them as a couple you risk alienating her. She's going to need her friends for the next time he tries to kill her.

Thankyou! I was hoping someone was going to say it as it is. I cannot believe the above posters comment, hence why i had to chip in. I agree it is a difficult situation as the friend is still OP's friend. I guess for a start it would mean being supportive and not meeting up with him in tow!

IncompleteSenten · 22/05/2022 17:20

You are under no obligation to have anything to do with him.
I know I couldn't.

Redruby2020 · 22/05/2022 17:20

bellac11 · 22/05/2022 13:28

Yes because its for you to forgive or not forgive.

You dont know whats happened in terms of therapy, change, remorse etcetc

Despite the general narrative,, domestic abusers can change, it is very unusual and doesnt happen often but it does happen sometimes. This might be one of those times who knows

Okay maybe not for the OP to have to worry about, more her friend. But I couldn't care a less whether a small percentage can change/there is remorse have some self respect that it is just not acceptable! And never proof that they won't do it again.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 22/05/2022 17:16

I wouldn't want to risk isolating my friend , chances are he'll do it again. It's bloody hard having to talk to the bastard though

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 17:10

Perhaps MN need to have a section where Domestic Violence can be discussed, if it doesn't already exist?

For crying out loud @LookItsMeAgain domestic violence doesn't need to pigeonholed or swept under a convenient carpet any more than is currently is.

It is a real life problem, & need to be discussed in real life settings.
Not consigned to some speciality section, just so that those who don't like it & don't get it can crack on with their nice non-abused lives without having to think too hard about all the unpleasantness.

btw - MN does have a few places where DV can be discussed without so much risk of people making ridiculous statements or dangerous assumptions.
Try the Feminism boards, or Relationships (altho you must surely already be aware of the very popular Relationships boards, where DA, DV, & coercive control are discussed daily? Are you being disingenous?)

RoyKentsChestHair · 22/05/2022 17:03

LookItsMeAgain · 22/05/2022 15:36

To be honest, if he thought it was ok once to beat his wife and throw her down the stairs, there is nothing, absolutely nothing at all on this planet that would stop him from doing it again.

Had I been in your shoes, as they approached, I would have stood up and said "If you think it's ok to hang around with a wife-beater then that's on you. I supported you during your recovery from the injuries he inflicted. However I don't have to be around him" and I would have left.

I wouldn't raise my voice but I'd say it with a very cold distain in my voice.

I honestly don't understand why women keep going back to the men that abuse them. Over and over and over it happens. I just don't get it.

Clearly.

You have no idea what you’re talking about and your holier than thou approach would probably have got your friend beaten up again. Good work.

madeleine85 · 22/05/2022 16:56

be very careful with how you communicate your feelings about this to your friend please. If he came to meet you he could be monitoring her, including her messages and calls. If you talk about him, make sure it is in person only when he isn’t there. It’s really hard and it’s unlikely he will ever truly change. She is likely feeling nervous and scared, and very judged which will make her isolated which is what he wants. If you consistently talk negatively on him you are likely to push her away in general. Though having the occasional “I love you, he hurt you, and I don’t want to ruin our friendship, so how do we get through this while you’re dating conversation? I want to support you but for obvious reasons I don’t want to have him forced on me” is maybe a good safe space conversation. The best thing imo you can do is be civil/non committal about him when he’s around/over the phone so he can’t insist she doesn’t see you. Just move the conversation onto other topics. In person try to give her space to talk and let her feel she can trust you. It’s sad but in a year or so she will probably be restarting her life without him, after another attack, and she’s going to need friends she can trust. If you flat out write her off (which you can), he wins. It’s unfortunately so easy for an abuser to win. Hoping she is ok when inevitably this all finishes.

oakleaffy · 22/05/2022 16:42

It’ll be bound to happen again.
The abuse.
Like a volcano, he’ll erupt again and cause harm to a woman.
My friend got back with a nasty abuser- after years apart
She has disappeared.
I just hope wherever she is with their child, she is safe and not a human kickboxing target/punchbag like before.

lljkk · 22/05/2022 16:30

Assuming OP doesn't plan to act like the violence never happened, I don't think it's going to help OP or friend if OP is obviously cold to him. I could be civil but not friendly. I'm also not going to condemn anyone who tells him to his face what bad things he's done, either. Like others said, the problem is can you watch your friend choosing to stay with him, building a future with him. This is very difficult. I probably couldn't do it.

Friend took back her cheating husband (for a while) & some other persons in her support network cut her off for that duration. It was a polite "Because I care about you, I can't handle knowing this is in your life so I can't be around you" kind of situation for them.

LookItsMeAgain · 22/05/2022 16:17

Sorry @Oysterbabe for the thread being derailed by people focussing on my posts and not the situation you found yourself in.

I don't think you did anything wrong either. Be frosty, don't include him in the conversation, block him out. Be there for your friend, if you feel you can be. You owe him nothing.

As for the others, you don't know my situation. Probably best if you don't make assumptions.

I'll bow out of this thread and wish you and your friend all the best.

LookItsMeAgain · 22/05/2022 16:09

Wow @KettrickenSmiled !
Just wow!

This AIBU. If the OP wanted a balanced reasonable response, she probably should have posted under "Relationships". Perhaps MN need to have a section where Domestic Violence can be discussed, if it doesn't already exist?

I'm entitled (however misguided) to my opinion and you are not allowed to tear me to shreds for typing that opinion. Fine, you may not agree with that opinion, but I'm not swearing at you. I didn't swear in my post either and I'm trying really hard to not tell you where to go with your pseudo-psychobabble.

Why would getting up and leaving if I saw the two of them approaching would be 'fantasy'? Perhaps I wouldn't speak to them, I would be thinking those things, (which in itself would be considered rude) but I don't have to spend my time with them if I was only expecting to meet her.

Oysterbabe · 22/05/2022 16:07

I didn't know he was coming and he was just there when I got there. Apparently he was meeting someone in town later so thought he'd tag along and they'd travel in together. I was a bit blindsided so maybe didn't deal with it in the optimum way but it's tricky knowing how to be with him.

OP posts:
sweatervest · 22/05/2022 16:06

A safeguarding lady recently said thhat it takes aan average of 50 instances of abuse before anyone discloses anything. (that was so true for me).

I tried to talk to people about it but they thought I was being stupid (literally)

I have no point to this post but its worrying thaat your friend is back with him.
Please bear in mind that 50 instances statistic.
I knew all about the free half hour with a solicitor, hide your passport, an average of eight attempts to leave someone. I thought I knew it all but I was so catastrophically wrong.

I just hope your friend is okay and not being controlled.

Whiskeypowers · 22/05/2022 16:03

LookItsMeAgain · 22/05/2022 15:36

To be honest, if he thought it was ok once to beat his wife and throw her down the stairs, there is nothing, absolutely nothing at all on this planet that would stop him from doing it again.

Had I been in your shoes, as they approached, I would have stood up and said "If you think it's ok to hang around with a wife-beater then that's on you. I supported you during your recovery from the injuries he inflicted. However I don't have to be around him" and I would have left.

I wouldn't raise my voice but I'd say it with a very cold distain in my voice.

I honestly don't understand why women keep going back to the men that abuse them. Over and over and over it happens. I just don't get it.

Do you really not understand?

let me help you out a bit.


  • children

  • fear

  • stigma

  • not being believed or supported by agencies / authorities

  • lack of financial independence

  • lack of familial support of friends around to support

  • misguided hope that they will change

  • that somehow it’s their fault


this is just for starters
be incredibly grateful you don’t understand but educate yourself instead of judging because it is the hardest thing to do as well as statistically the most dangerous course of action

Whiskeypowers · 22/05/2022 15:56

FlowersFlowersEverywhere · 22/05/2022 13:33

The fact she brought him with her would be a red flag to me - if it was supposed to be just the two of you meeting up, why didn’t she come on her own? I wouldn’t have been civil, to be honest. Whether she has got back with him or not, I don’t have to like, or speak to, a man capable of DV, and neither do you.

This

Peoniesandcream · 22/05/2022 15:54

@cleareyesfulhearts yup! I put up with my abuser for too long and I was definitely stupid doing that, until I saw sense and realised my safety relied on me escaping.

girlmom21 · 22/05/2022 15:54

Please just make sure she knows she's always got you.

If there was physical abuse and they've got back together within a matter of months I'd strongly suspect psychological abuse too.

She might not need you now but eventually it'll happen again. Make sure you're there for when she does.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 15:51

LookItsMeAgain · 22/05/2022 15:36

To be honest, if he thought it was ok once to beat his wife and throw her down the stairs, there is nothing, absolutely nothing at all on this planet that would stop him from doing it again.

Had I been in your shoes, as they approached, I would have stood up and said "If you think it's ok to hang around with a wife-beater then that's on you. I supported you during your recovery from the injuries he inflicted. However I don't have to be around him" and I would have left.

I wouldn't raise my voice but I'd say it with a very cold distain in my voice.

I honestly don't understand why women keep going back to the men that abuse them. Over and over and over it happens. I just don't get it.

You're absolutely correct @LookItsMeAgain. You don't get it.

Do you know what would happen after your fantasy scenario?
At best - H interrogates friend when he gets her home. Why was your friend so rude why are you talking shit about me is this how you repay me for being your god what is your awful woman's problem you are not allowed to talk to people that diss me how many other people have you been talking to show me your phone & private messages do you realise how much you have hurt me why are you always like this it always has to be all about you you are a selfish cow & your friends are all manhaters you will end up alone you are lucky I put up with you & your ugly face nobody else would have you ...
Even you get the picture I hope.

At worst - all of the above, plus he beats her up again.
While telling her it's her fault for trash-talking him behind his back to manhaters.
And she will not tell you about any of this, because you are not safe or trustworthy, & will do something to get her beaten up again.
Maybe that's all that's important to you - to feel superior & not have to deal with the unpleasantness of supporting a friend.

I honestly don't understand why women keep going back to the men that abuse them.
Then I suggest your get yourself fucking educated before spouting off juvenile & dangerous Heroine Fantasies on threads about domestic violence.
www.womensaid.org.uk/the-survivors-handbook/im-worried-about-someone-else/

What did you genuinely imagine would be the result of your stupidity if you acted like this in real life? The man falls at your feet, apologising, & promising to mend his ways? Or the woman weeps with awed gratitude, & LTB that very minute?
Pur-lease. Stop with the self-aggrandising posturing already.

WallaceinAnderland · 22/05/2022 15:40

I would not be around a man that beat up a woman. Why did he have to be there, is he controlling her. She is still with an abusive man. I would let her know I would be there to support her leaving him if that was the case but I would not be in his company.

Swipe left for the next trending thread