Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that this is fair?

63 replies

squashedalmondcroissant · 21/05/2022 19:17

I know that this has been done to death but I read another article today relating to 'common law spouse' stuff.

Essentially, this woman's long term partner died suddenly in his late 40's and she was upset that she's lost approximately £45,000 in bereavement benefits in the intervening years because they weren't married.

Obviously I have sympathy for her, it must be awful to lose your partner (which whom she had a young child) but she is starting a petition to say that the rules should be changed because she and her partner were 'living as husband and wife' and so she should therefore have the same rights/get the same benefits.

I disagree. The simple solution to these things is to get married! It can be cheaply and simply done if the legal and financial protection is what you want. If you don't get married then therefore you don't get the benefits. Otherwise, where do you draw the line? Do you qualify if you have been together over 5yrs but don't live together? What about if you've only been together 2yrs but have a child together? How do you determine who qualifies and who doesn't?!

OP posts:
whiteroseredrose · 22/05/2022 11:27

YANBU.

It shouldn't be automatic that you are legally and financially tied to someone just because you have lived together for x amount of time.

It should be an active choice.

If you want the privileges and downsides to marriage or civil partnership, you can choose that.

If not, nobody should make that choice for you.

If I lost DH I wouldn't want to remarry. I would want our assets to go to our DC. But I wouldn't want to never cohabit in case the Government suddenly decided we were 'as good as married'.

NamelessNancy · 22/05/2022 11:14

Totally agree OP. I think it's really important people retain the ability to live together without financial ties. Those who disagree can't you see any circumstances where this would be important?

As an example my DF (widower) spent his latter years living with a lovely lady who had also been widowed. Both had adult children and grandchildren. If they had been treated as if married she and her children would have had rights over my DF's estate on his death and vice versa. Neither DF nor his partner wanted this as both wanted their own children to inherit from them. If such a setup had been in place they would have chosen to remain living apart which would have been a shame as their relationship brought them happiness.

If you want the rights that marriage brings get married but allow those who don't want them to remain separate.

Abraxan · 22/05/2022 11:09

TigerRag · 22/05/2022 07:27

I disagree. If they live together, they're treated as living together as man and wife. But why not for bereavement benefits?

But legally they are not treated as being married, that's the whole point. We don't have a 'common law' rule.

It's very quick and easy to become married or joined in a civil partnership. It's also not particularly expensive either.

If you want the benefits of being a legal couple, then that's what you need to do.

If you want the benefits of remaining single, then you have to accept that you lose some benefits and rights which are only for those legally together.

If we went done the whole common law thing, at what point is the relationship defined as that? A year, 2 years, 10 years. If 2 years, why not 1 year and 364 days? And how do you define living together as partners? Do you have to declare a definite moving in together day and have this verified somehow?

Merryoldgoat · 22/05/2022 11:01

@cleareyesfulhearts

i agree entirely. Sharing assets should be opt-in.

There are plenty of reasons for that and wider education would potentially stop (usually) women sleepwalking into financial dependence with no protection.

cleareyesfulhearts · 22/05/2022 10:52

I disagree with @QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat , why should my rights to live with someone and remain unconnected be taken away? Now civil partnerships exist even more so,

Crazylazydayz · 22/05/2022 10:50

Now there is the option of Civil Partnership I have very little sympathy for those who choose not to enter into a legal relationship and suffer the consequences.

I agree there should be more education about finance and lifecycle options for everyone.

Hoppinggreen · 22/05/2022 10:17

TigerRag · 22/05/2022 07:27

I disagree. If they live together, they're treated as living together as man and wife. But why not for bereavement benefits?

For how long?

comealongponds · 22/05/2022 10:10

If people want the protection of marriage then they need to get married/civil partnership

if you choose not to, for whatever reason, you’re choosing not to have that protection.

dudsville · 22/05/2022 09:44

@Quartz2208 , I found your posts so helpful, thank you.

clumperoo · 22/05/2022 09:31

What are bereavement benefits!

Cant unmarried couples take out insurance?

Stuffin · 22/05/2022 07:32

It annoys me when people want the legal contract of marriage but then don't get married (or the equivalent civil partnership) because it's just a piece of paper or they don't agree with it.

Either form a legal contract or don't but don't expect to be able to retrospectively change the terms for everyone else because it doesn't suit.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 22/05/2022 07:32

orwellwasright · 21/05/2022 20:25

The people complaining they don't have the protection of marriage (because they're not married) would no doubt also complain if they wanted to exit their relationships with financial impunity and found they couldn't 😄

Be free or don't be free. Both have their pros and cons.

We definitely need better education though so that people make informed choices. So many of my friends still say 'but we're common law spouses' despite there being no such thing.

I agree. I think it's fair OP.

TigerRag · 22/05/2022 07:27

I disagree. If they live together, they're treated as living together as man and wife. But why not for bereavement benefits?

DifficultBloodyWoman · 22/05/2022 01:53

I’m with you, OP.

Although I think the woman you describe is way off about the £45k.

Babyroobs · 22/05/2022 00:33

The rules for Bereavement support payments are changing in the near future I think. If you have been living together long term and have children together you will be able to claim Bereavement support payments. they are no-where near as generous as widowed parents allowance was though - that used to be paid potentially for years on end until the youngest child left education. Bereavement support payment nowadays consists of a 3.5k lump sum then 18 months of payments of £350 per month if you have kids. It's even less generous if no kids.

Discovereads · 21/05/2022 23:27

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 21/05/2022 19:43

I disagree, I think life is different now, relationships and how we cohabit have changed significantly and the law needs to adapt. I don't know what this might look like but it isn't fair that she missed out on death benefits when she has been a partner for a significant amount of years and has children.

It’s fair, it’s not like she couldn’t marry or enter into a civil partnership. She chose not to. Choices have consequences. If you marry/do a civil partnership you can’t just break up and owe your ex nothing like you can with cohabiting. She wants none of the risk but all of the reward.

orwellwasright · 21/05/2022 20:25

The people complaining they don't have the protection of marriage (because they're not married) would no doubt also complain if they wanted to exit their relationships with financial impunity and found they couldn't 😄

Be free or don't be free. Both have their pros and cons.

We definitely need better education though so that people make informed choices. So many of my friends still say 'but we're common law spouses' despite there being no such thing.

Motnight · 21/05/2022 20:25

The main reason that dh and I got married after over 30 years together was for legal and financial protection.

orwellwasright · 21/05/2022 20:20

I think it was/is a state benefit - it used to be 'widow's allowance' or something like that but they've changed the name to something like 'bereavement support payments'. The 45k is over a long period of about 8yrs. Works out to just over £100 a week.

So you get bereavement support payment now.

Full rate is £3,500 lump sum then £350 per month for 18 months.

I think the support used to be for much longer but that's the current government benefit.

Obviously not to be sniffed at but not £45k. I was just a bit concerned I'd missed out when my husband dropped dead but I've just checked and I got all I was due 😃

oviraptor21 · 21/05/2022 20:15

I agree OP.
People have a choice. If they want the protections and restrictions that come with marriage then get married.
Otherwise don't complain when you're not eligible for those protections.

HappyHappyHermit · 21/05/2022 20:08

I agree, some people want to live together without anything legally binding them. One of my grandparents lived with a 'partner' for over 20 years but always deliberately kept finances separate as they each wanted it that way. They should have the right to live that way if they want to, just as this couple should have married if they wanted to be legally bound for financial purposes.

squashedalmondcroissant · 21/05/2022 20:04

@orwellwasright I think it was/is a state benefit - it used to be 'widow's allowance' or something like that but they've changed the name to something like 'bereavement support payments'. The 45k is over a long period of about 8yrs. Works out to just over £100 a week.

I do think it's sad that she and her child have lost out on that money which could have gone some way to supporting the family, but her partner was the wage earner and she didn't work. Women in this position are always vulnerable, even more so if unmarried. This is well known!

OP posts:
Quartz2208 · 21/05/2022 20:01

I agree and that a marriage isnt just a wedding. That you can indeed be married without a song and a dance - and if you simply want to sign then a civil partnership.

These rights cannot be given though without IMO an affirmation that is what you want - you need to actively consent to it rather than it simply being something that happens to you

Aroundtheworldin80moves · 21/05/2022 19:59

Marriage/civil partnership... active declaration you wish to legally be considered as a couple

Not getting married/civil partnership.either a) apathy, or b) an active choice to be considered legally single. There is no way of telling which is meant..

There needs to be education into the differences between marriage/cp and simply cohabiting. Especially when children are involved.

drpet49 · 21/05/2022 19:59

I completely agree, OP. If you want the status of a spouse or civil partner then you know what to do.

^i agree

Swipe left for the next trending thread