Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this text sounds as if someone is trying to place blame on me?

111 replies

merlinsway · 20/05/2022 21:36

My son A (8) runs plays with another little boy B on the street who is also 8. B is in my house a lot, has had a sleepover and stays for full days/dinner frequently. I'm friendly enough with his mum, but it is very much just because our kids are friends.

The other night B came for dinner here then went home, afterwards I received a text from him mum saying that he is grounded for swearing at her twice and that she's really struggling with his behaviour, in her text she said 'please don't send A for B until I text you'. I said I understood and that was that.

Yesterday I received a message saying 'Hi Merlin. Hope you are well. B is wanting to play with A but I am not allowing him to watch tik tok or certain YouTube videos. Not sure if he is free to play and if you are OK with that?'

I just text back that was fine and that YouTube and TikTok wouldn't be on when he was at my house however my son wasn't free to play today. After speaking to my friend she said the text sounds pretty accusatory. As if she's saying it's my fault that her son swore at her due to what he is watching here.

To be honest, they don't sit and watch TV here, they are usually playing however at the sleepover they were watching YouTube at night but it was Norris nuts and everleigh etc. all age appropriate.

I admit I do let my son watch tik tok (don't need a lecture) and I understand not everyone will agree so I understand her point there's but I've had her son loads during the past year and she's never said to me that he isn't allowed to watch this.

The more I read the text the more I do think she's kind of putting blame on me? AIBU?

OP posts:
PickySlackTastic · 21/05/2022 04:55

I think her text is really good. Clearly worded and simple. Not at all accusatory. I prefer her text to your suggestion as hers feels more straight and direct.

You are reading too much into this. In general, do you have different boundaries/parenting styles? Its easy to feel defensive when you are the more relaxed parent.

Nancydrawn · 21/05/2022 04:46

Surely if she included the line 'Want to see if his behaviour improves' it could be taken as a sign that she thinks TikTok causes poor behaviour and your friend would say:

she says tiktok causes bad behaviour + you use tiktok = she thinks you're causing bad behaviour.

All of which is to say, she's made a reasonable request, politely and without accusation, and you're being unreasonable.

Blarting · 21/05/2022 04:34

merlinsway · 20/05/2022 22:14

I just think there is a way to say things. For instance, 'hi merlin, hope you are well. B is allowed out now however, I'm not letting him watch YouTube or tik tok. Not sure if it's ever on at your house but if so could you do me a favour and not let B watch it? Want to see if his behaviour improves'

But it is on at your house abs she knows it is, so why would she make out she didn't know if it was on or not?

cutebutscary · 21/05/2022 02:31

No I think she's just being direct, but at the same time is getting LOTS of free childcare from you which doesn't really put her in the position to be placing any kind of demands like that . I would probably say , they are together so much that I can't possibly supervise what they are watching every second of the day. I presume you are also running a house and will be doing all the tasks associated with that so how can you possibly supervise 24/7 it's a tricky one as it is a bit of a cheeky request, but at the same time, you don't want to spoil things for your son either

Earlydancing · 21/05/2022 01:59

merlinsway · 20/05/2022 22:14

I just think there is a way to say things. For instance, 'hi merlin, hope you are well. B is allowed out now however, I'm not letting him watch YouTube or tik tok. Not sure if it's ever on at your house but if so could you do me a favour and not let B watch it? Want to see if his behaviour improves'

Hi Merlin. Hope you are well. B is wanting to play with A but I am not allowing him to watch tik tok or certain YouTube videos. Not sure if he is free to play and if you are OK with that?'

I don't really see the difference between the two messages, except for "could you do me a favour". And you're writing your text with the idea that there was an accusatory motive behind her text. So you're giving it extra thought.

And until your friend hadn't stuck her shit-stirring oar in, you weren't bothered by her text. Dump your friend and don't read so much into texts.

ThePoorWeeDonkey · 21/05/2022 01:48

I just read it as she's not letting him. Not being accusatory to you.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 21/05/2022 01:18

I don't think there was anything wrong with her message and you're overthinking purely because your friend decided it was accusatory.

AntiHop · 21/05/2022 01:06

GayParis · 20/05/2022 23:46

Good god not "shit" Hmm

She's in her bedroom with her door open, so I could hear anything wildly inappropriate.

I don't mind what she watches as long as it's still based on gaming - really couldn't care if they swear! She's 8, not 4. She knows fine well not to swear outside the house so again, I trust her.

You are very naive. You trust your child, I don't dispute that. But the point is she could accidentally be exposed to inappropriate content.

My dd is 7. We have agreed YouTube channels that she can watch unsupervised, that I've checked out. She is not allowed any other channels.

thevanilla · 21/05/2022 00:57

GayParis · 20/05/2022 22:22

My 8 yo DD watches YouTube unsupervised because I trust her and have told her what is acceptable/unacceptable Confused

yikes

Aubriella · 21/05/2022 00:49

I really like her text. The way she says ‘Not sure if he is free to play and if you are OK with that?'’ is so nice and considerate. She hasn’t assumed you will be ok with anything.

YetAnotherNameChange111 · 21/05/2022 00:42

My 8 yo DD watches YouTube unsupervised because I trust her and have told her what is acceptable/unacceptable
She's 8, not 4. She knows fine well not to swear outside the house so again, I trust her

Poor kid. I despair. She is 8, not 18. Protect her ffs

Triffid1 · 21/05/2022 00:13

Total non issue. She knows you allow certain types of screen time. She doesn't want that screen time. She's asking you to respect her boundaries. Seems fine to me.

At that age we had lots of similar conversations on play dates - can they play Fortnite? Can they eat certain treats? Can they watch YouTube. It's normal. You are massively over thinking.

Her first message just sounds like a woman expressing some difficulties to someone she thinks will understand.

saraclara · 20/05/2022 23:57

You seem incredibly easily influenced, OP. And your 'friend' is a piece of work.

This boy's mum is parenting well. He behaved badly, she punished him, and she is gradually bringing things back, but with restrictions. He can play with his friend again, but he's not to take advantage and try to find ways around her ban. She's asking for your support in that, that's all. And good for her.

She's been focusing on her boy, not on you. If she thought you or your child were the problem, she wouldn't be encouraging the next play date. She's just not releasing all her DS's restrictions just yet.

maddy68 · 20/05/2022 23:49

You are over thinking this. She is setting groundrules for HER son. She has said he can play our bit only if he doesn't access those things there as well as home

GayParis · 20/05/2022 23:46

twntho · 20/05/2022 22:48

@GayParis YouTube is full of videos that go from child friendly to not in an instant
My DS was watching minecraft videos the other day (supervised) and it was fine and out of nowhere they said 'shit'
It's stuff like that, that worries me
Even the kid version YouTube bad videos slip by

Good god not "shit" Hmm

She's in her bedroom with her door open, so I could hear anything wildly inappropriate.

I don't mind what she watches as long as it's still based on gaming - really couldn't care if they swear! She's 8, not 4. She knows fine well not to swear outside the house so again, I trust her.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 20/05/2022 23:33

merlinsway · 20/05/2022 22:14

I just think there is a way to say things. For instance, 'hi merlin, hope you are well. B is allowed out now however, I'm not letting him watch YouTube or tik tok. Not sure if it's ever on at your house but if so could you do me a favour and not let B watch it? Want to see if his behaviour improves'

That's a bunch of unnecessary words to say the same thing she did. You're being MUCH too sensitive.

Lavenderlast · 20/05/2022 23:30

If you’re letting your 8 yr old watch tiktok unsupervised then he’ll be learning swearwords and probably has passed some onto his friend. I don’t think she’s accusing you, more trying to fix an unacceptable situation so the boys can continue to play together.

KettrickenSmiled · 20/05/2022 23:30

I must have misinterpreted

@LutherRalph1 reading back, I think I may have, actually.
So - apologies for my intemperate tone. It was wrong of me.

I'm amazed anyone interprets a parent ensuring their 8 year old child doesn't go on unsupervised social media trawls as a personal attack on them.

(don't need a lecture)
I don't need to be scolded or made to feel like I'm doing something wrong in my own house by another adult.
The defensiveness says more about OP's suppressed guilt than she has maybe considered. It's the same defensiveness that allowed her to be baited by her friend into suddenly interpreting a perfectly reasonable request as an attack.

KettrickenSmiled · 20/05/2022 23:17

GayParis · 20/05/2022 22:22

My 8 yo DD watches YouTube unsupervised because I trust her and have told her what is acceptable/unacceptable Confused

Sure.

I let my 8 year old drive my car on the motorway, because I have taught her the highway code.

SolasAnla · 20/05/2022 23:15

merlinsway · 20/05/2022 22:54

@SolasAnla that's the thing, I don't need a blunt note - I am an adult, I don't need to be scolded or made to feel like I'm doing something wrong in my own house by another adult.

I would write a blunt note like that.

You took my reply to suggest that the note was about you and your house rules?

I read the bluntness as being about her son and what he has been told he is allowed to do at yours.
Eg
B is still in trouble, but can he play with A without using your son to access stuff he now knows he should not.

Or

B is still in trouble, and banned from SM. But can he please play under your supervision with A without using your son's hospitality as a way to access stuff he now knows he should not. Thanks.

Sometimes text is a poor way to communicate, but ask yourself if you had a problem with the message before your friend made the comment?
(Ps you now know that if your friend sends you that type of text she will definitely be blaming you🤷🏼‍♀️)

WonderingWanda · 20/05/2022 23:12

GayParis · 20/05/2022 22:22

My 8 yo DD watches YouTube unsupervised because I trust her and have told her what is acceptable/unacceptable Confused

Really, you explained all the dangers on the internet to her and she understood?

It's not about trust it's about the fact that an 8 year old doesn't have the ability to judge whether what they are watching is appropriate or not because they don't have a clue what it is or it has been targetted to look like a kids programme but is totally inappropriate....a good example of of this was the roadman peppa pig videos someone mentioned in a thread yesterday. Take a look at this link which explains it a bit better than I am. Safety Detectives

Karwomannghia · 20/05/2022 23:09

Your version sounds just the same level as accusatory as hers if you read it with that in mind. There’s no easy way to say she doesn’t want him watching it without mentioning that he might so so at your house.

BatshitBanshee · 20/05/2022 23:06

And FYI Op, no one can make you feel any kind of way. We're responsible for our emotions and responses. Maybe you actually know yourself that your 8 year old shouldn't be watching TikTok, supervised or not.

BatshitBanshee · 20/05/2022 23:04

Paranoia's catching. She sounds like a mother who is setting boundaries and ground rules for her son inside and outside the home and reads more like an FYI rather than blame on anyone.

BonnesVacances · 20/05/2022 23:04

I think the text was fine tbh