Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask dp to have a vasectomy even though I don't know if we will always be together

35 replies

Cheeseandlobster · 20/05/2022 15:50

I have had a coil in for 9 years and really conscious that it needs to come out. I have put up with weird long heavy periods during this time. Prior to that I tried different pills but after the last one, Yasmin, left me feeling suicidal, I gave up on hormones. I am really afraid of having the coil taken out and another put in. And I dont want another one either

Dp is 53 and has children and now grandchildren. He doesn't want more dc's. But he is finding the finality a bit daunting.

Our relationship has definitely had its ups and downs and I can't say hand on heart that we will always be together. I just don't know

Aibu to want him to consider this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cheeseandlobster · 20/05/2022 16:50

CaptSkippy · 20/05/2022 16:48

What about skipping intercourse? There are plenty of ways in which both partners can experience sexual pleasure that do not risk pregnancy. Your partner does not need to stick it in you to get off.

I quite like intercourse though

OP posts:
mistermagpie · 20/05/2022 16:50

mewkins · 20/05/2022 16:31

I really don't understand the 'if anything happened to me...' argument against a vasectomy. Surely anyone knows whether they want any more kids or not. Is the idea that a middle aged man must always seem able to produce kids if a younger childless woman turns up?

I don't get this either. I don't want any more children full stop, I wouldn't suddenly start wanting some more if DH died or we split up or whatever. We have three children and prior to that I covered the contraceptive area of the relationship. I've done years on the pill and years of pregnancy, I've told DH that it's over to him now. I would like him to get a vasectomy but it's up to him, so for now it's condoms. Every time. I think it's fine to say you've done your bit, family-planning wise, but he needs to make his own decision. Although why a grandfather in his 50s would be remotely interested in having a new baby, in any circumstances, is beyond me.

CaptSkippy · 20/05/2022 16:48

Cheeseandlobster · 20/05/2022 15:51

Oh and I fell pregnant a few years ago with condoms. I don't want to risk another unplanned pregnancy

What about skipping intercourse? There are plenty of ways in which both partners can experience sexual pleasure that do not risk pregnancy. Your partner does not need to stick it in you to get off.

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 20/05/2022 16:37

I was sterilised when my youngest was 2.

I was early thirties.

I had decided in my own mind I didn't want anymore dc that If me and dh did ever seperate and met other partners a STILL wouldn't want anymore children so I was sterilised.

I was in and out in a couple of hours and at home eating toast on just paracetomol

I actually went into work the next day on light duties.

It's done via keyhole and the tubes aren't cut anymore they're clipped.

I had absolutely no pain from the two small incisions or the procedure itself.

The pain was in my shoulder blades from the gas.

PinkSyCo · 20/05/2022 16:36

Thisismynamenow · 20/05/2022 16:22

You realise most doctors won't sterilise a woman of child baring age with less than 3 kids? And even if they do they require your husbands consent.

They ask no questions for a vasectomy

I went along to an appointment to discuss sterilisation after having 5 children! The doctor turned to my (now ex) husband and told him that he should have a vasectomy rather than a ‘young woman like me’ be sterilised. The joke was that I’m actually older than my ex Grin. It got me thinking though, and even though I was sure I didn’t want any more children, him having the snip was a simpler procedure and, as the nice doctor also mentioned, my body had been through enough, so I did change my mind and insist that he put himself out for a change and you wouldn’t be unreasonable to do so either.

mewkins · 20/05/2022 16:31

I really don't understand the 'if anything happened to me...' argument against a vasectomy. Surely anyone knows whether they want any more kids or not. Is the idea that a middle aged man must always seem able to produce kids if a younger childless woman turns up?

Cheeseandlobster · 20/05/2022 16:28

It's a copper coil I have. It has caused me to have really weird almost reverse periods where I start spotting for around 6 days then it's like a tap then it just stops suddenly. I really don't want any sort of coil again.

I know I am not his secretary though he is totally rubbish at sorting his own health appointments. He needs to do this one himself though. I am glad that counselling is offered beforehand as I don't want him to just do it because I have asked him to think about it.

I didn't know how hard it is to get female sterilisation so this post has certainly been an eye opener

OP posts:
Thisismynamenow · 20/05/2022 16:22

stepuporshutup · 20/05/2022 15:57

You could get streralised

You realise most doctors won't sterilise a woman of child baring age with less than 3 kids? And even if they do they require your husbands consent.

They ask no questions for a vasectomy

Basilbrushgotfat · 20/05/2022 16:22

@orwellwasright @stepuporshutup

It's all very well telling the op to get sterilised but it's nearly impossible for women to get this procedure.

Women are constantly refused sterilisation - yes, in the UK - because their future partner or husband might want children.

It's refused even in cases of medical need, eg incredibly painful and incredibly heavy periods.

Many NHS trusts also no longer offer it, so even a woman can find a doctor who accepts her autonomy over own body, she'd have to pay for it, making it financially impossible as well for most.

Those that do manage it, tend to be able to get it down as part of a c-section, which doesn't really help the op.

AnotherEmma · 20/05/2022 16:21

Cheeseandlobster · 20/05/2022 16:13

He isnt adverse to it. If anything he has been too flippant with it. When I first mentioned it he asked what would happen if he wanted more children and said he might struggle with that, then he said he doesn't want more children and to go ahead and book him in. I told him no. He will need to do his research and talk to people if he wishes first as its a big decision. I was just concerned that I might be being selfish if I can't swear that we will always be right for each other as we are very different

Why did he tell you to book him in? You're not his secretary.
You should have told him to book it himself. And I don't see why he has to discuss it with anyone other than the HCPs.

It doesn't really matter whether you two stay together or not, if he doesn't want any more children he should get a vasectomy.

What kind of coil do you have, is it a copper coil? Would you consider something like the Kyleena (lower dose than Mirena)? I understand that you don't want to be responsible for contraception any more but realistically even if he does get a vasectomy he won't get the all clear straight away.

ThatsBullshirt · 20/05/2022 16:20

Cheeseandlobster · 20/05/2022 16:13

He isnt adverse to it. If anything he has been too flippant with it. When I first mentioned it he asked what would happen if he wanted more children and said he might struggle with that, then he said he doesn't want more children and to go ahead and book him in. I told him no. He will need to do his research and talk to people if he wishes first as its a big decision. I was just concerned that I might be being selfish if I can't swear that we will always be right for each other as we are very different

It has to be something he is certain he wants regardless of whether or not your relationship is solid and last forever.

DH and I are in a stable, happy relationship of nearly 17 years, one I don't ever see ending. But if something were to happen to me or something changed and we divorced I would want him to know he had made the decision to get a vasectomy himself because it was 100% what he wanted - and I was happy with too. Not just because with me he is done having kids, iykwim.

Cheeseandlobster · 20/05/2022 16:18

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/05/2022 16:13

If he somehow harbours the notion that when he's in his sixties, he'll easily find somebody in her late twenties to early thirties willing to have children with him, unless he's massively rich and influential, he's really not being that realistic. Unless, of course, you're in your late twenties and are already the young second wife, at any rate.

He'd still be able to shag anybody daft enough afterwards, he just wouldn't have the added maintenance payments as a consequence.

Strange really - women have to come to terms with this at menopause (or if they need a hysterectomy) but men don't. Makes sense that it's something that hadn't occurred to him before because of that, but women are supposed to shrug it off.

It does seem utterly logical that where he isn't planning a second/third family that he would have the simple, lower risk and quicker recovery time of a vasectomy rather than you undergo higher risk surgery.

I suppose the alternative is that he doesn't get to have sex with you again. That might make the decision easier.

Haha I wish he was rich and influential and I was a 20 something. I am 44 so most probably peri menopausal but its still not entirely beyond the realms of possibility that I could get pregnant. I am already putting up with peri menopause crap. I don't want more invasive contraception if I can help it

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 20/05/2022 16:18

I don't think it matters if you will always be together if he is certain he doesn't want more children, ultimately.

You have had years of being responsible for contraception, you don't want to do it anymore, totally reasonable that the burden be on him. It's up to him if he wants to use condoms or save himself the bother.

museumum · 20/05/2022 16:15

Even if you broke up soon, does he really think he’d want more children with someone else at 55+?
of course it’s not unreasonable to ask him at his stage of life to consider vasectomy.

Cheeseandlobster · 20/05/2022 16:13

He isnt adverse to it. If anything he has been too flippant with it. When I first mentioned it he asked what would happen if he wanted more children and said he might struggle with that, then he said he doesn't want more children and to go ahead and book him in. I told him no. He will need to do his research and talk to people if he wishes first as its a big decision. I was just concerned that I might be being selfish if I can't swear that we will always be right for each other as we are very different

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/05/2022 16:13

If he somehow harbours the notion that when he's in his sixties, he'll easily find somebody in her late twenties to early thirties willing to have children with him, unless he's massively rich and influential, he's really not being that realistic. Unless, of course, you're in your late twenties and are already the young second wife, at any rate.

He'd still be able to shag anybody daft enough afterwards, he just wouldn't have the added maintenance payments as a consequence.

Strange really - women have to come to terms with this at menopause (or if they need a hysterectomy) but men don't. Makes sense that it's something that hadn't occurred to him before because of that, but women are supposed to shrug it off.

It does seem utterly logical that where he isn't planning a second/third family that he would have the simple, lower risk and quicker recovery time of a vasectomy rather than you undergo higher risk surgery.

I suppose the alternative is that he doesn't get to have sex with you again. That might make the decision easier.

CupidStunt22 · 20/05/2022 16:10

Carrotmum · 20/05/2022 15:54

Yes YABU you can’t tell him what to do with his own body. Do you think he should have the right to ask you to consider getting sterilised? Thought not.

Of course he has the right to ASK her to CONSIDER it. Same as she does. How is that vaguely the same as TELLING him what to do with his body?

It isn't and you probably know that.

Dixiechickonhols · 20/05/2022 16:10

At 53 with grandchildren surely he knows if he wants more children or not. It’s a very different kettle of fish to if he was 30 with one child and a rocky relationship. Even if you split unless he has a strong desire to be a dad again at 55 plus then surely ship has sailed.
You can’t force him but I’d make it clear you are done with taking hormones/invasive contraception and ball in his court.

theobligatorynamechange · 20/05/2022 16:07

It sounds like his family is complete, and he's having a wobble. It would be different if he might like to go on and have more children if you broke up.

It also sounds like you're finding the pressure of being responsible for contraception hard, and if he stepped up, it might bring you closer together, TBH.

ThatsBullshirt · 20/05/2022 16:05

YANBU to ask him to consider it. I think it's important to talk about all contraception with partners, including if a vasectomy is an option once you are both done having kids. Of course it would be unreasonable to demand it (not saying you are!) but it's fair to see if it's an option that he would consider.

DH has said he wants a vasectomy. The only contraception we've ever used is condoms and never had any accidents, despite being seemingly very fertile while TTC our DC. We are in our early thirties, have two kids and don't want any more. The finality of it does worry me (for him) but he's sure he's done having more kids, as am I so I'm happy for him to get one of it's what he wants. He does drag his heels on everything though so we are still waiting for him to do anything about it 3.5 years after he first mentioned it!

Hospedia · 20/05/2022 16:05

You should ask him, he can only say no. You could also let him know you want to get your coil out and that he/you will need to use condoms (and if you want it out then get it out).

Whether you'll always be together is irrelevant and it's one of the questions DH was asked at his appointment. He was asked what if we split up and he met someone else, he said that he would not want DC with a new partner as he already has enough DC.

Catcrazy83 · 20/05/2022 16:00

Totally reasonable to tell dp that you don’t want another coil putting in, that you won’t go on the pill again after the issues last time, and that you won’t rely on condoms again. It’s up to him then if he can find an alternative, or if you just don’t have sex again. Tbh you’ve managed the situation long enough, I think it’s only fair it’s now his burden.

Lemons1571 · 20/05/2022 16:00

I don’t see the issue with asking him. Only on mumsnet will everyone pile in on you insisting that it’s his body, his decision, you have no right to even think it’s reasonable to suggest this, end of.

The fact that you’ve done all the legwork and suffered all the side effects of preventing pregnancy for the last decade should be completely relevant. He steps up, or it’s no sex from now on. If he then bails on the relationship, it wasn’t worth it in the first place.

lassof · 20/05/2022 15:58

yanbu. I don't imagine he has put much thought into your contraceptive choices over the years but maybe he could start now. What are his alternatives? Would he prefer condoms? Fine, then go for that plus only sex in your non-fertile phase if you are worried about pregnancy. Or wait til your menopause?

stepuporshutup · 20/05/2022 15:57

You could get streralised