Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not wanting to share benefits with non-resident parent?

33 replies

MagnoliaPrimrose · 21/05/2022 13:39

Ex and I have 3dc, one with additional needs. I cannot work because of caring responsibilities for disabled dc. I get DLA for dc and carers allowance, also tax credits including disabled element for dc. This is my whole income, and I am gradually sliding into debt.

Ex has bi-polar disorder and hasn't worked since about 6 months after I met him. He stopped working when I became pregnant with dc1. He also became abusive at that point and I wasn't able to leave (as in psychologically I didn't see that I was able to, he had done a full on number on me). I worked throughout our relationship and we went on to have more dc (stupid of me - I know - but there we are). While on mat leave with dc3 I finally got the strength to leave and did so, moving back to my home town 50miles away - partly to escape ex and partly to get support from family etc.

We have been through court, various professional involvement and have an order of monthly contact, with option of mutually agreeing more.

Dc1 (disabled dc) didn't want to see ex for years and is old enough that he isn't subject to order (teen). Recently dc1 has decided he does want to see dad, and on advice from various professionals I am supportive of this.

Exs abuse was directed at me, not dc. I understand that they were being abused by witnessing, but there is no concern from any professionals involved about his contact with dc now and it is court ordered (just saying because I know people will say dc shouldn't be seeing him at all - that's not an option).

Ex lives in one bed flat. He says he doesn't have space to have all dc together. He wants to see dc1 separately to the others, and tbh that would be good for all - for dc1 to have 1:1 time with dad and others to have time away from dc1 (whose behaviour is challenging). But he says he can't afford it - the travel is too expensive and that I need to share the benefits with him to enable him to see dc1.

For the monthly contact - the court ordered arrangement is that we split the responsibility for travel and it's costs.

I cannot afford to subsidise ex in the way he is asking. But he may then say he cannot see dc1, or has to reduce how often he sees the other dc. AIBU to say it's his responsibility to find his contact?

For ref - he pays £30 pcm maintenance, and I pay for everything for the dc. They have nothing other than toothbrushes and toothpaste at his place.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KettrickenSmiled · 21/05/2022 19:19

He claimed in court that he no longer has any problems with his mental health because it was all my fault and now we are no longer together he's completely fine.
Great! He can get a job then.

But I do feel really conflicted because I do want dc1 to be able to see his dad.
How confident are you that Ex's cokehead days are behind him?
That he is not dealing drugs instead of earning a legal living?
That he is not still earning cash in hand & not declaring?

If you have doubts about any of this - he is not a man who is prepared to put his DC first. Your DC are therefore not going to benefit from having much more contact with him than they do.

None of the above is dc fault.
I know lovie. But their father is definitely a lying scammer, & possibly still a junk user/dealer. Who is exploiting their mother for cash, & using his DC as pawns in a game of brinkmanship. Who is enjoying harrassing their mother for kicks (as proved in court).

Think about it OP - he's prepared not to see them in order to coerce you into sending him a pathetic bit of cash. Cash that he's capable of earning for them himself - but doesn't.
DC don't need to know all this - but they need to be protected from it.
Flowers

MagnoliaPrimrose · 21/05/2022 19:05

The thing is, and I am very careful about who I speak to about this because I am aware that it may make me look unsympathetic - so just don't trust him.

Everything in his life is everyone else's fault and he accepts no responsibility for anything at all. When we were together it was always my fault that he was depressed, and was the 'reason' he was abusive and violent. He claimed in court that he no longer has any problems with his mental health because it was all my fault and now we are no longer together he's completely fine. While simultaneously cancelling telephone contact plans because he was too depressed.

He did cash in hand work when we were together while claiming benefits.

He forced me to go with him to his ESA interview. I know that these things need to be based on worst day but he pretended he was basically incapable of doing anything, walking down the road, looking at the interviewer, speaking in more than a mumble. He was never like that in real life, he spent a large part of most of his days sitting on the front step and chatting to absolutely everyone who went past. He was very active in organising and campaigning for a political party - travelling all over the country and talking to many many strangers in the street or at their doors while canvassing. He is incredibly talkative and gregarious.

For a period of years he took loads of coke, one weekend doing a 'deal' which involved spending £3000 on drugs that he was somehow going to recoup (presumably by selling it - I didn't know until it was all over, I do not support drug taking or dealing and tried to stop him with no success in general) but it ended up going up his and his mates noses and we were left without money to pay the bills that month.

I'm afraid I just don't trust him at all.

I moved away in large part to get away from him, because he was obsessed with me and harassing me (proved in court).

But I do feel really conflicted because I do want dc1 to be able to see his dad. None of the above is dc fault.

OP posts:
Isaidnoalready · 21/05/2022 18:52

With regards the chair

No you abandoned it

I asked you to remove it you refused thereafore you abandoned it and I owe nothing

I'm not paying come collect if your so inclined

Or a simple no im not paying you for that

Do not turn over the kids benefits to this man

RedPlumbob · 21/05/2022 18:39

@Soontobe60 did you miss the part where he was abusive? Every woman escaping DV is advised to move FAR away

KettrickenSmiled · 21/05/2022 18:12

It's not about "the moral high ground" @Soontobe60

It's about OP protecting herself from post-separation control by not allowing her ex to manipulate any communication with her. That includes taking a stand to prevent "thin end of the wedge" demands.

Did you ‘skate blithely past’ the bit about the OPs ex receiving PIP and having a mental health illness?

Most people with bi-polar - & I know some who have very severe symptoms - manage their illness via medication & counselling. It doesn't prevent them from working, or paying for their children. It certainly doesn't make them abuse their spouses.

Soontobe60 · 21/05/2022 17:57

KettrickenSmiled · 21/05/2022 15:08

This absolutely!
OP, you moved 50 miles away. If he had moved that far away, everyone here would be telling you that as he was the one who moved, he should pay travel expenses.

You say "moved 50 miles away" as if it is some kind of moral failing @Soontobe60. Strange how you focus on that, & skate blithely past the fact that this chancer abused OP for years:
While on mat leave with dc3 I finally got the strength to leave and did so, moving back to my home town 50miles away - partly to escape ex and partly to get support from family etc.

And as for -
I’d argue that if DS is spending a night at his father’s house, his father should get a % of the DLA.
You can argue as much as you wish. The courts disagree with you.
For the monthly contact - the court ordered arrangement is that we split the responsibility for travel and it's costs.

OP is only obliged to either do 50% of the travel, or meet 50% of the (already discounted to ex) travel costs - once per month.
At £6 per ticket, that would be £9 or £6 per month depending on how many of his DC this ex is prepared to see this month (he won't take all 3).

OP - the full time carer for the DC, who cannot work due to the needs of the ND child & because the children's other parent can only be arsed to see some of them once a month - is already falling into debt on a small income.
What is motivating you to suggest she hands over cash she desperately needs for her children to the man who abused her for years, & continues to do so post-separation?

What are you on about?
I’m stating facts. The OP moved away. Did you ‘skate blithely past’ the bit about the OPs ex receiving PIP and having a mental health illness?
With regards to the bit about DLA, the courts haven’t said a dicky bird about the DLA. It’s awarded to the child, for their benefit, to do things that they might not be able to do were they not to have the extra money. Like, oh I don’t know, visiting their father.
The only thing that is of any importance in all of this is the wellbeing and wishes of the child in question. As much as it would anger me to have to pay the travel costs were it me in the OPs situation, if it meant my child got to see the father they wanted to see, I’d bite the bullet and pay it. I have been in this situation having been through a very messy split and I always did my best put the needs of my child before that of any moral high ground.

krazykatzlady · 21/05/2022 15:14

I gave my ex the kids DLA.
The requests just got worse and worse....and I found out he wasn't buying the kids what they needed, so I stopped it.
Now I buy the kids everything they need even when they are with him...that way I know they are fed and clothed.

Find out if your disabled child can get a free bus pass - many council do them for disabled children/ or carer go free. Send your child with that for the travel.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/05/2022 15:08

This absolutely!
OP, you moved 50 miles away. If he had moved that far away, everyone here would be telling you that as he was the one who moved, he should pay travel expenses.

You say "moved 50 miles away" as if it is some kind of moral failing @Soontobe60. Strange how you focus on that, & skate blithely past the fact that this chancer abused OP for years:
While on mat leave with dc3 I finally got the strength to leave and did so, moving back to my home town 50miles away - partly to escape ex and partly to get support from family etc.

And as for -
I’d argue that if DS is spending a night at his father’s house, his father should get a % of the DLA.
You can argue as much as you wish. The courts disagree with you.
For the monthly contact - the court ordered arrangement is that we split the responsibility for travel and it's costs.

OP is only obliged to either do 50% of the travel, or meet 50% of the (already discounted to ex) travel costs - once per month.
At £6 per ticket, that would be £9 or £6 per month depending on how many of his DC this ex is prepared to see this month (he won't take all 3).

OP - the full time carer for the DC, who cannot work due to the needs of the ND child & because the children's other parent can only be arsed to see some of them once a month - is already falling into debt on a small income.
What is motivating you to suggest she hands over cash she desperately needs for her children to the man who abused her for years, & continues to do so post-separation?

Georgeskitchen · 21/05/2022 15:08

God no don't subsidise him. Can he not get a job?

KettrickenSmiled · 21/05/2022 14:54

Ex is asking me to pay him the value of a chair that we bought

Stop engaging at all over ChairGate.

He doesn't give a fuck about the chair.
How likely is it he would even spend any money he bullied out of you on this fabled bunk bed for the DC?
It is all about 2 things: 1) money 2) keeping you controlled.

Ignore the chair nonsense.
Short term -
If he raises it again (something tells me he will ...) "oh that ratty old relic? It's going to the dump. I'm not sure why you want me to give you money that I don't have because DC's chair is no longer usable - it's nothing to do with you, so don't ask about it again."
Medium term -
I recommend you get some co-parenting software to cut down on his manipulation-by-message.
If you are able to afford it (I know - sorry - but this is also an investment in your MH), set it up, send him his link, & make your first message on it -
"Hi Ex, this is the new software I told you about - we can manage all contact arrangements & schedules from this - next date is XYZ, can you confirm you are still seeing him/them - bye"
THEN BLOCK HIM ON EVERYTHING ELSE.

For a man who is only in his DC's lives once a month at best, he is taking up a horrible amount of space in your mind.
The software will help you 'distance' him. His name will no longer come up on your devices or social media.
It should also help increase his 'accountability' - as all his no-shows, unreasonable demands, extortion attempts etc will be safely stored in one central location ...
Very helpful for you to be able to store all this in one place.
Helpful for you not to knee-jerk respond to ad hoc messages coming in.
You will have the luxury of being able to log in when YOU see fit, manage his messages on a neutral platform, & ignore the fuck out of him the rest of the time.

Any more nonsense about chairs or money?
"It's not appropriate to ask me to give you the DC's benefit money. You have your own benefit money & discounted travel, both of which are provided in order to help you see your DC. Do not ask me for money again."
See? - then it's there, in black & white, on record.
And you DO NOT ALLOW him to drag you into discussion.
See links below for help with tactics & mindset:

www.revolutionlearning.co.uk/article/the-broken-record-technique/

www.e-counseling.com/mental-health/what-is-the-grey-rock-method/

outofthefog.website/what-not-to-do-1/2015/12/3/jade-dont-justify-argue-defend-explain

Soontobe60 · 21/05/2022 14:45

howtomoveforwards · 21/05/2022 14:32

He gets PIP, he can use that. Why should you use your child’s DLA when he won’t use his PIP?! Unbelievable. He really does think his needs are greater than your child’s

PIP is for the support of his own disability. And if he gets PIP, he clearly has needs himself. It is worth remembering here that there is a child that wants a relationship with their parent which is something no one can put a price on. It may not be the OP’s responsibility to financially facilitate contact but I am not sure it’s OK to put everything on the ex. Trying to find a compromise for the sake of the child is what is needed.

This absolutely!
OP, you moved 50 miles away. If he had moved that far away, everyone here would be telling you that as he was the one who moved, he should pay travel expenses.
Your DS wants to see his father. Even though it sounds like your ex is being an arse about the costs, surely the priority for both of you should be to facilitate your son’s wishes?
The question you should ask yourself is, ‘do I want to prevent my ds from seeing his father by refusing to pay the travel costs?’. Taking a moral stance here by insisting on sticking to the court ordered agreement may not be the way forward. I’d argue that if DS is spending a night at his father’s house, his father should get a % of the DLA.

RedPlumbob · 21/05/2022 14:36

howtomoveforwards · 21/05/2022 14:32

He gets PIP, he can use that. Why should you use your child’s DLA when he won’t use his PIP?! Unbelievable. He really does think his needs are greater than your child’s

PIP is for the support of his own disability. And if he gets PIP, he clearly has needs himself. It is worth remembering here that there is a child that wants a relationship with their parent which is something no one can put a price on. It may not be the OP’s responsibility to financially facilitate contact but I am not sure it’s OK to put everything on the ex. Trying to find a compromise for the sake of the child is what is needed.

With a father who he didn’t want to see for years - children don’t decide that on a whim. A child should not have to sacrifice out of their own disability payments, and the fact that it’s a mere £6 makes it even worse that the ex is demanding it comes out of DLA. What sort of father does that? A shit one, and the child probably won’t benefit much from a relationship with this arsehole.

As for his chair, OP, he can fuck right off with that too.

timeisnotaline · 21/05/2022 14:36

Why would you pay him for the chair? Of course you don’t. And your sons dla is not something to be sent to his dad. If he asked you for some of your wages every month would you be able to say no? This money is yours and you need it.

howtomoveforwards · 21/05/2022 14:32

He gets PIP, he can use that. Why should you use your child’s DLA when he won’t use his PIP?! Unbelievable. He really does think his needs are greater than your child’s

PIP is for the support of his own disability. And if he gets PIP, he clearly has needs himself. It is worth remembering here that there is a child that wants a relationship with their parent which is something no one can put a price on. It may not be the OP’s responsibility to financially facilitate contact but I am not sure it’s OK to put everything on the ex. Trying to find a compromise for the sake of the child is what is needed.

roarfeckingroarr · 21/05/2022 14:29

He's full of shit and a chancing bastard OP. You owe him nothing. Definitely not half the new value of an old damaged chair or the benefits you receive to look after your children every other day of the month.

Cailleachian · 21/05/2022 14:28

Was your third child born after 2017?

If so, he could claim Child Benefit for DC3, while you are unable to cos of 2 child limit. He would then also then be eligible to receive the child element of universal credit.

MagnoliaPrimrose · 21/05/2022 14:26

The £500 seems to be in Wales and maybe Scotland only but not England where I am.

Ex says he already spends all of his PIP on seeing the dc.

I'm sure he does get a hefty travel discount because dc told me it costs him £6 each for them to travel to his, and I know that fill price is at least 3 times this.

Ex is asking me to pay him the value of a chair that we bought together years ago, which is at my house and has been gradually ruined by dc1. I have offered him to take this chair many times and he hasn't. I really need to replace it and get some more sofas because we haven't enough for everyone to sit comfortably and I'm watching eBay and free local sites until something suitable comes up. Ex says that he wants the original value of the chair so that he can get a bunk bed for his place for the dc. I know for a fact that there are local charities he could ask for help to get furniture of this sort. I really don't want to pay him for a chair which I will soon have to take to the tip and pay myself to replace.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 21/05/2022 14:15

FatEaredFuck · 21/05/2022 14:04

I would consider it cheap respite if you can hand him back the £30 a month (I wouldnt cancel it) and maybe take DC1 food when you drop him off.

Yes you shouldn't have to pay anything, but sounds like if you are financially able to stretch at all it might be beneficial all round.

She isn't "financially able to stretch".
It's right there in the 1st paragraph FFS:
This is my whole income, and I am gradually sliding into debt.

Benefits are not a Mumsnet Chicken.

RedPlumbob · 21/05/2022 14:14

Don't give him a penny. DLA is for your child’s additional needs. You are already in debt. He has done fuck all to help you for years. You owe him nothing.

He gets PIP, he can use that. Why should you use your child’s DLA when he won’t use his PIP?! Unbelievable. He really does think his needs are greater than your child’s.

KettrickenSmiled · 21/05/2022 14:12

He is blackmailing you.

For the monthly contact - the court ordered arrangement is that we split the responsibility for travel and it's costs.
Don't give in - at very best you could concede paying half ex's travel costs - but it would be better to simply arrange to do half of the travel (ie pay your own fares/fuel) than actually hand over cash to him.
**
Because the first time you do that - he will take it as a green light to start extracting more. I guarantee it.

Also - it will allow him to 'win' ie he has exerted control, & bullied you again. I don't think that will be good for you.

it is NOT your responsibility to facilitate him seeing his son. It is his own job to ensure he has the money & means to do so.
I'm saying this because between the lines I can read some MumGuilt - that you may feel it's your fault that DC1 won't get to see his dad. But that's down to dad - not you. He chooses not to work - he chooses to manipulate you into funding his travel to see his own child FFS - what a despicable lowlife.

I'm so sorry you are having to endure this post-separation abuse. Because there is no doubt - this is what he is doing. I hope you gather strength & resolve from your thread, & don't spend a moment longer worrying about what you 'ought' to do for your ex. It's horrible for DS (& the other DC) but they are going to find out who their father really is in their own time. It's not your fault he's a shiftless arsehole who is trying to exploit their mother.
Flowers

Isaidnoalready · 21/05/2022 14:10

No its not for him it's for the benefit of the child

Is there specific equipment you can share? (Literally the only example I can think of) like a trampette or sensory swing that you can get for his house out of the dla?

cooldarkroom · 21/05/2022 14:10

You are already getting into debt.
You cannot afford it.
He will have to kids in 2 groups on a rotational basis

CandyApplePie · 21/05/2022 14:09

If he is on pip is he not entitled to a discounted travel? I know someone who gets discount on trains/ and free on buses, don’t know if that’s everywhere though

howtomoveforwards · 21/05/2022 14:06

M y child receives DLA and whilst I don’t share that with the ex, I do make sure that said child has what he needs when he’s at dad’s. I buy extra for him to take to dad’s and leave there, for example, but I recognise that I am fortunate to be able to continue working and as such my income isn’t as limited as yours. Is there a compromise you could come to over equipment/medication/ etc that would help?

RandomMess · 21/05/2022 14:06

It's emotional blackmail, yet more abuse of you.

You cannot afford it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread