Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want all models to look like 'real' women?

237 replies

beattieedny · 21/05/2022 18:31

Just that really. I am much more likely to buy clothing if the model looks like looks slim. I don't care for the current thing of showing clothes (aside from specifically for plus sized ofc) on fat people. It's not as attractive.
I am a thin person but have been fat by the way.

OP posts:
Opaljewel · 22/05/2022 08:47

GrumpyInsomniac · 21/05/2022 19:30

From a brand perspective, I want customers to be able to see how our clothes look on larger and smaller sizes, because you can’t tell how something will look on a size 16 by looking at a model in a size 10.

In addition, we don’t retouch out scars, birth marks, tattoos, folds or stretch marks because those are all normal things and there is nothing wrong with them.

We’re currently working on expanding our range beyond a 16 and I look forward to including models of a larger size once the larger sizes become available. It’s been hard enough to persuade our design team to go there so it will be a major celebration for me and my team.

If you’re a size 10 and don’t like seeing larger models because they don’t relate to your experience of buying clothes, just scroll past the images of larger models and try to have some sympathy for those larger women who want the same chance as you to see clothes on a body more like their own before buying.

You sound absolutely amazing. Would love to know your brand. I might even buy from you once you expand.

SquidwardsBigBlowhole · 22/05/2022 08:46

@Merryclaire
Phrases like real women also drive thin women to overeating and emotional spiral. I know it wasn't used in that context in this thread, but it's naive to think only bigger women get insulted based on their appearance.

Opaljewel · 22/05/2022 08:46

ladygindiva · 21/05/2022 19:14

George at asda do this, I think it should catch on everywhere.

You know I love george for this!

All sizes are together and I don't have to go to a separate area for plus size. They make shopping so much easier and nicer.

I like new look clothes but they don't have a plus size in every store. And I live in a big city! They closed down the one I used to use and only one in the city centre has plus sized.

ICannotRememberAThing · 22/05/2022 08:39

I also love Boden etc where customers show how it looks on them. Best of both worlds.

I’ve not seen Boden but I also love this!
You get a much better idea of what the clothes are actually like - minus all styling that goes on during a photoshoot - safety pins at the back etc!

beattieedny · 22/05/2022 08:34

Apologies, my nephew was staying last night and I had almost forgotten how hard it is to get small children settled! I enjoy reading through the replies. I think it's like some said, style is aspirational and I want to see how things look on slimmer frames. I also love Boden etc where customers show how it looks on them. Best of both worlds.
As I said I have been fat myself and it was bloody miserable and uncomfortable. It's not healthy, but lots of things we all do are less than ideal, and for many it is tied on with more complex issues. It's not just a case of starving oneself. But slim people do, asthaetically, look nicer. Whether that is innate or cultural

OP posts:
Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 08:29

Giraffesandbottoms · 22/05/2022 08:14

Why are the majority of posters ‘overweight’? Is that a comment on posters on MN in general?

because most people in the UK are overweight, so logic dictates if the population are proportionately represented on here, they are mostly overweight.

it’s also pretty telling from the comments

I think slim people look better. That’s not “prejudiced”, that’s just my opinion on the matter. “Prejudiced” would be if I disliked fat people based on their weight. Which I don’t.

Perhaps it’s my industry, but the vast majority of women I know are very health conscious and not overweight - certainly those in the age groups that these fashion brands are aiming for anyway. But I do also know some wonderful, gorgeous women that have a BMI classed as ‘obese’.
However, it’s not a case of one or the other as the vast majority of people sit somewhere in the middle between ‘model thin’ and ‘obese’.
You are entitled to think slim people look better, but you should probably think about how your public remarks come across. So many people have a negative body image that causes issues, and it’s very sad.

FirewomanSam · 22/05/2022 08:20

Deakin and Blue (a swimwear brand) is another good one that, while not as size-inclusive as some, takes the radical approach of having three different styles for different body types/bust sizes as well as dress size. And a range of different women with different body types too. Buying from there was probably the first time I’ve seen a model that I thought looked roughly my size and shape!

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 08:14

Sweepingeyelashes · 22/05/2022 07:59

I am a size 8. I rather resent the idea that I am not a "real woman" because I'm not overweight with a healthy BMI. (Yes, we know it doesn't work with very fit athletes but you're probably not an All Black rugby player are you? ) A lady who ran a boutique once confessed to me why she stocked very few large sizes. She said that she'd have a customer in, find an outfit that looked great and then the customer said she wasn't going to buy new clothes till she lost weight!

Christ, no one sensible is saying that slim women aren’t ‘real women’ - it’s just a euphemism - like ‘curvy’ because the terms ‘fat’ and ‘obese’ are so weaponised. It’s not saying those who are slim therefore aren’t real or can’t have curves. But I think you know that really.

Making larger women feel crap about themselves by using only negative terms and not allowing them any positive representation is not going to cure the obesity epidemic - it just drives people down a negative spiral where they may keep overeating to feel emotionally better.

Giraffesandbottoms · 22/05/2022 08:14

Why are the majority of posters ‘overweight’? Is that a comment on posters on MN in general?

because most people in the UK are overweight, so logic dictates if the population are proportionately represented on here, they are mostly overweight.

it’s also pretty telling from the comments

I think slim people look better. That’s not “prejudiced”, that’s just my opinion on the matter. “Prejudiced” would be if I disliked fat people based on their weight. Which I don’t.

ICannotRememberAThing · 22/05/2022 08:11

Companies don’t seem to realise that larger women come in different shapes!

I’ve seen so many larger models used to advertise clothing.
9.5/10 times companies use extreme Apple shaped women - very large bust & torso, no waist, small bum, thinner legs and arms.

I am a size 24 and they don’t look anything like me.

I love it when ‘average’ sized models are used because I can work out how the clothes will fit/ hang.

FirewomanSam · 22/05/2022 08:10

Creative34 · 22/05/2022 06:53

‘Snag tights do this brilliantly’ 😂😂😂

They can’t exactly use a skinny model can they?! ... there’s no chub to rub!

Snag make many many products, not just the Chub Rub shorts you’re presumably referring to (which come in small sizes too btw) and they use a whole range of models. Not just fat people (I say ‘people’ because they’re not all women either!) they have some very slim models too.

They also use models of different sizes in their design process so they don’t just design on a small model then scale up the pattern for larger sizes. That shouldn’t be revolutionary but apparently it is!

Lazerbeen · 22/05/2022 08:04

I find it's more than diversity to companies largely seems to mean obese. There should be a range of women- from petite through to tall, muscly, slim, overweight- it's impossible I know to cover all bases but this diversity they harp on about still just means a small number of bodies represented. Model like and unhealthily overweight, none of the inbetween.

Sweepingeyelashes · 22/05/2022 07:59

I am a size 8. I rather resent the idea that I am not a "real woman" because I'm not overweight with a healthy BMI. (Yes, we know it doesn't work with very fit athletes but you're probably not an All Black rugby player are you? ) A lady who ran a boutique once confessed to me why she stocked very few large sizes. She said that she'd have a customer in, find an outfit that looked great and then the customer said she wasn't going to buy new clothes till she lost weight!

Penguinsaregreat · 22/05/2022 07:55

I like it when they say what size the model is and how tall. I don’t want short dresses. I need to be able to bend down etc in them and not show my backside. However I did buy a dress on the basis that it was ‘below the knee’ and the model was 5”9. When it cam it was fat shorter.
Axxan aside is there a shortage of good looking men? Most male models I see are very unattractive and not slim.

alilstressed · 22/05/2022 07:47

@Discovereads in some cultures, women with gaps in their teeth are considered to be very beautiful and highly favoured.
We need to shift this -often damaging- western standard of beauty.

HMSSophia · 22/05/2022 07:39

For fuck's sake, clothes are photographed on models in preset for you the buyer to aspire, to hope, to desire, to look good in the item. It's advertising - you know, all about manipulating you. It's got fuck all to do with helping the buyer seriously identify if they will look good in said item. It's about promoting the fantasy that you MIGHT look good. Hence the use of "beautiful" "aspirational" models

shivbo2014 · 22/05/2022 07:38

I want to see them on a range of different sizes. Lucy and Yak are good at this.

MenopauseSucks · 22/05/2022 07:37

They need to show how clothes are on short women!!!!
I'm 5ft tall & most short ranges are for women under 5ft 3 so still too long for me but I like to see how they hang & whether the clothes look take-upable!

pattish · 22/05/2022 07:36

Sunquench · 21/05/2022 22:18

A very brief description on thin privilege. I suspect this will divide a lot of people but I guess that boils down to how you view overweight people. I for one don’t always assume they’re lazy or gluttonous for being overweight. I don’t think it’s always a simple choice. If it was, everybody would be thin.

Sorry, I think the Emperor is naked there…

How the hell is there such a thing as thin privilege? Phrases like that make a mockery of white privilege/male privilege.

Not being obese isn’t something you are born with - in most cases people avoid obesity by eating healthily, not binge eating and living an active life. That doesn’t make them ‘privileged’ - it means they’ve made good choices.

Not really the same as being black, or being a woman, is it? What a joke.

SnowyPetals · 22/05/2022 07:34

PurpleDaisies · 21/05/2022 22:24

I think a good idea would be to just have every body type available to view. It costs more money maybe, but I think customers would appreciate it

How can that possibly work? You’d need masses and masses of models.

Personally, I would prefer to pay less for the clothes than suck up the inevitable additional cost of having multiple models for everything. You have to use your imagination anyway, because seeing a dress on a size 14 model who is busty with long dark hair isn't really helpful if you're a size 14 pear shape with short blonde hair.

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 07:34

Giraffesandbottoms · 22/05/2022 06:19

My comment about absurdly thin was in response to someone talking about “heroin chic” models.

I think size 8/10 is reasonable. These threads are always skewed because the majority of posters are overweight.

Why are the majority of posters ‘overweight’? Is that a comment on posters on MN in general? Or just those with opinions about body image? Either way you sound very prejudiced. In my experience, an obsession with body image takes up too much headspace in most women of every shape and size.
The OP clearly has issues with her own body image and wanted to stir up a debate about whether fat people should be allowed to exist in the same ‘beauty sphere’ as thin people.
However, no one should need the approval of others to feel attractive and represented. You’re not going to find every model aspirational regardless of how slim they are.
Thin people are in no way underrepresented in media or advertising so I really don’t see why it’s so offensive to see other body types being included for a change.

WalkerWalking · 22/05/2022 07:28

What gets me is that thin or larger, all these models still have unachievable figures (or rather, only achievable through photoshop).

I'd love to see thinner models with a bit of a belly, or anyone with some wobbly arm fat. If a website could show me someone looking good with my actual figure (straight legs, wide hips, flat bum, solid gut) they could have all my money! It's easy to look good if your plus size shape is a perfectly proportioned hour glass.

Thedogshouses · 22/05/2022 07:28

I agree. This morning or Lorraine modelled the new trend of peasted skirts on very large models the other day. Pleated skirts make anyone with a big arse look like a centour. I wonder how many women 16 and above truly love their curves and celebrate?

pattish · 22/05/2022 07:27

Blossomtoes · 21/05/2022 21:45

And heroin chic was?

I don’t think you can compare. Yes, we do have a problem with eating disorders, but it is nothing like even on the same scale as our obesity epidemic. If we teach young girls that it’s ok to be fat (and to think otherwise is ‘fat shaming’) they will grow up thinking having an unhealthy BMI is normal.

While that might be good for their mental health, it certainly isn’t good for their physical health.

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 07:22

Creative34 · 22/05/2022 06:53

‘Snag tights do this brilliantly’ 😂😂😂

They can’t exactly use a skinny model can they?! ... there’s no chub to rub!

Completely untrue - many slim people get chafing too. The idealised ‘thigh gap’ isn’t a reality for most as is dependent on hip and thigh width etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread