Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD15 dropped from football team

111 replies

lookatallthisspace · 20/05/2022 19:05

DD15 has played football for 4 years. She's been with the same team for the whole time although a number of girls have come and go. Their coach has been trying to find out who will be resigning for next season. He pulled me aside this week to say that he is considering dropping my DD from the team to allow a new player in who plays the same position, but she is welcome to stay as train only if she wanted to.

She's not the strongest player on the pitch but she's definitely also not the worst, has had a really good season and got player of the match on a couple of occasions.

When I asked for the reasoning behind this I was told that although she is good on the ball, her brain just isn't 'quick enough' for football and it takes her too long to make decisions on the pitch. DD15 is autistic (Asperger's) and one of her biggest issues is indecisiveness. I can see during her matches that sometimes she may take a little longer to make a decision but it doesn't seem to affect the game (she doesn't stand there for minutes deciding what to do, it's a matter of seconds!).

In a nutshell, the coach wants to sign this new player but can't unless he drops someone and although he has said he knows that DD can't help being autistic, it's going to be an issue for the next season as it is much more competitive (although this is still grassroots!).

Would I be unreasonable to talk to the club about this? My DD has been with the team the longest out of all the current players and is extremely upset.

OP posts:
easyday · 21/05/2022 10:33

My son played competitive rugby and all were welcome. Sure there were weaker players but they still got to play matches. They might be subbed off more frequently than other players but all had the chance to participate - we had about 24 lads and obviously not all are needed but they still all got to (not necessarily every match).
So I wonder if the coach couldn't let your child (and other weaker players) play but maybe just less.
However, jumping to the conclusion that he is discriminating BECAUSE of her Aspergers may be incorrect. . Quick thinking is an essential part of the game and if she can't do it it's the same as someone else who can't or maybe can't run fast enough or whatever. Too bad they feel they need to cut these players rather than find a way for them to keep feeling like an important member of the team.

AngelinaFibres · 21/05/2022 10:24

Presumably the coach would like the team to be first in the league, not third. If the new player can help with that then it is perfectly reasonable to drop your daughter. She will have many knocks as she grows. Learning how to deal with them and move forward is far more important than getting a place out of pity.

bluegreygreen · 21/05/2022 10:13

saraclara · 21/05/2022 09:52

Realistically, if she's likely to hold the team back next season, when things get really hard and the opposition is tougher, then the outcome if that would be very negative for her. Her team mates would feel negatively about her, and that would easily be as bad for her as being dropped.

This sort of things is happening in many many households across the country. Kids, teens and adults are having to face being dropped from their team, and it hurts. A lot. But the vast majority do not have a condition that they or their parents can 'blame' for it. Assuming they've all tried their very best, they 'can't help' not belong good enough either. They just don't have anything to pin it on.

Agree with this.

As a child I wasn't picked for teams because I wasn't good enough (couldn't run fast enough and, like a poster above, had issues with depth perception).

There was never an issue with calling 'discrimination' - I just wasn't good enough. The coaches were clearly discriminating, in the original sense of the word, between those who were good and those who were not.

I think at 15 it is reasonable to expect the coach to want to put together the best team - perhaps different at 7/8 but mid teens is old enough to be realistic about competitive leagues.

Thehop · 21/05/2022 10:10

But at 15, it’s down to talent isn’t it? And if she’s too indecisive then that’s that. Sports is tough as they get older.

ehb102 · 21/05/2022 10:02

Check the constitution of your club. The FA is fighting the "win at all costs" ethos but individuals like this are still the problem. There's a difference between a selective team with trials and a team where the coach has taken against a child. Fairly sure at my club we have an inclusive ethos.

LindaEllen · 21/05/2022 09:58

iRun2eatCake · 20/05/2022 19:30

So he is discriminating her for her disability... which is a protected characteristic in law.

I would speak to the Safeguarding Officer and ask their opinion

I don't agree with this. In competitive sport you want the people who are the best at that sport. That's like saying if she wanted to play for a premier league team they'd HAVE to let her - no.

He is not saying she needs to leave the club, and is happy to have her there to train. Just saying that if there is a player in her position who is better, she will no longer get a match spot. That's all. And that's fair.

Nothing is worse than having a young person who thinks they can have whatever they want. It's an important lesson.

saraclara · 21/05/2022 09:52

Realistically, if she's likely to hold the team back next season, when things get really hard and the opposition is tougher, then the outcome if that would be very negative for her. Her team mates would feel negatively about her, and that would easily be as bad for her as being dropped.

This sort of things is happening in many many households across the country. Kids, teens and adults are having to face being dropped from their team, and it hurts. A lot. But the vast majority do not have a condition that they or their parents can 'blame' for it. Assuming they've all tried their very best, they 'can't help' not belong good enough either. They just don't have anything to pin it on.

rainbowunicorn · 21/05/2022 09:44

iRun2eatCake · 20/05/2022 19:30

So he is discriminating her for her disability... which is a protected characteristic in law.

I would speak to the Safeguarding Officer and ask their opinion

He has done nothing of the sort. Dont be so ridiculous.

bridgetreilly · 21/05/2022 09:40

So he is discriminating her for her disability... which is a protected characteristic in law.

Don’t be silly. It’s not discrimination when the disability has a material impact on the ability to do the job. Plus, this isn’t even a job, it’s a kids football team. If she’s slow to react, that means she’s less good on the team and the coach has every right to choose someone better.

OP, I’m sorry the coach seems to have handled it badly, and I think you could reasonably point out how well she seems to have contributed to the team this year. But your daughter is 15 not 5, and she may just need to come to terms with the fact that the way her brain works has an impact on what things she does well and what things she doesn’t.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 21/05/2022 09:34

ancientgran · 20/05/2022 20:26

Surely in competitive sport you do discriminate based on how good a player you are. I always say I'd like to be captain of the England football team but unfortunately I'm too old, too slow and I couldn't even kick a ball when I was young and fit. Perfectly reasonable for them not to pick me.

It is hard but that is competitive sport.

That's the reality of competitive sports. They want the best players. Its not your daughters fault OP but neither is it the coaches. They can't continue to keep your daughter if she simply isn't as good as the other kids. I would look for another team.

Andromachehadabadday · 21/05/2022 09:20

lookatallthisspace · 21/05/2022 09:00

@justfiveminutes I didn't see it coming because DD started every match this season, over the same 4 girls who always sat on the sub bench. She got player of the match a few times and also set up numerous goals. Those girls who have spent the season sat on the bench are being resigned, whilst DD is not. There is a girl in the squad who is noticeably worse than DD and she is also getting resigned!

Do those girls play her position though?

Can she play in their position? Is there a reason she can’t take one of their spots?

and I suppose it depends on wether the coach and support staff believe they are weaker.

isthisreallyweird · 21/05/2022 09:18

lookatallthisspace · 21/05/2022 09:00

@justfiveminutes I didn't see it coming because DD started every match this season, over the same 4 girls who always sat on the sub bench. She got player of the match a few times and also set up numerous goals. Those girls who have spent the season sat on the bench are being resigned, whilst DD is not. There is a girl in the squad who is noticeably worse than DD and she is also getting resigned!

What does the coach say when you say this to him?

wpse · 21/05/2022 09:14

Your daughter having autism doesn't mean the team can lose out. It's unfortunate for her but you can find more inclusive groups. You admit yourself that she isn't on the ball- pardon the pun.

ElenaSt · 21/05/2022 09:10

alanabennett · 20/05/2022 19:41

She's being dropped because she's a weaker player, which is a tough but valuable lesson for her to learn. I've been in your shoes and it doesn't feel good but you'd be doing her a disservice if you intervene. It might not be a super-high standard but it's still a competitive league.

I agree with this.

Find a team that plays for fun.

Iamthewombat · 21/05/2022 09:09

justfiveminutes · 21/05/2022 06:55

I coach a couple of school teams and am constantly challenged by parents who want their child to play despite being weaker than others. It's competitive, the aim is to win, the strongest players are chosen. There are teams where anyone can play, and teams that play competitively.

Last week I ran trials for a cross country event. I asked them all to run the distance and chose the fastest runners. I don't think it could have been fairer but still got four complaints from parents who can't accept their child hearing the word no.

OP, if you yourself can see that she hesitates and is one of the weaker players, then you must know in your heart that this is a reasonable decision even if it has upset your dd.

Thanks for giving us a coach’s perspective. What’s surprising to me is how many people continue to give up their time to coach kids when faced with the sort of nonsense you describe!

Some of the posts on this thread took me aback.

  • Describing the OP’s daughter’s football coach as “appalling”.
  • Suggesting that the OP “writes a stinking letter to the club chairman”.
  • Suggesting that the OP threatens the coach with a disability discrimination case in order to get the outcome she wants.
  • Complaining that, er, choosing the best players for a team is contrary to the aim of getting more women and girls playing sport.
Andromachehadabadday · 21/05/2022 09:07

lookatallthisspace · 20/05/2022 19:48

I think what's hard for DD is that she's basically being told she's the weaker player due to her autism - it's not like she is too slow or not good enough on the ball. She was in tears last night saying she can't help how her brain works.

And yes, it doesn't help that she's been with this coach for 4 years and he's only just met this player he wants to bring in.

My ds is autistic so I do understand.

But if a disability led to her being slower or not good enough on the ball, would you be ok with it? You seem to be believing these things are the only 2 things that count.

They are getting to an age where it’s really competitive. As far as I know, there’s no stipulation you have to keep a player because of their disability. But it doesn’t stop it being any less upsetting for the kids.

But even if she was NT it’s not haute tees this is something she could work harder at and fix.

I am sorry this has happened. I don’t know what the right answer is.

Libertaire · 21/05/2022 09:01

She’s 15. At that age group level, competitive team sports are supposed to be just that : competitive. It’s no longer just about participation, inclusiveness and fun, it’s also about winning. Also, by that age football should be becoming quite tactical with emphasis on speed of decision making, positional discipline in defence and moving the ball quickly and accurately in possession.

Consider also the position of the other 10 players on the team, who want to compete & want to win. They will want the strongest possible team on the pitch to enable that. Allowing your daughter to continue training with the team but not picking her for games seems the best way the coach can deal with the situation for everyone’s benefit.

lookatallthisspace · 21/05/2022 09:00

@justfiveminutes I didn't see it coming because DD started every match this season, over the same 4 girls who always sat on the sub bench. She got player of the match a few times and also set up numerous goals. Those girls who have spent the season sat on the bench are being resigned, whilst DD is not. There is a girl in the squad who is noticeably worse than DD and she is also getting resigned!

OP posts:
justfiveminutes · 21/05/2022 08:56

I'm surprised you didn't see this coming tbh. You need to help her to find a less competitive team.

EileenGC · 21/05/2022 08:48

It's tricky because it's not your DD's fault, but at the end of the day it's competitive sport.

I'm in a competitive field of the performing arts, and this is how it gets once you hit 12/14 yo and start auditioning for various projects. The UK takes this a step further and starts at 7 (too early even for me).

Regular auditioning is compulsory for everyone. You could have been top of your section for three years running, but then one year you go up against a very strong group of candidates and you're suddenly bottom of the list. It's sad but it happens, and now that I'm on the other side I sadly have to 100% agree with this method because it's what it takes to turn these kids into professionals (those who choose that path).

There are amateur groups and productions though, so kids who just want to do it for fun, can. Is there a lower category club nearby she could join? Or would she be interested in volunteering to help coach the little ones at this club, or another? It would be a shame if she stopped doing an activity she loves.

HoppingPavlova · 21/05/2022 08:35

If it’s come to the competitive stage it’s understandable. One of my kids sports we had to start doing that at 15yo. It sucks when the kid has been with the club for the past decade but it’s now about winning the flag. They have come third, they need a stronger team to come first. Most sports are no longer played for leisure at 15yo unfortunately, it’s pretty cut-throat.

Slagertha · 21/05/2022 08:30

Yes I'd find it upsetting, but this is just the nature of the game.
Whether she's been good in the past or not, he has told you she's lacking for whatever reason now. I'd definitely look into a lower league team, she shouldn't feel put off because of it if she enjoys it xx

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 21/05/2022 08:27

I can sympathise up to a point. I was always the last to be picked for teams at school as my severe myopia coupled with beer bottle bottom glasses meant my depth perception was rubbish so I could never catch or hit a ball. I still loved sports though and regularly trained with the netball team and hockey team but I didn't expect to be in the team for matches though because my visual difficulties would have held the team back. It wasn't my fault, I couldn't help not being able to judge distances but the reality was that this made me a less good player than other people who trained less but could see better.

I wasn't picked for athletics either but I couldn't blame my vision for that. That was just because I can't run fast or jump high. I did make the swimming team, not because anyone felt sorry for me or wanted to make allowances for me, but because I was good at it and could win sometimes. I valued my place because I knew I deserved it.

it's tough on your daughter that her Aspergers is preventing her shining at the game she loves but the coach is being realistic. It's a competitive sport. The whole point of a match is that the best team on the day wins. He needs to pick the team that has the best chance of doing that. Anything else isn't fair to the other 10 members of the team or to their opponents or the league. It's not fair to your daughter either to give her an unrealistic idea of her capabilities.

Portiasparty · 21/05/2022 08:15

I would look at some of the lower league teams. Not just because it would be easier to get in but because they have a much better ethos. Some of the guys running the more competitive teams do it as an ego boost and think they're running a Premier League team. I've had grown men not allow lads onto the pitch for five minutes at the end of games because of the league table. It's ridiculous.

Your local league page may have a list of teams looking for players. I get wanting to win, and there's nothing wrong with adopting a conscientious approach. But win at all cost, including dropping long-standing team players is a bit much. Often these new star players are a bit flakey as they're trying to get into professional academy teams, so they leave after a while leaving the coach in the poo.

It's worth persevering because once you've got a nice team, they make longstanding friends. My son still bumps into his old football team and really likes them all. He was actually a pretty good player but his happiest experience was in the last year when he played for fun with a less good team but a really nice coach who encouraged them but didn't mind if they lost and didnt ever square up to an opposing manager/ref/linesmen like I've seen some managers/parents do! One parent actually squared up to my teenaged son! Ludicrous for a grown man to do that just because a teen is a bit mouthy (not excusing the mouthiness, as I told him, but he was only questioning his football decision!!!

FabFitFifties · 21/05/2022 08:04

I really do feel for your daughter, but this is life in competitive team sports - you need the best players to win. Players get dropped all the time so that better players get a chance to shine.