Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is she being unreasonable about holidays?

209 replies

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 00:10

I have a sibling who lives abroad in Australia. He wanted to come home on holidays and it was his plan for months to come home this summer on holidays. My mom was cleaning the house in preparation for his return home.

He called home recently to say he's taking his fiancée and child. We met his fiancée before and she is a beautiful lady through and through. I am looking forward to seeing them.

Now my mom is apprehensive about him coming home. She is upset and anxious. We don't have the best of homes. It's ok. It's a roof over our heads. I was helping mom cleaning.

Now she doesn't want them coming home. She says she will get me to look for a holiday home for their stay and she will pay. I had a nightmare online all night looking for a place for them to stay but honestly I am having no luck whatsoever. I actually feel sick. The only places available are actually costing 1000s for a month.

Mom went to bed and she said we will look again tomorrow. I really don't think my mom is understanding me. Accommodations is is not available. Summer rentals would have been booked months ago and months in advance. My mom is expecting me to find a place out of thin air and within her budget. Three times toniishe asked me about the local apartments. Those apartments were always long term rentals and they are not available. She is expecting me to magic a home out of thin air. I don't get this though. The space is available at home. It's not the best quality but it's ok. Some cleaning over the next few more weeks and it should be better. My mom is flat out turning down the idea of now having them stay at home nor will she tell them what her stance is on this. It's all a mess. I think she's just being nervous but I think it will fall into place of they do come home. When they do come back and if they stay at home, they won't be here all the time. They will be going away here and there.

OP posts:
Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 17:25

Are there any budget holidays to Europe, perhaps Eastern Europe like Poland maybe.

Maybe have them stay for a few days at home and then redirect them to an Eastern Europe holiday. Costs and prices on the continent are usually so much more cheaper than home.

Any ideas?

OP posts:
Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 17:03

LicoricePizza · 21/05/2022 16:58

Remember that OP has said she has wondered.if Alzheimers is causing DM to act in this way - in addition to anxiety, embarrassment/shame re the house.,

DM has apparently been v distressed about some other situations recently where she wouldn’t have been before. May explain the OCD/collecting stuff too.

And why she can’t seem to grasp no accommodation is available.

So once DB & fiancé know the full facts of the situation - I don’t think they’d turn their backs on DM or feel sleighted in way some posters are suggesting.

She’s not being unhospitable out of choice. She’s clearly not well.,

My mother doesn't have an alzheimer's diagnosis but I wondered before now if dementia is setting in.

OP posts:
Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 17:00

ChateauMargaux · 21/05/2022 16:18

I would be cautious about telling your brother... if my brother told me I was not welcome in the house my sister and mother lived in, having paid for tickets to fly across the world so my child could meet and spend time with their grandmother, I would be very hurt. As you can tell... I have experience..

There is something epigentic and a touch of inherited trauma about this.. those who left for a better life.. returned to visit bearing inappropriate gifts, were shown the parlor and treated like visiting dignitaries as if they were parading their better life (and beautiful wives) and those who stayed behind being embarassed about their own lives. It sounds like there is a complicated narrative going on in your mother's head... her son is coming back to see her and to give his child and his mother the opportunity to get to know each other. He won't get it right.. however he plays it.. too much time and he is imposing and too little time... he is too good for us now.

I'm just sending hugs and love and wishing all of you the insight to find a way through without missing out on this opportunity for lovely family time together. If you can... ask your brother his plans and tell him you would like to spend time with him and would like to book a few days holiday when he does not already have plans.. spend time with him, his wife, your fiancé and your nephew / niece.

He and his family is not wanted at home. He might as well know that now instead of dragging it out over a few weeks. If they were truly wanted at home mother wouldn't be making obstacles.

I googled pictures of hoarding and it's truly horrific looking. Mom's hoarding is truly not that bag. There's some large boxes of storage bits but that's it. It would be absolutely manageable into vaccum bags.

I know up thread I was asked how many bedrooms and I said 3. I lied. It's 4 bedrooms but there's only 3 that's habitable. The other room is storage stuff and in a bad way too. I lied because I didn't want to be judged by people here for having a bad room in the house.

I think some sort of a solution could be found. An effort made could at least allow them to stay part time while they move about.

OP posts:
LicoricePizza · 21/05/2022 16:58

Remember that OP has said she has wondered.if Alzheimers is causing DM to act in this way - in addition to anxiety, embarrassment/shame re the house.,

DM has apparently been v distressed about some other situations recently where she wouldn’t have been before. May explain the OCD/collecting stuff too.

And why she can’t seem to grasp no accommodation is available.

So once DB & fiancé know the full facts of the situation - I don’t think they’d turn their backs on DM or feel sleighted in way some posters are suggesting.

She’s not being unhospitable out of choice. She’s clearly not well.,

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 16:47

InstaHun88 · 21/05/2022 16:26

YABU. I think your brother is unreasonable for changing the goal posts. Hosting your son is very different to hosting his fiance who you met once.

And you are unreasonable for not speaking to him. Tell him your mother is unwell, she's so stressed she's on the verge of a breakdown and he needs to book accommodation. If he can afford flights for 3 people from Australia, he can afford a holiday villa.

We met her several times. They housed us for a month in Australia. They had a 2 bed apartment at the time and they helped us no problem and allowed in their home and using their kitchen and bathroom and washing facilities. It wasn't pristine but it was perfect for me.

They came to Europe before and they housed us again.

The spare room is large and there's plenty of space for 2 people in there. I had an idea that maybe he might bring his child so I was preparing my room for her and I was going to sleep in a chair and I have a bed for a few weeks somewhere else.

The space is there but mother doesn't want them not even for one sleepover. She would rather throw thousands on alternative accommodation.

OP posts:
InstaHun88 · 21/05/2022 16:26

YABU. I think your brother is unreasonable for changing the goal posts. Hosting your son is very different to hosting his fiance who you met once.

And you are unreasonable for not speaking to him. Tell him your mother is unwell, she's so stressed she's on the verge of a breakdown and he needs to book accommodation. If he can afford flights for 3 people from Australia, he can afford a holiday villa.

ChateauMargaux · 21/05/2022 16:18

I would be cautious about telling your brother... if my brother told me I was not welcome in the house my sister and mother lived in, having paid for tickets to fly across the world so my child could meet and spend time with their grandmother, I would be very hurt. As you can tell... I have experience..

There is something epigentic and a touch of inherited trauma about this.. those who left for a better life.. returned to visit bearing inappropriate gifts, were shown the parlor and treated like visiting dignitaries as if they were parading their better life (and beautiful wives) and those who stayed behind being embarassed about their own lives. It sounds like there is a complicated narrative going on in your mother's head... her son is coming back to see her and to give his child and his mother the opportunity to get to know each other. He won't get it right.. however he plays it.. too much time and he is imposing and too little time... he is too good for us now.

I'm just sending hugs and love and wishing all of you the insight to find a way through without missing out on this opportunity for lovely family time together. If you can... ask your brother his plans and tell him you would like to spend time with him and would like to book a few days holiday when he does not already have plans.. spend time with him, his wife, your fiancé and your nephew / niece.

HotWashCycle · 21/05/2022 16:14

Hi OP. I hear your dilemma, and your mother's desperation coming through the words, which I totally get. I grew up in similar circumstances, so know the stomach-gripping fear this can provoke in your DM. I don't know how long you have before your DB's arrival in Ireland, but if you could do one room, say the spare room along the lines you suggest, and then encourage your DM to think you could do the same with the sitting room, she might feel encouraged. If there is excess stuff around, put it into temporary storage. If she is so extremely anxious about the state of the house, this will all be doing her a favour, as after the visit things will be better organised and easier for her. At the moment she is overwhelmed by the scale of the problem. Do you have time to do the odd touch up with paint? and make sure carpets are clean, etc.? A new rug in the bedroom might lift it. It could be a new start for your DM, even though initially it will be very anxiety-provoking for her. Your DB knows what it is like, presumably? How does he feel about bringing his girlfriend to the house? Does he know enough about your DM's issues, and could they be explained to the girlfriend (with DM's permission)?

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 16:05

Badlifeday · 21/05/2022 15:52

The fiancé will know this is about her coming too. You can reassure your mum that she isn't likely to come back.
This whole thing is the definition of dysfunctional.

They got on very well together when we went to visit them and they were here before. The mother is just anxious about having more people in the house. It's not about the fiancée.

OP posts:
Badlifeday · 21/05/2022 15:52

The fiancé will know this is about her coming too. You can reassure your mum that she isn't likely to come back.
This whole thing is the definition of dysfunctional.

FictionalCharacter · 21/05/2022 15:47

This isn’t your problem to sort out. You’re not her servant. How can she “make” you find something for them? Speak to your brother and explain, then tell her she needs to talk to him and decide what to do. She’s not a child to be looked after by you and she’s getting angry when you try to help. If you don’t gently withdraw from feeling responsible for her now, it will be far worse in the future.

Lurkerlot · 21/05/2022 15:47

Maybe consider hiring a storage facility and move the hoarded items for the duration of the stay. Once the visit is complete, she will have the space to consider what she wants to bring back into the house, and then perhaps sell/ junk the rest.

burnoutbabe · 21/05/2022 15:43

doesn't your brother need to know your mum is having a mental health crisis?

therefore he can share the burden of that with you. And seperarely confim that

a) he needs somewhere to dump bags - that can be the spare room
b) he will be visiting your town for say 2 days every week between visiting others - here are the dates - you/mum then find short term accom for those dates, rather than whole month.
he may well decide easier to rejig plans to spend a week elsewhere, then a week home, week in 3rd place rather than bed hop.

PattyMelt · 21/05/2022 15:38

Your poor Mum is in panic mode.
I'd suggest a storage place short term while they are here to store all her extra stuff.
Help pick out new duvet covers and pillows.
Some new dishes from somewhere inexpensive, Tesco or Asda, something bright and cheery.
Matching canisters for the kitchen countertops,
A rug for the living room and some cushions.
It'll all cost a whole lot less than a holiday home.

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 15:36

I am phoning him tonight to let him know that the mother is not happy to have them in the spare room. Now, mother asked me not to phone them instead she wants me to find accommodation for them but I will chat with them first.

OP posts:
whowhatwerewhy · 21/05/2022 15:34

You/ your mom need to let your DB know they won't be able to stay over . He can then make other arrangements

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 15:34

I only found out last night and in started looking for a place to see if there was anything available. It's now hitting me that this is going to be a problem. I was away all morning and I am home now a short while.

There is a time gap and it's the middle of the night now there but I will be free tonight to make a call.

OP posts:
Bobbins36 · 21/05/2022 15:34

Wh6nhavent you discussed this with your brother and asked him to have a s
conversation with your mother about this? You can’t leave him in the dark it’s not fair. You and your mum sound crackers.

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 15:32

Mother doesn't want them to stay over even for a sleepover. Not even for one night. I know the place isn't pristine but to turn them away like this. To not even spend one night at home.

OP posts:
CupidStunt22 · 21/05/2022 15:30

So have you still not bothered to actually talk to your brother?

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 15:26

I didn't hear anything back from any of my enquiries.

OP posts:
Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 15:13

ChateauMargaux · 21/05/2022 14:53

Maybe mention to your Mum that if she does not make her son and her grandchild who live on the opposite side of the world feel welcome when they will be spending a huge amount to travel, it may be the last time she sees them.

That's what I am thinking too. I can see a fall out on the cards over this. There is a spare room available but mom doesn't want to out a family in there even though some time over the next few more weeks and it will be ok.

OP posts:
Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 15:11

CupidStunt22 · 21/05/2022 14:43

Oh ffs, opposite sides of the county? This is Ireland, you can be at opposite ends of the country and still get there in a few hours! I commute over a county for work everyday. I driven from one side of the county to the other and back already this morning for a GAA match. What are you even talking about?

Cop yourself on, actually talk to your brother and stop deciding what he will be doing without asking him. Honestly, such a FUSS about everything!

Lucky for you but I don't own a car or a licence so I can't rent a car. When I finish a day's work I will be left with the bus routes and my route won't take me to the other end of the county if thats where they end up getting a place.

OP posts:
Fossiltop · 21/05/2022 15:09

Thing is, I get you want your brother to stay, but your mum doesn't and it's her house.

GirlInterrupted · 21/05/2022 15:02

CupidStunt22 · 21/05/2022 14:43

Oh ffs, opposite sides of the county? This is Ireland, you can be at opposite ends of the country and still get there in a few hours! I commute over a county for work everyday. I driven from one side of the county to the other and back already this morning for a GAA match. What are you even talking about?

Cop yourself on, actually talk to your brother and stop deciding what he will be doing without asking him. Honestly, such a FUSS about everything!

I agree with @CupidStunt22! I think you are being melodramatic. It's not like you'll have to circumnavigate the globe to meet up with your brother once or twice a week!

And I am unsure why you keep bringing up the whole "I work and can't take holidays at the drop of a hat" thing, I don't understand why you would be required to take holidays??? Again, drama, why?

Just speak to your brother and lay off your mum. If he is going to be out and about, surely you don't need to book a place for a whole month? Open communication with him, book a local Airbnb for the nights they are not touring. Simple, no drama.

Am I missing something? 😵

Swipe left for the next trending thread