Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate most mixed sex fitting rooms

182 replies

Humbold · 22/05/2022 12:45

I haven't been out shopping much post-Covid because it seemed pointless when the fitting rooms were closed. Went with my teenage daughter to pick up some summer clothes this week and was shocked by how many stores have gone for mixed sex changing rooms.

First stop was Primark. Headed to fitting room and noticed the mixed queue, got to the head and was pointed to changing area "it's mixed just pick any cubicle". I was a bit surprised but went with it thinking it would be fine as long as there were self-contained cubicles with floor-to-ceiling lockable doors. Got met with row upon row of curtained cubicles, hard to see which ones were occupied without angling myself to check down the gap at the side (they never seem to close over properly without much faffing) or looking at the bottom to see if I could see feet. Gingerly opened one and to my relief it was free. I hated it.

I was trying on a dress that involved me taking my shoes off and stripping down to my bra and knickers. My elbow would move the curtain every now and again so I was constantly checking it was closed over properly. I could hear teenage lads walking past and the girl in the next cubicle was squeezed in with her boyfriend who was chatting away. It was crazy. I felt so vulnerable and tense so didn't bother trying my other 2 dresses on.

Previously I would have got an outfit on and maybe if I needed help with the zip or wanted my friend/daughter's opinion I would come out into the communal area and look in the full length mirror. I might come out partially dressed (unbuttoned, unzipped etc...) and ask an assistant for the next size up etc... But there's no way you can do that in this mixed setting. When I pulled back the curtain there was a man waiting at the end of one row, looking on his phone, probably just waiting on his wife or girlfriend. It just felt wrong.

I remember when there were communal changing rooms and they were bad enough but at least they weren't mixed. My DD said she went to H&M with her boyfriend and they were exactly the same - just curtained. Her boyfriend came in and just sat on the floor at the end of a row of curtained cubicles and she said it didn't feel right but didn't say anything.

I've been to Cos and their changing rooms are completely self-contained, lockable, floor-to-ceiling cubicles. It's on a much smaller scale too which helps - probably a max of 10 cubicles. I can deal with that. But since when did shops think they could pile in 30/40/50 curtained spaces and mix in men with women and make the changing experience so bloody horrible? I haven't been in an M&S changing room for a while - are any of theirs going mixed? I'm concerned it's becoming a trend and I don't understand why.

As a young girl I'd have been worried about lads pulling back curtains 'accidentally'. As an adult I'm worried about anyone pulling back a curtain and exposing me in a state of undress but more uncomfortable if there's a chance my best mate's Dad is stood there! I'm not keen on shopping at the best of times but if this is the way things are going, it's online all the way for me. The High Street can do one.

AIBU?

OP posts:
TreesAtSea · 22/05/2022 15:58

My local Primark has this too. I knew the main changing rooms were mixed-sex but had naively thought the ones right next to the lingerie and children's clothes wouldn't be. Started trying on bras then heard two young men chatting in the cubicle next to mine, with another walking back and forth. Later spoke to the assistant who was very nice but said the only other option would be to use the disabled cubicle, which was the only one fully enclosed and lockable. Hardly fair on disabled people, of course, and anyway not the point. Needless to say I won't be back. Did tweet them but they didn't have the courtesy to reply. The complete disregard for women's safety and privacy makes me so mad. The only solution is for women and girls en masse to boycott these stores and to tell them why. Hit their profits and they'll take notice.

settingsunshine · 22/05/2022 15:54

I have to say I avoid clothes shops which do this unless the doors are properly lockable and open onto the shop floor or an open space as I suffer from slightly from anxiety and being naked or semi-clothes in a communal space would make me feel anxious.

Shame my feelings don't count.

I assume we are going back to the good old days when men can flash at women and children and it's just accepted that's the price we pay for being female and more vulnerable

Soontobe60 · 22/05/2022 15:47

user1474315215 · 22/05/2022 12:51

It honestly wouldn't bother me. You were no less clothed than you would be on the beach or in the swimming pool.

In that case why don't we do away with separate cubicles completely? In fact, do away with changing rooms and try clothes on on the shop floor!

TammyOne · 22/05/2022 15:44

I really don’t want to be in my bra and knickers behind a flappy curtain with men around either Geordie quite aside from when trying on bras (or sun dresses, swimwear, or anything else you would might take your bra off to try on).
Anyway, why is just not wanting to use mixed sex changing rooms not enough of a reason for shops to stop with this nonsense? I also don’t want to be in a mixed sex hospital ward with one of those arse exposing gowns on. NOT because any man would be dying to look at my arse, just because I don’t want to. That should be enough of reason.

Rainbowshit · 22/05/2022 15:39

Do women get naked when trying clothes on? I think most men would tend to keep their underwear on.

You can't really try a bra or a bikini top on with your underwear on FFs. Typical males having zero understanding of the issues women face and thinning they can comment.

Rainbowshit · 22/05/2022 15:38

I took my 12 year old DD into H&M. She was obviously very uncomfortable with the boys sitting on the sofa in the changing room just outside the cubicle while she was changing. The curtains didn't close across properly so I had to hold them.

It was very unfair on her.

LocalHobo · 22/05/2022 15:31

@Holly60
I don't really get why it's different with men though. I've always done the uncomfortable dance even in single sex changing rooms. Why is the fact that some of the people happen to have willies more uncomfortable? 😂

TBH I would rather I knew men were present than, in a female only space, encountering a person choosing to identify as female.

SlightlyGeordieJohn · 22/05/2022 15:17

skilpadde · 22/05/2022 13:19

You've never understood? The statistics on sexual crimes would enlighten you as to why it's much more frightening to be naked in front of men than women.

Do women get naked when trying clothes on? I think most men would tend to keep their underwear on.

daretodenim · 22/05/2022 15:13

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10300295/Bearded-6ft-reporter-let-female-changing-room-stores.html

A DM writer tested it out - but there were actually women’s changing rooms then!

daretodenim · 22/05/2022 15:11

Here's why OP:

We have to have men in our changing rooms - to the point of them being "mixed sex" because it's not fair on shop assistants to put them in the position of policing the men who enter. Any man is a woman if he says so and there's no way of knowing if he's temporarily identifying, just to get the the female space, or he's got a psychological condition that makes him apparently believe he's literally a woman. There's also no way to differentiate these two types of men now, because bring a woman isn't biological, it's how you feel. What a man wears, how he presents, has no bearing on his womanhood.

So it saves the shops a whole lot of hassle, plus being targeted as transphobic by Stonewall and Mermaids, as well as randoms on Twitter who start boycotts, if women just accept that they are being silly if they feel uncomfortable around men. After all, silly woman, not only might that man be a woman, he may also see women in his daily life so why would he think anything about your body? Also, there are other women who don't mind getting undressed in front of men - it's just bodies - so you need to get over yourself.

Humbold · 22/05/2022 15:10

I think I might write to H&M and Primark and see why they've done this. Is it a space saving issue? Or do they think people genuinely don't mind? Have they asked their customers via surveys? It just seems quite a rash thing to do. I half expected my DD to give me a bit of an eye-roll but she felt the same. She hasn't had a huge amount of shopping experience be ause of Covid and would probably just buy something and take it back if it didn't fit. But I thought it would be an enjoyable thing to do and we could have a bit of a laugh trying on stuff that we'd probably not consider normally. This experience felt like a grit-your-teeth ordeal to be got through as quickly as possible. Not conducive to selling more clothes I don't think.

I wonder if Primark and H&M are doing this UK-wide or just trialling it in certain cities?

OP posts:
TammyOne · 22/05/2022 15:07

I hate them too. I’m not scared of men in changing rooms on the whole I just don’t want to strip off next to them. If I had female children I would be very unhappy about them changing behind flimsy curtains with men and older boys around. Also I watched that documentary about South Korea and the epidemic of secret filming which made me really conscious of how easy it is to plant filming devices places. Why make it easier for perverts, I don’t get it??

Bonjovispjs · 22/05/2022 14:55

I had no idea this was happening until I heard a man coughing next to me in a primark changing room, I got out of there pretty quickly and won't be using them again, it's ridiculous!

Beamur · 22/05/2022 14:53

I don't like them at all.
There are some changing facilities near me at a water feature very popular with children. I was advised by the attendant not to leave DD to change alone and to effectively stand guard by the door as they have a huge issue with men taking photos under the doors.

WallaceinAnderland · 22/05/2022 14:53

It honestly wouldn't bother me. You were no less clothed than you would be on the beach or in the swimming pool.

That's really great for you isn't it. You can get changed right in the middle of the store, you don't even need changing rooms at all. Smashing 😊

For most of us though, we prefer the privacy of a changing area away from prying eyes and the safeguarding of not being vulnerable around males who may or may not be predatory.

WeWillLookBack · 22/05/2022 14:52

twitter.com/SuzzanBlac/status/1453001944373604367

There have been many more too ....

They know that mixed-sex changing rooms are more dangerous - but just for females. So it doesn't matter. I don't shop on the hughstreet anymore - I order online and I send loads back.

Ncwinc · 22/05/2022 14:48

www.lbc.co.uk/news/met-officer-admits-secretly-filming-woman-primark/

A met police officer admitted secretly filming a woman in Primark changing rooms.

Ncwinc · 22/05/2022 14:45

’Mixed sex changing room put women at increased risk of sexual assault, harassment, and voyeurism.’

This. Though I’d change it to women and girls. Teenaged girls are more vulnerable, more likely to be targeted and less likely (than older women) to challenge or report behaviour.

SierraSapphire · 22/05/2022 14:43

From Govt statistics 98% sexual assault perpetrated by men. https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/articles/natureofsexualassaultbyrapeorpenetrationenglandandwales/yearendingmarch2020

At least we've not yet had "should lesbians be banned from changing rooms too?" Hmm

DdraigGoch · 22/05/2022 14:41

men aren't anymore dangerous than woman, plenty of woman have been convicted of sex crimes.

@Grumpybutfunny are you going to quantify that claim?

user75 · 22/05/2022 14:38

Grumpybutfunny · 22/05/2022 13:57

@Albgo men aren't anymore dangerous than woman, plenty of woman have been convicted of sex crimes. Thinking back to my childhood it would have been girls who were bullies that would have pulled back the curtain to embarrass the girl inside, boys would have just had a good scrap and that wouldn't have been the end of it. If a boy had pulled back the curtain they would have already been legging it in the opposite direction laughing. As a teenage girl I often had to get dressed infront of boys most looked the other way and blushed if they got a look!!

As for if a man opened the curtain I very much doubt he wouldn't be the only other person in the changing room to have any opportunity to do anything but look.

You are either stupid, a troll or a mens rights activist. Men carry out well over 90% of sex crimes.

user75 · 22/05/2022 14:36

I was videoed in a mixed sex changing room. The man was just walking up and down filming. The staff did nothing. It was Topshop/Topman in Leeds. It has shut now.

MoobsAreNotBoobs · 22/05/2022 14:31

I will not use mixed sex changing rooms. Who the fuck thinks that’s a good idea. 🙄

PriamFarrl · 22/05/2022 14:20

Grumpybutfunny · 22/05/2022 13:57

@Albgo men aren't anymore dangerous than woman, plenty of woman have been convicted of sex crimes. Thinking back to my childhood it would have been girls who were bullies that would have pulled back the curtain to embarrass the girl inside, boys would have just had a good scrap and that wouldn't have been the end of it. If a boy had pulled back the curtain they would have already been legging it in the opposite direction laughing. As a teenage girl I often had to get dressed infront of boys most looked the other way and blushed if they got a look!!

As for if a man opened the curtain I very much doubt he wouldn't be the only other person in the changing room to have any opportunity to do anything but look.

Are you actually fucking kidding me?

schnubbins · 22/05/2022 14:16

I hate it also .But also cannot stand when men think they can shilly shally through the lingerie department.There I am trying on a thousand bras and some eejit of a man walking backwards and forwards bringing his wife stuff to try on but always peeping through the curtain when passing.