Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is she being unreasonable about holidays?

209 replies

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 00:10

I have a sibling who lives abroad in Australia. He wanted to come home on holidays and it was his plan for months to come home this summer on holidays. My mom was cleaning the house in preparation for his return home.

He called home recently to say he's taking his fiancée and child. We met his fiancée before and she is a beautiful lady through and through. I am looking forward to seeing them.

Now my mom is apprehensive about him coming home. She is upset and anxious. We don't have the best of homes. It's ok. It's a roof over our heads. I was helping mom cleaning.

Now she doesn't want them coming home. She says she will get me to look for a holiday home for their stay and she will pay. I had a nightmare online all night looking for a place for them to stay but honestly I am having no luck whatsoever. I actually feel sick. The only places available are actually costing 1000s for a month.

Mom went to bed and she said we will look again tomorrow. I really don't think my mom is understanding me. Accommodations is is not available. Summer rentals would have been booked months ago and months in advance. My mom is expecting me to find a place out of thin air and within her budget. Three times toniishe asked me about the local apartments. Those apartments were always long term rentals and they are not available. She is expecting me to magic a home out of thin air. I don't get this though. The space is available at home. It's not the best quality but it's ok. Some cleaning over the next few more weeks and it should be better. My mom is flat out turning down the idea of now having them stay at home nor will she tell them what her stance is on this. It's all a mess. I think she's just being nervous but I think it will fall into place of they do come home. When they do come back and if they stay at home, they won't be here all the time. They will be going away here and there.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/05/2022 10:15

If mom was to leave me at it cleaning for a whole entire weekend I could put shape to a lot of rooms but she won't let me because she wants control over it all

That's why hoping to "get the place in shape" is unlikely to work, and I doubt a bit of "airing" will cut it

It's not clear whether your DB realises just how bad things are, but it'll probably be a hell of a shock to his fiancee. Personally I wouldn't want a child around this sort of thing, and if she comes and feels the same there could be an even worse problem

There doesn't seem any easy solution, but I'd tell your DM very clearly that the rented accommodation isn't going to work and perhaps have a very honest conversation with your DB

burnoutbabe · 21/05/2022 10:15

If they just need a bed for a few days and somewhere to leave bags why can't they leave bags at yours ) and just book b&b for those days?

Thethreecs · 21/05/2022 10:05

This sounds very stressful.

Your dm is obviously a hoarder. She will not be able to allow someone to take control. This is how her brain works. To non hoarders, we see the 'stuff', we can easily say bag it up, store it, throw it out. To a hoarder this is their life's precious possessions.

A hoarder will want to keep their things in the home. Unless they have reached the point of wanting to get rid of some of it you'll have to work around it and come up with a plan to make some space.

Your brother obviously knows his dm is a hoarder, he will have told his partner. His partner will know it's more than untidiness.

Speaking from personal experience, when I couldn't get a hotel when visiting my parents and had to stay with them, I arranged one bed room, the sitting room, the kitchen. The bedroom I would stay in I would move the stuff out off to another room, same with the sitting room, move stuff to a spare room. The kitchen I would wash and sort dishes and make enough space to cook. Anything I moved into a spare room I would then lock that room. I would then air the rooms and put fresh bedding on, give it a good hoover etc

It's overwhelming for a hoarder to have their belongings touched, it's overwhelming for them to do it. It's overwhelming for them to watch it being done. You need to explain that you're just temporarily moving things and will move them back. You're not throwing anything out.

By just doing a couple of rooms, enough for your brother and his family to stay, it won't take as long and they'll have a room they can stay in comfortably.

I wouldn't be giving up beds and rooms, you could assemble the bed and put in a high air bed, there's fantastic air beds out there now. The child can sleep in with the parents on an airbed. Buy a small TV for the bedroom so that they can go there for their own space. Tvs are really cheap now and they can watch Netflix on it.

The main thing is, once there's enough space to move around the rooms they'll be using then it will feel better. It doesn't matter if the walls are lined with possessions. Sometimes when we think of hoarders we think of those programmes on TV where they're climbing over 6ft of stuff, but there are hoarders who just keep everything and stack it in any space available meaning they can never clean properly or have it looking tidy.

Once your dm sees the progress without having to throw her belongings out she will be OK. She probably won't while it's happening and there'll be arguments etc but I always found not working at a really fast pace, showing I was careful and respectful of their belongings and explaining what I was doing helped.

Good luck with it all. I understand the stress and it is very difficult to deal with.

nomistake · 21/05/2022 10:04

I agree with those saying rent a storage unit for the clutter, bring in a cleaner and a decorator to give the place a spruce.

LicoricePizza · 21/05/2022 09:59

Is the kitchen & bathroom accessible & user friendly albeit maybe dated or tired/shabby? No offence intended.
How long do you have before they arrive?
Need you go to the trouble of decorating/painting? Your mum may be embarrassed but as long as it’s functional & clean that’s all that really matters.

Porcupineintherough · 21/05/2022 09:43

thevanilla · 21/05/2022 00:49

Well it’s her home so she’s not being unreasonable to decide who stays and who doesn’t

It's pretty unreasonable to tell someone they can stay, let them book flights then pull the rug out from under them though. And likely to severely damage the relationship with her son and his family.

Teaandtoastedbiscuits · 21/05/2022 09:43

Sorry I don't know how to link it but it's clean bee.ie they did a fab job on my moms house, just clear and dump what you need to first, maybe once she sees that done she might decide to do painting or whatever is annoying her about the house

Teaandtoastedbiscuits · 21/05/2022 09:39

I don't think you are being unreasonable your mom is , but that fact isn't going to help the situation. Are you living in proximity to a university/college campus? Sometimes they are available during the summer months. You could contact the colleges to see if private landlords would be willing to short let the houses they rent to students. I'm in Ireland too so I know just how ridiculous her request is but the simple fact of the matter is that their visit is causing her extreme anxiety.
Could you broach it as this being a perfect opportunity to get the house in order, if you are near the real capital😉i know of a c9npany called clean bee who will come in and blitz the whole house from top to bottom inside and out for about a grand. I'll try send a link if I can

Pandarinio · 21/05/2022 09:36

My mom is flat out turning down the idea of now having them stay at home nor will she tell them what her stance is on this. this is so unfair on your brother. She needs to own her choice. You shouldn't even have to get involved with this.

Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 21/05/2022 09:36

Velvian · 21/05/2022 08:03

@Giveme2gins if your mum is prepared to spend 1 to 1.5K on accommodation, could she spend that in getting professional cleaning/decluttering or a decorator?

I don’t think 1.5k would go far with the amount OP says needs doing. In would imagine it would make a dent on the stuff but there would be no money left for cleaners or decorating.

HangOnToYourself · 21/05/2022 09:35

Could you use the money she would spend on accommodation to initially hire a skip and get rid of any she will let you bin then maybe pay for a storage locker for a month for the clutter she wont let you bin? Then get some professional cleaners in once its cleared.out and maybe a lick.of.paint if you have the time and money left?

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 09:34

Sortilege · 21/05/2022 09:27

Buy in help. Handy man, cleaner, a man and a van and a storage unit: whatever it takes.

That would be my plan too.

OP posts:
Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 09:33

Honestly I think all they need is a place for their bags and put their heads down from time to time. They will be travelling about all the time no doubt about it, coming and going and booking little stays here and there.

Hopefully accommodation will show up for me today but I doubt it. I'm waiting to hear back on some enquiries I made last night. It would be good if there was a place free but I doubt it. It's summer season now. We won't be able to find a full month anywhere. It won't be suitable dipping in and out from dates that may be suitable here and there on Airbnb. There needs to be something more solid.

OP posts:
Wolfiefan · 21/05/2022 09:33

Sounds like you don’t have the space and the house isn’t in a fit state to take them all in. Talk to your brother. Maybe a video call so he can see the house. Ask him to make alternative arrangements. He can’t stay with you.

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/05/2022 09:31

Tbh, I’m not sure I’d want even my closest family staying for a whole month, whatever the state of my home.

can your brother contribute towards accommodation nearby?

Sortilege · 21/05/2022 09:27

Buy in help. Handy man, cleaner, a man and a van and a storage unit: whatever it takes.

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 09:26

I understand my mom's concerns but she's expecting me to magic a place in a suitable location and within her budget and it's not what it was like 10 or 15 or 20 years ago where you can get accommodation at a reasonable price.

Mom got thick at me last night when places that she had in mind weren't available or free. As if it was my fault.

I have a lovely neighbour who would probably be delighted to take them in and I think its going to look bad when another friend or neighbour will take in my brother and his family for their holiday and we can't make and effort.

OP posts:
WTF475878237NC · 21/05/2022 09:26

None of this is your responsibility. Tell your mother to talk to her son to make plans.

Aprilx · 21/05/2022 09:26

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 01:15

I think some OCD has set in with my mom. She has some rooms torn upside down trying to air them even though they are not bad and they don't smell bad. The sitting room is unusable because she decided to put storage behind the TV, the the couch and chairs around and side ways and put in more storage. The bed is dismantled in the spare room. I think some work of putting some shape to the rooms and it would be ok.

I honestly think your mother has a better grasp on reality than you do, the house does not sound like it just needs a little bit of a tidy up. It sounds like it really is not suitable for visitors.

But I don’t see why your mother should be paying for accommodation and I don’t know why you don’t just talk to your brother! Ring him, FaceTime him, tell him he might not want to stay at the house because of the clutter and mess. I am sure he is more than capable of deciding for himself what to do and organising it.

Badlifeday · 21/05/2022 09:22

A weekend away for your mum and so much could be sorted...
You mention the vacuum bags a lot, but they only help with soft things (duvets, jumpers etc) not boxes or papers.
You can't deal with this all, or be expected to deal with this all, yourself OP. Get your brother involved. You didn't create this situation.

Badlifeday · 21/05/2022 09:20

Clymene · 21/05/2022 08:43

Rent a storage container for a month. Move all the crap to the container. Make the rooms habitable.

This would be cheaper than booking accommodation. Would have a major impact too, the rooms used by the visitors could be completely cleared and a fair bit done elsewhere.
A by-product of this is that is might be easier to let go of stuff once it has already taken one step out of the house..

Beautiful3 · 21/05/2022 09:19

The hoarding issue puts a different spin on things. She feels too embarrassed to let the dil and grandchild, see what kind of state her home is in. Its her home so if she doesn't want them to stay, that's fine. But she really has to tell them now. Could you call up your brother and explain?

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 09:17

AnneLovesGilbert · 21/05/2022 09:07

You need to talk to your brother. Your mum is spiralling. Possibly for good reason.

I had a similar experience to @StoppinBy with ex’s family home. He didn’t warn me fear it was like and it was really really awful. The loo didn’t flush, the carpets were damp, ceilings were mouldy and peeling and flaking, the smell was horrifying in places. I put up with it for short visits a few times a year but if I’d had a child with me I’d have walked out the first time and not gone back and insisted on staying in a b&b instead.

I was going to give up my bed for the the child and I now that I know the fiancée is coming I can give up my room and move into the spare room for the time and it would work then.

All that needs to be done is to reorganise the rooms she has turned upside down. The sitting room is a state because she has the couch turned one way, the coffee table pushed to the wall, storage behtthe TV, chairs turned sideways, storage on tope of everything else.

Some vacuum bags and I could get a lot of that compacted.

There will be a time where I won't be even be at home for that month for about 2/3 weeks too and I think it could possibly work.

If mom was to leave me at it cleaning for a whole entire weekend I could put shape to a lot of rooms but she won't let me because she wants control over it all.

OP posts:
AnneLovesGilbert · 21/05/2022 09:07

You need to talk to your brother. Your mum is spiralling. Possibly for good reason.

I had a similar experience to @StoppinBy with ex’s family home. He didn’t warn me fear it was like and it was really really awful. The loo didn’t flush, the carpets were damp, ceilings were mouldy and peeling and flaking, the smell was horrifying in places. I put up with it for short visits a few times a year but if I’d had a child with me I’d have walked out the first time and not gone back and insisted on staying in a b&b instead.

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 09:04

Mom is just anxious because she wants the place pristine even though we never grew up like that.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread