Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To lie to the midwives/health visitors about sleeping arrangements

255 replies

Butitssafe · 22/05/2022 00:49

My fourth is a week old. Not my first rodeo.
I’ve done all my research and was really pleased that recent advice (ie lullaby trust et al) has changed in terms of not completely de-crying cosleeping and sharing ways in which to do
so safely.
I have decided to sleep with my baby in my bed at night following all this guidance.
However, I know trusts are slow to update policy/change culture etc and I’ve been asked so often about how she is sleeping and been told sharply so many times they ‘can’t recommend and don’t advise’ cosleeping that I decided, before she was born, that I was going to fib and tell them she goes down in her Moses basket (she has one for daytime naps etc) and that’s what I’ve been doing.
aibu?

OP posts:
Topgub · 22/05/2022 13:05

@Intrigueddotcom

Why would bedsharing help colic?

Id offer to help look after the baby so she wasn't so tired. Id make sure the babys dad was doing their share.

If she was adamant she wanted to bedshare despite being fully aware of the risks then I wouldnt say anything else

Intrigueddotcom · 22/05/2022 13:03

@Topgub

If your daughter (if you have one) became a mother and her baby developed colic. It was unbearable and you watched your daughter begin to seriously suffer from extreme exhaustion. But then she began to improve a little, having managed to begin to snatch a few hours sleep. Why? Co sleeping and she was adamant she wanted to continue

What would you do / say out of interest?

Topgub · 22/05/2022 12:49

@Intrigueddotcom

If that's what they need to tell themselves 🤷‍♀️

The facts remain.

And most bed sharers aren't the last resort at risk of pnd women any way.

They're the oh it's just so natural and beyond actually more safe women.

The fact deniers

Lady1576 · 22/05/2022 12:48

Holskey · 22/05/2022 01:41

I don't tell them. Of course you can "own" your decision, but many HVs/midwives believe it's their duty to ask follow-up questions and warn you of the risks (you already know about). Such patronising time-wasting can be politely avoided by lying.

This!
some hvs are supportive but it’s hit or miss. You never know what you’re going to get and having weighed up all the options I just don’t need that conversation. However, part of me thinks we should all admit it, so that hvs have an accurate picture of how unrealistic the safe sleep recommendations are. It annoys me that they just rattle off this info, knowing that people co-sleep because the guidelines don’t physically work for a lot of babies. To be fair the hvs I’ve had, word the information very carefully saying, ‘You’ll be aware of the safe sleep guidance that says…‘ like they know it‘s a tricky one and are merely fulfilling their obligation to tell you.

On another note, has anyone else seen the WHO Infographic which states that as many babies die in cots as from co-sleeping (and the co-sleeping stats include all the unsafe practices and high risk cases)? I also read an article from a scientist arguing that co-sleeping was dangerous and her argument was 48% of deaths occur from co-sleeping babies and I’m thinking, so 52% occur from babies in cots etc….? Why would you even use that statistic to argue against co-sleeping? What an I missing?

Intrigueddotcom · 22/05/2022 12:46

Topgub · 22/05/2022 12:44

@Intrigueddotcom

But bedsharing and exhausted mother aren't the only 2 options.

Bedsharing doesn't reduce sleep deprivation anyway

but surely you can appreciate for some it could
and could be the difference between PND due to extreme exhaustion and a mother who is engaged, alert and… happy

Topgub · 22/05/2022 12:44

@Intrigueddotcom

But bedsharing and exhausted mother aren't the only 2 options.

Bedsharing doesn't reduce sleep deprivation anyway

Topgub · 22/05/2022 12:42

@Intrigueddotcom

If you Google the article it comes up but it doesn't give more detail.

Id presume entrapment and suffocation are the main causes though.

Butitssafe · 22/05/2022 12:40

Baby is breastfed and bed is a super king 😊

OP posts:
Intrigueddotcom · 22/05/2022 12:38

Topgub · 22/05/2022 12:37

@SickAndTiredAgain

There is research (mostly American I think) that separates out unsafe and 'safe' bedsharing

Its still higher risk than not.

All research shows the safest place for a baby to sleep is its own bare sleep space

Parents can make their own risk assessments with this knowledge of course. We all make lots of risk assessments all the time.

But it seems daft to deny the facts

But you weigh that up against the risk presented but a chronically sleep deprived mother incapable barely of holding herself together.

whereas the difference with co sleeping may enable that mother to be much more alert than would be the case if she wasn’t.

Intrigueddotcom · 22/05/2022 12:37

Topgub · 22/05/2022 12:34

@Intrigueddotcom

SIDs isn't the same as suffocation.

A small % of babies will still die of SIDs even if all safe sleep practices (back to sleep, feet to foot, own bare sleep space) are followed.

I saw recent research about an enzyme?

Its not the same as a baby being suffocated in its parents bed. And sids can still occur while bedsharing.

Agreed

the link doesn’t work so we can’t see a definition of “accidents”

Topgub · 22/05/2022 12:37

@SickAndTiredAgain

There is research (mostly American I think) that separates out unsafe and 'safe' bedsharing

Its still higher risk than not.

All research shows the safest place for a baby to sleep is its own bare sleep space

Parents can make their own risk assessments with this knowledge of course. We all make lots of risk assessments all the time.

But it seems daft to deny the facts

Intrigueddotcom · 22/05/2022 12:36

@Choufleurfromage

your link doesn’t work
so no idea what “accident” constitutes

Topgub · 22/05/2022 12:34

@Intrigueddotcom

SIDs isn't the same as suffocation.

A small % of babies will still die of SIDs even if all safe sleep practices (back to sleep, feet to foot, own bare sleep space) are followed.

I saw recent research about an enzyme?

Its not the same as a baby being suffocated in its parents bed. And sids can still occur while bedsharing.

SickAndTiredAgain · 22/05/2022 12:31

More than 130 babies die each year as a result of accidents while sharing a bed with their parents, new data has revealed. An average of 133 babies have died each year over the past five years in cases where co-sleeping is a factor, according Department for Education data.29 Jan 2018

I don't think that data separates out bed sharing vs for example sleeping on the sofa (which is known to be more dangerous).
And it definitely doesn't separate out falling asleep accidentally with the baby on your chest while lying or sitting in bed, which is also more dangerous.
So it's not completely applicable to what OP is doing, as it sounds like she is following all the advice, as opposed to waking up and realising she has accidentally slept with the baby on her.

I'm not saying there are no risks, just that data that combines cases where someone has been lying/sitting in bed with pillows and blankets and has accidentally fallen asleep, with cases where the co sleeping has been planned and all recommended precautions taken isn't that helpful.

Intrigueddotcom · 22/05/2022 12:27

Choufleurfromage · 22/05/2022 12:03

More than 130 babies die each year as a result of accidents while sharing a bed with their parents, new data has revealed. An average of 133 babies have died each year over the past five years in cases where co-sleeping is a factor, according Department for Education data.29 Jan 2018
www.independent.co.uk › news

How many died of SID in their cots or Moses baskets?

Coldilox · 22/05/2022 12:22

My son was born in 2014 and my midwife and HV both gave me advice on safe co-sleeping. I had no intention of co-sleeping, and I never did, but they said they wanted me to know the safest way to do it in case I changed my mind.

Choufleurfromage · 22/05/2022 12:03

mathanxiety · 22/05/2022 06:56

Oh come on Choufleurfromage.

What a crock of nonsense.

More than 130 babies die each year as a result of accidents while sharing a bed with their parents, new data has revealed. An average of 133 babies have died each year over the past five years in cases where co-sleeping is a factor, according Department for Education data.29 Jan 2018
www.independent.co.uk › news

RedHelenB · 22/05/2022 12:01

I told my HV I put my babies down on their tummies. Obviously she had to go through the fact it wasn't advised etc but then the conversation moved on. They all would only sleep any amount of time like that, had strong necks and rolled over quite early. They were also full term As a parent you make choices, sometimes against advice.

Topgub · 22/05/2022 11:53

The practices described on this thread are a perfect example of why bedsharing isn't safe

Even those claiming they do it safely never do.

Eddiesferret · 22/05/2022 11:50

Nothing wrong with Co sleeping. Did with all three of mine. (Now grown up)

However some practical advice that I found worked really well for us.

  1. Big bed. Biggest you can get especially if partner in with you as well.
  1. For us a non sprung bed was fabulous. (Super king futon) this meant adults can get in and out without baby rolling . Baby doesn't move)
  1. Breast feeding is ideal if Co sleeping . No wandering around /getting up and getting bottles. Simply roll over , pop out a boob. Stick baby on and both go back to sleep.

Three kids . No sleepless nights.

No child was clingy. All had independently decided to move into their own rooms between 2-3 yrs old.

Topgub · 22/05/2022 11:49

@orwellwasright

In context of the question?

Not reductionist.

And yes op yabu in lying.

Youve made your (poor) risk assessment. No need to lie.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 22/05/2022 11:42

The midwife in the hospital eventually had my baby sleep in the hospital bed with my on the second night - I had had a c section my baby was so upset every time she was out in the cot

I had to keep buzzing for the midwife to come and help - I had been awake at this stage for 30 hours 🥲. She put the side up on the bed and stuck the baby in beside me safely

she just did you gotta go what you gotta do!! 😂

I did lie though on occasion - the midwife at the second visit I went to after she was born phrased the question like - she sleeps in her own bed at night right ? So I just said yea. Felt it was easier

BigWoollyJumpers · 22/05/2022 11:37

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

And again - An incredibly ridiculous, and inaccurate assertion.

BigWoollyJumpers · 22/05/2022 11:33

Lazerbeen · 22/05/2022 09:08

Not the same as co sleeping though is it. Co sleeping can benefit both parent and baby, baby in a different room from day 1 only benefits the parent whilst increasing the risk of SIDS. Talking to an antenatal class is also different from talking to a HV.

Classic MN. Everyone saying they make judgements of risk of safe co-sleeping. because the risk is tiny, which it is. Mention you put a baby in a room on their own, and immediately someone comes along and tells you it is unsafe. It is no more unsafe than safe-cosleeping, and very much less risky than "un-safe" cosleeping. The overall risk is again, incredibly low. High risk (although in context the total risk is still incredibly low in the general population), is the well known, smoking, drinking, drug taking, multiple birth, low birth weight, and not putting on the back to sleep.

Safe co-sleeping and sleeping in a separate room are the same slightly increased risk (which, again, to re-iterate, is tiny).

Momicrone · 22/05/2022 11:30

By baby 4, I wouldn't give a fuck what any one thought of my child care choices so no, I would not lie