Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ILs refusing to use my name

340 replies

namechangedasouting · 22/05/2022 12:21

DH and I married 5+ years ago. I kept my name, children are double barrelled. MIL (divorced from FIL but has kept her married name) has always found it personally insulting that I wanted to keep my name. All cards etc. Are addressed to "Mrs DH surname" and for the kids the same. I've really tried to just let it go - she knows these aren't our names so correcting her over and over seems pointless. She's now started "correcting" DH's other family members who send the kids cards addressed correctly. Her latest comment to DH's aunt (whilst we were there) was "they are "DH surname" through and through, why pretend otherwise?"

AIBU in finding this annoying?

OP posts:
Gizacluethen · 22/05/2022 16:44

I'd start addressing her as Ms. Maidenname "but you're not married MIL, you're Ms.Maidenname through and through, why pretend otherwise?"

Bergamotte · 22/05/2022 16:42

BananaShrimp Wow, that is amazingly silly of your SIL. You deserve respect for staying calm!

katepilar · 22/05/2022 16:37

Perhaps she resents taking on her husbands name and even keeping it to make her life easier.

BananaShrimp · 22/05/2022 16:30

OTOH your DH sounds like a keeper
He can be a dick about some things but this is one thing that he’s consistently backed me up on. Perhaps because we’re not the same ethnic background, and he understands that my surname matches the ethnicity of my firstname and connects me to my heritage in a way his surname would not.

Hyy4323 · 22/05/2022 16:29

I have that but I've just had to let it go.DC have my surname though we are married. Whats the point in correcting them...takes too long

150poundrebate · 22/05/2022 16:29

BananaShrimp · 22/05/2022 16:25

So, you’ve never actually said ‘stop this, I find it offensive, use my name’?
As I said, I’ve told them repeatedly that they’re using the wrong name and title but they just keep doing it. They’re so convinced that my name changed automatically when I got married and therefore I’m Mrs Hisname, and I’m making a mistake by thinking that I’m not! SIL actually said my driving licence is illegal because it’s the wrong name.

They’re not the only ones - occasionally people who know DH have automatically written Mrs Hisname without asking what my name is. People who’ve known me for 10-20 years have automatically addressed things to Mrs Hisname. Conversely when I’ve introduced myself to someone as Banana Myname and they later meet DH, they automatically call him DH Myname. Because they’re so convinced that we must have the same surname. Funnily enough they don’t seem to assume this with gay couples!

Telling them they’re using the wrong name/title and directly, point blank, telling them to stop doing so aren’t the same thing.

Stravaig · 22/05/2022 16:28

You have a 'DH not insisting his mother treats you with respect' problem, as well as a MIL problem. Either he's been complaining to his mother about you and the kids not having his name, or he's not been clearly correcting her when she raises it.

Return all mail addressed with the wrong names as 'not known at this addess' until MIL gets the message.

If she still can't treat your and your children with the basic respect of knowing your names, then she doesn't get to have a relationship with you or them.

BananaShrimp · 22/05/2022 16:25

So, you’ve never actually said ‘stop this, I find it offensive, use my name’?
As I said, I’ve told them repeatedly that they’re using the wrong name and title but they just keep doing it. They’re so convinced that my name changed automatically when I got married and therefore I’m Mrs Hisname, and I’m making a mistake by thinking that I’m not! SIL actually said my driving licence is illegal because it’s the wrong name.

They’re not the only ones - occasionally people who know DH have automatically written Mrs Hisname without asking what my name is. People who’ve known me for 10-20 years have automatically addressed things to Mrs Hisname. Conversely when I’ve introduced myself to someone as Banana Myname and they later meet DH, they automatically call him DH Myname. Because they’re so convinced that we must have the same surname. Funnily enough they don’t seem to assume this with gay couples!

Waterfallgirl · 22/05/2022 16:23

BananaShrimp · 22/05/2022 15:53

I’ve told them they’re using the wrong name and title. They just keep doing it. When the christening incident happened, SIL insisted that my ID must be wrong/illegal/outdated because I’m Mrs Hisname, I can’t be Dr Myname any more because I’m married. She said that’s your old ID from before you got married and it isn’t valid any more, can you get updated ID in your married name to match the church paperwork please. I said no that’s not possible because I actually am Dr Myname, there is no such person as Mrs Hisname.

So she whinged to DH that I need to update my driving licence/passport, and he told her they are up to date and correct because I am Dr Myname. Then she and MIL complained that it was rude and inappropriate for me to change my name back after I got married, and DH said she didn’t change it back, it never got changed from her maiden name in the first place. It appears they thought that a woman’s name changes automatically when she gets married and I must have purposely changed it back!

In the end I just said look, there’s my ID, it says Dr Myname, take it or leave it. And she refused to write Dr Myname as godmother because she wanted all the godparents to be Hisnames. So she picked someone else.

Bloody hell - I have no words - monumentally stupid as well as rude !! (Sorry if you love them but WOW!)
OTOH your DH sounds like a keeper 😉

TrashyPanda · 22/05/2022 16:20

My DD got married last weekend.
she and DSIL have both double barrelled their names.
your MILs head would spin at that - so you might want to try it!

Waterfallgirl · 22/05/2022 16:18

stayathomer · 22/05/2022 15:23

Has anybody ever asked these people ‘why’ they are doing these things? Like, what is the thought process?
my friend decided to change her name to her dhs and her fil showed up to thank her as they’re the last with the family name as all his siblings died young and never had kids. That’s why people get like this. It’s both rational and irrational but the more I think about it the more I get it

But that’s not this situation - as far as we know from the OP.

Pandarinio · 22/05/2022 16:18

If you ever send Christmas cards miss off half their name And misspell their names in the card. They don't respect you.

150poundrebate · 22/05/2022 16:17

Lizziekisss · 22/05/2022 16:08

I don’t have an opinion either way and I’m just being curious, with the DCs having double barrelled surnames, so if your DCs are Smith-Jones and then they become a parent and have a child with someone whose surname is Brown- Green what happens to the baby’s surname then?

In cultures where this is the norm, the children generally get one name from each parent. It used to be the father’s name (so, their grandfather), but that’s no longer the case.

So, in your example, they’d be DC Smith-Green or similar.

greatblueheron · 22/05/2022 16:17

Mark everything that arrives incorrectly addressed 'not known at this address' and pop them back in the post. Every time.

Lizziekisss · 22/05/2022 16:09

So sorry OP in response to your original question, yes I agree your MIL is being incredibly rude. Your name your choice.

Lizziekisss · 22/05/2022 16:08

I don’t have an opinion either way and I’m just being curious, with the DCs having double barrelled surnames, so if your DCs are Smith-Jones and then they become a parent and have a child with someone whose surname is Brown- Green what happens to the baby’s surname then?

150poundrebate · 22/05/2022 15:59

BananaShrimp · 22/05/2022 15:53

I’ve told them they’re using the wrong name and title. They just keep doing it. When the christening incident happened, SIL insisted that my ID must be wrong/illegal/outdated because I’m Mrs Hisname, I can’t be Dr Myname any more because I’m married. She said that’s your old ID from before you got married and it isn’t valid any more, can you get updated ID in your married name to match the church paperwork please. I said no that’s not possible because I actually am Dr Myname, there is no such person as Mrs Hisname.

So she whinged to DH that I need to update my driving licence/passport, and he told her they are up to date and correct because I am Dr Myname. Then she and MIL complained that it was rude and inappropriate for me to change my name back after I got married, and DH said she didn’t change it back, it never got changed from her maiden name in the first place. It appears they thought that a woman’s name changes automatically when she gets married and I must have purposely changed it back!

In the end I just said look, there’s my ID, it says Dr Myname, take it or leave it. And she refused to write Dr Myname as godmother because she wanted all the godparents to be Hisnames. So she picked someone else.

So, you’ve never actually said ‘stop this, I find it offensive, use my name’?

I’m not saying you should, just clarifying.

Handyweatherstation · 22/05/2022 15:54

Eightiesfan · 22/05/2022 15:11

I just think this is an example of older people being very petty. My DP parents are the same, we’ve been together over 20 years so they know my surname perfectly well, but insist on addressing everything to Mr and Mrs xxxx. We’re not married!

Not quite the same but we're not married either, though have been together for about 35 years. One family member always addressed me as 'Miss' my name, even though I'm 60. Eventually I waited until the family were gathered and had had a couple of drinks and asked her if she did that because she thought I was still a virgin. Cue much mirth. She stopped doing it.

BananaShrimp · 22/05/2022 15:53

150poundrebate · 22/05/2022 15:31

Have you asked either of these women to stop doing this? Told them you find it offensive? If so, what was their response? What reason did your SIL give for refusing to use your correct title?

I’ve told them they’re using the wrong name and title. They just keep doing it. When the christening incident happened, SIL insisted that my ID must be wrong/illegal/outdated because I’m Mrs Hisname, I can’t be Dr Myname any more because I’m married. She said that’s your old ID from before you got married and it isn’t valid any more, can you get updated ID in your married name to match the church paperwork please. I said no that’s not possible because I actually am Dr Myname, there is no such person as Mrs Hisname.

So she whinged to DH that I need to update my driving licence/passport, and he told her they are up to date and correct because I am Dr Myname. Then she and MIL complained that it was rude and inappropriate for me to change my name back after I got married, and DH said she didn’t change it back, it never got changed from her maiden name in the first place. It appears they thought that a woman’s name changes automatically when she gets married and I must have purposely changed it back!

In the end I just said look, there’s my ID, it says Dr Myname, take it or leave it. And she refused to write Dr Myname as godmother because she wanted all the godparents to be Hisnames. So she picked someone else.

ProfessorFusspot · 22/05/2022 15:46

Accepting letters/cards sent from far away with the wrong name is a personal decision; OK to let it go to avoid the hassle as you might if they persistently mispelled your first name. But I wouldn't force children to accept them. As for the kinds of face-to-face comments people have mentioned - no. And the parents who are knowingly correcting others to use wrong information are actively harmful as well as very rude.

If your husband had a sister whose children were Herlastname-Herhusbandslastname or vice versa, would your PILs be sending them cards using only Herlastname? In most cases, it's not a mistake or forgetfulness or familiarity or a desire to elevate their own (child's) name, it's misogyny. It's absolutely reasonable to reject it on one's own behalf and to protect children from it.

SmellsLikeMiddleAgeSpirit · 22/05/2022 15:38

150poundrebate · 22/05/2022 14:55

That’s the one I’m referring to. Where’s the other one?

And I’m perfectly happy for ageism to be called out. I just don’t think that one (or two, according to you) out of 52 constitutes an ‘ageist theme’ to the thread. Which is what I said.

I quoted two examples!

Those highlighted parts were from two different posts.

Robinni · 22/05/2022 15:38

To clarify @Lesperance OP should bear in mind that people can find it hard to get around deviations from cultural norms and there may be mistakes or people who are very traditional and find it hard to grasp…..

There will be more confusion as the years go on and it’s important to just brush some of it off as no need to distress yourself. Our friends don’t give a tinkers!

In the case of this MiL it sounds like she’s getting quite nasty about it though so words are needed.

cheesychips15 · 22/05/2022 15:36

My in-laws kept addressing stuff to Mrs Husband'sname too. They also doubly annoyed me when I was pregnant by sending things for the baby addressed just to Mrs Husband'sname instead of both of us, or even just my husband.

My husband had a word with them and they (mostly) stopped doing it.

If anyone ever refers to me as Mrs Husband'sname now my husband starts laughing and says that's his mum.

ATadConfused · 22/05/2022 15:35

YANBU to be annoyed.

However, I find working on the theory that getting the envelope through the correct front door is all that matters. If it arrives it's fine it's job, read the contents.

if she's correcting others I'd just say 'No Aunt Daisy, your envelopes are always perfectly addressed, +some people just can't seem to remember the DH is smith, I am Jones & the children are Smith Jones . I know it's not complicated, but it seems beyond them! So you carry on as you were, it's perfect!'

150poundrebate · 22/05/2022 15:35

Robinni · 22/05/2022 15:29

Bear in mind other people have kept their maiden name for professional purposes and may have legally gone to change to their husbands name or not.

And they’re able to carry on and not be offended every time somebody writes Mr. and Mrs. Or the X family…

But then in the instances I’m talking about the people involved have never made a big issue over it. They know what their names are and if people make mistakes due to cultural norms it doesn’t ruffle feathers. Even in the case of double barrelled kids names; hadn’t heard of it until they had travel issues.

The situation with three different family names sounds overly complicated but it is what they want and people should respect that.

Mil sounds a nightmare.

Lots of people choose to do lots of different things. Why do you feel that what these random women chose to do is relevant to the OP? It wasn’t clear to @Lesperance and it’s not clear to me, either.

Swipe left for the next trending thread