Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD15 dropped from football team

111 replies

lookatallthisspace · 20/05/2022 19:05

DD15 has played football for 4 years. She's been with the same team for the whole time although a number of girls have come and go. Their coach has been trying to find out who will be resigning for next season. He pulled me aside this week to say that he is considering dropping my DD from the team to allow a new player in who plays the same position, but she is welcome to stay as train only if she wanted to.

She's not the strongest player on the pitch but she's definitely also not the worst, has had a really good season and got player of the match on a couple of occasions.

When I asked for the reasoning behind this I was told that although she is good on the ball, her brain just isn't 'quick enough' for football and it takes her too long to make decisions on the pitch. DD15 is autistic (Asperger's) and one of her biggest issues is indecisiveness. I can see during her matches that sometimes she may take a little longer to make a decision but it doesn't seem to affect the game (she doesn't stand there for minutes deciding what to do, it's a matter of seconds!).

In a nutshell, the coach wants to sign this new player but can't unless he drops someone and although he has said he knows that DD can't help being autistic, it's going to be an issue for the next season as it is much more competitive (although this is still grassroots!).

Would I be unreasonable to talk to the club about this? My DD has been with the team the longest out of all the current players and is extremely upset.

OP posts:
Morechocmorechoc · 21/05/2022 07:49

FYI I got kicked out if ballet because I have a funny leg. I was 6! Life is harsh sometimes.

Morechocmorechoc · 21/05/2022 07:48

Ask him directly why one of the other players isn't being dropped who gets subbed. Ask if she can try a different position for ine of those players potentially.

However in regards to your comment about how her brain works, yes she can't help it. Equally people with no coordination can't help it and may be desperate to play too. Sadly that's life. Same with school team sports, you don't always get picked for the team. That's life and it's how it is, so she will need to harden to that if she wants to do competitive sport.

If above doesn't work go find her a more friendly team to play in.

jgw1 · 21/05/2022 07:47

lookatallthisspace · 20/05/2022 19:05

DD15 has played football for 4 years. She's been with the same team for the whole time although a number of girls have come and go. Their coach has been trying to find out who will be resigning for next season. He pulled me aside this week to say that he is considering dropping my DD from the team to allow a new player in who plays the same position, but she is welcome to stay as train only if she wanted to.

She's not the strongest player on the pitch but she's definitely also not the worst, has had a really good season and got player of the match on a couple of occasions.

When I asked for the reasoning behind this I was told that although she is good on the ball, her brain just isn't 'quick enough' for football and it takes her too long to make decisions on the pitch. DD15 is autistic (Asperger's) and one of her biggest issues is indecisiveness. I can see during her matches that sometimes she may take a little longer to make a decision but it doesn't seem to affect the game (she doesn't stand there for minutes deciding what to do, it's a matter of seconds!).

In a nutshell, the coach wants to sign this new player but can't unless he drops someone and although he has said he knows that DD can't help being autistic, it's going to be an issue for the next season as it is much more competitive (although this is still grassroots!).

Would I be unreasonable to talk to the club about this? My DD has been with the team the longest out of all the current players and is extremely upset.

In rugby any junior (up to U18s) who turns up to training gets to play at least half the match. Seems to make a lot of sense to me.

Lazerbeen · 21/05/2022 07:46

ANUsernam · 21/05/2022 07:40

It would be unfair for a better player to be denied the opportunity just because they've not been there as long. What you're asking for is favouritism and THAT is the kind of attitude that puts kids off participating.

Both NT and ND kids need to learn that they will not always be good enough, and it's often for reasons beyond their control, and how to deal with the associated disappointment. It is your job to help support her to handle this/ find another team.

She's been good enough plenty of times before- winning woman of the match etc. Pulling a parent aside and saying that doesn't seem as fair as holding trials or sessions to observe and select that way, seems like an easy out to me.

Lazerbeen · 21/05/2022 07:44

Has he done anything in the past 4 years (where she's been playing, they have scored well and seemingly this hasn't been raised before?)- or is it an easy out for him now? I agree that teams want the best players, but it's also the case that people are far too quick to throw people who are ND on the scrap heap as they can't be arsed to try and help them (as evidenced by this thread). I'd try and find another team, or one that plays more for fun so she can keep the flame of enjoying it alight hopefully. I have played on adult teams with people who have similar and they have been welcomed and form a vital part of the team as anyone else.

ANUsernam · 21/05/2022 07:40

It would be unfair for a better player to be denied the opportunity just because they've not been there as long. What you're asking for is favouritism and THAT is the kind of attitude that puts kids off participating.

Both NT and ND kids need to learn that they will not always be good enough, and it's often for reasons beyond their control, and how to deal with the associated disappointment. It is your job to help support her to handle this/ find another team.

saraclara · 21/05/2022 07:28

It's competitive sport. She can't think quickly enough to keep her place in the team. Someone else might not have the stamina to keep their place in the team. Someone else might not be able to cover the ground fast enough to keep their place in the team.
The reasons behind those failings are completely irrelevant. You might as well say that someone with a limp should be on the team because they can't help it. That I should be in the England netball team because I can't help being in my 60s.
The coach's job is to create a team that will win. To field the best players available to him. It's not about who's been there longest, who works hardest, who's the nicer person. They're teenagers in a competitive league, and it's not just about having fun.

I know it hurts for your DD and for you. But this is the nature of competitive sport. Up and down the country every week, kids lose their spot on sports teams. And all their parents can do is sympathise, encourage, and help their teenagers pick themselves up.

Loopytiles · 21/05/2022 07:27

poor DD. As she’s good at and still enjoys football would look at her options.

The coach’s decisions might or might not work out well, or change. If she stays and trains she may well be picked for the team, or she might prefer to try another team.

Happymum12345 · 21/05/2022 07:26

The whole campaign of trying to get women back to sport is the exact opposite of the coaches behaviour. Unless the team and some of its players are destined for great things and on a path to win championships, then this is ridiculous. The coach needs to get over themselves.

ittakes2 · 21/05/2022 07:25

OP this man is appalling - but he is not dropping her because she is autistic. And I say that as someone who is also neurodiverse. He’s dropping her because she is not making quick enough decisions. What he should have done is raised this ages ago and given her advice on how to be quicker and a chance to be quicker with decisions. Quite frankly I think it’s worth moving to a team where the coach is better.

PinkSyCo · 21/05/2022 07:19

God I’d be so upset for my DD if I were you. Then again football is a competitive sport and they will obviously want the strongest places on their team, so there’s not much you can do I guess other than help your DD navigate her disappointment and find ways to keep her self esteem high.

Bednobsbroomsticks · 21/05/2022 07:18

The martial arts suggestion is very good. My husband teaches autistic students martial arts . It's great at teaching independence confidence and for the social aspects of it. You go at your own pace and the testing is based on your own ability and less reliant on team based progession my daughter loves it and her confidence and resilience is through the roof

InChocolateWeTrust · 21/05/2022 07:09

Slow processing speed is common in many neurodiverse conditions. It looks like indecisiveness to an observer. Not all autism assessments include it, but it's possible it may be in her diagnostic report(s). It's important she knows it's not her fault.

My DS slow running speed isnt his fault either. No ones lower ability is their "fault". Once you get to teens it's not enough to try hard, you need effort and ability.

Slow processing speed isnt unusual among NT either. Everyone is focussing on the autism here but I think it's a bit of a red flag, an NT teenager could be dropped for similar reasons if they are weaker on the strategic/decision making side of the game.

We can't all be good at everything.

PineappleMojito · 21/05/2022 07:03

Unfortunately this is competitive sport. I used to play in my teens and as a student and my dyspraxia meant that super competitive teams were just not where I belonged. I found teams that valued fun over winning at all costs. It wasn’t so much the coaches I had issues with, the other girls would get frustrated and yell at me for mistakes on the pitch. I really wanted to play and enjoyed playing, but the harsh reality was that my disability made me not skilled/quick enough to play in a very competitive team that wanted to win over having fun and being inclusive. That is, unfortunately, the reality of competitive sport. I gravitated more towards individual sports in adulthood as team sports are just too much pressure. This of course means fewer neurodivergent kids and adults play team sports, as many of us aren’t great when put under pressure to make snap decisions. It isn’t fair on your DD right enough, but it also isn’t fair to other players not to make the squad as good as it can be. Competitive sport just isn’t always fair and that’s a reality.

Unfortunately your DD may need to find another team that’s more inclusive, plays in a lower or “just for fun” type league where there isn’t so much emphasis on winning at all costs.

Ferngreen · 21/05/2022 07:00

It's possible someone has come along looking for a place who is a colleague or friend of the coach. Or the coach sees her problem with decision making as something which will not improve over time. If this is so then she will fall behind as the others improve.
Is there no other sport she would thrive at. Is there no other team she could join.

Mindymomo · 21/05/2022 06:59

As a wife of my DH managing both my sons football teams for over 14 years, I see it both sides. I would ask coach what the other girls feel should happen, if they are happy with your daughter’s ability to play, then this should be considered. I agree with previous posts, tell coach you would be happy for DD to share the position.

Canyouengineerfreespeech · 21/05/2022 06:58

DH coaches sport and gets this all the time. The bottom line is that your DD is playing a competitive sport. The coach says it will become more competitive next year. The coach is going to choose the best players. If your daughter is the best player she will be selected. If another player is better, she will be selected. Your DD’s autism is irrelevant in this context as any other disability would be. A girl who is slower, or less fit, or has poorer ball skills will not be selected either. It is different in younger age groups where some coaches will play mixed ability teams - but not at 15. All the other players will have been selected because they are the best in that position at that time - and they will not thank the coach for including a weaker player in preference to a stronger one.

It sounds as if you are happy with the idea of selection if your DD is selected in - but not if she is selected out. Presumably you have been happy with the selection principle to date? What about the other girl who is a better player? Why should she be excluded?

If you do talk to the club, I would focus on the need for a second team for girls who want to play but are not good enough to make the first team. If this club can not accommodate that then perhaps look around for one that plays at a less competitive level?

justfiveminutes · 21/05/2022 06:55

I coach a couple of school teams and am constantly challenged by parents who want their child to play despite being weaker than others. It's competitive, the aim is to win, the strongest players are chosen. There are teams where anyone can play, and teams that play competitively.

Last week I ran trials for a cross country event. I asked them all to run the distance and chose the fastest runners. I don't think it could have been fairer but still got four complaints from parents who can't accept their child hearing the word no.

OP, if you yourself can see that she hesitates and is one of the weaker players, then you must know in your heart that this is a reasonable decision even if it has upset your dd.

InChocolateWeTrust · 21/05/2022 06:54

Why is it in any worse to be being dropped because of "how your brain works" than because of how fast your feet move?

In her case her autism may affect it, but there will be other NT players for whom the mental side is what let's them down too - the strategic side etc.

Its competitive sport. It's a hard lesson in life but I'm sorry, at 15 it will get more cutthroat. There will be other less competitive clubs who may appreciate her skills more or where she may be the right fit for the rest of the team.

pilates · 21/05/2022 06:48

It is cut throat at that age - they want the best players. It’s not discrimination. I would try and find another club if she wants to continue.

KangarooKenny · 21/05/2022 06:48

This is the way football is. The manager is always going to want the best player they can get. You don’t get a place just because you’ve been there longer.

Riverlee · 21/05/2022 06:46

Thats awful. I would find another team, but write a stinking letter to the club chairman.

However, sports clubs are often run by volunteers which I think always makes the situation more tricky. The coach is giving up his time to run the team.and is not obligated to it.

Herbyhippo · 21/05/2022 06:45

I’d find a new team. It may be better, the coaching may be better. She may learn new skills by playing in a new team. And get new friends.

rocketfromthecrypt · 21/05/2022 06:41

It's about who's best at football. If she broke her leg you wouldn't expect her to play 'because she's been there four years and can't help it' would you?

user1494050295 · 21/05/2022 06:39

My daughter plays football and I can see something like this happening in the future with the weaker players moving to the lower team. Can you ask him that given there are halves or quarters in the game he can still include her in training and play in a quarter (or a half) so both her and the new player get match time. Whilst I am probably of a dog eat dog mindset and put forward your strongest players I do think inclusion is something all players can be mindful of and he should keep her in the team. If that fails find another team where she will be welcomed with her skills