Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is she being unreasonable about holidays?

209 replies

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 00:10

I have a sibling who lives abroad in Australia. He wanted to come home on holidays and it was his plan for months to come home this summer on holidays. My mom was cleaning the house in preparation for his return home.

He called home recently to say he's taking his fiancée and child. We met his fiancée before and she is a beautiful lady through and through. I am looking forward to seeing them.

Now my mom is apprehensive about him coming home. She is upset and anxious. We don't have the best of homes. It's ok. It's a roof over our heads. I was helping mom cleaning.

Now she doesn't want them coming home. She says she will get me to look for a holiday home for their stay and she will pay. I had a nightmare online all night looking for a place for them to stay but honestly I am having no luck whatsoever. I actually feel sick. The only places available are actually costing 1000s for a month.

Mom went to bed and she said we will look again tomorrow. I really don't think my mom is understanding me. Accommodations is is not available. Summer rentals would have been booked months ago and months in advance. My mom is expecting me to find a place out of thin air and within her budget. Three times toniishe asked me about the local apartments. Those apartments were always long term rentals and they are not available. She is expecting me to magic a home out of thin air. I don't get this though. The space is available at home. It's not the best quality but it's ok. Some cleaning over the next few more weeks and it should be better. My mom is flat out turning down the idea of now having them stay at home nor will she tell them what her stance is on this. It's all a mess. I think she's just being nervous but I think it will fall into place of they do come home. When they do come back and if they stay at home, they won't be here all the time. They will be going away here and there.

OP posts:
LookItsMeAgain · 21/05/2022 19:30

Do you know what? If he's not due to show up in the next week or two, what I would do is use that time to make the 4th bedroom habitable. As it's a house and not an apartment you're living in, you have an attic space that you can chuck EVERYTHING up into that doesn't need to be down.

Then you buy some paint, a cheap pair of curtains, use some duvet covers that you may already have, dress the room up nicely and then present it to your mother. If she can see that the room looks nice (and no one sleeps in it until they arrive) then it's a 'good' room and acceptable to guests.

I do think that your brother should have run it past your mother first before arranging for his fiance to join him on the visit. Your mother probably feels that she has to be 'on' for the entire time. She doesn't. That said, if you've already met each other, then it really boils down to a house-proud thing. There are ways around it that don't resort to spending '000s to put them up somewhere different. Your mum can't see the wood for the trees at the moment and if she doesn't welcome her son and his family to stay, this is going to have a very negative impression on them.

Perhaps you could take a breath. Both you and your mum, and you come up with a plan to tackle the clutter and dress the house nicely. Honestly, a couple of hours each night for the next few weeks should see a completely different place and one that she is very proud to show off!

Beancounter1 · 21/05/2022 19:23

The work can be done if I am allowed to do it.

This is about the power balance between you and your mother: the parent-child relationship, which gets switched round as people get elderly and become dependent. She may not be ready yet to accept that she is getting older and needs to put you in control of a lot more of everything. It may take years, and she may fight the inevitable outcome every step of the way. Meanwhile you are stuck in the child role, as a grown woman, because it is your mother's house and you have no control and no say in anything.

Are you willing to physically just carry on doing the work in front of her while she protests? Would that be too damaging to your relationship with her?

In my previous post I suggested getting storage and professional deep clean. If your view is correct and you just need coat hooks, vacuum bags, etc, that is still an issue if your mother doesn't want you to do any of it.

If it looks like fixing up the house is not going to happen, you need to let brother know as soon as possible that he will likely be staying in a hotel - it is not fair on him to leave it to later.

I would suggest that the top priority is getting specific dates from your brother - nail down his plans so that you know exactly which nights either you or he need to book a B&B or hotel near to you, should mother's wishes prevail. You also need to know which days you are going to book off work to spend time with him. It is not acceptable for your brother to leave his plans vague or open-ended in this situation, as you need to know.

How would your mother react if you phoned your brother even though she said not to? Tell her after, or tell her beforehand - that is your immediate choice.

Stomacharmeleon · 21/05/2022 19:20

It's not normal when you have a four bedroom house at your disposal.
Just phone him and enquire about his general plans. Then you can plan.

Bobbins36 · 21/05/2022 19:20

You need to tell her booking accommodation IS NOT POSSIBLE. And you need to tell brother ASAP that there’s a problem and allow him to make plans. Stop looking online - tell her it can’t be done and it’s a waste of cash. Either you tidy up and they stay or they book a hotel for the short periods they need one. You are making more of a drama than you need to.

Wolfiefan · 21/05/2022 19:16

It still isn’t normal.
She doesn’t want to put them up or can’t? She needs to tell them.
Can you look to move out soon?

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 19:11

Wolfiefan · 21/05/2022 19:04

It’s not normal to have boxes of clothes and Christmas decorations dotted round the living room.
it’s not normal to sleep in a chair for a couple of weeks as there isn’t enough space to house visitors.
There isn’t space for them to stay? Tell them. Or get her to do so. Say you thought it was just him coming.
Dont bother renting somewhere for them. That’s not your role here.

My chair is comfortable and I slept there a few times. I like I said, I have some options for a bed for 2 weeks so it won't be a month completely in a chair.

OP posts:
Wolfiefan · 21/05/2022 19:04

Or more sensibly let your mum and brother sort it out between them.

Wolfiefan · 21/05/2022 19:04

It’s not normal to have boxes of clothes and Christmas decorations dotted round the living room.
it’s not normal to sleep in a chair for a couple of weeks as there isn’t enough space to house visitors.
There isn’t space for them to stay? Tell them. Or get her to do so. Say you thought it was just him coming.
Dont bother renting somewhere for them. That’s not your role here.

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 18:58

I got more replies back today turninge down for 4 weeks accommodation.

My mom has it in her mind that she wants 4 weeks continuous accommodation.

OP posts:
Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 18:56

There was a new kitchen put in about 13 years ago. So it's not an old kitchen.

OP posts:
Favouritefruits · 21/05/2022 18:52

You’d be better spending the money that you would spend on a rental property on doing the house up a bit, paint, new carpet, new cupboards in kitchen etc.

LicoricePizza · 21/05/2022 18:33

Well I do hope you get to see your brother & family - whichever way that happens. You know your mother best & how to handle her. Good luck

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 18:16

LicoricePizza · 21/05/2022 17:30

Which might explain some of the difficulties she’s having no?
When you mentioned this up thread I posted that older age can exacerbate eccentric & stubborn behaviour as I’ve seen with my own mum. And that I don’t know if your mum is older?

Our house was similar growing up & I could never fathom why my parents had rooms filled with stuff & no organisation. People coming to stay was always a massive panic to try to present the house as normal in a short space of time. I hated it. It continues to this day & her eccentricities or imh are definitely affected by older age. I too wonder if dementia is a factor for my mum but she has not been diagnosed either yet.

It’s just that you mentioned it earlier & so it could be adding another layer to this & explain why she’s behaving this way. What I’ve found with my own mum is that if I try to convince her against something that doesn’t seem completely rational to me, or that is giving her more grief than it should, it usually only makes her stick to her guns all the more.

Which is why I think you need to accept that she’s - for whatever reason -just not able to have them stay. Unfortunately.

This wasn't the first time where my made things more complex and difficult where really it shouldn't have been. I think maybe it ties into the poor planning and organising that sometimes goes with dementia.

OP posts:
C152 · 21/05/2022 18:16

Ok, OP, this is just going around in circles. I think you're nearly as stressed as your mum and you're possibly fixating on the wrong things. Rightly or wrongly, your mum is stressed about having your brother and his family to stay. She's asked you to look for alternative accommodation, which you've done, and there isn't any. That's the end of that option.

You say you just need a weekend, or even a day, to sort your mum's house out. If this really is feasible, do you have any other family, or does your mum have friends that she can stay with for the weekend, or a best friend that can take her out for the whole day i.e. breakfast, shopping, lunch, relax and dinner at her friend's house? I would try this so you have a good understanding of what is actually achievable. Accept that your mum probably won't want to go out, as she'll be afraid of what you may throw out / reorganise while she's gone, but this has to happen at some point, irrespective of whether or not your brother comes to stay. (I am very sympathetic, as I have reached this stage with my own mother and, as harsh as it seems, there are some things I just need to take control of and say, 'this is happening' and make it so. It is very easy for things to spiral, especially if there may be some form of dementia.)

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 18:13

FusionChefGeoff · 21/05/2022 18:05

Can you move in with her for a month and brother has your place?

I don't have a place. I live with mom.

There's 2 weeks of their holidays where I won't be at home so the my room is available and I am more than happy to give it up and sleep in a chair when I get back or make alternative arrangements for a bed a couch somewhere.

OP posts:
FusionChefGeoff · 21/05/2022 18:05

Can you move in with her for a month and brother has your place?

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 17:57

This here. I will phone with this

Is she being unreasonable about holidays?
OP posts:
Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 17:53

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/05/2022 17:26

I am phoning him tonight to let him know that the mother is not happy to have them in the spare room. Now, mother asked me not to phone them instead she wants me to find accommodation for them but I will chat with them first

I thought you said you were going to "wash your hands of it all" ...?

I don't know what his plans are. How can I let him come here with his family if he thinks he has a place to stay when he doesn't.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 21/05/2022 17:49

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 17:25

Are there any budget holidays to Europe, perhaps Eastern Europe like Poland maybe.

Maybe have them stay for a few days at home and then redirect them to an Eastern Europe holiday. Costs and prices on the continent are usually so much more cheaper than home.

Any ideas?

Bloody hell.

Stop trying to organise everyone!

Call brother, tell him mum is panicking about accommodation. Tell him to call her and speak to her directly.

That’s all you should do. Other than have a nice chat with him about when you can catch up properly when he’s over.

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 17:45

BookFiend4Life · 21/05/2022 17:38

OP, I think you need to stop worrying about your brother right now because it sounds like the home situation is dire. If there is spare money to rent accommodation that should be spent on a storage unit to get all the junk out of the house so that you make necessary repairs and clean, including from the "bad room". Also therapy for your mom! Your brother can manage his own accommodation and maybe help you get your mom assessed when he is visiting. The storage space may feel like a good solution to her because she won't be "getting rid" of stuff. There are services that help with this stuff and it truly sounds like you need the help. I don't think some vacuum bags and a coat rack are going to solve this.

I googled pictures of hoarding and it's not even near that. There's pictures online of hoarding and it's a room filled to the brim of stuff. The sitting room and spare room isn't like that. I can count 4 boxes of different sizes in the sitting room. One filled with Christmas decorations and I don't know what the others are but it's softish stuff. I think it's her clothes. Winter/summer clothes. I think they could be compacted down into one box.

It really isn't bad. I think an armchair from the sitting room could be brought up to the spare room too. There would be plenty of space.
The work can be done if I am allowed to do it.

OP posts:
LicoricePizza · 21/05/2022 17:44

He and his family is not wanted at home. He might as well know that now instead of dragging it out over a few weeks. If they were truly wanted at home mother wouldn't be making obstacles.

OP do you really think this is the case? Whilst you might think it would be easy to clear out & make presentable - clearly she doesn’t. Or can’t. Telling him it like that is bound to cause further problems.

BookFiend4Life · 21/05/2022 17:38

OP, I think you need to stop worrying about your brother right now because it sounds like the home situation is dire. If there is spare money to rent accommodation that should be spent on a storage unit to get all the junk out of the house so that you make necessary repairs and clean, including from the "bad room". Also therapy for your mom! Your brother can manage his own accommodation and maybe help you get your mom assessed when he is visiting. The storage space may feel like a good solution to her because she won't be "getting rid" of stuff. There are services that help with this stuff and it truly sounds like you need the help. I don't think some vacuum bags and a coat rack are going to solve this.

LicoricePizza · 21/05/2022 17:30

Giveme2gins · 21/05/2022 17:03

My mother doesn't have an alzheimer's diagnosis but I wondered before now if dementia is setting in.

Which might explain some of the difficulties she’s having no?
When you mentioned this up thread I posted that older age can exacerbate eccentric & stubborn behaviour as I’ve seen with my own mum. And that I don’t know if your mum is older?

Our house was similar growing up & I could never fathom why my parents had rooms filled with stuff & no organisation. People coming to stay was always a massive panic to try to present the house as normal in a short space of time. I hated it. It continues to this day & her eccentricities or imh are definitely affected by older age. I too wonder if dementia is a factor for my mum but she has not been diagnosed either yet.

It’s just that you mentioned it earlier & so it could be adding another layer to this & explain why she’s behaving this way. What I’ve found with my own mum is that if I try to convince her against something that doesn’t seem completely rational to me, or that is giving her more grief than it should, it usually only makes her stick to her guns all the more.

Which is why I think you need to accept that she’s - for whatever reason -just not able to have them stay. Unfortunately.

ChateauMargaux · 21/05/2022 17:30

Do not send them to Europe... that is not your place. Clear a room, clear the sitting room, make the kitchen and bathroom hospitable. Reassure your mother that this is the right thing to do. Contact your brother... ask him if he has plans to travel / visit other areas or if he plans to spend the entire month in your house.. explain your mother's anxiety to him and ask him to reassure her that he is not expecting a red carpet but he is looking forward to spending time together and is happy to take you as he finds you.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 21/05/2022 17:26

I am phoning him tonight to let him know that the mother is not happy to have them in the spare room. Now, mother asked me not to phone them instead she wants me to find accommodation for them but I will chat with them first

I thought you said you were going to "wash your hands of it all" ...?

Swipe left for the next trending thread