Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want all models to look like 'real' women?

237 replies

beattieedny · 21/05/2022 18:31

Just that really. I am much more likely to buy clothing if the model looks like looks slim. I don't care for the current thing of showing clothes (aside from specifically for plus sized ofc) on fat people. It's not as attractive.
I am a thin person but have been fat by the way.

OP posts:
PermanentlyTired03 · 22/05/2022 12:38

I think there's a happy medium- seeing a pencil thin person modelling a dress that would look better on a someone with hips and boobs is as bad as an obese model modelling a skimpy dress that only suits slender people.
It's good to have a mix but I find it hard to picture myself in an outfit when the model is really big and it's an unflattering look. To clarify- I'm a 12 so not a skinny minnie!

IstayedForTheFeminism · 22/05/2022 12:36

Arguing that a slimmer sibling has been to hospital more often than a larger sibling is ridiculous subjective logic

I did say not always true. Aka you can't extrapolate from my sample size of 2. Of course obese people on average need more healthcare than slim people.

But that doesn't negate the fact that bodies of all sizes need clothes. And the people buying the clothes want to know what they will look like on them.

DinoWoman · 22/05/2022 12:30

I'm finding it interesting to read that lots of people on this thread don't believe that seeing overweight and obese models more often in the media will make young girls think obesity is healthy. Yet at the same time I'm also seeing lots of talk about the negative impact of only seeing slim models. It doesn't make sense.

Arguing that a slimmer sibling has been to hospital more often than a larger sibling is ridiculous subjective logic. Obviously fat people on average are less healthy than slimmer people. There probably are fat people out there that eat healthy but eat too much or people with thyroid issues etc, but the reality is that most fat people eat significantly more unhealthy food than slimmer people.

I'm all for having average height models ranging from sizes 8 - 12. I'm not saying that fat people aren't entitled to look good and that their sizes shouldn't be available to buy. I do think that the growing trend for size 18 - 20 models will have a negative influence on younger girls.

We are doing the next generation a disservice to promote obesity in the way that we do. There is no point in protecting the mental health of fat people and then seeing their physical health ultimately suffer. Maybe not in their teenage years or 20s, but it generally will have an impact at some point in their lives.

Sushi7 · 22/05/2022 12:11

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 08:14

Christ, no one sensible is saying that slim women aren’t ‘real women’ - it’s just a euphemism - like ‘curvy’ because the terms ‘fat’ and ‘obese’ are so weaponised. It’s not saying those who are slim therefore aren’t real or can’t have curves. But I think you know that really.

Making larger women feel crap about themselves by using only negative terms and not allowing them any positive representation is not going to cure the obesity epidemic - it just drives people down a negative spiral where they may keep overeating to feel emotionally better.

”Real women have curves.” That makes women who are underweight or a healthy bmi feel excluded. Curvy means hourglass, not Jess Holiday.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 22/05/2022 11:52

Imo showing obese models isn't making it "OK" to be obese. (Although if you're happy then it's no one else's business really. And before anyone mentions nhs costs, my skinny sister uses the NHS more than I do so it's not always true)

What it does do is let us obese people see what the clothes look like on us. If I know I look as ok as a disgusting fat person can, I'm more likely to go out for a walk. I'm trying to lose weight. But I'm allowed to look nice in the mean time.

aSofaNearYou · 22/05/2022 11:43

DolphinaPD · 22/05/2022 11:15

I think it's good to show a range of body types, sizes and heights but I don't think it's right to use morbidly obese models. They should only use models within the healthy bmi range. They aren't supposed to use models with a bmi below 18 so why is it ok to use them with a bmi over 25?

It makes people think it's ok to be that size and I don't think it is. I don't care what anyone says, you cannot be that size and be healthy. Not for long, anyway.

And I say that as an obese person. I'm losing weight to become healthy.

Over 25? Are you sure that's the number you meant? That's just borderline overweight, it's not obese let alone morbidly obese.

DolphinaPD · 22/05/2022 11:15

I think it's good to show a range of body types, sizes and heights but I don't think it's right to use morbidly obese models. They should only use models within the healthy bmi range. They aren't supposed to use models with a bmi below 18 so why is it ok to use them with a bmi over 25?

It makes people think it's ok to be that size and I don't think it is. I don't care what anyone says, you cannot be that size and be healthy. Not for long, anyway.

And I say that as an obese person. I'm losing weight to become healthy.

sweeneytoddsrazor · 22/05/2022 10:28

I like the Yours website because it tells you the size and height of the model. The height is a great idea because I am on the edge of petite/regular so great way of working out where the hemline is likely to land or whether the wonder Web needs to come out.

motogirl · 22/05/2022 10:23

Yabu I'm far more likely to order online from companies that have models in a variety of sizes. My evening dress (thus expensive) came from the company that had plus sized models on their website

Spruik · 22/05/2022 10:20

I agree to an extent. I am overweight right now. I don't look or feel great and need to work on it. I don't need to see obese models to normalise unhealthy body weight. People are different shapes and sizes so I am not talking about different builds/heights/shapes but of the ads and companies that show unhealthy obese people in their clothes to normalise an unhealthy body and make them feel like its ok and they fit in. Just doesn't need to happen. There's a particular legging brand that advertise on Facebook that sell small sizes to super 40XL and show these unhealthy people in these tight clothes that don't flatter them anyway.

As I said I am overweight and want to do something about that for my health not look at others who are unhealthy in advertisements... Hard to explain my point in words but I get it. Unnecessary. Show us the different body shapes in healthy ranges in a variety of clothing instead of trying to make it ok to be obese and unhealthy...

FirewomanSam · 22/05/2022 09:57

I do. Stepping away from diet culture has genuinely changed my life. I have pity for people with nothing else to talk about but calories and keto and clothes sizes and obesity. The threads on here are so sad.

Same here @SexyLittleNosferatu. I’m a 14-16 and wouldn’t say I ‘celebrate my curves’, more that I just realised I have more interesting things to think and talk about. It was so liberating the day I realised I didn’t have to constantly talk about my size and weight and what I was going to have for dinner tonight and how it was ‘ok’ for me to have that cookie at lunch because I was going to the gym later. One day I just disengaged from that cycle completely and my life almost immediately improved for the better.

I exercise a lot because I enjoy it and it makes me feel good, I keep an eye on what I’m eating because I know what gives me energy and what makes me feel sick and sluggish. But I don’t try to ‘lose weight’ any more.

Ever since I stopped dieting I’ve taken far better care of my appearance and started buying clothes I like. When I was slimmer and perpetually dieting I lived in cheap shapeless crap because there was ‘no point’ buying nice clothes until I reached my mythical goal weight. That’s no way to live!

I find it sad when people make their weight their whole identity and their proudest achievement.

Sunquench · 22/05/2022 09:49

@SexyLittleNosferatu

Totally agree. On the one hand I think severe obesity is clearly a health issue and needs addressing, but on the other hand I am surrounded by women who are size 12s and 14s at work and relentlessly pursuing a thinner body and for what? Just eat nutritious foods when you’re hungry, stop when you’re full and move your body. Keep stress, alcohol, cigs to a minimum and live your life.

Ikeameatballs · 22/05/2022 09:41

www.sugarhillbrighton.com are good for showing a range of sizes/different models.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 22/05/2022 09:38

I mean as a size 10, 5'3, pear shape the 5'10 size 4 models give me absolutely 0 idea of what clothes will look like on me... so I'd like a variation

SexyLittleNosferatu · 22/05/2022 09:37

I wonder how many women 16 and above truly love their curves and celebrate

I do. Stepping away from diet culture has genuinely changed my life. I have pity for people with nothing else to talk about but calories and keto and clothes sizes and obesity. The threads on here are so sad. Hundreds of women who spend their lives desperatelt striving to be thin because they've been told thin is good and thin is the only way to achieve "health". Tearing down other women as they go and all for male approval. So men, mostly strangers, will nod their assent and say I approve of your body shape. Just sad.

Norgie · 22/05/2022 09:27

The models are hardly Jabba the Hut op.
People come in all shapes and sizes, and all need clothes.

Butchyrestingface · 22/05/2022 09:23

I'm 5 feet 2 and would like to see how clothes look on fellow short-arses and not just tall types (fat or thin).

SexyLittleNosferatu · 22/05/2022 09:19

its not shaming to say that models should be healthy looking

You can't tell if someone is "healthy" just by looking at them. You just mean thin. You assume thin equals healthy. Which is doesn't.

Lazerbeen · 22/05/2022 09:12

Opaljewel · 22/05/2022 08:46

You know I love george for this!

All sizes are together and I don't have to go to a separate area for plus size. They make shopping so much easier and nicer.

I like new look clothes but they don't have a plus size in every store. And I live in a big city! They closed down the one I used to use and only one in the city centre has plus sized.

The advantage of separate plus size ranges is that the clothes are not just scaled up from a smaller size (which starts to become distorted and out of proportion around a size 16)- but I agree that it shouldn't be a separate section should be able to look in the same place.

SemperIdem · 22/05/2022 09:04

I think different heights would be useful, not just different sizes.

A size 8 woman at 6ft looks very different to a size 8 woman at 5’6, it’s just the same for every other size.

Given the average height in the UK is 5’4 it is bizarre to me that clothes are modelled by women far and above the average height, regardless of size.

Echobelly · 22/05/2022 09:02

I think it's great that this has become almost a norm now - it helps to see how things will look on women of different sizes. I'm also glad that labels are starting to move away from just using perfectly-proportioned 'hourglass' shaped larger girls and using some who have big tummies as well - a friend of mine was asking a few years ago why she didn't see larger models who were her shape in that way.

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 09:01

SquidwardsBigBlowhole · 22/05/2022 08:46

@Merryclaire
Phrases like real women also drive thin women to overeating and emotional spiral. I know it wasn't used in that context in this thread, but it's naive to think only bigger women get insulted based on their appearance.

I absolutely agree it’s not just bigger women that are impacted. Let’s face it, women of all shapes and sizes have body image issues - even the most ‘attractive’ by society standards. And people can be so thoughtlessly critical.
But I do think it’s the overweight who are particularly marginalised.
I’m just pro diversity and representation for all body types really - would love to see this being more widespread so no one has to feel like they are unattractive and not worthy.

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 08:54

On a side note, for anyone into sewing, Tilly & the Buttons uses a very diverse range of models to show off each pattern, which is great.
I do think dressmaking is an amazing hobby for anyone who finds it hard to buy clothes that fit well as you can adjust every element of the pattern - e.g short torso, big boobs, wide shoulders, etc etc.

PurplePill · 22/05/2022 08:52

I would just like to see average sized models! Everything is to the extreme. Just a regular height, size 12 woman.

I am short, just shy of 5’2 and I don’t need to see clothes on a carbon copy of me - but at least in some way I can envision actually what the clothes would look like on me!

Opaljewel · 22/05/2022 08:50

I don't feel like we're normalising obesity. I feel like we're normalising a better shopping experience.

I still need clothes to wear when I'm fat. Surely you wouldn't want to look at me naked? Lol. I sure as hell don't.

At the moment, I am trying my best to lose weight. I'm going to the gym a few times a week and my friend is personal training me.

But guess what, I still like to look nice and in fashionable, flattering clothes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread