Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want all models to look like 'real' women?

237 replies

beattieedny · 21/05/2022 18:31

Just that really. I am much more likely to buy clothing if the model looks like looks slim. I don't care for the current thing of showing clothes (aside from specifically for plus sized ofc) on fat people. It's not as attractive.
I am a thin person but have been fat by the way.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Passedmybedtime · 23/05/2022 17:09

You say you don't care because you are slim, the vast majority are not though, again average uk dress size is 14 to 16, since we don't fit into slim or large we often get ignored by clothes designers. Models should come in all shapes and sizes. Tall and sturdy women to small and petite women. Gone is the tall supermodel type body. It's all arses, tummy or boobs or all of them now or average height slim women. As we move onto a more diverse culture clothes have to accommodate all body types. So this who cares attitude you have is selfish. And while we are on the subject why should petite or tall ladies pay extra for their clothes?

jammyrose · 23/05/2022 11:25

My favourites are the ones that show the same item on a few different models, showing a wide size range and how they look on the different body types.

SquidwardsBigBlowhole · 23/05/2022 09:38

@pattish oh my, that's insane. I can't believe how vicious some people can be! I can only assume you bring out an insecurity in her, because how can anyone have so much hatred to you for just existing?

And it's definitely still hard to find clothes when slim. I'm the same size as a typical model and clothes don't fit me. Even in the photos in online shopping - the clothes don't fit the models!

blameitonthecaffeine · 22/05/2022 23:46

I'm not sure the online shopping experience should be improved any further. It's already massively more convenient than actual shopping. The only advantage to going shopping in person is being able to see how the clothes look on you. Make that available to online shoppers too and you'll be nailing the coffin shut on the high street.

Also, posters on this thread (collectively) want models in a range of:
sizes
shapes
heights
levels of attractiveness
unusual physical features

If that became the norm, how would someone's success or suitability to be a model be determined? Anyone with a bit of confidence could do it. No need for any acting ability or special talent - just wear clothes. It would be impossible to select between the hundreds of thousands of would be models.

pattish · 22/05/2022 23:32

Also, I’d like to point out that you can be very slim and be healthy. I’m genetically very small and a size 6 - nothing I could eat would change that. There are lots of women like me. We don’t starve ourselves, we don’t have disordered eating, we just happen to be naturally small.

Buying clothes can be really difficult. Most of the shops I like - Whistles, French Connection, Hush - are completely out of bounds because the sizes aren’t small enough. For that I have to go to shops aimed at teenagers. But then the clothes are too young for me.

I wish clothing ranges would come in a bigger variety of sizes.

Passedmybedtime · 22/05/2022 23:28

The average womans size in uk is 14-16 so often those sizes are missed for bigger ladies or slimmer ladies and if they do have a 14 to 16 lady it's usually she has an hourglass figure which most of us falling into that size category do not have.

They should have models all shapes and sizes, not one or other but a wide range of models.

pattish · 22/05/2022 23:20

SarahSissions · 22/05/2022 22:43

I don’t really care, but what does bother me is pinning of clothes to make them fit better.

Yes! The number of times I’ve seen a lovely dress in a shop window only to find that the size ‘8’ would easily fit a size 12 but it was pinned on the mannequin. It’s so misleading.

pattish · 22/05/2022 23:19

SquidwardsBigBlowhole · 22/05/2022 08:46

@Merryclaire
Phrases like real women also drive thin women to overeating and emotional spiral. I know it wasn't used in that context in this thread, but it's naive to think only bigger women get insulted based on their appearance.

I agree. Some women are horrible to me.

I was in a clothes shop a little while ago and the sales manager made a comment to me about how slim I was. She said she hated me because all clothes would look good on me. I told her actually it wasn’t that easy to find clothes that fit well, being so petite. She said, ‘No, you’ll never make me feel sorry for you, I still hate you.’

Lovely woman.

SarahSissions · 22/05/2022 22:43

I don’t really care, but what does bother me is pinning of clothes to make them fit better.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 22/05/2022 22:39

grapehyacinthisactuallyblue · 22/05/2022 22:38

I'm Asian, and I'm flat chested, my body is like a child's body compared to western woman. So what should I do? Maybe they should do size 4 - 22, rather than 10-22. If they need to be representing everyone.

I did say there was no one super skinny or flat chested. And that it wasn't perfect but "better" than most sites.
That means they could do better.

grapehyacinthisactuallyblue · 22/05/2022 22:38

IstayedForTheFeminism · 22/05/2022 13:09

More sites should do this imo. Models range from 10-22 so you can see how it looks in a variety of sizes. Ok so there's no one super skinny, or flat chested. But it's better than a lot of shops are doing.

I'm Asian, and I'm flat chested, my body is like a child's body compared to western woman. So what should I do? Maybe they should do size 4 - 22, rather than 10-22. If they need to be representing everyone.

cont · 22/05/2022 22:29

Just what exactly are they being excluded from?

"Shaming is fine as long as it's not me being shamed". Really odd response to that persons statement to jump to the "who cares" response.

grapehyacinthisactuallyblue · 22/05/2022 22:26

Really doesn't bother me at all.
I'm slim. Most of the clothes fit me just fine.
If you are slim, then why does that bother you? You have so much choice.
Why does the fact there are clothes fit different sizes bother you so much?
I had no problem buying what i want, being very slim.

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 17:50

Sushi7 · 22/05/2022 12:11

”Real women have curves.” That makes women who are underweight or a healthy bmi feel excluded. Curvy means hourglass, not Jess Holiday.

Just what exactly are they being excluded from?

AffIt · 22/05/2022 15:11

As PPs have said, I would just like to see what clothes look like on somebody who looks like 12-14, early 40s me - I'm 5'9, so a bit taller than average, but certainly not a 6'+ catwalk stomper.

There must be a demand for a middle ground between size zero and 22?

ghostyslovesheets · 22/05/2022 14:47

Companies have cottoned on to the fact that larger women have money to spend on clothes - I mean maybe they should all be spending it on Peleton bikes, slim fast and diet fads - but why should they - women of all sizes and ages wear clothes - and buy them.

Thin doesn't equal healthy either - I was once under a size 4 - I was a chain smoking anorexic - now I am larger - healthy, exercise regularly and don't smoke - all the teen tiny folk here would probably think I'm huge compared to how I was - fuck that shit I'd rather be alive!

NippyWoowoo · 22/05/2022 13:14

beattieedny · 21/05/2022 18:31

Just that really. I am much more likely to buy clothing if the model looks like looks slim. I don't care for the current thing of showing clothes (aside from specifically for plus sized ofc) on fat people. It's not as attractive.
I am a thin person but have been fat by the way.

😂

Not even engaging, Mumsnet is full of fat haters and disordered eating. Knock yourself out.

IstayedForTheFeminism · 22/05/2022 13:09

More sites should do this imo. Models range from 10-22 so you can see how it looks in a variety of sizes. Ok so there's no one super skinny, or flat chested. But it's better than a lot of shops are doing.

to not want all models to look like 'real' women?
serenghetti2011 · 22/05/2022 13:03

I’d just like to see clothing modelled on all sized women, real is all of us, whether that be size 8 24, 10, 14, 18 etc short tall etc someone modelling an outfit in a size 6 will not help me imagine the same outfit on my size 14 figure especially if they are 5’10 and I’m 5’2 and yes I’m fat and I hate it and want to lose weight. I have no thyroid and it’s just not for shifting. I class myself as a real woman, I have a family, a job etc etc I don’t like the term based only on ladies who are since 14 and above - we are all real and we should all be represented in advertising and tv

dottiedodah · 22/05/2022 12:57

I think plump (not obese) models are fine to use.Most women in UK are size 16 plus anyway. Thus they are going to reach a wider audience with clothes shown on different dress sizes .(Also what about some shorter models too?)

DinosApple · 22/05/2022 12:54

I like to see different size models. For a start I can see quickly if something will flatter my body shape.

It saves the 'Oh this looks lovely' (on the size 8 model, Vs I try it on and look like a sack of spuds tied in the middle (size 14).

DyingForACuppa · 22/05/2022 12:49

TeenPlusCat · 21/05/2022 18:40

YABU. I wish they would show clothes on 3 models eg size 8, 14, 20
Maybe at the start of a website you could set your preferred size.
Some clothes translate well up the sizes, and some don't.

Yes, that would be good.

I dream of future websites that will let you put in your height and weight and it will show you the 'closest to your size' model wearing the clothes.

KettrickenSmiled · 22/05/2022 12:44

You have time to get mithered about 'real' women working as clothes models?

Are you not too busy making a twat of yourself by parading your ridiculous wish to impose your patriarchally-driven body facism onto other women?

Merryclaire · 22/05/2022 12:44

DinoWoman · 22/05/2022 12:30

I'm finding it interesting to read that lots of people on this thread don't believe that seeing overweight and obese models more often in the media will make young girls think obesity is healthy. Yet at the same time I'm also seeing lots of talk about the negative impact of only seeing slim models. It doesn't make sense.

Arguing that a slimmer sibling has been to hospital more often than a larger sibling is ridiculous subjective logic. Obviously fat people on average are less healthy than slimmer people. There probably are fat people out there that eat healthy but eat too much or people with thyroid issues etc, but the reality is that most fat people eat significantly more unhealthy food than slimmer people.

I'm all for having average height models ranging from sizes 8 - 12. I'm not saying that fat people aren't entitled to look good and that their sizes shouldn't be available to buy. I do think that the growing trend for size 18 - 20 models will have a negative influence on younger girls.

We are doing the next generation a disservice to promote obesity in the way that we do. There is no point in protecting the mental health of fat people and then seeing their physical health ultimately suffer. Maybe not in their teenage years or 20s, but it generally will have an impact at some point in their lives.

The problem is that model figures are not achievable for the vast majority of people, so being constantly told this is what is beautiful is extremely harmful if other examples are not also included. This limited scope makes thin and fat people alike feel like they are never good enough or thin enough.
I have never known a girl or woman see an obese model and then say - ‘they have inspired me to look the same’. But it might just boost the confidence of people who struggle tremendously with their weight.
The obesity epidemic is a big and very complex problem, but excluding those women from the beauty and fashion sphere and ostracising them is not going to help anyone.

DolphinaPD · 22/05/2022 12:39

aSofaNearYou · 22/05/2022 11:43

Over 25? Are you sure that's the number you meant? That's just borderline overweight, it's not obese let alone morbidly obese.

Yes, healthy bmi is 18-25.

Swipe left for the next trending thread