Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

This isn’t selfishness

62 replies

FourteenCats · 21/05/2022 08:41

Been having difficulties for a while juggling a lot- work/SEN dc/health issues etc .
Decided to give up and try to have a career break and get better , get things sorted out at home and for dc.

However, DSis has now decided that me no longer working means I share care of elderly parent with her. I’ve said no. I am not well and gave up in order to sort out things at home and with dc not to be sharing the responsibility with her. I’ve suggested we look at carers as I’m not going to be available.

i will also add that I had a terrible relationship with DM and I was not treated well and we’ve been extremely low contact and at times no contact over the years. I’m not even in the Will so I really feel like she wouldn’t want me caring for her anyway even if I was willing.

Ive made the decision I have for my family and I’m being help up as an example of pure selfishness

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mossstitch · 22/05/2022 13:55

What seems to have been missed is that the mother is getting attendance allowance, that is money given to people who need care in order to pay towards it........ I work with a lot of elderly patients, many running their children ragged who refuse to actually spend this money for the purpose it is intended.
Also a lot of posters are coming from the point of view of a normal loving family, the op has pointed out that she does not have a good relationship with either her mother or her sister. Only people with similar dysfunctional families can understand. If they were normal loving relatives they would realise not to add any further stress to somebody who has given up work to care for special needs child and is on the verge of burnout already.
Looking after yourself op and, therefore, being able to look after your children should be your priority💐💐

Thatboymum · 22/05/2022 13:08

MargosKaftan · 21/05/2022 09:12

Perhaps you should say to your sister "so can I be clear, you think I should provide my time for free to care for our mother, because otherwise her savings would have to be used to pay for external care. As I have been cut out of her will, this means you think I should provide my labour for free to ensure you get a good inheritance? Is that correct?"

Point out if she wants to run herself ragged to protect her inheritance, that's a choice she and her DP can make.

^Exactly this it’s true and straight to the point ^

MargosKaftan · 22/05/2022 12:46

@Onwards22 - but the Dsis is chosing to do 100% of the care. Theres money available to buy in care so the sister doesn't have to do it all. Theres money available so the sister doesn't have to do any care. But she is chosing not to use that money that way, in order to spend it on something for herself when her mother dies.

The sister has a choice. She can provide the care and protect the inheritance, or she can spend the money on care, inherit less /nothing, but have more time now. What she wants is to both not do all the care and inherit all the money.

The OP isn't wrong to say no.

ATadConfused · 22/05/2022 10:28

Onwards22 · 21/05/2022 10:34

YABU I feel sorry for your Dsis.

I’m sure she’s had her own issues with her parents but she’s now doing 100% of the caring.

If you don’t work then you could offer to help out a tiny bit even if it means dropping shopping off once a week or something.

Honestly I can see why you’re not in the will as you seem pretty selfish.

How many children with SEN do you care for??

How did your parents treat you??

id suggest a long walk on a shirt pier, it's a lovely day for it.

ATadConfused · 22/05/2022 10:27

MargosKaftan · 21/05/2022 09:12

Perhaps you should say to your sister "so can I be clear, you think I should provide my time for free to care for our mother, because otherwise her savings would have to be used to pay for external care. As I have been cut out of her will, this means you think I should provide my labour for free to ensure you get a good inheritance? Is that correct?"

Point out if she wants to run herself ragged to protect her inheritance, that's a choice she and her DP can make.

Spot on!!

myuterusistryingtokillme · 21/05/2022 11:22

There’s resistance over paid care I think when the family feel needs could be met for free

Well of course there is, I imagine from the people who are set to inherit....in which case they can provide the free care and benefit financially from it.

minipie · 21/05/2022 11:19

If your mum has savings they should be used for her care, end of. I’ve no truck with this saving the inheritance stuff. Old age is what savings are for. If your Dsis would rather do it herself and save the inheritance that’s her choice, nothing to do with you.

Colourfulrainbows · 21/05/2022 11:19

@FourteenCats if your sister wanted to go down the route of social care assessment for additional carers.

They would do an assessment of needs and decide how much care required. They would either get the care in from an agency on the framework or source to a direct payments team to do this.

They can also assist with personal assistant rather than agency if required the same person.

Dependant on your local authority. There would also be a financial assessment, savings would be taking into account regarding if social care funded part all or mum would have to self fund.

This would be based on your mum's income.

If you want any other advice regarding what I know ( not a social worker but work within this area and doubt in same LA). Just PM me.

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 21/05/2022 11:13

@FourteenCats

I'm close to my parents and I do things to help
Practically as and when I can but at the moment they're still able.

However I have made it clear to them both that I will not be providing care where caters are needed.

It's not personal at all and I saw my dad and uncles and aunties ran ragged with grandparents for years before they eventually went into a home and I will not be doing the same.

My grandparents refused carers because they didn't want to spend the money even though they had it because they wanted to leave it for their dc in death however by which point the mortgages were paid off and pensions were coming into force and my dad still says now how hard it was and there was three of them plus partners.

I have one sibling a few years older than me that lives closer with no work so is free however she does nothing to help my parents ever and it's always me who gets the call so I know very well how it would go.

I totally agree with you and you should tell your sibling the money and savings are to be used for care and if and when that runs out then you can review the situation however you will not be participating in personal care

Onwards22 · 21/05/2022 11:09

That was responding to the standard set by the poster I was replying to. If that's the standard, I'm off the hook, which is contrary to the actions I have taken, if you actually read the post.

@WildCoasts sorry I misread the tone of your post.
I thought you were being serious!

Nanny0gg · 21/05/2022 11:07

FourteenCats · 21/05/2022 09:00

She gets attendance allowance I think plus has savings I suggested that could be used and I’d help to arrange carers but apparently I should be helping to avoid savings etc being used

So your sister doesn't want to eat into her inheritance?

Then she'll have to 'earn' it

WildCoasts · 21/05/2022 11:03

Onwards22 · 21/05/2022 10:56

Lucky you to not understand what some people have to experience. I suppose I'm off the hook though as my parents haven't been childcarers for me or offered financial support.

Lol

So the amount of care your elderly parents get is dependent on how much they take care of their grandchildren or how much money they give their adult children?

Jeez!
How about the time and money they spent on raising you when you were a child.

That was responding to the standard set by the poster I was replying to. If that's the standard, I'm off the hook, which is contrary to the actions I have taken, if you actually read the post.

In my parents own words, I didn't cost them much, leaving home at 17 and requiring nothing from them from then. I'm quite willing to help out my parents anyway, but not in the remote overseas location they have taken themselves to. That was an impractical decision on their part. If they want to come back, I can help them more.

Onwards22 · 21/05/2022 10:56

Lucky you to not understand what some people have to experience. I suppose I'm off the hook though as my parents haven't been childcarers for me or offered financial support.

Lol

So the amount of care your elderly parents get is dependent on how much they take care of their grandchildren or how much money they give their adult children?

Jeez!
How about the time and money they spent on raising you when you were a child.

Colourfulrainbows · 21/05/2022 10:56

@ChoiceMummy

You are adamant that the OP is Shefish and sister is shefless.

You are missing a variable... What is the sisters circumstances. Yes she has her own life as well but the OP does as well.

Did you miss the bit where she has taken a carer break due to additional need child going through echp and her own health issues? And it's only since she has taken this break that her sister has asked. Therefore ignoring why she has taken a carer break.

Yes I read your post about how much you do. So do lots of others. So do I but this is not about what you do i do. But the OP s own limits - which is absolutely fine to have and should not be made to feel guilty for it.

My own son has additional needs and I have 1 child so when I am old and because of his circumstances, he won't be able to care for me in my old age should I be calling him Shefish for that? Erm no it is not the onus on my child to look after me when I am old. Even without his needs I did not have a child to care for me when I am older. I am the parent.

We have a social care system in this Country for exactly these reasons. ( a bit not always brilliant).

There are many many families who are not able to provide the care to their parents in elderly. There are some who can but choose not to.

Calling her Shefish and her sister selfless without knowing both circumstances is making a huge judgement.

Just because you can do everything, don't mean everybody else can. Sorry but you come across as very unempthatic for some one who says has children with additional needs and previous health issues themselves.

Or maybe annoyed that the onus and pressure was on you.

LicoricePizza · 21/05/2022 10:52

Majority of the posters on here should be ashamed of themselves. Their attitude towards their own vulnerable parents is deplorable.

But if you’re physically & emotionally incapable of providing care or support - which the OP is - why is that so unacceptable? She’s offering to arrange carers & do the little she can from home. Even if she had a good relationship with her DM she could still be incapacitated from being able to help (although would obviously feel very differently about it).

YANBU or selfish OP

WildCoasts · 21/05/2022 10:35

ChoiceMummy · 21/05/2022 10:28

Majority of the posters on here should be ashamed of themselves. Their attitude towards their own vulnerable parents is deplorable.
I hope that all those having these opinions have expressed this is how they feel to their parents, so they're fully aware. And I presume they have never accepted free childcare from their parents, or financial assistance of any kind. Because to have done so when of this opinion is is an even bigger hypocrisy.

Lucky you to not understand what some people have to experience. I suppose I'm off the hook though as my parents haven't been childcarers for me or offered financial support. They have been there in a couple of emergencies, as I have for them and always would be. My parents also never lifted a finger to care for their own elderly parents as they had siblings closer who did all the work.

I have encouraged my parents to stay closer to me so that I can provide support in old age. Instead they have taken themselves to some remote location with no services or family available, overseas. So I have informed them there is a limit to what support I can give them as I can't be jetting back and forth all the time.

I've got decades more caring for others ahead of me. Avoiding burnout is a priority for me. I'm sure my rich, childless sibling will have an opinion about it but too bad. People can think what they like because they aren't living my life.

Onwards22 · 21/05/2022 10:34

YABU I feel sorry for your Dsis.

I’m sure she’s had her own issues with her parents but she’s now doing 100% of the caring.

If you don’t work then you could offer to help out a tiny bit even if it means dropping shopping off once a week or something.

Honestly I can see why you’re not in the will as you seem pretty selfish.

ChoiceMummy · 21/05/2022 10:28

WildCoasts · 21/05/2022 10:24

Actually no, it doesn't make a difference if she is in the will or not. If OP is stretched to her limit, she can't do it. It's not like she hasn't offered an alternative way to help.

Whether sister can do it or not is also immaterial. Let's assume the sister has equal reasons she can't do it alone. Then she needs to accept that neither of them can give the required level of support and organise outside help.

Majority of the posters on here should be ashamed of themselves. Their attitude towards their own vulnerable parents is deplorable.
I hope that all those having these opinions have expressed this is how they feel to their parents, so they're fully aware. And I presume they have never accepted free childcare from their parents, or financial assistance of any kind. Because to have done so when of this opinion is is an even bigger hypocrisy.

cushioncovers · 21/05/2022 10:28

Not it's not selfish op. It's you putting your mental health first. You don't have a good relationship with your mother and she obviously doesn't think much of you if she's cut you out if her will. So I would support your sister in other ways if you can. If your sister can't understand this then unfortunately your relationship with her may ultimately suffer as well but there's not a great deal you can do about that. Toxic parenting can have a long lasting effect.

ChoiceMummy · 21/05/2022 10:24

Colourfulrainbows · 21/05/2022 10:07

@WildCoasts

Totally get that one. Problem you get when you care for others in your life is that you become naturally inclined to want to help.

Then the guilt when you can't or just want to say erm sorry no I can not do that as already have abc.... Defgxyz to do.

What I learned over the years is the people who get it and understand when you say no to things without having an issue or making you feel bad. Are the people who stay in your life.

OP has already made the hard choice a lot of people who have SEN children have to do as in taking a break from a carer ( maybe in the future she will be able to go back). And look after her health.

This is not the time for others to add to what is already a lot of pressure things going on in life

On the other hand we don't know the sisters circumstances.

If sister is literally got no other additional caring responsibility, health issues then she is being inconsiderate even asking the OP.

However if sister also has additional things then it's more circumstances and outside help would be beneficial for all.

Regardless of the inheritance. OP basically should not be made to feel guilty or called Shefish for taking a huge step in admitting that it would be too much.

Some people have nothing additional to have to look after, just run of the mill work life etc yet can not care for the parents.

Some people blatantly refuse to care for others. Some people give the children up because they can not care for them.

Everybody has there own boundaries and limitations but nobody should be made to feel guilty for that. X

I disagree.
The sister is most definitely not being selfish. Selfless yes.
She's done all of the care to date. Presumably whilst running her own home, family needs work etc. And now the op actually could step up, she's reaching out obviously in need and wanting to share the load in the best interests of their mother.
The advice should be that the op should be looking out for her sister's needs! Given that she's ensured her own are met.

WildCoasts · 21/05/2022 10:24

ChoiceMummy · 21/05/2022 10:20

So if she's in the will that makes a difference?

Atm, the op does not know for absolute definite she's not in the will and is by the sound of it, making the decision to not provide care for her own mother, as a result of this possibility.

Actually no, it doesn't make a difference if she is in the will or not. If OP is stretched to her limit, she can't do it. It's not like she hasn't offered an alternative way to help.

Whether sister can do it or not is also immaterial. Let's assume the sister has equal reasons she can't do it alone. Then she needs to accept that neither of them can give the required level of support and organise outside help.

ChoiceMummy · 21/05/2022 10:21

Colourfulrainbows · 21/05/2022 09:49

@FourteenCats what is your sisters circumstances?

Sorry you have some people jumping on you saying you are being Shefish. When you have made the presumably hard choice to take a carer break to help your child and look after your own health.

I mean you have given up your carer at this moment as you have too much and need to concentrate on that. Yet people then say you are Shefish for recognising this.

Anybody would think that you took a carer break as a holiday not for real life stuff.

To the post who is all I work I have multiple children with additional needs and she is Shefish... We ain't all superhuman bit of empathy and understanding would have been better. Do u recall going through assessments? Are fighting to get support for your children.

And yes I have lost a parent and my other parent has health needs. None of my siblings call me Shefish for not being a carer for my parent.

They may not say it, but they will be thinking it.

WildCoasts · 21/05/2022 10:20

@Colourfulrainbows Totally agree. I'm a natural caregiver type and always have been. I know it's expected that the bulk of the care for elderly parents will fall on me too. In spite of the childless sibling who doesn't have additional care responsibilities for anyone. I think it's age, maturity and life experience that has finally given me the ability to say no and not feel bad about it. I have had to tell my parents that I have limitations in relation to their care, especially with some of the choices they have made, but no-one could call me selfish and be fair. I do feel a bit bad about it, as much as I am aware how important those limitations are so I can keep going.

ChoiceMummy · 21/05/2022 10:20

WildCoasts · 21/05/2022 09:39

I don't think this is fair. I limit the work I do and still skirt the edges of burnout sometimes because of the care I am already doing. At one point I could have taken more on but, as the years have dragged on, it's got to where I know I need to put my ability to continue caring and well being first, and not be afraid to say no. It gets harder, we don't get any younger.

In OP's case, I think she is being generous. She has offered financial resources to help fund a carer knowing her mother has cut her out of her will and is giving it all to her sister. Her mother has sent her a strong message, not a good one, so she's lucky her daughter is willing to do that much for her.

So if she's in the will that makes a difference?

Atm, the op does not know for absolute definite she's not in the will and is by the sound of it, making the decision to not provide care for her own mother, as a result of this possibility.

Colourfulrainbows · 21/05/2022 10:07

@WildCoasts

Totally get that one. Problem you get when you care for others in your life is that you become naturally inclined to want to help.

Then the guilt when you can't or just want to say erm sorry no I can not do that as already have abc.... Defgxyz to do.

What I learned over the years is the people who get it and understand when you say no to things without having an issue or making you feel bad. Are the people who stay in your life.

OP has already made the hard choice a lot of people who have SEN children have to do as in taking a break from a carer ( maybe in the future she will be able to go back). And look after her health.

This is not the time for others to add to what is already a lot of pressure things going on in life

On the other hand we don't know the sisters circumstances.

If sister is literally got no other additional caring responsibility, health issues then she is being inconsiderate even asking the OP.

However if sister also has additional things then it's more circumstances and outside help would be beneficial for all.

Regardless of the inheritance. OP basically should not be made to feel guilty or called Shefish for taking a huge step in admitting that it would be too much.

Some people have nothing additional to have to look after, just run of the mill work life etc yet can not care for the parents.

Some people blatantly refuse to care for others. Some people give the children up because they can not care for them.

Everybody has there own boundaries and limitations but nobody should be made to feel guilty for that. X