Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD15 dropped from football team

111 replies

lookatallthisspace · 20/05/2022 19:05

DD15 has played football for 4 years. She's been with the same team for the whole time although a number of girls have come and go. Their coach has been trying to find out who will be resigning for next season. He pulled me aside this week to say that he is considering dropping my DD from the team to allow a new player in who plays the same position, but she is welcome to stay as train only if she wanted to.

She's not the strongest player on the pitch but she's definitely also not the worst, has had a really good season and got player of the match on a couple of occasions.

When I asked for the reasoning behind this I was told that although she is good on the ball, her brain just isn't 'quick enough' for football and it takes her too long to make decisions on the pitch. DD15 is autistic (Asperger's) and one of her biggest issues is indecisiveness. I can see during her matches that sometimes she may take a little longer to make a decision but it doesn't seem to affect the game (she doesn't stand there for minutes deciding what to do, it's a matter of seconds!).

In a nutshell, the coach wants to sign this new player but can't unless he drops someone and although he has said he knows that DD can't help being autistic, it's going to be an issue for the next season as it is much more competitive (although this is still grassroots!).

Would I be unreasonable to talk to the club about this? My DD has been with the team the longest out of all the current players and is extremely upset.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Atomsaway · 05/06/2022 13:51

It’s really upsetting.

My son has just been dropped from his little league team because “his application to learn is a little low, which means he picks things up more slowly.” (Direct quote from the coach.)

My son has dyslexia and ADHD so he finds it difficult to follow long instructions. The coaches did not try to accommodate him as far as I know. No one spoke to me to say that there was a problem.

What’s more upsetting, is that until very recently, all the feedback was super positive and they were telling him he could make it into their better team. No one has mentioned anything up until the bomb shell email on Friday morning.

Football was the only thing he thought he was decent at. School has been a disaster. This has destroyed him.

thing47 · 22/05/2022 12:13

Something similar happened to DS as a teenager @lookatallthisspace . It wasn't so much the dropping that upset him as the way it was handled – the coach viewed it purely as a playing decision and had no empathy for the fact that DS had been at the club for a few years and enjoyed the whole team environment etc. Coach was a former professional footballer and took it much too seriously for what was meant to be a church-affiliated inclusive community team.

We found him a new club which turned out to be a much better fit. He played for 3 more seasons and met boys from a different school he didn't know before who turned into some of his best friends.

DolphinaPD · 22/05/2022 11:31

Can you start your own inclusive team?

My sisters started a girls football league in the Borough because there wasn't one.

ancientgran · 22/05/2022 10:52

dottieautie · 21/05/2022 20:27

Whatever happened to second and third teams? We used to move less capable players between 1st,2nd & 3rd squads and more capable or improving players would be moved up and it could change within seasons as well as between them.

It seems a shame they don’t have lower level competitive teams for players who may be going through a bad patch or need more practice at set pieces and drills, which really can help competent neurodivergent players overcome some of the processing problems by making the response habitual (Talking from experience as both player and coach in my younger years)

There are 2 competing issues here. The first is that as a competitive team the coaches will always want the best players for the team but there is also a discrimination issue which arises not because of the daughter potential exclusion but the way in which it came about. It’s true that discrimination cannot be overcome by adjustment in elite sports but it can be overcome by having seasonal selection events/competitions among all competent available players (this is common practice in most team sports), alternative and backup teams and less competitive teams. No one should find themselves unable to play due to disability. Inclusive teams may be too slow for op’s daughter & where does that get her?

You need enough adults involved to run mulitple teams. Maybe the OP could offer to run one?

lljkk · 21/05/2022 22:59

It's not meant to be all inclusive activity: it's meant to be the most competitive team. There's no way she's dropped if she isn't (in the round, for the moment) the weakest player.

Remind her about Jamie Vardy getting dropped from Football Academy at age 15.

I'm very impressed that it took until age 15 before she was dropped. Anyone who gets that far must be very good, actually. Could possibly get on another team. DS was dropped from community footie at age 9.

Fluval · 21/05/2022 21:18

dottieautie · 21/05/2022 20:27

Whatever happened to second and third teams? We used to move less capable players between 1st,2nd & 3rd squads and more capable or improving players would be moved up and it could change within seasons as well as between them.

It seems a shame they don’t have lower level competitive teams for players who may be going through a bad patch or need more practice at set pieces and drills, which really can help competent neurodivergent players overcome some of the processing problems by making the response habitual (Talking from experience as both player and coach in my younger years)

There are 2 competing issues here. The first is that as a competitive team the coaches will always want the best players for the team but there is also a discrimination issue which arises not because of the daughter potential exclusion but the way in which it came about. It’s true that discrimination cannot be overcome by adjustment in elite sports but it can be overcome by having seasonal selection events/competitions among all competent available players (this is common practice in most team sports), alternative and backup teams and less competitive teams. No one should find themselves unable to play due to disability. Inclusive teams may be too slow for op’s daughter & where does that get her?

Only a couple of clubs where I grew up had B teams (none had C).

Other than the OP’s daughter, are there another 15-19 players who would want to play for the B team (particularly if there are other clubs around where they could be on the ‘A’ team)?

Are there sufficient coaches available to run B and C teams at the various age groups?

Does the local league even allow B teams?

Etc.

dottieautie · 21/05/2022 20:27

Whatever happened to second and third teams? We used to move less capable players between 1st,2nd & 3rd squads and more capable or improving players would be moved up and it could change within seasons as well as between them.

It seems a shame they don’t have lower level competitive teams for players who may be going through a bad patch or need more practice at set pieces and drills, which really can help competent neurodivergent players overcome some of the processing problems by making the response habitual (Talking from experience as both player and coach in my younger years)

There are 2 competing issues here. The first is that as a competitive team the coaches will always want the best players for the team but there is also a discrimination issue which arises not because of the daughter potential exclusion but the way in which it came about. It’s true that discrimination cannot be overcome by adjustment in elite sports but it can be overcome by having seasonal selection events/competitions among all competent available players (this is common practice in most team sports), alternative and backup teams and less competitive teams. No one should find themselves unable to play due to disability. Inclusive teams may be too slow for op’s daughter & where does that get her?

Iamthewombat · 21/05/2022 19:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Fluval · 21/05/2022 19:38

He won’t have just one player for every position (we know there are subs), but there’ll be a maximum squad size allowed by the league (I think it’s usually 20 players at the 15+ age group), which prohibits him from having 2 players for every position.

Like · 21/05/2022 19:17

It doesn’t make much sense to me that the coach would only want 1 player for each position. Surely you want to have options and depth.

It would be perfectly reasonable for him to bring in another player as competition for your DD which would keep both of them on their toes, but to drop her altogether is poor imo.

Pixie2015 · 21/05/2022 18:57

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

XelaM · 21/05/2022 18:55

all*

XelaM · 21/05/2022 18:55

Blanketpolicy · 21/05/2022 10:41

If she is in a "competitive" team such as a professional teams youth football, then fair enough, it is hard, but they are professionals who know their sport and how to spot and nurture the type of talent they want.

It is hilarious anyone thinks football clubs with volunteer coaches and local leagues/tournaments are "competitive". Grass roots isnt "cut throat" it is barely trained adults playing football manager as a hobby because they are bored of their day job. Some coaches have loyalty to their players as they realise children develop at different rates others just shouldnt be coaches.

Err...... so do you think professional athletes get dropped down from heaven at 18? They would have al had to be trained at grass root level

XelaM · 21/05/2022 18:51

Could you find another team to sign her?

saraclara · 21/05/2022 18:03

KrisAkabusi · 21/05/2022 17:42

I've not come across sports snobbery before, but @KrisAkabusi is obviously a winner at it.

Er, no, I was pointing out what a bad attitude that was, not condoning it!

Aaargh! I am SO sorry. I even knew that, but then forgot to look back to see who you'd quoted. Sincere apologies, and I should of course have tagged @Blanketpolicy for being an arse.

KrisAkabusi · 21/05/2022 17:42

I've not come across sports snobbery before, but @KrisAkabusi is obviously a winner at it.

Er, no, I was pointing out what a bad attitude that was, not condoning it!

saraclara · 21/05/2022 17:34

KrisAkabusi · 21/05/2022 17:30

It is hilarious anyone thinks football clubs with volunteer coaches and local leagues/tournaments are "competitive". Grass roots isnt "cut throat" it is barely trained adults playing football manager as a hobby because they are bored of their day job.

I hope you're not the parent of a child who does any sort of sport, because that's disgusting attitude to the people who give up their time to make that possible.

Exactly. And the kids take their games extremely seriously. At 15 of course they're competitive. The national sportsmen and women wouldn't be where they are if it wasn't for the people who nurtured them as kids, and without having that competitive spirit.

I've not come across sports snobbery before, but @KrisAkabusi is obviously a winner at it.

KrisAkabusi · 21/05/2022 17:30

It is hilarious anyone thinks football clubs with volunteer coaches and local leagues/tournaments are "competitive". Grass roots isnt "cut throat" it is barely trained adults playing football manager as a hobby because they are bored of their day job.

I hope you're not the parent of a child who does any sort of sport, because that's disgusting attitude to the people who give up their time to make that possible.

ManateeFair · 21/05/2022 17:03

She’s been dropped from the team because she isn’t good enough at football to stay in this particular team at this particular level, because she is 15 and not 5, and football at that stage is competitive. It doesn’t matter how good her ball skills are or how physically fit she is if she can’t manage the instinctive decision elements of the game - the fact that she’s autistic is neither here nor there; plenty of neurotypical kids don’t have that ability either. There is no discrimination here. The nature of competitive team sport at that level is that teams are picked by ability. That’s what competition is.

I’d suggest looking for a football club that has more than one team. Plenty will have a first team and a second/third team, which means the kids are training together and still getting games regardless of whether they’re the best players at the club, and can move up and down between teams according to their form.

I absolutely do feel sorry for your daughter because rejection is extremely hard, especially at that age. But it is part and parcel of competitive sport.

saraclara · 21/05/2022 13:07

StudentMumTo3 · 21/05/2022 12:31

There are weaker players but she's being dropped because of her disability?
Discrimination and I'd tell him that.

The ableism on this thread is depressing but not surprising too.

She's not being dropped "because of her disability", she's being dropped because her reactions and decision making are not fast enough. There may be players who are on the bench more, but they might play in different positions, or they might be showing potential that the coach is building on.

The new person joining the club presumably plays in DD's position. I remember my own football playing daughter getting very stressed when someone who played in her position joined her club from another. The threat is always there that someone might take your place in the team. DD's condition is a bit of a red herring, tbh. She's not being judged by it, she's been established at the club for some time, so the charge of ableism seems misplaced. She simply doesn't meet the standard needed for what appears to be a particularly challenging next season.

Like I said, this is happening to hundreds if not thousands of children, teenagers and adults right now. Playing team sports can be brutal in that sense.

StudentMumTo3 · 21/05/2022 12:31

There are weaker players but she's being dropped because of her disability?
Discrimination and I'd tell him that.

The ableism on this thread is depressing but not surprising too.

AlphaThree · 21/05/2022 11:20

If the coach thinks her indecisiveness will lose them matches then it’s better for her to move on really. She will quickly become unpopular if she’s perceived by the team as their weak link that means they keep losing. It seems harsh but it’s probably the best thing.

I was dropped from the dance squad in school and was gutted, but I did recognise that I wasn’t as bendy or quick as the rest of them so I just became their #1 supporter and stayed friends as I kept going to class. It was hard, but better than to have been the one who let them down all the time.

Johnnysgirl · 21/05/2022 10:46

So he is discriminating her for her disability... which is a protected characteristic in law.
Not really, no. It's competitive sport, there isn't really scope for reasonable adjustments.
They want to win.

Blanketpolicy · 21/05/2022 10:41

If she is in a "competitive" team such as a professional teams youth football, then fair enough, it is hard, but they are professionals who know their sport and how to spot and nurture the type of talent they want.

It is hilarious anyone thinks football clubs with volunteer coaches and local leagues/tournaments are "competitive". Grass roots isnt "cut throat" it is barely trained adults playing football manager as a hobby because they are bored of their day job. Some coaches have loyalty to their players as they realise children develop at different rates others just shouldnt be coaches.

TeenPlusCat · 21/05/2022 10:38

It seems from some PP that the coach needs to register players, and there is a limit on that. So maybe only 15 or whatever individuals can play for a team in a season?

I wonder whether rugby or cricket have similar rules at this age, or if they are more flexible? Anyone know?