Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate most mixed sex fitting rooms

182 replies

Humbold · 22/05/2022 12:45

I haven't been out shopping much post-Covid because it seemed pointless when the fitting rooms were closed. Went with my teenage daughter to pick up some summer clothes this week and was shocked by how many stores have gone for mixed sex changing rooms.

First stop was Primark. Headed to fitting room and noticed the mixed queue, got to the head and was pointed to changing area "it's mixed just pick any cubicle". I was a bit surprised but went with it thinking it would be fine as long as there were self-contained cubicles with floor-to-ceiling lockable doors. Got met with row upon row of curtained cubicles, hard to see which ones were occupied without angling myself to check down the gap at the side (they never seem to close over properly without much faffing) or looking at the bottom to see if I could see feet. Gingerly opened one and to my relief it was free. I hated it.

I was trying on a dress that involved me taking my shoes off and stripping down to my bra and knickers. My elbow would move the curtain every now and again so I was constantly checking it was closed over properly. I could hear teenage lads walking past and the girl in the next cubicle was squeezed in with her boyfriend who was chatting away. It was crazy. I felt so vulnerable and tense so didn't bother trying my other 2 dresses on.

Previously I would have got an outfit on and maybe if I needed help with the zip or wanted my friend/daughter's opinion I would come out into the communal area and look in the full length mirror. I might come out partially dressed (unbuttoned, unzipped etc...) and ask an assistant for the next size up etc... But there's no way you can do that in this mixed setting. When I pulled back the curtain there was a man waiting at the end of one row, looking on his phone, probably just waiting on his wife or girlfriend. It just felt wrong.

I remember when there were communal changing rooms and they were bad enough but at least they weren't mixed. My DD said she went to H&M with her boyfriend and they were exactly the same - just curtained. Her boyfriend came in and just sat on the floor at the end of a row of curtained cubicles and she said it didn't feel right but didn't say anything.

I've been to Cos and their changing rooms are completely self-contained, lockable, floor-to-ceiling cubicles. It's on a much smaller scale too which helps - probably a max of 10 cubicles. I can deal with that. But since when did shops think they could pile in 30/40/50 curtained spaces and mix in men with women and make the changing experience so bloody horrible? I haven't been in an M&S changing room for a while - are any of theirs going mixed? I'm concerned it's becoming a trend and I don't understand why.

As a young girl I'd have been worried about lads pulling back curtains 'accidentally'. As an adult I'm worried about anyone pulling back a curtain and exposing me in a state of undress but more uncomfortable if there's a chance my best mate's Dad is stood there! I'm not keen on shopping at the best of times but if this is the way things are going, it's online all the way for me. The High Street can do one.

AIBU?

OP posts:
daretodenim · 22/05/2022 19:47

Yeah but I think there’s a big difference between genuine trans women who just want to buy some clothes, and the fetishised, pretend ‘trans women’ who get off on putting themselves in women’s spaces.

and

I suspect most genuine trans people avoid single sex public changing rooms for fear of being ostracised. However I still feel it shouldn’t be a free for all. Maybe big stores could offer both a women’s and a unisex section?
If a predatory ‘trans woman’ is dressed up to look enough like a biological woman at a passing glance and entered a women’s changing room, then unfortunately it would be incredibly difficult for changing room attendants to police. As with most things in life, there are always a few that spoil things for everyone else.

Do you realise there there is no "true trans"?! If there were, it would require someone to decide that someone's a fake trans ie not who they say they are. And the entire point of this whole thing is that whoever you say you are IS who you are and cannot be disputed.

Who is someone to say that the man who you think is faking being trans isn't actually trans just because he assaults a woman? That would mean that no trans-identified male could ever assault women. And given the prison stats, that's statistically impossible.

We have to understand that when we say that everybody should be free to identify as they want and everybody else has to accept that or they are bigoted/transphobic, then it means that even the guys in Scotland who identify as trans in prison, get transferred to the women’s prison and then re identify as male upon release (this is documented as happening) are as trans as the person with diagnosed gender dysphoria lasting decades. There is no "fake trans" with self-ID.

UsernameNotAvailableHmm · 22/05/2022 19:47

LondonQueen

user1474315215

It honestly wouldn't bother me. You were no less clothed than you would be on the beach or in the swimming pool.

This. It's not like you strip off completely!

But when going to the beach, or in the swimming pool, you are willingly going to those places perfectly happy to be seen in your swimming costume or bikini by any man who happens to be there also.

When you are out shopping, say at Primark, you're not necessarily as willing to be seen in your undies and the changing rooms should be arranged so that men cannot access the area where women are trying on clothes. Women's privacy and dignity should be respected.

If I take my mum to M&S and she likes the look of a blouse, it would be nice for her to try it on in changing rooms which afford her the privacy and dignity she deserves, away from men.

Norgie · 22/05/2022 19:44

Regardless of whether you're just removing your cardigan or completely stripping off, the fact remains that yet another female space is being taken over by some men and their wants, in other words, their needs override that of women.
If you're happy for this to happen, then shame on you.
If trans want to use facilities other than male ones, then they should have their own and not have the right to impact on women.
This is just the tip of the iceberg.

UsernameNotAvailableHmm · 22/05/2022 19:39

I will not go into any mixed changing facilities, whether they be in shops or sports centres etc.
In fact there are shops I have boycotted recently, because of their policy to have mixed changing rooms

I won't even order online from them, total boycott.

00100001 · 22/05/2022 19:35

00100001 · 22/05/2022 19:32

So you'd be perfectly comfortable walking round in your underwear in a shop...?

And also, you'd be fine with just taking your shorts and t-shirt off, Essentialy strip down to your underwear and try in a dress in the shop, by the rail it was displayed on?

And you'd be equally fine, with some one else doing the same? You'd have no quibbles about walking past someone who is in their underwear, and they're trying on a pair of trousers?

00100001 · 22/05/2022 19:32

LondonQueen · 22/05/2022 19:14

This. It's not like you strip off completely!

So you'd be perfectly comfortable walking round in your underwear in a shop...?

PronounMadness · 22/05/2022 19:24

TheOriginalEmu · 22/05/2022 17:39

What makes you think it was?

Impossible to know. But maybe they get off on wearing women’s clothing. That’s under the trans umbrella (according to stonewall, anyway).

PronounMadness · 22/05/2022 19:17

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 17:33

Yeah but I think there’s a big difference between genuine trans women who just want to buy some clothes, and the fetishised, pretend ‘trans women’ who get off on putting themselves in women’s spaces.

How can you tell the difference?

LondonQueen · 22/05/2022 19:14

user1474315215 · 22/05/2022 12:51

It honestly wouldn't bother me. You were no less clothed than you would be on the beach or in the swimming pool.

This. It's not like you strip off completely!

SolasAnla · 22/05/2022 19:10

Norgie · 22/05/2022 17:57

The missing point here is that this is just the start.
Already we have had women raped, sexually assaulted and been made to feel embarrassed and uncomfortable in places they should feel secure in.
Such as hospitals and prisons, now changing rooms and toilets.
Now we have......

Women as natural women.
Pregnant women and mother's.
Rape crisis and counselling.
Women's careers.
Women's ' safe ' spaces.

All being eroded bit by bit by the trans community.

All the years of hard work that women have put into being taken seriously and accepted as equals are being eroded......in favour of men!
Don't kid yourself otherwise.

Now, not all men are sexual predators and the decent ones are actually siding with women on this issue, but don't assume that all men, trans or otherwise are harmless. They're far from it.

If you don't stand up for your rights as a woman, then those hard won rights will be lost forever, much to the detriment of your daughter's and granddaughters.

In the USA the ACLU is going to court to argue that there is no difference between a female and a male.

That argument has already been raised as evidence in the UK.

In the USA the ACLU argue that a male rapist who identifies as a woman must be housed in female prison if he chooses that.

In the UK the policy is to house males in female prisons and hope for the best. The women prisoners can be sanctioned if they object or don't describe the male as a woman.

In the USA, same organisation, the ACLU, is campaigning that everybody; not women needs an abortion. Its no longer a womans right to choose it's everybody's right.

So how is that going to work in legislation?
the parent's right?
the male's right?
the birthing parent?

Since the avent of birth control more and more pregnancy been seen as a lifestyle choice. If anybody thinks that the removal of sex as a protected characteristic in the UK would not result in women of child bearing age being passed over for promotion "just in case" they are optimistically naive.

axolotlfloof · 22/05/2022 19:06

Holly60 · 22/05/2022 13:37

I don't really get why it's different with men though. I've always done the uncomfortable dance even in single sex changing rooms. Why is the fact that some of the people happen to have willies more uncomfortable?

I sort of get some women feeling more vulnerable to attack, but just sort of more embarrassed?? Nope. I highly doubt the men getting changed and chatting to their girlfriends were any more bothered by a bit of your naked flesh than any of the women were to be honest.

Were you suddenly way more interested in your fellow changees just because some of them were men?? Did you find it header not to ogle at the men changing?? Thought not. You kept your head down and thought about how you looked in the clothes. The men were doing that too.

That's a very generous description of men's intent in these situations.
Men are the perpetrators of violent and sexual crime (including peeping Tom's) against women. The last thing we need is to give them more opportunity.
If you haven't had that life experience as a woman then you are very fortunate.

balalake · 22/05/2022 19:05

Agree with you 100% that changing rooms in stores should not be mixed sex.

Another reason to never shop in Primark.

JacquelineCarlyle · 22/05/2022 18:52

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 22/05/2022 13:14

What would help women feel more secure Grumpy would be for men to stop committing sexual offences against women. And 98% of the offences are committed by men. Until then I'd like to keep protections in place.

This!

ChiefInspectorParker · 22/05/2022 18:44

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

ChiefInspectorParker · 22/05/2022 18:44

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

CampervanKween · 22/05/2022 18:37

YANBU. I never use changing rooms anymore for this reason. I order everything online in multiple sizes, then usually end up sending most of it back. Cant be cost effective for the shops.

equuscaballus · 22/05/2022 18:36

It bothers me.

I used a very large changing room in Birmingham a few months ago (possibly H&M) on a weekday, so almost deserted and the curtains didn't close fully on either side.

I felt very unsafe and switched into "high alert" mode when I realised other customers (male) had followed me in to use the same facilities.

In this case, their intentions were perfectly innocent but that didn't stop me from feeling incredibly stressed and vulnerable.

It just seems to be at open invite for those rare people who want to take advantage.

SolasAnla · 22/05/2022 18:35

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 18:06

It was the sort of busy shop where clothes just get left in the changing rooms. Who knows - but I think it’s unfair to assume it was likely to be a trans woman.

How about:
it was a male human (post puberty)

Concestor · 22/05/2022 18:34

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 18:06

It was the sort of busy shop where clothes just get left in the changing rooms. Who knows - but I think it’s unfair to assume it was likely to be a trans woman.

Yes don't be unfair, you big meanie, #bekind

🙄

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 22/05/2022 18:22

user1474315215 · 22/05/2022 12:51

It honestly wouldn't bother me. You were no less clothed than you would be on the beach or in the swimming pool.

It bothers me! I wouldnt want anyone to jump in while I was trying out stuff in my underwear. I boycott all shops with this policy

MintJulia · 22/05/2022 18:17

I've never shopped anywhere with a mixed changing room.

It's very simple for me, single sex changing rooms and single sex loos or they don't get my custom.

I'd hand the clothes to an assistant and tell her why I was leaving, then she could waste her time putting them back on the right rail, just as they had wasted my time by not providing proper facilities.

The only way to deal with such shabbiness to to vote with your wallet (or lack of it). Smile

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 22/05/2022 18:15

Grumpybutfunny · 22/05/2022 13:57

@Albgo men aren't anymore dangerous than woman, plenty of woman have been convicted of sex crimes. Thinking back to my childhood it would have been girls who were bullies that would have pulled back the curtain to embarrass the girl inside, boys would have just had a good scrap and that wouldn't have been the end of it. If a boy had pulled back the curtain they would have already been legging it in the opposite direction laughing. As a teenage girl I often had to get dressed infront of boys most looked the other way and blushed if they got a look!!

As for if a man opened the curtain I very much doubt he wouldn't be the only other person in the changing room to have any opportunity to do anything but look.

This is possibly the most disingenuous comment so far, you are ridiculous and quite clearly do not give a shit about women’s safety or dignity.

Googlecanthelpme · 22/05/2022 18:13

Anyone who says they “don’t understand the problem / issue / upset” “isn’t an issue” “no worse than sharing with women” clearly has lived a very lucky life and are making these comments from a position of privilege and naivety and I really envy that in some ways.

meanwhile the rest of us live in the real world where men are the almost (not all but not far out) the sole cause of sexual assault, rape (they are the sole cause of this), violence against women and murder of women.

Are we likely to be murdered in a primark changing room - no. Are we likely to be secretly filmed, peeked at, wanked over, exposed to, subjected to deviant unwanted behaviour- yes

Fuck primark anyway - their use sweatshop labour tells you all you need to know.

I haven’t shopped there for a while and I definitely won’t be going forward.

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 18:09

Norgie · 22/05/2022 17:57

The missing point here is that this is just the start.
Already we have had women raped, sexually assaulted and been made to feel embarrassed and uncomfortable in places they should feel secure in.
Such as hospitals and prisons, now changing rooms and toilets.
Now we have......

Women as natural women.
Pregnant women and mother's.
Rape crisis and counselling.
Women's careers.
Women's ' safe ' spaces.

All being eroded bit by bit by the trans community.

All the years of hard work that women have put into being taken seriously and accepted as equals are being eroded......in favour of men!
Don't kid yourself otherwise.

Now, not all men are sexual predators and the decent ones are actually siding with women on this issue, but don't assume that all men, trans or otherwise are harmless. They're far from it.

If you don't stand up for your rights as a woman, then those hard won rights will be lost forever, much to the detriment of your daughter's and granddaughters.

I don’t want to bash genuine trans people, as I sympathise with how marginalised they are, but I do agree with this to a degree. Certainly over issues like women’s prisons and crisis centres.
I don’t know what the answer is though - maybe they need their own safe spaces.

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 18:06

HipTightOnions · 22/05/2022 18:01

What makes you think it wasn’t a transwoman that had soiled the dress?

What makes you think it was?

Maybe because he'd gone into the changing room with a dress?

It was the sort of busy shop where clothes just get left in the changing rooms. Who knows - but I think it’s unfair to assume it was likely to be a trans woman.