Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if anyone can solve this Maths question?

117 replies

Hydrangea444 · 21/05/2022 21:08

DD is doing Further Maths A-Level and is stuck on this question.

AIBU to ask if anyone can solve this Maths question?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Hydrangea444 · 22/05/2022 08:11

SilverSilverStreet · 21/05/2022 23:47

I’ve managed to work through @LovelyJubbly1234 ’s solution to (a) and I love it, especially in the third line when you complete the square to get 1 - u squared from -16xsquared -24x + 8. (sorry, ^2 should be squared,)

Here’s my version of that solution - I had to write out lots of steps to properly understand it.

Thank you for some unexpected entertainment on a Saturday night. It’s a very long time since I did anything like this.

Thank you for this🙏🙏

OP posts:
chiickenandmayosandwich · 22/05/2022 04:58

Back to the OPs maths question, clearly this is one of those where you need to know what to do with the equation and show your working, so the answer alone, and calculators, won't get you very far.


The OP clearly didn't ask for just the answer. She asked for help for her daughter so she can improve her skills.

chiickenandmayosandwich · 22/05/2022 04:56

@eastegg

What has she done before when she hasn’t understood something or has needed help? Surely she doesn’t ask her mum to ask mumsnet?

I don’t know much about maths, but I imagine it’s not going to help her to simply know the answer. She needs guidance on whatever about it she is finding difficult. From maybe er I dunno, a teacher?


😂😂

Are deliberately being an arse?

Anyone capable of working this out won't just give the answer and fuck off. The OP clearly said her daughter was struggling with the steps so was clearly asking for help on how to work it out, not asking for the answer.

chiickenandmayosandwich · 22/05/2022 04:50

Bloody hell there are some utter twonks on this thread.

OP was very clearly asking for help/explanation/ideas to bounce off so her daughter could crack on with her revision instead of waiting for her teacher next week. I am sure someone doing A level maths knows to check anything they are unsure of with the teacher.

BarbaraofSeville · 22/05/2022 04:34

This reply has been deleted

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Or the poster who said 'I'll get DH to explain tomorrow'.

Real conversation in our 'facility' not so long ago.

Man 1 to a group of us, looking puzzled because he's a non specialist on the particular question the rest of us all know more about to varying degrees - does anyone know about X, I've got to give a statement about it to the board.

Man 2 and Man 3 start blustering between them, showing that it's something in their vague memories, but there's a publication that explains everything very well but it's very old and they'd need to track down a copy which only exists on paper.

Me, in a loud voice to the other woman in the group, 'yes Publication Y, the one that you wrote'.

Man 2 and Man 3 continue to bluster about whether publication Y would answer the question about issue X and also reminisced about the antics of the secondary (male) author of the publication, who is now long retired.

To his credit, Man 1 picked up on what was going on and said to the woman who clearly knew more than any of us about issue X, shall we talk about this in the office later and you can advise on the statement for the board, so we know it's technically correct.

Back to the OPs maths question, clearly this is one of those where you need to know what to do with the equation and show your working, so the answer alone, and calculators, won't get you very far.

SilverSilverStreet · 22/05/2022 01:49

What I particularly like about this question is that, apart from differentiating arcsin x (where the result is printed on the FM formula sheet), it only needs knowledge from the single Maths A level syllabus.

It’s just hard - in my opinion, especially if you’re doing it under exam conditions.

Nat6999 · 22/05/2022 00:10

I can just about do ordinary maths, that example would give me nightmares.

Nat6999 · 22/05/2022 00:10

I can just about do ordinary maths, that example would give me nightmares.

supperlover · 22/05/2022 00:02

I'll ask my retired maths teacher husband in the morning. He's not very well at the moment but might be up for a challenge.

SgurrNaCìche · 21/05/2022 23:55

I think the answer is probably z-pi+72/4(37*xyz)/23+7(43p-28rs)Q

Only joking. Just the mere mention of differentiation and integration sends me quaking in a corner.

It's taken me 20 years to get over those. I'll blame you if I have maths a level nightmares tonight 🤣

SilverSilverStreet · 21/05/2022 23:54

dootball · 21/05/2022 22:31

I see the previous posters solution. Surely a more sensible substitution is u = 2x^2-3x+1 then you notice that du/dx = 4x-3 and therefore you can replace the part at the front with du/dx to get du/dx ( root (8u) ) + arcsin(u) and off you go?

@dootball, this looks like a neat method, but doesn’t that substitution give you arcsin (du/dx) rather than arcsin(u) ? How do you differentiate that?

SilverSilverStreet · 21/05/2022 23:47

I’ve managed to work through @LovelyJubbly1234 ’s solution to (a) and I love it, especially in the third line when you complete the square to get 1 - u squared from -16xsquared -24x + 8. (sorry, ^2 should be squared,)

Here’s my version of that solution - I had to write out lots of steps to properly understand it.

Thank you for some unexpected entertainment on a Saturday night. It’s a very long time since I did anything like this.

AIBU to ask if anyone can solve this Maths question?
Apollonia1 · 21/05/2022 23:38

I've a degree in maths, but have completely forgotten calculus.

I've twin toddlers. When they're in secondary school, I plan to take their maths books, and work out every single question. I want to understand the way they learn maths, and be able to help/do the advanced questions (the way I helped my friends in school).

lemmein · 21/05/2022 23:32

I always thought I was good at maths and even would go as far to say I enjoyed it.

This thread has made me realise, there's very different types of maths - the one I like, and the type the OPs DD is doing! 🤯

LannieDuck · 21/05/2022 23:25

I used to love calculus. It's been too many years since I've done it, but this thread has made me want to re-learn :)

HollowTalk · 21/05/2022 23:25

Is it from a past paper? You can find the answers online if so.

Eeornottoee · 21/05/2022 23:15

@EmilyBolton It’s Saturday evening Emily.

BluecheeseandBaskerville · 21/05/2022 23:15

I never really knew why someone would be a class clown but I feel a strong sense of inferiority right now that makes me want to say, “Hey you guys! I can burp the alphabet!”

BluecheeseandBaskerville · 21/05/2022 23:13

@lemmein Damn it you beat me to it.

Bovrilly · 21/05/2022 23:11

I feel like a Y7 gazing at the Y13s in admiration

ColouringPencils · 21/05/2022 23:10

I haven't got a clue but I love this thread!

EmilyBolton · 21/05/2022 23:05

Please please encourage your daughter todo as far as she can and then write something on question on why she is then stuck. Then submit to her TEACHER and ask for help.
I went through A level maths asking others when I got stuck. Ended up with a “u” grade. (This was80’s).
I then took a year out. Has a private tutor. No mates to ask as they’d all gone off to uni. So I had no choice than get as far as I could, get stuck. And ask my private tutor. She told me to do this…and within weeks had got inside my head and started to teach me how to get over my obstacles.
best lesson I ever learnt


  1. I resat with an A grade ( yep U to A)

  2. I learnt that if I didn’t understand something or couldn’t do something I needed to work with my teacher or tutor. Never missed a tutorial at uni. Not my mates or course participants

  3. It gave me a massive confidence boast in my ability to overcome difficulties


please please, do her the biggest favour and encourage her to use her teacher to specifically request help on the places she is stuck.

Whimz · 21/05/2022 23:04

Hi my DP is a maths teacher, he teaches further maths and pure maths at A level.

hope it helps :)

AIBU to ask if anyone can solve this Maths question?
AIBU to ask if anyone can solve this Maths question?
ZiggZagg · 21/05/2022 23:01

Well this thread has made me feel utterly thick 🤣 I can't believe my maths teacher begged me to do A Level 🙈 and I'm glad I didn't!

BetterDaysareComming · 21/05/2022 23:00

I didn't even realize stuff like this existed Blush
I wish I could help but I'm afraid I wouldn't know where to start.

Swipe left for the next trending thread